ipl-logo

Mandatory Treatment Vs Rehabilitation Essay

843 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Drug rehabilitation vs incarceration

For some drug addicts that get incarcerated help may seem far away. For some the thought of getting clean is never going to cross their mind. In some situations, the criminal justice system instead of sending someone to jail or prison they will send them through a legal pressured drug rehabilitation program. These kinds of programs are more effective than the programs offered once incarcerated, which tend to have a success rate of about 11 percent. The big difference between the mandatory treatment and treatment that is provided through the prison system is that it is a more intense program that meets more than one time a day for one hour. This will have a huge impact because they will be spending more time focusing on rehabilitation versus …show more content…

Coerced vs Voluntary Treatment.) it does work and has been tested by the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) and the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) have found out that people who enter the programs because they are ordered by the courts have the same success rate of those who enter because they want to. Even though the rates are similar does not mean that people do not fail and relapse. Mandatory treatment does not work for everyone, this is not to get mixed up with it does not work at all, but it will not work the same for everyone. The same goes for anything else, everyone is different from each other and just because it works for one person does not mean that it will work for everyone. For the people that relapse it can be because they have no personal support through their rehab and once they are out it can be hard to stay clean if they done have different people to be around that want to see them succeed. This can be a weak spot on mandatory treatment because if that person is being made to be there they might not have the extra support that they need to be successful at becoming clean. Now only they might not want to be there in the first place but they also wont have anyone to help motivate them to cure their

Show More
Related
399 Words | 2 Pages

After conducting some research I have reached the conclusion that drug offenders are the population in which could be more successfully controlled and rehabilitated in less secure correctional alternatives. There are a couple different beneficial aspects to transferring drug offenders out of prisons and into programs. The first is that is saves money while also being more effective. When you place an inmate into a program that is designed to help them with their specific problem your results improve. The Center for Substance Abuse Treatment’s final report on NTIES noted that “In summary, we observed a pattern of substantially reduced alcohol and drug use in every type of treatment modality, with reductions typically between one-third and two-thirds

Read More
453 Words | 2 Pages

The prisoners that have struggled with drugs are place in a pre-released program to prepare them for their release. I think the justice system hands are tied a little bit to maintain the prisons and community well

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

Rehabilitation is paramount in order to form a brighter, healthier future. After all, what good to society is a brilliant mind, if a highly disorientating substance continually afflicts it? Most of the time these same people that abuse drugs are the ones being directly affected by some type of outside oppression. Our jails and prisons serve as a type of rehab as well. Once in jail or prison, abusers have no access to illegal drugs and are forced to quit cold turkey from all illegal substances, including nicotine.

Read More
1434 Words | 6 Pages

All the reasons that the mandatory minimum sentencing laws were set into place appear to be good ideas, but they are ineffective. The law has not shown crime reduction. The history of mandatory sentencing in the United states for federal drug crimes had started with the passage of the Sentencing Reform Act of 1984, also known as SRA. Congress had changed sentencing by rejecting the idea or the possibility of

Read More
448 Words | 2 Pages

The idea behind these program was to help treat the offenders for their substance abuse disorders while still holding them accountable for the crime that they had committed (Lutze & Wormer, 2013). Many studies have been conducted in order to assess the effectiveness of drug court programs across the country. In a qualitative study done by Gallagher 100 participants of the drug court program were examined. This study found that of the drug court participants, seventy-nine percent were not rearrested in the follow-up period. Twenty-one percent of those participants were rearrested (Gallagher, 2014).

Read More
520 Words | 3 Pages

Most people in the United States each year go the prison and keep there for non-violent crime, such as drug related offenses. This issue has affected many family’s life for many years and caused the prisoners to deprive from many of their rights. Lacking the appropriate policies for keeping drug related offenses in prison has been a public health crisis and created a new addiction, like penchant for locking people up in prison. The author in this article “prison addiction: why mass incarceration policies must change.” discusses about lacking the appropriate policies for incarceration for non-violent drug related offenses.

Read More
1190 Words | 5 Pages

Drug courts focus on dealing with substance abuse or cases involving alcohol (Patchin & Keveles, 2004). This method desires to effectively battle the drug and alcohol problem by specifying the type of treatment. The drug courts can center their attention on the addressed drug and alcohol problem faster than traditional courts, while providing offenders with the appropriate method of rehabilitation or treatment. Drug courts: require for offenders to participate in random drug tests, can reward or discipline the offender based on their progress or failure to not to drugs, are available to selected participants, and can help offenders avoid a guilty charge in court if they are successful in their participation in the programs. A useful example regarding drug courts involve individuals who are normal substance abusers, but the traditional courts have found that their methods have not helped the offenders stay out of jail.

Read More
1728 Words | 7 Pages

The Drug Treatment Alternative-to-Prison Program is another attempt to provide better treatment for people who are convicted. The study showed that drug offenders who underwent a treatment program outside of prison had a 26 percent less rate of re-arrest after two years than a control group that was sent to prison (Justice Policy Institute, 2010). Rehabilitative programs like the Second Chance Act and the Drug Treatment Alternative-to-Prison Program has shown to growth and positive

Read More
119 Words | 1 Pages

In 2000, U.S. agencies surpassed the $100-billion-a-day barrier in spending to incarcerate individuals with serious addiction problems. Rehabilitating and managing offenders who misuse alcohol has proven to be extraordinarily difficult. Despite traditional sanctions and ever-increasing terms of incarceration, addiction drives many of these offenders to continue committing crimes, resulting in a revolving door. Alcohol- and drug-involved offenders are overwhelming the criminal justice system, creating unwieldy court dockets, burdensome caseloads, and overcrowded jails and prisons. Yet, programs and sanctions have had little impact on the rate of alcohol-involved crime.

Read More
237 Words | 1 Pages

Thus an assumption can be made that incarceration by itself is a rehabilitative method. While this is true in many ways, going cold turkey off of drugs does nothing to treat their minds, and habits when free. By having these programs available to all prisoners it will allow them to work out their problems

Read More
1233 Words | 5 Pages

If an addiction is caught before any arrests are made, and the user is willing, they will most likely go to rehab. Also, in some cases they will be given a choice in court between going to rehab and going to jail. In a typical drug and alcohol rehab facility they will start with intake, where they will see if you're a correct fit for the treatment plan, they would then move on to detox which is a service to assist with withdrawal, and for the remainder of the time they would go to multiple therapy sessions throughout the day. After rehab some recovering addicts will go to Narcotics Anonymous meetings to help them stay on the right track. According to rehabs.com, only a third of people who have been sober for less than a year will stay sober, and if one makes it to five years of sobriety their chance of relapse is less than 15

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

Rehabilitation gives the person a chance to learn about his/her problems and offers them to learn how to change their behavior in order to not commit crime while incarceration puts the offender in a cell in order for one to think about the crime he/she committed. Rehab is suppose to help ease the offender 's reentry. Unlike rehabilitation, punishment does not offer one help, unless one is in the process of rehabilitation or other alternative programs while “behind bars.” Incarceration is widely used in the adult system, while rehabilitation is a selective program which is not always offered to all or at specific locations. It is possible that rehabilitation can be related to drugs such as drug addiction rehab, alcohol addiction rehab, violent behavior rehab, gambling addiction rehab, and even many more.

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

Why we should incarcerate drug users Currently one of the less heated but still talked about debates is the issue of what we should do with those who have been caught using illegal substances. Some people say that we should be giving them rehab, and some say that they deserve to be in their. Both sides have their points, but the evidence points towards incarceration being a better option. The reason our judicial system incarcerates drug abusers are because enforcement will discourage drug use, it will keep them away from innocent people, and it will punish the addicts so they know not to do it again.

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

According to americanaddictioncenters.org (Oct 21, 2022), the levels and types of treatments are detoxification where it helps patients stabilize and overcome symptoms of withdrawal, inpatient/residential rehab where patients will receive supervised treatments and structured care plans to help them overcome their addiction, and outpatient rehab where patients go to their treatments and therapy on their own and at their own time without supervision. Treatment can be a very long process and it is important that it goes step by step to ensure that a patient doesn’t relapse. Relapses can be very dangerous and common but with effective treatment they should be less likely to happen. In brief, there are numerous treatments to help people dealing with substance

Read More
2078 Words | 9 Pages

This leads to the question of whether the justice system is doing an adequate job of dealing with drug addiction. Instead of incarcerating people for drug abuse, an alternative is treating victims by rehab and treatment. This paper will exam why treatment is the superior option for

Read More

More about Mandatory Treatment Vs Rehabilitation Essay

Related Topics

Open Document