ipl-logo

Of The Article 'Scoundrels Or Scapegoats' By Tim Low

716 Words3 Pages

Stage 1 English Pre-Studies
Close Reading
1. Tim Low, the author of the article Cats: Scoundrels or Scapegoats, talks about many different issues that have arisen over the years concerning the way cats are viewed. Low talks a lot about the fact that cats prey on native birds, however, so do a large amount of other animals. “Birds are killed in forests too, by a whole gamut of predators including snakes, goannas, falcons, butcherbirds, quolls, Dingoes and even spiders.” Low presents his answer to the question throughout the entire piece by giving examples of how and why cats are viewed as scoundrels, but then backing those examples up with why he believes they are scapegoats.

Low believes that although feral cats are a bigger problem than pet …show more content…

Reid places the blame for the destruction of Australian wildlife on cats. In response to Tim Low’s article defending the cat’s nature of predation, Reid seems to disagree with almost everything Low mentions. Reid states that “Cat owners are irresponsible people” which also partially places the blame for the destruction of wildlife on the people who own cats. To solve the problem of the declining native species, Reid suggests that governments should “introduce a program for the utter eradication of all cats from …show more content…

His words are delivered with low modality and does not need to use aggressive tones to deliver his beliefs. Reid presents his argument from only his perspective. This is an effective way to have people agree with what you are writing about, however, Low adds the perspective of both cat owners and people who believe that cats are in fact scoundrels. Low states that “because cats prey on native birds they could bring about their extermination.” He also admits “enormous numbers of birds are killed by pet cats in gardens.” By giving these facts to the readers, he is allowing them to understand what has made him write this article. After writing that yes, cats kill birds, he argues that “hunting by pet cats would only be a problem if the rate of predation, combined with other deaths, exceeded the breeding rate of the birds.” Low then says that this is not the case. He is using different perspectives to give the readers a chance to form their own opinion instead of seemingly forcing his onto

Show More
Related
485 Words | 2 Pages

Another way the corruption of power is exemplified, is in books. In William Golding’s “Lord of the Flies”, the character Jack is proven to show corruption of power. In the beginning of the story, Jack is innocent young boy who gradually becomes power hungry. When Ralph was elected as chief and it was clear that Jack wasn’t happy because he thought he was a better leader. Jack said, “I ought to be chief, because I’m chapter chorister and head boy.

Read More
438 Words | 2 Pages

“Our love affair with our pets has gotten out of control” (Bilger 10). Burkhard Bilger is the author of the literary non-fiction piece, “The Last Meow”, that was published in The New Yorker September 8, 2003. He explains the extent people are willing to go for their animals and pay any amount of money no matter how much it may cost. According to Bilger, pet owners spend about forty seven billion dollars a year on their pets, that ranges from food all the way to surgeries.

Read More
123 Words | 1 Pages

In her work “What’s Wrong with Animal Rights,” Vicki Hearne challenges common beliefs of animal rights, arguing that animal rights groups do very little to actually benefit animals. She argues that natural selection should be allowed to take place for wild animals, and animals such as cats and dogs should not be seen as property. To persuade the audience to support her position, she uses ethos, pathos, and logos. Her credibility as a trainer makes the logic behind her views reliable, her logic reinforces the examples she uses, and she appeals to emotion using her relationship with her Airedale, Drummer, to support everything her argument is saying. Through these strategies, Vicki Hearne effectively counters the current, popular views of the

Read More
127 Words | 1 Pages

After a sporting event, have you ever heard “We lost because of this person” or “It’s his fault we lost?” Well, this is an example of scapegoating. Scapegoating is the act of putting the blame of an event on to a specific person, or a group of people. Scapegoating plays a big role in some pieces of literature, especially The Crucible by Arthur Miller. The Crucible is about the Puritan village of Salem Massachusetts back in 1692, during the witch hunts.

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

Foremost, Carson evokes pity towards the defenseless birds, and anger toward the farmers for their actions, with emotionally-charged words. The repetition of the word “killing” supports Carson belief that the destruction of birds is savage path farmers choose, because the word connotes evil. The evil, associated with the word, arouses anger at the farmers for their ill doing; additionally, the word

Read More
110 Words | 1 Pages

Hypocrisy is the practice of claiming to have moral standards or beliefs to which one's own behavior does not conform; pretense. In the book the Crucible there are many hypocrites some dishonest some just following any one to be guilty, but one of the many character is Judge Danforth he mocks Marry when he ask "How were you instructed in your life? Do you not know that God damns all liars?"(3-84), since Danforth is in power for being the judge he thinks that everyone else is ignorant and not being equal as him.

Read More
1560 Words | 7 Pages

Like many scapegoats, Socrates was blamed and hated for having a different outlook on life. He questioned the status quo of society creating an upheaval that Greek citizens felt they had to handle. In 399 B.C, Socrates was killed with hemlock because he corrupted society with his intense questioning. Due to his wisdom, Socrates became a scapegoat for the Greeks simply because they were not prepared to face the reality of knowledge (Fieser). Similarly, all scapegoats like Socrates are faced with blame, hatred, and punishments in order to keep society from realizing they are actually inferior.

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

Although, many people that were condemned weren’t actually apart of the Communist Party, (under McCarthyism around 1950-1954) they got blacklisted or lost their jobs. This social injustice is also portrayed in The Crucible as its characters face the Salem Witch Trials. Arthur Miller wrote The Crucible as his own reaction to the injustice of McCarthyism. Miller’s purpose was to show how people accused each other with false denunciations because of their fear, jealousy and solely hatred of one another under McCarthyism.

Read More
880 Words | 4 Pages

Corruption’s Rise to Power Combined Joseph Stalin and Adolf Hitler killed 54 million people. This begs the question, why do people who are clearly corrupted and even murderous followed by many? William Golding in his novel The Lord of the Flies attempts to answer that question through his portrayal of the character, Jack. In the novel, a group of boys get stranded on an island and attempt to create a proper government.

Read More
521 Words | 3 Pages

Pet owners say that they will take care of their pets no matter what. Bilger’s argument is that people’s love for their pets has gone too far. Although Bilger is incorrect because some people use the money to help their pets, he is primarily correct because people spend their money on stuff their pets don’t need and how some pets are forced to endure more than they have to. I concede that bilger is wrong because In “The Last Meow” the Leverings were willing to spend 15,000 dollars on their cat Lady to help her. Shawn Levering said “If Lady comes through this thing alive, I won’t think about it twice.”

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

Jonathan Edwards once said: “Resolution One: I will live for God. Resolution Two: If no one else does, I still will.” Since birth (October 5th, 1703), Jonathan has always been a devoted Puritan which explains why he began the Great Awakening, along with George Whitefield. Edwards started preaching and wanted people to reconvert to Puritanism. His work, “Sinners at the Angry Hands of God,” was written on July 8, 1741.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

Attention Getter: Imagine living on the streets, constantly looking for your next meal and never knowing the feeling of companionship. This is the life of stray animals. Credibility Statement: No one really knows how many stray animals roam the streets, but it is predicted that there are more than 70 million stray cats in the United States alone. Central Idea (Proposition): By adopting pets from the American Humane Society or other rescue shelters, we can reduce the amount of stray animals on the streets.

Read More
811 Words | 4 Pages

Is an average fully grown cheetah or a cat more likely seen in someone’s house? If one of the animals previously stated was to viciously attack someone, which one would cause the most damage? The answer to the first question is a cat. The answer to the second question is an average fully grown cheetah because they can do more damage to someone compared to a cat. A cheetah compared to a cat is an exotic animal compared to a pet.

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

What if there was a society where God was loved the same amount as His wrath is feared? Well, in the play The Crucible by Arthur Miller, the Puritans were a society who loved and feared God equally. They loved and feared Him to a point where they blamed others for their sins. A group of young girls were caught doing witchcraft in the forbidden woods. The girls put the blame on others so they would not be the ones in trouble and the accused Puritans were all innocent of doing witchcraft.

Read More
1235 Words | 5 Pages

Despite the consequences of owning a wild animal, many people disregard the

Read More

More about Of The Article 'Scoundrels Or Scapegoats' By Tim Low

Related Topics

Open Document