ipl-logo

New Deal Dbq Essay

980 Words4 Pages

People were desperate for a change during The Great Depression. Franklin Roosevelt, remembered as the one who successfully guided the nation through the Great Depression and World War Two, was able to pass a deal that would help the nation drastically. This deal became known as the New Deal. The components of the New Deal changed millions of lives for Americans struggling through the Great Depression, however, many people were still opposed to FDR’s program.
One reason so many people opposed of the New Deal Program was because they deemed it unconstitutional. In document one the picture depicts a “constitutional officer” arresting a “New Dealer”. The officer is arresting him because of FDR’s disrespect and violation of the principals of the …show more content…

In 1937 he attempted to remake the supreme court which became known as the court packing scheme. This scheme threatened the principles of separation of powers, which scared many people in government, especially conservatives. Another thing FDR wanted to do was change the checks and balances systems.
The idea of changing the government was not just going against the constitution, it also made FDR seem like a dictator. For example document four talks about Fortune Magazine and the “Case against FDR”. This article criticized FDR and accused him of having “dictatorial efforts” to control the free enterprise system and redistributing income. The author of the article states they believe FDR is becoming a dictator by saying “Let us save ourselves! Let us Act! …. The Roosevelt theory of federal administration is a dangerous and menacing.” The author continued this statement by comparing him to Stalin and Hitler.
Document seven, also comparable to document one, talks about FDR as a dictator. They believed his court packing scheme was one step closer to dictatorship. Frank Garnett, the writer of this article, stated that “he cleverly camouflaged this scheme”. This means that FDR’s plan to raise the number of judges from nine to fifteen, to many people was seen as …show more content…

Hoover stated that the New Deal was violating the Free Enterprise system, regimenting the economy, centralizing economic and political control, and social experimentation, according to his statements in document six. This statement can be compared to the other documents because, as the previous documents have stated, he is changing too much in the government.
Another reason people opposed of FDR’s New Deal is because they disagreed with how FDR was dealing with the amount of poor people in the country. According to document three, Huey Long talked about many of the things FDR does not do in regard to the poor. For example, he believed FDR was too conservative when it came time to doing something to help the poor. In fact, Huey Long criticized him for actually spending more time with men like the Rockefellers and Carnegies. Huey believed that instead he should take a more active approach on Robin Hood economics through taxing the rich and through

Show More
Related

President Franklin Roosevelt's Court Packing Scheme

435 Words | 2 Pages

Was president Franklin Roosevelt’s Court Packing scheme a plan that consisted of a wish to help end America’s Great Depression or was it a hunger for dictatorial power? Franklin Roosevelt based his election campaign on a New Deal, a series of programs he claimed would help end the Great Depression. While Roosevelt won the election, many of his New Deal bills would not win the approval of the United States Supreme Court. Franklin Roosevelt believed the problem lied not in his bills but in the Supreme Court. He believed the four Conservatives Justices would convince Justice Owen Roberts, who was somewhat neutral, to vote against Roosevelt’s bills.

Read More

Summary Of Kim Phillips-Fein's Invisible Hands

1208 Words | 5 Pages

In Powell’s writing he stated that FDR “seemed willing to try practically anything as long as it involved more government control over the economy” , this very point shows why the conservative party, as pointed out by Phillips-Fein, was so aggressive in reducing the need for government control. In both cases it seems apparent that since the New Deal was unleashed that there was a persistent movement in supporting and opposing

Read More

Hoover's Rugged Individualism

134 Words | 1 Pages

Even though Hoover wasn’t re-elected after 1933, his failed attempt at laissez-faire still affected the American people. An example of this is Roosevelt’s attempt at counteracting Hoover’s Rugged individualism. During Roosevelt’s campaign he promised a ‘New Deal’ for the American people, where, especially in comparison to Hoover’s: ‘laissev-faire’, the US government would be more involved with businesses and the country’s citizens. Summed up, the ‘New Deal’ was about doing everything to keep the country from disaster.

Read More

The Approaches Of Presidents Hoover And Franklin D. Roosevelt

449 Words | 2 Pages

Roosevelt had seen the public’s response and opinions to Herbert Hoover’s methods. The public blamed everything bad during the Great Depression on Hoover for example they named towns built by the homeless “hoovervilles”. Roosevelt wanted to take action. This would increase the power of the federal government more than ever and implement deficit spending like never before. His main approaches to attack the economy’s problems were through a series of programs called the New Deal.

Read More

Dbq The New Deal Questions And Answers

753 Words | 4 Pages

All of those who opposed had their own views as to why they disliked FDR’s ideas, as explained in the documents. The first of the opposed was the Supreme Court. Document 1 is a cartoon of a baseball game where President Roosevelt is the

Read More

New Deal Dbq Essay

564 Words | 3 Pages

In their opinion, the employees were not employed in interstate commerce, so their wages had nothing to do with it either (Document F). They also thought that the government had no right to give workers the right to self-organize and break the law (Document G). The authority of the federal government expanded, and FDR was, in a sense, abusing the power he had. Roosevelt’s administration increased the role of the federal government in the economy. His New Deal programs were more successful in empowering the government than lightening the effect of the Depression.

Read More

What Was Fdr's Court Package Plan

1143 Words | 5 Pages

FDR's Court-Packing Plan On February 5th of 1937, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt surprised the public when he announced the controversial Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937 (more commonly known as the Court-Packing Plan). This plan was constructed in response to the criticism his New Deal programs were facing during his first term as president. He presented a bill that was aimed at expanding the membership of the judges in the Supreme Court.

Read More

The New Deal Dbq Essay

587 Words | 3 Pages

But even though this new deal helped us get through the great depression it was the next world war that really got our economy back on its feet. But unlike Franklin Roosevelt other Presidents before Roosevelt did not share the same view. Because during the

Read More

Was Franklin Roosevelt's Court Packing Scheme Evidence Of This?

473 Words | 2 Pages

Thus, as the public grew angry at the Supreme Court’s decisions, Roosevelt struck, proposing the Judicial Reforms Bill of 1937, now known as the Court Packing Scheme. He wanted to add more justices to the Supreme Court to shift the court towards his favor, so the court would allow his bills. Intending to gain public support, Roosevelt introduced this idea to the public through his 9th fireside chat, But this backfired.

Read More

New Deal Dbq Analysis

1944 Words | 8 Pages

(Doc D) The audience of Procter’s letter was President Franklin Roosevelt, who in 1935 was still able to heavily dictate the direction the nation would follow in reform. This is significant because Roosevelt’s New Deal policies were still largely flexible and could easily be tailored to

Read More

New Deal Dbq Essay

493 Words | 2 Pages

Before the New Deal, most Americans citizens would have very with the Federal Government. With the New Deal, Americans came to be more likely to depend on the government for a job and etc.… The Federal Government took no responsibility for the people prosperity or even financial security. They were basically letting people know they have to take care of themselves.

Read More

President Herbert Hoover In The 1930's

604 Words | 3 Pages

Hoover President Herbert Hoover didn’t believe that it was the federal government’s role to provide direct relief. Instead he suggested voluntarism, asking corporations to improve working conditions and wages. Lowering income taxes was another idea promoted by Hoover. If people would spend less on taxes, they would invest in stock market and purchase products. Hoover refused against any form of a welfare program.

Read More

Franklin D. Roosevelt's Impact Of The Great Depression

1101 Words | 5 Pages

In 1933, Franklin D. Roosevelt became the president of the United State after President Herbert Hoover. The Great Depression was also at its height because President Hoover believed that the crash was just the temporary recession that people must pass through, and he refused to drag the federal government in stabilizing prices, controlling business and fixing the currency. Many experts, including Hoover, thought that there was no need for federal government intervention. ("Herbert Hoover on) As a result, when the time came for Roosevelt’s Presidency, the public had already been suffering for a long time.

Read More

Economic Reform In President Hoover's New Deal

917 Words | 4 Pages

As the Great Depression chewed up and spit out the American people, they turned to the federal government for help when all hope was lost; however, President Herbert Hoover was a strong believer in the old-time individualism of “pulling yourself up by your bootstraps,” and that pride came from picking yourself up and dusting yourself off, but the suffering, impoverished Americans that were unemployed and stripped of their possessions and hard earned money had no one else to turn to and Hoover was only willing to help the big businesses. Hoovervilles, full of shacks built from garbage, Hoover flags, otherwise known as empty American pockets, Hoover blankets or newspapers used to shield Americans from the cold, and Hoover leather, the sad, reused cardboard replacement for worn out old shoe soles, became national symbols by 1932 when President Hoover was

Read More

New Deal Turning Point

1830 Words | 8 Pages

How far was the New Deal a turning point in US history? The New Deal was made in response to a set of policies by Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) to combat issues caused by the global financial meltdown of 1929, initiated by the Wall Street Crash. This decade long historic financial downturn has been identified as the Great Depression (1929-1939). The New Deal focused on what people refer to as the ‘three R’s’:

Read More

More about New Deal Dbq Essay

Related Topics

Open Document