ipl-logo

Literature Circles

957 Words4 Pages

2.1.3 Students’ Roles and Responsibility in Literature Circles

One of the special aspects about literature circles is that every student has a particular role to play during the discussions. These roles allows students to approach the text from different perspective and look closely at specific aspects of the text (Brown, 2009). There are eight roles include four basic roles-a discussion director, a literary luminary, a connector and an illustrator as well as four optional roles-a summarizer, a vocabulary enricher, a travel tracer, and an investigator (Daniels, 1994). The information about eight roles is provided below:
1. Discussion director: The job is to make a list of thought provoking questions and maintaining flow of the discussion. …show more content…

9), are Macgillivray (1995) benefiting second-language learners and English-as-a-foreign-language learners (Dupuy, 1997). They have revealed that literature circles are effective for not only students whose mother tongue is English but also for who are learning it as a second or foreign language.
Literature circles promote EFL students’ acquisition and practice of both receptive (i.e., listening and reading) and productive (i.e., speaking and writing) skills. According to the transactional theory (Rosenblatt, 1988), readers approach a text from efferent stance and/or aesthetic stance. As Brown (2009) explains, the efferent stance is searching for information in the text by using the 5 W's: Who, What, Where, When, and Why. On the other hand, the aesthetic stance deals with more personal, affective, and qualitative aspects of the text. Unlike mature readers who can adopt either stance and often use both together, L2 readers only access to the efferent stance in many cases. Is it important to note that literature circles have the potential to move developing readers into more aesthetic interpretation of the text by breaking up the reading to be approached from several angles (Brown, 2009, p. …show more content…

Sometimes literature circles might become a monotonous and repetitive activity. For instance, Lloyd (2004, p. 115) and Calderón (2010, p. 27) complain that their students filled in their role sheets mechanically and some of them did not even participate in the discussions. Literature circles have to be lively and spontaneous, but above all, they should be in English. There is a possibility that EFL students use their first language to talk to each other, especially if the teacher is not present. For Hill (1992, p. 42), the students’ overuse of their mother tongue is one of the main issues of book discussions in EFL classes. It is necessary for the teachers to emphasize the importance of discussing the texts in English. Otherwise, the activity cannot be meaningful and helpful to improve the learners’ communicative competence in the foreign language. Furthermore, teachers could deal with conflicts or behavior problems that may emerge from group work. Literature circles may improve the class climate, but creating and maintaining a positive and respectful atmosphere is difficult. Clarke and Holwadel (2007) discuss the issues that arose in their sixth grade class. Their observation shows there was a pervasive feeling of hostility in the classroom and disagreeing, interruptions and role-switching dominated group

Show More
Related
762 Words | 4 Pages

In the introduction of “How to Read Literature Like a Professor” , Thomas C. Foster focuses on the grammar of literature and the qualities of a professorial reader. He asserts that practise is crucial to learn how to read literature in a more rewarding way. In addition, he defines main elements of the context such as pattern , symbols, and conventions. The purpose of Foster appears to be informing students who is beginning to be introduced to literature. Although Foster’s style is slightly condescending, he utilizes the conventions of literature quite well, and mentions the arbitrariness of these conventions in a sensible way.

Read More
966 Words | 4 Pages

Readers should identify the approaches to the text in each reviewer’s assessment

Read More
181 Words | 1 Pages

By reading “How to Read Literature like a Professor” and “The Kite Runner”, the reader is aided in his or her ability to understand the true meanings behind the text. One is able to decipher how the act of coming together to eat can mean anything from a simple meal with family, to an uncomfortable situation that leads to anger or stress in an individual character. The reader is able to understand the use of rain or other weather in a novel to transform the mood and tone of scene, or understand the cleansing or destructive qualities that weather may have on the overall plot of the story. The use of illness can be transformed, as it can lead to the reader discovering veiled means behind tuberculosis, cholera, a simple cold, or even cancers such

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

These artistic qualities make the reader more involved and makes them want to continue reading the

Read More
903 Words | 4 Pages

Both texts, make use of of the reader’s interpretations to depict the character’s physical

Read More
1203 Words | 5 Pages

In How to Read Literature Like a Professor Thomas C. Foster writes about how to thoroughly read and analyze literature. He focuses on the many different aspects of writing that are used by authors. Despite being a relatively serious and informational subject, Foster is able to use language that is entertaining and more light hearted. He uses many jokes and puns in his book, and even many titles include artistically worded headings that grab the reader's’ attention.

Read More
1241 Words | 5 Pages

In Sandra Cisneros “Mericans” she creates a young character named Michelle who faces cultural differences and nonunderstanding, gender roles and culture stereotyping which can be exhibited in the real world. The author introduces Michelle as a foreigner with in her own culture, with this being said throughout the story Michelle seemed to be uninterested in her Grandmothers ideals and the principles of the Mexican heritage. The evidence behind this statement is; throughout the passage Michelle refers to her grandmother as being “awful” (Cisneros 93). I think a big reason for this is the fact that the grandmother has the children wait outside the church doors as she goes and say her daily prayers.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

Thomas Foster's How to Read Literature Like a Professor, is a thought provoking guide to reading literature. This book helps with understanding the “language of reading” and the importance of details. Foster opens up a new side of literature where rather than reading emotionally, you dig deeper into the grammar of the literary work to discover the true meaning. How to Read Literature Like a Professor, is beneficial when reading any kind of literary work. It explains the particular “set of conventions and patterns, codes and rules” (Foster xxv) used when dealing with literary works.

Read More
624 Words | 3 Pages

In math gives students a chance to share different methods and angles for solving mathmatical equations. In english, students can analyse characters from different points of view. In every class, students will learn to work together efficiently to gather and organize ideas. Sadly, some students believe "it is a waste of time listening to peers compared to listening to teachers.

Read More
411 Words | 2 Pages

As the digital age comes upon us, more and more Americans become dissatisfied with the state of literacy in this generation. Because the Internet paves the way for shorter and shorter interactions, namely articles versus novels and six-second viral videos versus films, many people that grew up in the age of the Internet have a preference for this condensed form of entertainment. Dana Gioia of The New York Times asserts in his essay “Why Literature Matters” that the decline of reading in America is destined to have a negative impact on society as a whole. Gioia opens his essay with a bittersweet account of which trend is occurring in the twenty-first century America arts scene. He notes that as college attendance rates blossom, the interest

Read More
214 Words | 1 Pages

Flashback to my junior year. I sat quietly in my AP Lang class as my teacher, Mrs. Fisher, announced that the reading competition between the language arts classes called for the book count for September. She stood at the board, marker in hand, staring out expectantly at her large class. Hands shot up across the classroom, and my own nervous hand rose up to join them. Mrs. Fisher happily chalked up the small fortune of books that our class had read.

Read More
269 Words | 2 Pages

In this article “ Why literature matters” by Dana Gioia explains that American art has changed. It points out the fact that literary knowledge is declining. Some of the changes that were pointed out is that most people no longer read. His main purpose is to encourage people to begin to read again and that will help them improve their intellectual level. In the article Gioia expresses reasoning and includes evidence of the importance of reading.

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

Reader-Response Criticism is as important as the author is since; readers are active participants in literary works and has his or her own opinion, understanding and image of the work read. Even though the interpretation may look similar from one person to another, nonetheless, there will always be a slight difference in how it is perceived. According to Barnet, Burto, and Cain (2011), readers are to give a response that cannot be compared to the real life. “At one extreme are those who say that our response to a work of literature should be purely aesthetic- a response to a work of art-and not the response we would have to something comparable in real life” (p. 1745). Moreover, it is also important for readers to keep in mind that

Read More
807 Words | 4 Pages

She believes the syllabus provided to students do not include any challenging books, and her belief toward high school teachers becoming too lazy to examine thoroughly if the book the education system provides them with represent any true and significant value is a recurring concern of hers’- therefore ineffective to students. All in all, Prose used ethos, pathos, logos and the usage of specific words to help her argument. She successfully persuades her point of view and makes it clear that if schools want their curriculum to improve, they must change their way of teaching and push their students to view literature in a new

Read More
1859 Words | 8 Pages

This endeavor is to present a unique combination of visual art with literature. Visual art in literature is commonly referred to as “Ekphraisis”*, or as Horace coined his famous dictum “Ut picture poesis”*. Several other writers have rejected the idea of Ekphraisis, based on the fact that language is linear while visual art is spatial. I suggest that our ancients were correct in instituting a relation between the words and art. I feel that one can accomplish a greater understanding of the two if they are either compared or understood in companionship reading, running parallel to each other.

Read More

More about Literature Circles

Related Topics

Open Document