ipl-logo

Naive Guard By Natasha Tretheway

1588 Words7 Pages

Autumn Ivins Diversity in Literature Dr. White 27 February 2023 Equity in the Classroom How educators treat students in the classroom impacts them immensely, “I cried aloud, shaking my head all the while until I felt the cold blades of the scissors against my neck, and heard them gnaw off one of my thick braids. Then I lost my spirit (Long Soldier).” The events that happen in the early years of education affect the development of a person. The government and social system has had flaws ever since it was made. This can be seen from a collection of poems by Natasha Tretheway called “Naive Guard”, highlighting the hardships faced after the civil war regarding “the one drop rule” and other racial issues in America. On the contrary, Artress …show more content…

Students need to feel accepted for who they are; which includes their culture, skin color, identity, and sexual orientation. Being discriminated against or experiencing bias in the classroom creates a place that is no longer safe for the student. In Layli Long Soldiers article, “Now, You Will Listen '' she tells a story about her daughter standing up and speaking the truth about how her teacher should be more culturally appropriate in the classroom. Layli Long Soldier expresses the heartwarming feeling that she experiences from her daughter's strength to be able to defend and shield a culture that she doesn't even belong to. The courage it takes to be an ally at such a young age should be normalized. She explains how she was not as strong as her daughter at that age, ”I told them that they are speaking up in the ways that we (the older generation) could not. When I was small, I told them, I was so quiet in the classroom. The prevalence of racism was too powerful. I absorbed all that hurtful language, those attitudes toward Native people, the messages I took everything home with me, silently, in my body (Long Soldier).” Layli Long Soldier felt like she did not have a voice because in her generation, racism was extremely dominant. This expresses the issues with racism in American history. There should have never been a time where a student is scared to speak out and protect themselves …show more content…

“The final performer, a faculty member, proceeded to regale the audience with a piece about growing up in the South, replete with references to his father dressing up in blackface and “Negros” all around, especially his beloved Mammy (White 162).” Artress White explains how the performance was in front of multiple students and teachers who came forward to apologize for their colleagues' behavior. This example is damaging to not only Dr. White, but to the students viewing these behaviors as well. Witnessing blunt racism by individuals who are supposed to be their educators is disgusting and creates a toxic environment for all involved. She goes on to say, “In fact I fear for students of color in the classes of these unsympathetic faculty because of their inability to exercise empathy beyond the terrain of their own racial subject positions. If they cannot display compassion for a colleague, how would they ever be able to mediate for a vulnerable student? (White 164).” This represents the direct concern from an educator that this colleague is not fit to lead the younger generation because of his neglect of compassion towards people of color. Comparing this to Natasha Tretheway poems, a black mother carrying an interracial baby has concerns about how the world will treat her child. The mother was born in Mississippi where interracial marriage

Show More
Related
827 Words | 4 Pages

‘Don’t you know you’re not supposed to touch them,’” (Hoose 3). Throughout her childhood, she learned the hardships that would come to shape her resolve. Sadly, this is only one example to show, expressing the deep south racism through a simple quote to define what her childhood was primarily surrounded by. Not only seeing the injustice in her community from a young age, she also experienced loss:

Read More
729 Words | 3 Pages

Discrimination towards different races/cultures happens every single day. It's not an issue that could be kept hidden forever. Educating students about different cultures/ races/ beliefs is not the same as making them believe one certain thing. It opens an opportunity to be the better person in the world and create a more equal

Read More
1023 Words | 5 Pages

The teacher asks whether or not black students still care about racial justice and the boy responds by saying, “In the fifties we still had something to prove so we had a reason to fight”. The teacher asks, “you don’t think black students are competing now?”. His response: “No.” Maybe the filmmakers took this exchange out of context or maybe the student was trying to say something else, but it saddened me to think that there might be children who already feel a sense of defeat. The recent media campaigns surrounding police violence against black individuals, something that has been going on for decades just without media coverage, is showing the public that there is far more that needs to be done in order to make America equal for all races.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

Where do we draw the lines between adoration and mockery, influence and appropriation, and individuality and stereotyping? Accordingly, the racial subject has always been a touchy topic to discuss, but with the lasting effects that the black minstrelsy has left in the society, we most definitely need to deal with the racial subject. Only this way can the American society move forward both as a nation and as a species, and through such efforts, only then can we ensure that such history can never repeat

Read More
1071 Words | 5 Pages

The episode ―With Apologies to Jesse Jackson is important because it aims to answer the question: how do we, as young people in the 21st Century, discuss racism? But with further examination, a critical eye

Read More
722 Words | 3 Pages

Her Mama is always saying racist statements such as, “ ‘Shut that dern radio off, Maggie,’ Mama said. ‘I can’t stand all that news about the coloreds. All that stuff about them using the public parks’ (16). She also says, “ ‘I knows Cinda and Zeke and those other coloreds, Maggie,’ Mama said, the glass poised still, ‘and i guess it’s shameful enough you ‘ssociatin’ with them’ “ (222). Maggie was shut off from a world where equality was an idea, until, her colored friend Zeke tried explaining it to her through his job, “ ‘Maggie,’ he said, putting his face right next to mine, ‘don’t you see?

Read More
1213 Words | 5 Pages

She begins with her son’s teachers teaching him to be color-blind, and she comments that “the very notion of” color-blindness isn’t a reasonable practice because it promotes “ideological confusion at best and denial” of real and present day issues “at its very worst” (Williams 4). Williams argues that the principle of color-blindness is faulty, because these teachers are trying to promote unity in their classes by leading an example of ignorance between student rather than acceptances of people’s differences. In addition, Williams rhetoric use of pathos encourages the readers emotional attachment to Williams viewpoint, and therefore increases the support of her argument. Another example Williams provides is when she was blatantly confronted with racism on a train and she laments about “how precisely does the issue of color remain so powerfully determinative,...in a world that is, by and large, officially color-blind’?” (Williams 15).

Read More
529 Words | 3 Pages

The protagonist faces systemic racism when he overhears the principal on the phone talking about expelling him. “No, I guess not, they could care less if I expel him… They need him in the fields.” “Well, I just hope our boys don’t make too much out about it to their parents.

Read More
1350 Words | 6 Pages

When kept in the curriculum, it can have a portion of students uncomfortable in a classroom when discussing the topics because of events that took place within their lives. Racism is a continuing problem in the twentieth century, and continues to be a problem in the twenty first century. During Perry’s time in an orphanage, there were nurses who “… hated me… being half-Indian. There was this one nurse, she used to call me ‘nigger’ and say there wasn’t any difference between niggers and Indians” (Capote 128). Racism is still occurring well into the twenty-first century, but with a new aspect, social media.

Read More
596 Words | 3 Pages

He believed this class was anti-American. A bill was passed, where the class had to be cancelled or the school would lose 10 percent of their funding. This class shows oppression, different teaching styles and can be related to other historical and more recent events.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

By sharing his own encounters with racism and the resulting shame he felt, Gregory humanizes the issue and allows readers to connect with his experiences on a deeply emotional level. Moreover, Gregory's essay offers a powerful critique of systemic racism and the need for societal change. By highlighting his own experiences and the broader implications of racial discrimination, he prompts readers to reflect on the pervasive nature of racism and the importance of confronting and dismantling it. His narrative serves as a call to action, urging readers to actively work towards a more inclusive and equitable society. However, one potential limitation of Gregory's essay is the limited exploration of potential solutions or strategies to address the issue of

Read More
920 Words | 4 Pages

Through interviews and reactions from Adam Yamaguchi, from the CBSN Originals, this documentary shares interviews from a varying number of teachers, students, and parents and ask their different points of view and how do they interpret the critical race theory. Activists and parents oppose the critical race theory and point out. Their claims on how schools teach their children “too young and too far” when teachers are teaching students the history of the United States and the effects of ethnicity and race in a minority’s daily lives (The Critical Race Theory, 5:21). Then, John adds on how the “critical race theory is wrong by implying that black people are in a permanently down condition or that it could change by some revolution in the way people think that deep we know is never going to happen” (The Critical Race Theory, 8:34). Although this may be true on the other hand, in an online critic meeting held by Moms for Liberty, an organization against the critical race theory, they are opposing the school district’s efforts to combat the critical race theory.

Read More
594 Words | 3 Pages

This dynamic relationship between Black teachers and Black students occurs because of a lot of different reasons. The first of all, Black teachers are walking on a tightrope between socializing Black students to the mainstream culture and affirming their Black culture. This is a contradictory notion because we are teaching these students that part of themselves, and part of their culture needs to be adjusted. This has a detrimental effect on how the students perceive Blackness as a whole and their own Blackness. This is actually prepping them to living a subordinate position in society (Bourdieu).

Read More
1343 Words | 6 Pages

However as Ken Jensen said, “Students need to understand the context of the huge race riots of the early part of this century [being 1900’s].” This relating to what he later gave, “Between the years 1882 and 1951, 4,730 people were lynched in the United States: 3,437 African-Americans and 1,293 white Americans.” These facts surprise most, as it has been the stereotype that whites were the only racists and blacks the only oppressed, and it is true in some cases, as black were subject to slavery and oppression very openly, but what most people don’t realize is that oppression wasn’t only one-sided, and it’s our modern ignorance that has lead us to believe

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

The overall goal of this film is to explicate how a simple experiment can help children as well as adults understand racism. This film is highly successful in achieving its purpose as is heard from the sentiments expressed by Jane Elliot’s students while discussing the impact the film has had on their lives. The film begins with a reunion of the 1970 class of third graders with their teacher Jane Elliot, 15 years later. They have all matured into adults and are ready to review the experiment that their teacher conducted many years ago in class.

Read More

More about Naive Guard By Natasha Tretheway

Open Document