ipl-logo

Murdoch's Utilitarianism: The Ideal Of Humility

959 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Implications of the study of moral development

In criticizing the utilitarian behaviorist framework, Murdoch says that moral philosophy should provide not only an ideal of what it means to be good, but also advice on how to move oneself towards that ideal. One way that the ideal of humility can help a person be good is by providing a test for actions. Instead of asking himself the rather difficult question “Is this a good action?” an agent can ask himself “Would a humble person do this?”, and if the answer is “no”, then the action is probably bad. The same test can be applied to persistent behaviors or attitudes.
If being humble is a way of being good, it is worth considering that someone might try to be humble. In addition to applying the test, he might seek out humbling experiences, …show more content…

This is potentially problematic for a couple of reasons; (1) A humble person is outward-looking, whereas self-improvement is inward-looking; and (2) if you try to be humble and find that you’ve succeeded, you are now in the awkward position of thinking “I am humble”. While the ideal of humility involves having “no self”, an ordinary person can’t just discard one’s self and instantly become humble; change takes time. A person in the process of this change can think “I am trying to be humble”, which does not share the contradiction that “I am humble” implies. So for someone at the beginning of the process of unselfing, the second problem is not significant because “success” is so far …show more content…

An ideal humble person has no self to improve, but self-improvement is an essential part of being a real-life good person, and an ideal that excludes self-improvement would not be a useful one. The ideal of humility should not be interpreted as saying that a person should pretend he has no self, but as a humbling reminder of what’s important and what is not. Self-cultivation of humility is only useful insofar as it enhances, rather than distracts from, attention to others, which is of primary

Show More
Related
88 Words | 1 Pages

Accordingly, in The Lakota Way, it says, “When choosing a leader, we always kept in mind that humility provides clarity where arrogance makes a cloud. The last thing we wanted was to be led by someone whose judgment and actions were clouded by arrogance.” Nevertheless, Humility is an important trait, consequently, people will notice acts of bravery, valor, and kindness when they are not boasted about. Nevertheless, Humility is an important trait, consequently, people will notice acts of bravery, valor, and kindness when they are not boasted about.

Read More
405 Words | 2 Pages

Mt 18:1 Christ tells disciples to be humble as a little child Jas 4:6 We are to struggle against covetousness 6 But he giveth more grace. Wherefore the scripture saith, God resisteth the proud, but giveth grace to the humble.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Having humility is a great thing to have. Even if someone is worse than Someone at something they don't say they are better or push them down. Humility is a very important trait to have. This is the theme that Runs through the story “Raymond's Run” By Toni Bambara because Humility makes you look like a good person. Humility makes you look like you acknowledge people and Humility allows better emotion control.

Read More
1358 Words | 6 Pages

It explores the pitfalls of ego and pride, which can obstruct our capacity to form meaningful relationships and find true fulfillment. By embracing humility as a guiding principle, I can shift away from self-centered tendencies and cultivate deeper connections with others. This meditation sets readers on a path of reflection and humility that will result in increased spiritual fulfillment and harmony. Meditation eight examines the idea of heaven from a Christian point of view, highlighting its significant implications for

Read More
1113 Words | 5 Pages

In today's society, people try everything to do what is right, but although they do their best to be moral, they may still

Read More
749 Words | 3 Pages

According to Lencioni (2016), “Humility is the single greatest and most indispensable attribute of being a team player” (p. 157). Humility is a form of integrity. When a team player is humble they do not have egos, neither are they concerned about their status. When a team player is humble, they tend to point out the contributions of others and do not highlight the contribution of their own. The success of the team is collectively not an individual effort.

Read More
1596 Words | 7 Pages

The Triumph of the Humble It is often understood that those who go above and beyond requirements and standards of society make it far, they are the leaders of the world, have been and will continue to be. They are said to inherit the best out of life. But, it all comes down to a few simple things. A person who forever tries to lead, attempts to be the best of the brightest and aims for greatness and nothing less will usually fall from their place.

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

"The Road to Character,” which is written by David Brooks is a book that examines the idea of our own individual uniqueness, character and its importance in our lives. In “The Road to Character,” Brooks contends that instead of cultivating inner virtues and character, our society today has grown more concerned with generating resumes. In his book, Brooks contrasts two different kinds of virtues; resume virtues and eulogy virtues as well as discussing the two different human natures (Adam I and Adam II) which he uses to depict the differences between the virtues he discusses throughout the duration of his book. Brooks also looks at several historical characters and modern people. He talks about the significance of humility, self-control, and

Read More
140 Words | 1 Pages

The principle or lesson from this essay as stated before is that self-respect is key to feeling fulfilled in life, but it must come from within

Read More
1070 Words | 5 Pages

An unwilling spirit, refusing to abandon their pride or an individual tortured by their past experiences can both tip the scales in a negative way. The natural sense of achievement and improvement involves perspiration to grow as a self-motivated individual searching to prosper and transform into a well-rounded individual that reflects on the happiness of a person. Happiness is due

Read More
1079 Words | 5 Pages

Studies have shown that people tend to act more decorously when they are under the impression of being observed. This suggests that human nature is more bad than good in general. Over the decades, various philosophers such as Jean Jacques Rousseau and Thomas Hobbes have argued over the nature of humanity. Though this question remains unanswered, there is paramount evidence throughout history to suggest human beings are inherently malicious and immoral. The purpose of this essay is to portray my different views on why I agree with Xunzi about human nature being bad.

Read More
1357 Words | 6 Pages

The point is that one should constantly be proud of who he/she is and not try to hide it. One should be proud of being a good friend, be proud of who he/she is, be proud of oneself every time he/she makes a good decision, be proud of all the small things one has accomplished, be proud of one’s unique strengths, and do not leave it to another person to make one feel like ‘he/his is enough’; leave it to oneself. Also, there are advantages to this. By being proud of who one is, one’s confidence skyrockets, one becomes honest and likeable. Life becomes worth living, and nearly stress-free.

Read More
959 Words | 4 Pages

“Virtue” is an idea we all strive for but often struggle to define. Throughout Philosophy many have come to define virtue in different ways with arguably the two most famous being Aristotle and Kant. While the two initially seem to be conflicting with each other there also many ways in which the philosophies align with each other and this is something the paper will explore. To gain better insight to the philosopher’s arguments in regards to birtue and moral worth, we will explain both their views and discuss a scene in which we identify how the similarities in assessing the agent as well as what leads to Aristotle’s argument being more compelling in doing such. Kant’s value of moral worth concerns itself with the importance of acting out of duty even in the presence, or lack thereof, any internal desire to execute said action.

Read More
1485 Words | 6 Pages

Theoretically, the majority of people might already know what or how they should act and behave to be a good person. Nevertheless, the most fundamental problem is that they forget to do those actions in real practices. I firmly believe that the one and only reason for these problems to occur is due to the modern secular society. In the present days, the secular society seems to think that telling the individuals to behave in good manners such as looking after the poor, showing solicitude for others, and more only for a single time is perfectly adequate. Nonetheless, Alain de Botton had answered from an interview as follows “All religions disagree here: they insist that if anyone is to stand a chance of remembering anything, they need reminders on a daily, perhaps even hourly basis.”

Read More
714 Words | 3 Pages

Praise will reinforce positive characteristics and does not focus on limitations as it builds pride. In artice 1, it says “Self-worth is a function of living with dignity, which exists apart from any

Read More

More about Murdoch's Utilitarianism: The Ideal Of Humility

Related Topics

Open Document