ipl-logo

ECT Literature Review

1024 Words5 Pages

Literature review Introduction The efficacy of ECT to treat major depressive symptoms has been established by means of multi studies that developed during the last decades. ECT is the most effective physical and biological therapy available for depression, and no other type of therapy up to now has shown to be effective more than it with major depression patients according to controlled trials studies(Antunes et al., 2009). Despite of that there was controversial issues around using of it. The aim of this revision is to present proponents and opponents perspective regarding using of ECT with MDD disorder according to reviews , meta analyses, and randomized clinical trials. Proponents of using ECT with major depressive disorder …show more content…

According to Royal College of Psychiatrists Registered charity that highly recommended using of ECT with MDD under specific conditions , if there was need for quick symptoms relief like suicide and catatonic behavior, using several antidepressant were ineffective, patients intolerance side effects from medication, patient experience and preferred that, and had resistance to other types of treatment(Royal College of Psychiatrists Registered charity, 2015) . People with major depression suffer from poorer Health Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) that measure of a person ability to perform physical and mental health over time. So some studies concern to measure it, for example study done in the Journal of Affective Disorders, the researchers is measured HRQOL in 283 patients they had treatment-resistant depression before ECT, several days after ECT, and 24 weeks after ECT. The researchers found that there was significant improvement in HRQOL in people with major depression (Bjelseth et al., …show more content…

Opponents of using ECT with major depressive disorder Cognitive side effects consider as the main limitation of ECT(Kellner et al., 2010; Prudic, 2008 & Sackeim et al., 2009). Although the decrease symptoms of depression obtained by ECT, the improvement in some neurocognitive functions have been seen, like attention, concentration and general intelligence, some alteration has been observed in abstract thinking and reasoning and creativity (Kellner et al., 2010) . and adverse cognitive effects for examples disorientation, impairment in learning, anterograde and retrograde memory loss , may be happened after a convulsive shock(Prudic, 2008). Other study done by Consoli, De Carvalho, and Cohen (2013) conclude that ECT treatment effect on decreased intellect, attention, executive functions , perception and visual function , also can slower information processing speed and reaction time, additionally may contribute with language

Show More
Related

Assessment Overview Of Pat's Case

997 Words | 4 Pages

Bipolar disorder most often requires pharmacological treatment as an intervention. Less than half of individuals with bipolar disorder are successful with just the pharmacological treatment approach. CBT shows positive results when used together with pharmacological intervention in treating bipolar disorder (Gregory, 2010). Bipolar disorder treatment benefits from CBT as it focuses on improving identifying distorted thoughts, improving communication and problem solving skills, areas that need intervention for individuals with bipolar disorder. CBT is effective in teaching coping skills to address times when symptoms are first displayed, but are not at top severity (Driessen & Hollon, 2010, p. 544).

Read More

Sherwin Nuland Analysis

263 Words | 2 Pages

I really enjoyed this talk by Sherwin Nuland about how he became so severely depressed due to a bad marriage that even the doctors thought nothing could be done for him. They felt the only thing left that might fix him, was a pre-fontal lobotomy and thankfully for him and for us that did not happen. If he had had a lobotomy, I doubt we would have had the chance to hear that wonderful speech he just gave. Anyhow, I was aware that electroshock convulsive shock therapy is one of the last resort treatments for depression and that it can help those that are severely depressed when nothing else would work. In fact, my husband’s grandmother received a form of it called insulin shock therapy for her depression many decades ago.

Read More

Psy 270 Week 2 Compare And Contrast Depression And Anxiety

497 Words | 2 Pages

Medication, like SSRIs, help balance these chemicals. Along with proper medication, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) or psychotherapy can effectively help sufferers of anxiety and depression recover from their disorder. This type of therapy slowly eradicates the fear, stress and pessimism the sufferer feels by changing the way he or she views the situations and events surrounding their life. Most sufferers of this disorder over exaggerate things, leading to excessive worrying, anxiety and depression. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy also employs methods such as proper breathing, meditation and visualization to teach patients to take control over their anxiety and

Read More

Biomedical Therapies: Electroconvulsive Therapy

303 Words | 2 Pages

Concluding, that taking antidepressants may be a more easier approach for someone with depression. Other than antidepressants, electroconvulsive therapy, also known as shock therapy, is another therapy that falls under the biomedical approach. Electroconvulsive therapy is used for people with severe depressive disorder (Hockenbury and Hockenbury 2013). Electroconvulsive therapy is used when people with depression do not respond to antidepressants. When undergoing electroconvulsive therapy, the patient is given a brief shock resulting in a mild-brain seizure.

Read More

Li-Cbt Guided Self Help Literature Review

1105 Words | 5 Pages

1.3.4 Low Intensity-CBT (Li-CBT) guided self-help “With the increased prevalence of depression around the world, there is a growing need for assessing effective therapeutic interventions that are cost-effective, time limited interventions, to help improve outcomes and to be used as preventive measures as well. The Increasing Access to Psychological Services (IAPT) programme in England was developed in 2006 to test the effectiveness of providing significant increases in evidence-based psychological therapy services to people with the common mental health problems of depression and anxiety disorders (Juice, 2011). Being a new protocol of intervention for mild and moderate depression, there is few literatures referring to Li-CBT guided self-help

Read More

Biological Vs Psychodynamic

1012 Words | 5 Pages

Patients are prescribed psychotropic medications to help regulate their moods and effect the emotions and thought processes of each patient, (Comer, 2014). Most practitioners believe that all psychiatric and behavioral disorders are the result of a brain dysfunction that requires the use of medication, (Loewit-Phillips, P. M., & Goldbas A., 2013). The downside of the use of the psychotropic drugs are that people misuse them and/or become dependent upon them. Electroconvulsive therapy or ECT causes miniature brain seizures in depressed individuals that, after several sessions, will help them to feel less depressed. The last biological treatment known as psychosurgery is an actual surgery that requires the patient’s connections between the frontal lobes and lower regions of the brains to be cut, (Comer, 2014).

Read More

Depression In The 1800s

876 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the nation and our world people are suffering from this disease. Depression effects people of both genders, all ages, and any background. The history of mental illness, specifically depression were extremely helpful in today’s treatment and diagnosis. We know that all individuals are different and because of this, we can assume that each case of mental illness, more specifically depression, is unique in its own way as well. One treatment that is very effective for one person may not be equally as effective in a similar case simply because of the differences in patients.

Read More

Trauma Informed Care Essay

562 Words | 3 Pages

EMDR can help treat mental health conditions that occur due to traumatic events. Although it is best known for treating post-traumatic stress disorder, it can also treat other conditions and offer numerous

Read More

Mindfulness Therapy Annotated Bibliography

1698 Words | 7 Pages

In phase two, the TAU group received the treatment and was assessed both before and after receiving it. The results from this were combined with those receiving MBCT in phase one and the two groups were followed up at three months. It was concluded that MBCT group in phase one had significant improvements and a decrease in anxiety while in phase two, both groups at three month follow up showed statistically significant improvements in both anxiety and depression. It was also concluded that the effect on depression/anxiety was brought about by self-compassion. Although the study was successful and showed positive results, it would be better to use larger sample size for the purpose of a substantial

Read More

Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Case Study

999 Words | 4 Pages

The patient had a full recovery after 11 ECTs. It was found that ECT became a very popular treatment because it was cheaper and could be very effective with 10-20 treatments. A side effect of ECT was retrograde amnesia, so the patients

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Electroconvulsive Therapy

526 Words | 3 Pages

She also says that proposes many psychiatrists consider that ECT is the most successful way to treat patients who do not respond to antidepressants and imperative for preventing suicide attempts. With this therapy there is a risk of having brain damage and the side effects of it. Although I agree with Dahl to a point, I cannot accept her overall conclusion that this therapy is helpful because of the side effects because it can cause brain damage and other problems after the therapy.

Read More

Essay On Antidepressant Medication And Suicide

622 Words | 3 Pages

Results that have come forward from researchers who have been trying to find a correlation between antidepressants and

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Adolescents And Antidepressants

1312 Words | 6 Pages

If antidepressants do not work for the patient there are other clincal trial pills that a patients could also take for mild to moderate depression. The University of Vermont’s Emily Tarleton researched a clinical trial for an over the counter magnesium pill. “Consumption of magnesium chloride for six weeks resulted in a clinically significant improvement in measures of depression and anxiety symptoms” (Nachbur). This treatment relieved the patients symptoms, some as early as two weeks.

Read More

Adequacy Of Dmt

1512 Words | 7 Pages

Inquire about in the field of DMT is developing, and 17 years have passed since the last and just general meta-examination on DMT was led. This study analyzes the current state of learning in regards to the adequacy of DMT and move from 23 essential trials (N =1078) on the variables of personal satisfaction, self-perception, prosperity, and clinical results, with sub-examination of sorrow, nervousness, and interpersonal fitness. Results recommend that DMT and move are successful for expanding personal satisfaction and diminishing clinical manifestations, for example, misery and tension. Positive impacts were likewise found on the increment of subjective prosperity, positive disposition, influence, and self-perception. Impacts for interpersonal ability were empowering, yet because of the heterogeneity of the information stayed uncertain.

Read More

Psychotherapy And Effectiveness

1257 Words | 6 Pages

Effectiveness is defined as the degree to which objectives are achieved and the extent to which targeted problems are solved; the ability to be successful and produce the intended results (Cambridge). Effectiveness is determined without reference to costs and means "doing the right thing" while efficiency means "doing the thing right". Various meta-analysis established the effectiveness of CBT in depression (Hans and Hiller, 2013); Social Anxiety Disorders, General Anxiety Disorders, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Panic Disorder (Stewart and Chambless, 2009); Specific phobia (Wolitzky-Taylor, Horowitz, Powers, and Telch, 2008) in clinical settings. Findings from a meta analysis (Ebert, Carlotta Zarski, Christensen, Stikkelbroek et al, 2015)

Read More

More about ECT Literature Review

Related Topics

Open Document