ipl-logo

Mcmahan And The Upper Brain Criterion Of Death

1370 Words6 Pages

Sarah Shaut
PHI 237
Paper Topic #7
11/6/2017
McMahan and the Upper Brain Criterion of Death Determining when someone dies has been an important issue in medicine. There are many contradicting views on the specific criteria for death. Some people believe that death has one concept in which it is an irreversible biological phenomenon. Professor of philosophy, Jeff McMahan believes there is a need for two senses of death: a biological sense and one where you cease to exist. There is a difference between the organism dying and ceasing to exist. An organism can be dead, but the person does not cease to exist until it disintegrates because the organism’s body is still there. The upper brain criterion suggests that death occurs when there is an irreversible …show more content…

Bernat believes that the upper brain criterion of death would pronounce many patients in persistent vegetative state and possibly severely demented patients as dead even though they are spontaneously breathing. Even though they have lost the ability to gain experience and incorporate social skills through conscious function, Bernat believes they are alive because their circulatory and respiratory systems are still functioning and in order for the organism to be dead, the entire brain and circulatory-respiratory system must not be functioning (Bernat). Bernat’s view suggests that death is explicitly biological and something that happens to organisms. Since we are human organisms, then our death means the death of a human organism. McMahan believes this assumes the person and the organism are identical to each other and that the concept of death is univocal. A problem would occur when considering the dicephalic-conjoined twin example. If the organism were identical to the person, then the conjoined twins is one person. Most do not believe this would be accurate because it is clear to see two separate people each with their own personalities and own ability to consciously function. This suggests that death needs to have more than one concept: death of a person and the death of an organism. It seems to make more sense to declare a person dead based on their death as a person because they can no longer communicate their needs, and possibly lose conscious control of their other regulatory functions. This shows just how important the upper brain is. If the person irreversibly lost consciousness, the person has ceased to exist even though the organism may still be functioning. The person is no longer there and will never come

Show More
Related
1766 Words | 8 Pages

On January 11, 1983 Nancy Cruzan lost control of her vehicle and was ejected from the car. She was found face down in a ditch with no pulse or breathing, paramedics were able to resuscitate her. “The Missouri trial court in this case found that permanent brain damage generally results

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

Death is like an object lit on fire. Once the object has been swallowed by the flames, there is nothing left but ashes of the object, it is irreversible, evil. When one is to think about death, they promptly think of things like wicked, evil, and darkness. they wonder, how can it have the nerve to be so cruel. Some could furthermore wonder if in some world, if death could be taken into a conscious form, what would it have to say for itself?

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

For example, in the book, person “H” was brain dead, but her heart, liver, and other body organs are still functioning. The chapter also provides information on a time in history when it was hard to determine if a person was brain dead. “Before brain activity could be measured, the stopping of the heart had long been considered the defining moment.” (Chapter 8, page 170) Sometimes finding a heartbeat was difficult and lots of people feared being buried alive.

Read More
875 Words | 4 Pages

Death isnt always refering to a body even though we often times think of it that way. In the memoir Night by: Elie Wiesel there are many instances of non-physicals deaths thoughout out the events that occur. In this memoir the examples of figuritive death are non stop. Three main instances are the death of freedom,the death of identity, and the most important the death of faith. Death is not just physical but figurtive displayed by Elie Weisel in the memoir of Night.

Read More
455 Words | 2 Pages

There are many cases on people who are brain dead. For example, George Pickering was pronounced brain dead. The doctors wanted to take him off of life support but his father said that he was going to die with his son by killing himself with a gun. Before the father did anything else he told his son to squeeze his hand. George squozed his dad’s hand and then the father repeated himself once more.

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

The brain is a vital and complex organ. “It controls everything that is happening in the body, like breathing and heartbeats. Therefore, if the brain stops working, the individual is brain dead. This does not mean that the individual is in a coma. It means that the person is dead but the heart is still beating thanks to life support”, (“Brain death”).

Read More
1092 Words | 5 Pages

In contrast, Scheffler’s characterization, which he terms the collective afterlife, holds that (1) biological death means

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

This argument is based on three criteria. The first criterion is the termination thesis, which states that one ceases to exist at death, this

Read More
1354 Words | 6 Pages

Each hemisphere of the man’s brain is then separately transplanted into the two waiting bodies. The aim of this case for Parfit is to establish whether or not the man survives. It has been proven

Read More
329 Words | 2 Pages

In Martin Heidegger's Being and Time, he argues that in order to be an authentic self, one must think about death as subjective. First, an authentic self is to be able to reflect and know what is truly important in one's own personal life, to be subjective. Nevertheless, Heidegger believes in his argument by how people see death as an event in life, an event that people see the possibility of happening in the future. Heidegger argues this because people need to see that one's death is only one's own stage in life. Thinking of death will lead the person to realize one's own death is subjective.

Read More
409 Words | 2 Pages

A sunset or a bee or something By using something to show that death is no different from life, are we confronting the idea of death or are we deflecting it? Can anything accurately represent death? Juxtaposition of light opposing dark, a decision to make Choose heaven

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

1. In the textbook, the author discusses organ donation. Take a stance and argue – do you think definitions of death should be created which allow for more organ donation? Is it ethical to ‘define’ death for functional purposes?

Read More
466 Words | 2 Pages

For me, there is really no concept about death. Every one of us are going to die when the day comes. We will not know and we really do not know when are we going to experience death. All of us has no idea about it.

Read More
1340 Words | 6 Pages

As modern medicine has advanced and the use of life sustaining technology has become more mainstream, a greater number of families and doctors are being faced with an important decision; when to use artificial organs, and when to shut them off. It’s a decision that haunts people long after it is made (Park). The topic of whether or not life support should be used for long periods of time to sustain brain dead patients is heavily debated. Many believe that brain death, a condition in which one loses all brain function and brain stem reflexes, is the same as final death. Science also points in this direction, and many doctors agree that brain dead patients should be removed from life support because they are technically already dead (Rubin).

Read More
913 Words | 4 Pages

A soul is part of a jiva, a living being, who goes through the concept of Karma. Death is therefore a natural process in the existence of a jiva, as a resting period during which it reenergizes and adjusts its course to return to the next phase of life. Buddhist and Hindu religions share similar stages of the transitionary

Read More

More about Mcmahan And The Upper Brain Criterion Of Death

Related Topics

Open Document