ipl-logo

Monkey's Paw Compare And Contrast Essay

446 Words2 Pages

“The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs and “What of this Goldfish Would You Wish?” by Egaret Keret are both exciting fictional short stories that engage the reader. There are many differences as well as similarities between the two stories. Overall, the two stores are more diverse. The differences lie in the areas of character traits and plot.
Even though “The Monkey’s Paw” and “What of this Goldfish Would You Wish?” have many similarities, evidence shows the two stories have less in common. Many of the differences ly within plot. In “The Monkey’s Paw” the characters are given 3 wishes from a magical monkey paw, but with the wishes comes terrible consequences. After wishing for 200 pounds, Mr. and Mrs.White are given the dreadful news that their …show more content…

In “What of this Goldfish Would You Wish?” Sergei shows many positive character traits throughout the story. Sergei proves that he cares about other people over himself, and is considerate of others feelings. Sergei proves he is kind by using one of his wishes to cure his girlfriend’s son. “The Monkey’s Paw” Mr. and Mrs. White show more negative positive traits than positive. Mr.White is selfish with his wishes and is inconsiderate for what others might want. Mr.White uses his first wish to ask for 200 pounds to pay off the rest of his house mortgage, which is only beneficial for him. Although the stories consist mostly of differences, there are also a few similarities. In both stories the characters get 3 wishes from personified objects. In “The Monkey’s Paw” Mr. and Mrs.White received a cursed monkey paw that allows 3 men 3 wishes. In “What of this Goldfish Would You Wish?” Sergei received a magical talking goldfish that granted him 3 wishes.
In spite of the similarities the stories are different in more ways than one. The stories are different through the plot and character traits. The stories contain many examples of different plots, along with completely different character traits. The two stories compared together are only similar in one way, while the differences are

Show More
Related
298 Words | 2 Pages

In this essay, i will be telling you about the two stories that we read. First, i will be telling you about “The Monkey’s Paw.” , it’s a story Sergeant Major Moris brings The White family a magic monkey paw that grants any three wishes that you want. The next story is “The Third Wish.” which is about a man that frees a swan that is in trouble that turns out to be the king of the forest.

Read More
466 Words | 2 Pages

The two stories, Drumbeats and Bullets and The Drummer Boy of Shiloh have many comparisons and contrasts. One story is mostly fact based, while the other is more of a story. Both stories have facts about the life in war as a drummer boy. Johnny Clem (from Drumbeats and Bullets) and Joby (from The Drummer boy of Shiloh) can relate in many different ways.they also have factors that make them very different.

Read More
730 Words | 3 Pages

Although there are many differences between the two, there are also many similarities. Like how in both the movie and the novel she outsmarts the

Read More
519 Words | 3 Pages

One being how they display Old Scratch. In both tales, Old Scratch is displayed as his sinister man who wants nothing but your soul. He does everything in his power to get what he wants. A quote states, “These he offered to place within Tom Walker’s reach, having conceived an especial kindness for him; but they were to be had on certain conditions. ”(Irving 317)

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

Thesis: In The Monkey's Paw by W.W Jacobs, the realistic essence of the monkey's paw made it fundamentally creepy. Point 1: The monkey's paw is a symbol for inclination for greed, exposing our superior wants as people, even the most humble. Point 2: Consequences for the actions of those using the paw develops the image of regret and fear. Point 3:

Read More
1716 Words | 7 Pages

Although, they have similarity, the two stories has major differences also. First, both author differs the way they introduce and develop their lead characters to the reader. Second, they also differ in perspective from which their stories are being told. Third, they differs on the choice of settings and how it impact to the stories.

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine you were granted three wishes; and that's all. You can make whatever wishes you desire, but if not justifiable or reasonable, there could be a price to pay. The short story "The Monkey's Paw" by W.W. Jacobs discusses the alarming tale of an older couple being granted "three wishes" from a monkey's paw given to them. However, the purpose of the paw isn't to grant wishes; it is to show that you shouldn't change your fate. The film adaptation of the short story by Ricky Lewis Jr. also showcases that moral.

Read More
675 Words | 3 Pages

Shamyra Thompson Fiction Compare and Contrast Essay ENG 102-B27 Liberty University Outline Thesis: In the short, fictional stories, “The Rocking-Horse Winner” and “The Lottery”, they both share some similarities with each other, however there are differences in both of their plot, conflicts and structures. I. In both of the short stories, both of the main characters dies, but their conflicts are very different, as well as happens differently.

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

In the story “The Monkey’s Paw” there was a small amount of cause and effect events, these cause and effect events create different feelings like suspense and much more. Mr. White told a story about the monkey’s paw after hearing it he wanted to test it to see if it was true he then wished for 200 pounds. The next day a soldier came to their house, saying their son had died, but they got the two hundred pounds they wished for, this happened all because he wished for two hundred pounds its simple

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

Two stories and two magical wishes. The Monkey’s Paw and the Story of an Hour share several similarities throughout the passage. In the beginning of each passage, the author creates a sense of mystery and curiosity for the readers. As each passage reveals the characters in the story, the reader begins to relate the characters role from each story and how they act towards the conflict in the text. These different events, conflicts, or plot in both stories connect with death and wishes.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

In the story “The Monkey’s Paw” the theme is don’t mess with fate and this story elements like character, setting, and plot all help contribute to the theme. The character’s emotions, reaction, and actions are a significant role in revealing the theme. The setting, though not realized as much actually shapes the story too. As normal, plot most definitely contributes to the theme. The character’s reaction contributes to the theme.

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

In This Goldfish, Would You Wish, Sergei withholds bringing a boy, Yonaton, back from the dead so he can keep the fish as company. In The Fisherman and His Wife, the fisherman's wife,IIsebill, wanted to selfishly have whatever the next best thing was, even when she had it good already. In both text, the three wishes are used in the same manner, but for different

Read More
445 Words | 2 Pages

The poem and folktale The Old Grandfather and His Little Grandson and Abuelito Who are similar and different in plenty of ways. One is about someone who is mistreated and one is about someone who dies. One has a narrator and one is told by the granddaughter. Those are just some of the differences. The characters, theme, genre, change in characters, events, and message expressed by theme are different and similar.

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

Some similarities are small, like the magic talking fish; but others, like the underlying motivation to be happy, are very important to the morals of the stories. Both Sergei and the fisherman want to be happy, Sergei wants to be happy alone on quite fishing trips, while the fisherman wants to be happy with his wife. The morals, even though they are tied together, are fairly different. For example, the theme of ‘What of This Goldfish, Would you wish’, doing the right thing, no matter the cost, is not the same as be grateful, which is the theme of ‘The Fisherman and His Wife’. Other differences include: the consequences, setting, and major character motivations.

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

Have you ever watched a suspenseful movie about magic? Have you ever wished you had your own genie that would grant you three wishes? However, the three wishes aren 't exactly what you wished for? Well in the story the Monkey’s Paw that pattern seems to be happening a lot.

Read More

More about Monkey's Paw Compare And Contrast Essay

Related Topics

Open Document