ipl-logo

Najmah's Losses In Under The Persimmon Tree

1299 Words6 Pages

(AGG) Throughout the book “Under The Persimmon tree Najmah faces many losses that cause her to change at the end. (BS-1) The loss of Najmah’s family causes loss of voice and control. (BS-2 The losses she faced caused her to regain hope and make a plan to travel to Pakistan. (BS-3) Loss helped Najmah regain her voice and make her end overall decision. (TS) The losses Najmah had to face in the story under the Persimmon tree have shaped how she turned out to be at the end of the book. (MIP-1) Due to the family losses Najmah inhabited, she lost the capability to speak, and control over her own decisions. (SIP-A) Because of Najmah’s loss of family and her own home, she had to begin traveling over the mountains, but because of safety precautions …show more content…

(SIP-A) Najmah losing her identity as Shaheed caused her to begin to talk. (STEWE-1) Nusrat was conversing with Najmah to get to know her better and figure out her story. Nusrat suddenly begins to mention how she knew Najmah was a girl. “But it is very dangerous for you to pretend you're a boy.”(194). Out of confusion and Najmah’s loss of pretending to be Shaheed she spoke for the first time in a while “How did you know.” says Najmah, her voice a hoarse whisper.” (194). Nusrat explained it was because of the identical calluses that Najmah had on her hands in the same spots as Nusrat from doing girls work. “She opens her own hand and shows Najmah her own calluses in identical places on her fingers.” (194). (STEWE-2) at first Najmah's speaking was quiet and sounded strange “The Taliban forced my brother to fight with them,”(207). Najmah says in a husky voice.” But as Najmah had continued to speak, her voice developed back into its normal form and Najman Had completely regained her voice back. (SIP-B) once Najmah regains her voice she makes her decision to go back home after the loss of her family she has faced. (STEWE-1) Nusrat has made her decision she wants to go back to New York, but she would like Najmah to accompany her. “I've been thinking how different your life would be if you came with me to America.” (238). Najmah knew that she wanted to go back home, but she did not want to tell Nusrat so soon. “She has so much pain. I do not want to give her more so I nod yes, to say I will think about it.” (240). (STEWE-2) Najmah has made her decision to go home because of the loss of her father. “It was our father's last wish that we should keep our farm from the hands of the Taliban or uncle.” (256). Najmah wants to go back with Nur to fulfill her father's wish of going home and protecting the land. Najmah has regained her control and no matter what Nusrat says Najmah has

Show More
Related

Under The Persimmon Tree Sparknotes

992 Words | 4 Pages

But I need to know what happened to your family so I can help you find them”(197-198).(SIP-B) While living with Nusrat Najmah sees what she is like and starts to understand her more.(STEWE-1) Husna dislikes Najmah and talks to her bitterly , she told her to not take advantage of Nusrat,” I decide I will call the teacher Bibi Nusrat, a term of respect and affection”(204).(STEWE-2) Najmah sees how much Nusrat misses Faiz and worries,” Several times I have seen her lying at night under the stars on the cot, talking to her husband and crying”(223).(CS) Those are the reasons why I think Najmah is shaped from meeting

Read More

Trigger Avoidance In Najmah's Suicide

755 Words | 4 Pages

Additionally, it is more difficult for them to recover (Park). By avoiding speaking about her mother and baby brother, she is unable to make new connections which could ultimately help her heal from PTSD, as shown directly after the bombing when “[Khalida] does not try to talk to [her], and [she] is grateful” (Staples 83). Najmah at that point had no real family left, as her brother and father were taken by the Taliban and her mother and baby brother died in the

Read More

How To Write A Thesis Statement For Myriam Toew

459 Words | 2 Pages

ESSAY OUTLINE The topic 1 chose: 6 1. Introductory Paragraph Introductory Sentence: A Complicated Kindness is one of Myriam Toews’ humoristic creation yet, it depicts the harsh reality of 17 years old Nomi Nickels, struggling to find her identity in the Canadian Mennonite community she lives in.

Read More

Epiphany In The Awakening

171 Words | 1 Pages

But she had refused to do so in the beginning. However, she had surrender to those demands. Her wanted to be free show how stubborn she is against her husband. Because her being “conscious” and not wanting to follow her husband

Read More

Obstacles In Marji's Life

1216 Words | 5 Pages

Life threw young Marjane Satrapi, also known as Marji, a plethora of lemons throughout her life, and she was one of the few individuals to survive the sour nature of living in 1980’s Iran. This life entitled government oppression, unforgiving societal norms, and rigorous religious rules among other things. Marji endured the obstacles life threw at her by committing acts of rebellion, rather than going with the grain, which is what most of society chose as their path. These rebellious acts were risky, yet rewarding for Marji under the rules of the revolution because it helped her grow as a person.

Read More

Najmah Character Analysis

1293 Words | 6 Pages

(MIP-1) Najmah has lost her voice and control over her life due to the traumatization after witnessing death of her mother and little brother. (SIP-A) Najmah has lost her voice due traumatization after witnessing the horrific passing of her mother and baby brother Habib. (STEWE-1) Najmah is trying to communicate right after the death of her mother which occurred on page 82 but she cannot since she mentally states,”But I feel as if my tongue has been locked inside my mouth ever since I saw my mother airing the quilts just Before the bombs fell." (Staples 88) Najmah is completely traumatized, and is just speechless.

Read More

Effects Of Trauma On Identity Development

1097 Words | 5 Pages

Identity Development Everyone experiences trauma at some point in their lives. Whether it be small, like skinning one’s knee, or large, like witnessing the death of a loved one, trauma can drastically affect how an individual grows and finds their own identity. In the long run, trauma can either be beneficial towards establishing one’s identity or detrimental. Traumatic events play a large part in the overall outcome and development of positive and negative self concept and identity progression.

Read More

How Did Najmah Change In Under The Persimmon Tree

1572 Words | 7 Pages

Towards the middle of the book, Najmah had went through many losses but had started to fix them. (BS-3) At the end of the book, Najmah had been shaped positively and she became stronger from all the losses she had faced throughout the book. (TS) Najmah’s life had been affected through impactful losses that she faces throughout the story. (MIP-1)

Read More

Ashley And Jaquavis Analysis

1098 Words | 5 Pages

Ashley & JaQuavis is the writing team of Ashley Antoinette and JaQuavis Coleman, the youngest African American authors to make the New York Times and Publishers Weekly bestselling lists twice. The writing duo made their name when they were aged only seventeen when they were discovered by Carl Weber, a New York Times bestselling writer. It was during their college years as freshmen that they both got publishing deals from independent publishing houses and began publishing novels individually and later as Ashley & JaQuavis. The Cartel that was published in 2009 was their breakout novel as it turned out to be a smash hit setting the two up as some of the best novelists in the street literature fiction genre. As Ashley and JaQuavis they have written more than twenty blockbusters that continue to thrall their fans across the globe.

Read More

What Is Affecting Parvana's Life?

266 Words | 2 Pages

So I believe that she can’t remember what Afghanistan without war. The text says “We need water,” Nooria said. “Can’t I sit down for awhile first?” Parvana asked her mother. “You will rest better when you work is done.

Read More

Naveed By John Heffernan Essay

870 Words | 4 Pages

After getting her legs amputated when they are blown up by an IED, improvised explosive device. Regardless of her environment she has joy and her attitude remains cheerful even when everyone else sees her condition as a disadvantage. “I used to be sad about having no legs” “but now I realise it’s a blessing in disguise”. She sees that being legless is a blessing as she doesn’t have to marry an older, uglier man. She breaks out of the victim mentality and finds a motivation to go on and inspire others, especially Naveed, “Nor has she ever shown any sign of self-pity.

Read More

Under The Persimmon Tree Analysis

1615 Words | 7 Pages

She was then rescued by Akhtar and Khalida. They promptly embarked on their painstaking journey through the mountains leaving Najmah’s old life behind, “As the stars disappear one by one, Akhtar leads us away from the path” (Staples 85). The author shows that Najmah is hopeless by making the stars disappear, just like her family members and her motivation. (STEWE-2) Najmah and her rescuers were hiding from the Taliban on the side of the road; to disguise themselves effectively, they cover themselves with their shawls to look like boulders. The refugees must wait for a long time, and Najmah looks up at the star called al-Qutb for strength, “I think of Nur and my Father, and I look at al-Qutb, the star that never moves before I remember we are under the cover of the shawl”

Read More

Analysis Of Santha Rama Rau's By Any Other Name

639 Words | 3 Pages

Premila says,“We’re going home for good” (Rau,32). Santha was very confused because the school day was not finished. When the sisters came home their mother and ayah were very concerned. Premila talks about her insular teacher and states,“She said it was because Indians cheat” (Rau,38). Premila added,“So I don't think we should go back to that school”(Rau,38).

Read More

Lusus Naturae Character Analysis

529 Words | 3 Pages

Her grandmother agreed with her as well, saying that it’s better for one to be gone so both will not have to suffer. The narrator also lets her mother move in with her sister after someone offered to buy their farm she volunteers, "Do it, I told her. I'll vacate my room" (Atwood 227). She felt that it was time for her to be on her own for once, and she chose to stay in their old house. She would go to the woods at night and explore, because she knew that nobody would be there and she wouldn’t be in the

Read More

Najmah And Nusrat Analysis

1994 Words | 8 Pages

(SIP-B) When Nusrat does not feel bonded with her family, the author describes the stars in harsh or unappealing ways. (STEWE-1) When Nusrat lost Margaret, she felt she had no special relationships with anyone, and that she had no bond with her family. “Her mother tried to tell her that Margaret was

Read More

More about Najmah's Losses In Under The Persimmon Tree

Related Topics

Open Document