ipl-logo

Opposing Viewpoints In Context By Motoko Rich And John Broder

475 Words2 Pages

This excerpt is taken from Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context, a premier online resource database, covering pro/con arguments for many of today’s important social issues. The authors contributing to this viewpoint are Motoko Rich and John Broder, contributing writers from the New York Times. This source can be deemed credible and reliable since the New York Times is an institution when it comes to honest reporting. Although this is an older source (2011), the topic presented in this article remains relevant in our society today. This source remains very neutral and presents viewpoints from both sides of the argument. This source presents research and case studies to acknowledge that this debate of job creation vs environmental regulation is complex and need to be analyzed and interpreted from many different angles to realize the various effects created by these two opposing viewpoints. One study shows how the Clean Air Act caused a job loss of 600,000, but at the same time, reduced the infant mortality rate and increased housing prices, thus creating a wealth effect for the real estate market. It is mentioned that one data point (such as job loss, improved health, etc..) should not …show more content…

Based on the evidence set forth by the authors, I can formulate my own opinion on this debate based upon what I deem to be most important in my daily life. Although I can see how environmental regulations can be detrimental to the economy and many working families around us, I do not believe the safety and health of the environment and the people living in it should be compromised. Our health and quality of life should come before money, therefore if these environmental regulations need to be implemented to preserve that health, then the hit to the economy is a necessary evil I am willing to live

Show More
Related

Rhetorical Analysis Of Glenn E Martin's One In Three

561 Words | 3 Pages

Glenn E Martin uses multiple rhetorical devices in his article “One in Three” to put forth his argument that the politicians and the government as a whole, use race as a factor in considering how and where a person should live his life. He uses strong, confident language, details, and colloquial, technical diction to convince his readers in believing his argument or at the least understand his point of view. The author uses short, simple words in the article to reach all readers. For example, he says, “ They did a crime and shouldn't get anything for free.”

Read More

Summary Of Race Truth And The Two Realities By Chris Lebron

1293 Words | 6 Pages

Whether by ignorance or by will, inequality is viewed differently based on personal experiences.” He points out that when we discuss race, depending on who you are having the conversation, you are not talking about the same topic or issues(Lebron). The writer also states that we believe our democracy to be a superior form of government mainly because we have evolved to respecting the rights of one another, for the most part. The argument to that theory is systemic racism and how it continues to affect wealth, jobs, education and public services for minorities(Lebron). Other people would argue that minorities cause their own problems and hinder their own progress.

Read More

Clean Air And Water Act Dbq Essay

840 Words | 4 Pages

Following the Clean Air Act of 1970, air pollution had significantly decreased in statistical levels, even corroborating the fact that Americans experience longer and healthier lives, with better visibility due to diminished smog and fog levels. On a broader note, even crops and farm animals saw a benefit in this Act, with cleaner and fresher air to use in many processes, like respiration and photosynthesis. In response to the Clean Water Act of 1972, the loss of wetlands have significantly decreased, and the bodies of water used for leisurely activities, such as fishing and swimming, have seen an increase. More impactfully, billions of pollutants have been eradicated from national waters, purifying and cleansing it for public use. Furthermore, public advocacy efforts such as the protests seen in the New York Times post in Document 3, and the speech given by Hansen in Document 5, have set the stage for global climate change activism.

Read More

Similarities Between Bill Mckibben And Jensen

1094 Words | 5 Pages

Bill McKibben and Derrick Jensen were born in 1960 in the U.S.A., and both have accomplished successful academic backgrounds. McKibben graduated from Harvard University in 1982, and Derrick Jensen graduated from the Colorado School of Mines with a degree in Mineral engineering in 1983. Both are environmental activists and have written many articles and books. Two of their articles “Waste Not, Want Not” by Bill McKibben and “Forget Shorter Showers” by Jensen are published in the Bedford Reader book (557-567). When we analyze these articles both authors agree on consumers contribution to environmental pollution, but they have different points of views concerning whether individuals or industrialists cause more environmental pollution.

Read More

Gloria Steinem A Balance Between Nature And Nurture

408 Words | 2 Pages

In the essay “A Balance Between Nature and Nurture,” Gloria Steinem gives the audience an insight into her beliefs on this controversial topic. Gloria has a belief that both nature and nurture impact us throughout our lives. In her article she writes about how her parents thought that traveling was just as “enlightening as sitting in a classroom.” Beside her parents, Gloria saw the world through a different perspective compared to other kids her age. However, once she got to school things changed- she was exposed to gender obsessions, race and class complexities, and the idea that war and male leadership were part of human nature.

Read More

Schindler's List Best Influence Public Views On The Holocaust

523 Words | 3 Pages

Contrasting perspectives are addressed, not all in great detail, but there weren't any forced facts or strong opinions. Overall this article does well in hitting important points, and there’s an acceptable balance of bias and

Read More

Letter From Birmingham Jail Analysis

528 Words | 3 Pages

The United States claims to value equality, but many often discriminate people who seem different. From the time of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s reflection in “Letter From Birmingham Jail” to present day, many people in society conjectures that everyone has the same rights and privileges, however, there is still inequality. All people in America are not given the same advantages others have when unjust and prejudicial treatment remains. It is evident that injustice can spread throughout society.

Read More

Satire Essay On Illegal Immigrants Today

1401 Words | 6 Pages

immigration-today-3/ Immigration can be viewed as something that has forever blessed or plagued this country. Perspective plays a big role in the discussion of illegal immigrants that enter America daily. With American society becoming more and more prejudice in each decade since Martin Luther King had his “I Have a Dream” speech Blacks are not the only ones on the discrimination list. This problem has since began to come to a head under President Trump and his term. Unbeknownst to many who support the deportation of illegal immigrants wholeheartedly, immigrants add to the society just as much as people fear they’ve been taking.

Read More

EPA Mission Statement

1009 Words | 5 Pages

An example of air pollution that has become more prominent in the last few years has been acid rain. Acid rain had increased the marginal social cost on the American people through its risks of a persons health, however, most people only realize the marginal social benefits that it represents, like the goods that are made, with the rain as their product. Title IV of the Clean Air Act is where we find the laws that regulate Acid Deposition, which occurs when sulfur and nitrogen emissions combined with other substances, are changed in the atmosphere and then dropped back on Earth in a form that is very harmful to a persons and the environments health. The Clean Water Act was put into place in order to create a system so that there aren 't too many pollutants released into the U.S. 's water supply and to make sure that the water is deemed as safe for Americans to use and drink from.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Environmental Protection Agency

987 Words | 4 Pages

The protection of environment is crucial to the wellbeing of this planet. The job of government is to protect and preserve the land on which its people live. However, there is a bill being considered that completely goes against this, one that calls for the eradication of the Environmental Protection Agency, a government program created to protect human and environmental wellbeing through their regulation of laws. I urge you to oppose bill H.R. 861 - the termination of the Environmental Protection Agency - because of the ways that the EPA protects air, water, and land.

Read More

Cold War Environmental Awareness

1017 Words | 5 Pages

In Rachel Carson’s book which was published in 1962, it made a powerful case for the idea that if humankind poisoned nature, nature would in turn poison humankind. Throughout the book, she went on about the detrimental affects that human’s bad habits would have on Mother Earth. Her main argument was that society as a whole would have to change their previous ways of living in order to maintain good health for the Earth and in return the Earth would continue taking care of us, providing land and good weather. One of the actions that was a result of her begging for change was the Clean Air act and the Clean Water act. The Clean Air Act was a law which was designed to control air pollution.

Read More

Air Pollution California Essay

1511 Words | 7 Pages

This landmark symposium made the introduction of the federal government involvement in environmental regulation. In 1955 congress passed its first environmental legislation which was upheld and supported strongly by the public and improved science. After this huge merge the United States environmental protection Agency and the effective public policy toward the environmental were instituted. (Usepa,

Read More

Global Warming In New York City

794 Words | 4 Pages

Global warming is one of the biggest issues facing the world today. It causes many problems in the world. Storms are made stronger, the ocean levels rise, and hotter temperatures cause more frequent wildfires. The main cause of Global Warming is the greenhouse effect that carbon dioxide creates in the atmosphere, but there are many factors that contribute to the problem. There are critics of global warming that say the earth is fluctuating at a normal rate, but there are many things that prove its existence.

Read More

Pollution Persuasive Speech

857 Words | 4 Pages

Pollution may be a threat, but it can be solved in our

Read More

Plastic Bag Levy: A Case Study

1713 Words | 7 Pages

These are some for the barriers and competitiveness issues which environmental regulation, taxes and policies encounter with the respective stakeholders during policy making and during policy implementation. Therefore, a balanced approach has to be achieved; and not to focus on avoiding environment damage only, while destroying industries and forgoing the opportunity of economic growth which creates tax base for government’s revenues. The policy or package will also have to guarantee that the polluter is charged or taxed accordingly and not the affected society at large to be bore the environmental damaging costs. According to Green Fiscal Commission 2009, there are two criteria’s which can be used to assess the effectiveness of environment taxes.

Read More

More about Opposing Viewpoints In Context By Motoko Rich And John Broder

Related Topics

Open Document