ipl-logo

Maus Should Be Banned Essay

1671 Words7 Pages

Maus is a graphic novel that explains well what the author, Art Spiegelman’s father, experienced during the holocaust as a jewish man. The book was put in school libraries where students were able to be taught a lesson about the Holocaust through the eyes of Vladek, a jewish mouse, against the German cats, alongside Polish pigs. According to the school board in Tennessee, the novel was not suitable for children, therefore they banned the book from certain schools due to offensive language, disturbing imagery and nudity. But was their reasoning truly valid? I believe that school board should not have banned Maus, seeing how it is a novel about the truth and experiences of a Jewish person in the Holocaust according to the author, as well as, …show more content…

And with the current debate on why the school board is banning the book and what’s right for the students, it is honestly more problematic to ban the book than to use the novel as a teaching tool. If they want to teach students about the Holocaust, why teach it any way other than truthfully? Students are already very unaware about multiple tragedies that have occured in their own country. The Every Child Matters movement had a huge spike in popularity last year after multiple bodies of Indigenous children were found and most people were just finding out about residential schools and how poorly it impacted Indigenous people and their future generations to come. So, is the Holocaust the next mark in history that is soon to be forgotten just because America wants to look good and supposedly wants to “protect their children”? Even if they want to teach the youth about the Holocaust, they want it in a fuzzier and gentler way so that America seems as though they were innocent and were right about what had happened. Many teachers believe that the Tennessee school board's goal is to whitewash history. That the school board’s are in fact, “Opposed to any effort to coerce belief, suppress opinion or punish those whose expression does not conform to what is deemed orthodox in history, politics or beliefs.” It seems to be an unfettered swapping of ideas that are indispensable to keep a free democratic society. History is no longer dates that must be memorized, rather, it is events that lead to the understanding of the present day and it helps to take repercussions for the future. While “Maus” is not a teaching tool and it’s goal was not made to be so, it is a personal element that compels an authentic story. Consequently, why would the novel be banned from school

Show More
Related

Catcher In The Rye Banning Analysis

423 Words | 2 Pages

Blei’s argument, as to why banning the book is counter productive, is very insightful. While other critics argue that the profanities in the book should be ignored when considering banning the book, Blei accepts the profanities and points out that there are a multitude of other ways for kids to be exposed to such things in their

Read More

Banning Books Like Maus By Gwen Katz Analysis

1378 Words | 6 Pages

In the article there is not much of a rebuttal, but it can be assumed where one is. John Boyne wrote his novel The Boy in the Striped Pajamas telling a story of the Holocaust about a boy who befriended a Jewish boy on the other side of a fence. Katz and Vishny don’t support the book’s purpose, “nevertheless, this book and others like it are often used to teach the Holocaust because, regardless of their intent, these narratives do not challenge or educate readers, but serve to comfort them”(Katz and Vishny 6). The authors touch on the false comfort these books give throughout their article. The point they made was strong, and evident when the audience researches what books are taught in school, and which are banned.

Read More

Board Of Education Vs Pico Case Study

1091 Words | 5 Pages

The board then removed the books claiming they were “anti-American” and that it was the board’s duty to protect their children from moral danger as well as physical and mental ones (FindLaw). Of course, this angered some students so much that some of them -- most notably Steven Pico -- decided to take it to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York. At the district court, the defendants argued that since “the books offended their [the board’s/PONYU] social, political, and moral tastes and not

Read More

8th Grade Should Be Taught The Holocaust Essay

568 Words | 3 Pages

Many people don’t know about the Holocaust or only know that it happened during the time of WW2. The Holocaust was the mass massacre 6 million of Jews and other minorities in Europe by the Nazi regime. Some people might not want their kids to be taught this in 8th grade because they believe that their children’s minds will be polluted by thoughts of killing and extended torture. Students in 8th grade should definitely be taught about the Holocaust because it is necessary to teach them to learn from history and never judge anyone by their race, and finally explain to them that being silent towards others suffering can lead to mass destruction over a period of time.

Read More

Should To Kill A Mockingbird Be Banned In Schools

731 Words | 3 Pages

Nothing like the Holocaust has happened since because people have learned from their mistakes. If school students are

Read More

Banning To Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee

844 Words | 4 Pages

Some school districts believe it is an inappropriate book to be showing their students because of the racial content. It shouldn’t be banned because of history, its representation of empathy and justice, and its literary value and success. Some people believe it’s a hard topic which I agree with, but you need to teach hard topics to get the point across and help educate the youth about bad times so it doesn’t happen again. We need to preserve historic items, not throw them away and forget about them; we wouldn’t just scrap the Titanic. To Kill a

Read More

The Diary Of Anne Frank By Elie Wiesel

589 Words | 3 Pages

Ultimately, if kids in history class learn about this at a young age, then it should stop it from happening in the future. The Holocaust is significant because you will be able to learn about the sympathy of those who suffered. In the book “The Diary of Anne Frank” Anne Frank and her Jewish family hid in the attic for over 2 years, a girl by the name of Miep had been supplying the Jewish family with ration books but the people from whom Miep got the ration books from had been arrested so Anne states “So we have had to cut down on our food. Our stomachs are so empty

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Should The Holocaust Be Taught In Schools?

819 Words | 4 Pages

Should the Holocaust be Taught in School? The Holocaust was a tragic event that killed and scarred millions. It is of the common misconception that only Jews were scarred by The Holocaust, however, the reality is that anyone that did not fit the expectation of Hitler perceived to be of a correct breed was killed, exiled, or imprisoned. Although this was a tragic and turning point of history, many claim it should not be taught in schools.

Read More

Why Should Maus Not Be Banned

557 Words | 3 Pages

The book Maus 1 written by Art Spiegelman should not be banned from Owensboro Middle School (OMS) based on the content found throughout the book because it goes against the principles of free speech and it also helps us understand the Holocaust.

Read More

How Should Of Mice And Men Be Banned

902 Words | 4 Pages

This particular party of people feels that these depictions allow readers to be educated on the wrongdoings of the past, and can help prevent a repeat in history. Shauna Smith explains, “It is a book that provides a snapshot of America; although this snapshot is not indicative of the entire country, it is still based in truth and reality…by banning the book, we are effectively stating that the events that occur within it are either untrue, taboo, or preposterous. These are exactly the types of topics that need to be discussed openly” (Jade Davis). Topics loaded with heavy content need to be explained to younger generations so that they may understand why certain actions have negative impacts on society. Kids are taught about slavery in school so that they can learn from mistakes in history and not repeat them.

Read More

Should The Holocaust Be Taught In Schools Essay

893 Words | 4 Pages

That's just another reason we need to teach kids about the holocaust, but don't stop there. We need to teach them about all the genocide events that took place. They need to learn about the flaws of their world, so they can fix them. In conclusion, the holocaust should be taught in schools because, it teaches students about the thin line between good and evil, it was a major event of history in the 20th century, they should know the past early so they can prepare for the future, and it helps them deal with the world they live in

Read More

Should 8th Graders Study The Holocaust Essay

762 Words | 4 Pages

Should 8th Graders Study the Holocaust? The Holocaust was a devastating event that happened in 1933 that affected many Germans. Should such an tragedy even be taught to eighth graders? I believe eighth graders should study the Holocaust because it helps them understand what it would be like at that age and helps combat Holocaust denial, and teaching them at a younger age could be bad because they are more immature about this sensitive topic.

Read More

Why Should The Holocaust Be Taught In Schools

475 Words | 2 Pages

The Holocaust Debate The Holocaust was the ordered procedure, state sponsored persecution that killed about 6 million Jews by the Nazi’s rule of government. The Holocaust should be taught in schools because they are old enough, they can learn from their ancestors mistakes, and some say teaching the Holocaust may desensitize students which may not be necessarily true. Students are old enough to learn about the Holocaust because it teaches students that life isn’t some fairy land.

Read More

The Importance Of Teaching The Holocaust In Schools

1223 Words | 5 Pages

Does it make sense to teach the Holocaust in schools? You might offend someone, but it is worth being educated about the Holocaust. As the famous philosopher George Santayana said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” This is true as many events in history have been repeated, such as discrimination against different races such as Jews (Jews were not let into America for a good portion of the Holocaust) and now discrimination against Muslims in America. Students in 8th grade and older should be taught the Holocaust so that they can learn valuable life lessons and help make sure it never happens again.

Read More

Holocaust Reaction Paper

541 Words | 3 Pages

The Holocaust is a terribly tragic event that has effected the lives of all Jewish people. Although the Holocaust took place approximately 70 years ago, we must never forget those who have lost their lives during the Holocaust and the mark it has left on our Jewish society. I have learnt and spoken about the Holocaust each year at school, although I do not attend a jewish high school the school board understands how important it is to discuss and learn about this tragedy in history. I have heard so many of the terrible stories and facts about the Holocaust. My teachers have spoken about the different concentration camps and the torture methods that have been put upon the Jews.

Read More

More about Maus Should Be Banned Essay

Related Topics

Open Document