ipl-logo

Macbeth Fate Vs Free Will

1608 Words7 Pages

The nature of fate and free will has puzzled philosophers for thousands of years. Some argue that there is no free will and everything is predestined, while others argue that humans make their own choices. Stephen Hawking once said, “I have noticed even people who claim everything is predestined, and that we can do nothing to change it, look before they cross the road.” Even though people may believe in fate, they don’t believe in it enough to trust it fully. The playwright Shakespeare explores this theme of fate vs free will in multiple plays, one of which includes Macbeth. Shakespeare uses multiple characters to demonstrate this theme, with Macbeth being the most prominent. Macbeth’s varying levels of confidence lead to his increasing reliance …show more content…

As he is on his way to kill Duncan, he meets Banquo and says, “I think not of them. Yet when we can entreat an hour to serve, we would spend it in some words when that business, If you would grant the time” (II.i.21-23). Macbeth chooses not to speak to Banquo over the prophecy of the witches. At this time Macbeth’s confidence is lowering because he feels conflicted about killing Duncan. Speaking with Banquo would most likely persuade him not to kill Duncan, and Banquo would notice the guilt on his face. Macbeth’s poor confidence pressures him to not discuss his fated prophecy, showing he is still clinging to his free will. However, Macbeth’s confidence begins to lower even more as he creeps closer to Duncan’s bedchamber. Macbeth begins to hallucinate and cries, “Is this a dagger which I see before me, the handle toward my hand? Come, let me clutch thee… Thou marshall’st me the way that I was going...It is the bloody business which informs thus to mine eyes… While I threat he lives. Words to the heat of deeds too cold breath gives” (II.i.44-55). Macbeth hallucinates a dagger and believes that he is doing so because of the murder he is about to commit. He also says that he must hurry to kill Duncan before his courage cools. The way Macbeth reacts after seeing the dagger makes it seem as if he has no choice in following the dagger, which demonstrates how strongly he is relying on fate. He is so unsure and conflicted about the murder, that he is hallucinating a dagger to help him follow through with it. Without his wholehearted reliance on fate, Macbeth would not have been able to murder Duncan. Overall, Macbeth’s confidence continues to decrease which shifts his reliance on free will to reliance on

Show More
Related
664 Words | 3 Pages

Macbeth struggles with the decision of whether or not he should kill Duncan. He is drowning in the desire for power and hallucinates a dagger that will allow him to kill Duncan. “Is this a dagger that I see before me? The handle toward my

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

Macbeth battles this conflict until his conscious is flooded with dark desires, his call upon evil to wash away his good, and his desire for power. At the beginning of the soliloquy, Macbeth’s imagination started to corrupt his mind; he began to hallucinate a bloody dagger floating in front of him, which was the product of his guilty conscious due to his contemplation to kill the king, which is the byproduct of his quest for power. “A dagger of the mind, a false creation/ Proceeding from the heat -oppressed brain?”

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

If someone is told that they will become a millionaire in the future, will they spend their money right away or wait until they have it? Fate is the concept that destinies have been predetermined regardless of one’s choices, whereas free will is the idea that one can choose their destiny. In most cases, people have a choice in their own destiny. William Shakespeare's play, "The Tragedy of Macbeth", Macbeth is told the prophecy that he would first be named Thane of Cawdor then king, however he misinterprets it and goes to extreme lengths to become king, ultimately resulting in the deaths of Duncan and Banquo. Macbeth is driven by his craving for power, causing him to think deeper to achieve his fate.

Read More
3092 Words | 13 Pages

Macbeth’s hallucinations of the bloody dagger in his hand reflect the small part of him that knows that what he is doing is wrong, as the image of the bloody dagger is meant to scare him, to make him feel threatened, and to let him embrace the small part of him that knows the immorality of his doings. These hallucinations serve as a self-conscious warning to himself because his nature was initially vulnerable; he was not willing to murder the

Read More
696 Words | 3 Pages

In Act II of Shakespeare’s play, characters commit a gruesome and corrupt crime that cannot be reversed. By murdering King Duncan, Macbeth will fulfill his prophecy of becoming King of Scotland. Because Macbeth knows what he is about to do is wrong, he is approached by a floating dagger before entering King Duncan’s room, “art thou not, fatal vision, sensible to feeling as to sight … a dagger of

Read More
780 Words | 4 Pages

Macbeth is seen as a noble, honest, loyal, and brave soldier. Not until he heard about the prophecies that led to his downfall. The exploration of fate versus freewill becomes a central topic in the play, as some argue it is Macbeth’s own choices that lead to his downfall, and some believe it is his predetermined fate that causes all the tragic events that happened in the play. The exploration of fate and free will reveals a delicate balance between predetermined events and Macbeth’s own actions. While the prophecies and supernatural elements suggest his fate, Macbeth’s choices, internal struggles, and the influence of external factors demonstrate the significant role of freewill in shaping the tragic outcome of the play.

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

Consequently, Macbeth hallucinates and this event represents his guilt before even committing the act. Macbeth is wracked with guilt over what he is about to do, and his mind races with thoughts of such evil action. Because of his own ambition, the decision to murder Duncan is supported by the prophecies of the Witches as well as the encouragement of his wife. He first sees a dagger hanging mid-air, “Is this a dagger which I see before me” (2.1.41) and with “gouts of blood” (2.1.54) dripping from it. Even though guilt and insanity are weighing him down, he still decides to kill Duncan and follows his

Read More
1489 Words | 6 Pages

“With this speech, Shakespeare foreshadows the toll that Duncan 's murder will exact upon the conspirators. For now, the appearance of a bloody dagger in the air unsettles Macbeth. Even he doesn 't know whether the dagger is real or a figment of his guilty imagination. It is, however, certainly a harbinger of bloodier visions to come. Macbeth will suffer more frightening

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

Fate, destiny, prophecy all important pieces of tall tales, stories, and legends, that give everything and everyone an unchangeable path. In the play, Macbeth by William Shakespeare, the lives of man are once more played to the tune of a mischievous master. Though throughout the tale, Macbeth seemingly has free will, but in the end, realizes that he was just a pawn in someone’s game to be thrown away at a moment’s notice. As shown throughout the Book many times the witches tell Macbeth of his demise showing that he had truly no control of what was to come. In this case as in all cases the creator is at fault for creating Macbeth to bring horror, pain, and death to all those he betrayed.

Read More
323 Words | 2 Pages

One can see that fate and free will both have their proper places within the context of Shakespeare's play. Both themes contribute to Macbeth’s personality and overall character but one stands tall above the other. Said theme is most certainly Free Will. Within the context of the narrative, free will is far more important to the story. While fate drives Macbeth to perform the actions he does throughout the story, said actions are still of his own free will.

Read More
824 Words | 4 Pages

Macbeths guilty conscience makes him unable to play the ‘true’ role of a villain of the play. Macbeth begins to see ‘false creations’ before murdering Duncan; the image of a floating dagger taunts Macbeth’s senses. Macbeth is devoured in his anxiety he starts to hallucinate the crime before going through with it. Macbeth is unable to dispose thoughts of his guilt and doubt, which prevents him from being stuck at the point where it is too late to turn back, yet the fear of his nature prevents him from turning completely into a ruthless coldblooded

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

He says, “Is this a dagger which I see before me, The handle toward my hand” (Act 2.1.33-34). Macbeth hallucinates a bloody dagger leading him towards Duncan. He is already filled with guilt, knowing he will forever have Duncan’s blood on his hands. This makes his mind hallucinate a dagger similar to the actual

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

Macbeth had been one of the more popular works of Shakespeare. Like many of his other dramas, the play was a tragedy. Like many of Shakespeare’s plays, Macbeth itself portrays many themes. One recurring theme is the controlling of one’s fate by external forces. Macbeth tells us that fate may be determined, but the way it comes about is through your free will or a man’s free choice.

Read More
787 Words | 4 Pages

This dagger is tempting him to grab it and he says “Thou marshal’st me the way that I was going, And such an instrument I was to use” (2.1.54-55). This line shows how Macbeth already had the plan to use a dagger, and now his mind is tricking him into seeing that same weapon that was to be used. His intentions here are clear because the dagger is involved. In Roman Polanski’s version of this scene in his 2010 remake shows a dagger in front of macbeth. When Macbeth says “I see thee yet” and there is a dagger visible to the audience it makes Macbeth’s scheme to murder Duncan more realistic.

Read More
781 Words | 4 Pages

In Shakespeare’s Macbeth the witches informs Macbeth of his fate that he will become the king in the future. Macbeth believes the witches words and Lady Macbeth persuade him to become the king and murder all the people that get in the way. Shakespeare shows us that fate is complicated by our actions, Macbeth will do anything to meet his fate that in the end lead him to his death because of his greediness.

Read More

More about Macbeth Fate Vs Free Will

Open Document