ipl-logo

Lemon Grove Incident Sparknotes

731 Words3 Pages

The film, Lemon Grove Incident, depicts the hardships a community of Mexican Americans endured as education, a tool commonly used for upward mobility and inclusion into the dominant American society, became another form of racialization against them. In this community discourse driven by stereotypes and actions geared by academic profiling, denied Mexican Americans students from co-existing in the same school as their white peers. Members of the Lemon Grove PTA and School Board, believed that segregation of the two races would create better learning environments for both parties because the Mexican students lacked full ability of speaking the English language. Mexican American students were targeted because their ability of speaking Spanish …show more content…

In the Anglos eyes, Spanish is an inferior tongue that should be erased and replaced by English. For example, Roberto, an older student, who was highlighted as an example to the class by Ms. Katherine Elliot as “someone they should aim to be.” A student who is fully assimilated into “American culture” by carrying manners that shows respect and who speaks English fluently. Here the ability of speaking Spanish is stigmatized as holding back the Mexican American students from fully integrating with American society. Most importantly, they are not only pushing students to adhere to the dominant language but they are also teaching them that one linguistic capability is preferred and legitimized over the …show more content…

Even if the Mexican students assimilated through the Americanization classes, like the student Roberto, they were academically profiled as deficient and non-white and casted away to the “New School” based on their race and not on their academic fall backs. Borrowing the words from Ofelia Garcia, “The Spanish language (and bilingualism) in the United States have become markers of being nonwhite, of being out of place, thus minoritizing the position of U.S. Latinos and excluding them” (Garcia, 2009). Anglos in this community were creating a visible divide by using Spanish language as a marker of “otherness” and framing racial stereotypes to this linguistic

Show More
Related
303 Words | 2 Pages

After reading Miguel and Valencia’s “From the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo to Hopwood,” I was shocked to find how Mexican Americans were treated in American students. I was expect poor treatment from our discussions in class as well as other readings, but after reading what the authors reported, including schools failing to address learning issues and pushing kids instead into economic mobility, I am deeply troubled I was not made aware of this sooner. Along with segregation on race basis, I would argue the struggles of Mexican American students was the greatest struggle for education equality in the 20th century, though the struggles gone through by other minorities surely should be discounted or overlooked. I found the role of religious institutions

Read More
255 Words | 2 Pages

Second, there a ton of Spanish speaking people in the USA and especially in the California. So the author Charles Krauthammer states his worry is about Spanish being the “official” language of the USA rather than “English”, which is fair because more and more people migrate from Mexico to the United States and now-a-days even in schools, they teach Spanish. The fear is growing by each passing day. In the article “In Plain English: Let’s Make it Official” by Charles Krauthammer, tells that: “Growing rapidly through immigration, it creates large communities—in some places already majorities—so overwhelmingly Spanish speaking that, in time, they may quite naturally demand the rights and official recognition for Spanish that French has in French-speaking

Read More
291 Words | 2 Pages

However, the fact is that most Americans have the impression that Hispanic immigrants are perceived as a threat for not assimilating into the American mainstream, more so into the Anglo-Protestant values. Why is that? Is it for fear that the Spanish Language may overrun the country? Similarly, Neil Foley, author of, Mexicans In The Making of America, asks the same questions, why fear? In his prologue chapter, Foley makes a point by proving the fact that in the past, Mexican immigrants were not a concern but were, “ let in to provide the labor force for the rapidly expanding economy”(2).

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

Mexican-American students went back to the prestigious Anglo schools, but now, Anglo-Americans were trying to Americanize them even more. “...segregation became widespread during the 1920s, aided by the “No Spanish Rule”―the rule prohibiting Mexican children from speaking spanish in school” (Acuña 187). Mexican-Americans took pride in speaking Spanish, now they were being stripped away from their culture. In fact, they would get punished for speaking spanish. Most of the time Mexican families spoke Spanish in their homes, but once they stepped outside their door they had to speak english.

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

Growing up Mexican-American in the United States can be a challenge itself. Throw in the task, of learning two languages, it made for a very confused little girl. There was often times growing up when I wondered why no one, but my family spoke Spanish. Why everyone at school and all my friends spoke this different language. Sometimes it even seemed like I was two different people.

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

Spanish language in the classroom was banned because due to its type of linguistic terrorism, and only English was the official language that was accepted in the classroom. Assimilation was the word they used to promote to revolt against the racial and political injustice in the Chicano Movement in the

Read More
1458 Words | 6 Pages

Segregation of Mexican Americans from the dominant Anglo race has been around for many years. Since the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo Mexican Americans have been treated like a second-class race facing racism and segregation. As a result, segregation in the education system affected Mexican American children. An increasing number of Mexican Americans across California led to an increase of Mexican children enrolling in schools. Author David James Gonzales (2017), explores the degrading school facilities Mexican students were assigned to.

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

In the book Chicano Students and the Courts, the author Richard R. Valencia provides a very detailed overlook of the education litigation that the Mexican American students and community went through for education. They fought for education equality and desegregation in schools throughout the country from K-12 and in higher education facilities. The separation of Mexican Americans from their white colleagues around 1848; this started the mistreatment and discrimination of students of Mexican decent. The objective that the author would like to demonstrate is the effort that the Latino community, parents and students, endured for equal opportunities in the educational system. The number of desegregation lawsuits that were created by Mexican

Read More
706 Words | 3 Pages

“Precious Knowledge” is a documentary about the Mexican-American Studies Program offered to highschool students in Tucson, Arizona (2011). This documentary follows students enrolled in the Mexican-American Studies Program offered at Tucson Magnet High School: Crystal, Pricilla, and Gilbert; as well as the teachers of the Mexican-American Studies courses: Curtis Acosta and Jose Gonzalez. The students and teachers are interviewed throughout the documentary and explain how they are impacted by the program and their activism to keep the program is demonstrated. This film features individuals who opposed the program, such as superintendent Tom Horne and incoming superintendent John Huppenthal. They believed that ethnic studies were racist, promoted

Read More
265 Words | 2 Pages

During class we saw this film called “The Lemon Grove Incident” it was a film in which made me feel very comfortable. It showed full on racism towards the Latinos in that location, they literally described Mexican people as dirty people with diseases. It was quite fascinating hearing the outrages claims/reasons the white people had for sending the Mexicans kids to a new school “a barn”. I did feel quite proud when the parents of those Mexican children stepped up and arranged gathers to determine that they would not allow such injustice towards their children. Almost close to the end I was smiling the whole time, during the court scene it was quite clear the white people had no knowledgeable excuse towards their actions and decisions other than

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

Both readings claim that Hispanics are here to stay, but with opposing views on how this affects society. One place where Hispanic presence is on the rise is in schools. However, some Hispanic students know more Spanish than English, and therefore struggle in school. This idea of exemplifies the stereotype that Hispanics are “dumb”.

Read More
1290 Words | 6 Pages

Thus, bilingual-bicultural programs are seen by Chicano educators as a major breakthrough in the ethnic rigidity of the controlling white supremacy nation whose preference has long been towards a presumed monocultural middle-class American student. In order to understand bilingual-bicultural education properly one has to look at it in the framework of the cultural experiences of the Chicanos. Important to note that chicano experiences may be polarized and reflect different philosophies of education. The evaluation of bilingual-bicultural programs should take into account the expectations of Chicano educators and see program developments from their standpoint. This article is relevant to my paper because it provides a more progressive perspective since it focuses on the social recognition, respect, and self-determination that Chicanos are receiving.

Read More
1062 Words | 5 Pages

Richard Rodriguez offers a rare glimpse of the world of a racialized American – one that belongs neither in their homeland nor in the American community. Born into a family of Mexican immigrants who had received only basic education, Rodriguez was an early bird in realizing the changes education had brought on him. On numerous occasions, he

Read More
1142 Words | 5 Pages

Today, you either get educated or you get stuck in a dead-end job without much prospect for the future. The gap between those with a higher education and those without one is becoming wider with advancements in technology and the growing competitiveness of the job market. There are many dangers of this gap. One such danger is the people who have a higher educations having the leisure to ignore those who are less educated. Joy Castro in her essays “Hungry” and “On Becoming Educated” discusses her life and educational journey.

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

Apparently, some states in America bar undocumented students from attending university, or charge students out-of-state or international tuition rates. Also, programs that are designed for the needs of Latino students are being attacked. 41 years ago, the NEA committee held a conference about Spanish speaking children in schools located in the Southwest. The participants came to a conclusion that Spanish speaking children were victims of inappropriate material, undertrained educators and poor learning techniques. Back then, Spanish speaking children were put at the lowest grade or called ‘mentally defective’.

Read More

More about Lemon Grove Incident Sparknotes

Open Document