ipl-logo

Our Overeducated Workforce Summary

1459 Words6 Pages

Citation:
Jack Metzgar, “Our Overeducated Workforce: Who Benefits?”

Central Thesis: The key claims the author makes in this article are that it is becoming more difficult for college graduates to find jobs that require a college degree and have a higher salary. The author also discusses how the research that says a college degree is needed in today’s society to get a job is faulty.

Summary: One of the main points Metzgar makes in this article is that there are not enough “college jobs” for all of the students who are graduating college. In fact, according to reliable sources cited in the article, only two out of three college graduates will be hired for a “college job.” The future projections look even worse because only one-third of …show more content…

Many different companies and organizations claim that “experts” have found evidence that there is not enough college graduates in our work force actually only refer to one “expert,” Anthony Carnevale. Carnevale is the director on the Georgetown University Center of Education and the Workforce, which receive major funds from Lumina, which is a non-profit foundation that helps provide money to Americans to receive college degrees. This, along with being the only researcher in this area, makes Carnevale an unreliable source of information. He gets most of his results by looking at well-respected public opinion surveys and also considers jobs that do not require a college degree, but pay college graduates more than non-college-graduates to be defined as a “college …show more content…

He uses reliable data provided mainly by the government. He gives eye-opening statistics on how hard it may be to find a job after college. Metzgar also provides credible information that breaks down certain companies’ claims that a college degree is needed in today’s society to get a job. Although he does not give many examples of what the job market and selection will necessarily be like in the next year or two, he suggests how likely it will be for a college graduate to get a “college job.” He provided a better definition for what a “college job” is than Carnevale did. He implies that his definition is that a “college job” requires a college degree to get hired, rather than being paid more than employees who don’t have a college

Show More
Related

Analysis Of Anthony Carnevale's Essay 'College Is Still Worth It'

730 Words | 3 Pages

In 2008, the Bureau undercounted the number of postsecondary educated workers roughly by 22 million people. Carnevale adds his opinion on how to reconcile the BLS projections with real life, “is to assert that the Bureau’s projections reflect the number of college degrees employers actually require, not the actual numbers of college educated workers they decide to hire” (Carnevale 370). This statement help show his opinion is backed up by

Read More

Summary Of The New Liberal Arts By Sanford J. Ungar

396 Words | 2 Pages

The second misperception claims that “The college graduates are finding it harder to get good jobs with liberal arts degrees” (Ungar, 228). But, Ungar explains that,

Read More

An Analysis Of Andrew Delbanco's Essay 'Making It In America'

1388 Words | 6 Pages

Delbanco explains how students have changed their reasons for attending a college when he states, “...yet on the assumption that immersing themselves in learning for the sheer joy of it, with the aim of deepening their understanding of culture, nature, and, ultimately, themselves, is a vain indulgence” (222). Secondary education has become too expensive for learning to be an indulgence. Students only go to college to get a degree in order to gain a high paying career. Davidson explains how dire the situation with low paying job is by saying how the process should work, “Only through productivity growth can the average quality of human life improve” (339). Unfortunately, the productivity growth only leaves a bigger pay gap.

Read More

Should Everyone Go To College Stephanie Sawhill Analysis

544 Words | 3 Pages

The fact that not everyone needs to go to college is the main point that Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill write about in great detail throughout their essay. Even though the authors do say that people that go to college usually earn more, they state that this is on “average,” and that the key focus of their essay is to focus on those that the benefits are not greater than the cost of going to college. (Page 211, Paragraph 1). They also include a graph right under the text that shows how “on average” people with a college degree earn more than those that are just high school graduates. (Page 211, Figure one).

Read More

Analysis Of 'Where College Fails Us' By Caroline Bird

838 Words | 4 Pages

The Greek Philosopher Aristotle identified “The years between puberty and age twenty-one as the formative time for mind and character.” It was customary for young Greek men to attend a series of lectures that resembled our notion of a college “course”(Delbanco 36). Aristotle is a believer of education and the power it has on the development of the young mind. Likewise, he believes college is a place to establish one’s character. Caroline Bird’s essay, “Where College Fails Us,” definitely does not correlate with the opinion of Aristotle.

Read More

Charles Murray's Essay Are Too Many People Going To College

1090 Words | 5 Pages

In his Essay “Are too many people going to college,” first published in a 2008 issue of AEI, Charles Murray explores many insights onto the topic of furthering education as well as exploring various other options to pursue after high school. Who exactly would think that too many people are going to college? Well with more and more students flooding campuses at the end of every school year and less and less going into trade schools, a shift in the job market is just beginning to be seen on the horizon. Charles Murray’s essay “Are too many people going to college” shows that not only are there other avenues to pursue a potential life long career, but that much of the time pursuing these avenues may offer better results for some wanting to go to college.

Read More

Comparing The Pros And Cons Of Going To College

2291 Words | 10 Pages

Melissa views both sides of the argument, but instead of picking sides, she leaves it up to the reader—people who are deciding whether or not they should go to college. This emphasizes that she is writing the article unbiasedly and is just trying to get the information across. Melissa also lists the average median pay per week from someone without a high school diploma to a doctoral degree, which is from six hundred twenty-six dollars to one thousand nine hundred and nine dollars (“Brook”). And since the 1980’s, around seventy percent of workers need some type of college experience. Information Melissa acquired from the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce (Brook).

Read More

Is College Worth It

1022 Words | 5 Pages

Living where we live, you begin to comprehend that living off of $11.00 per hour including with your family will never suffice your needs. Getting a college degree can ensure the graduate a higher chance of being able to earn more financially. In the article “Why College Isn't And Shouldn't Have to be For Everyone” by Robert Reich, he states that “A degree from a prestigious university can open doors to elite business schools and law schools-and to jobs paying hundreds of thousands, if not millions. ”Even though Reich’s article is on the opposing side of the argument, he fails to overlook the fact that in the long run having a college degree will, and can open doors to many new opportunities. One of those opportunities is to be able get a well paying job that can earn more than the average non college graduate.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Is College Worth The Cost?

1197 Words | 5 Pages

College education doesn't guarantee employment. In 2012, there was a lot of evidence suggesting the education to work link being broken. (Allen, 2011) A lot of college graduates are searching for work today. A lot of college students feel that college is a waste of money.

Read More

Synthesis Essay On Attending College

1019 Words | 5 Pages

A rising issue in today’s society is deciding whether or not college is worth the cost. There is an extreme amount of pressure that is forced upon high school students by parents, teachers, and peers to further their education and attend college. However, there is research that challenges the thought that college is the best possible path for a person to take. College may be a great investment for some people, but it is not meant for everyone. This is supported by the arguments that colleges are expensive, jobs do not always require a college degree, and students are forced to choose a lifestyle before being exposed to the real world.

Read More

Argument Essay: Reducing College Tuition

1328 Words | 6 Pages

In recent years, the economy and job outlook has become super competitive throughout the States. With so many people seeking and applying for the same job, employers can only afford to hire a very small amount of people. As a result, they choose the best qualified applicant, which most likely means the applicant with the highest education. With competition increasing exponentially, it is becoming more and more difficult to find, let alone keep a job. That is why college is a necessity in today’s society.

Read More

Degree Attainment

728 Words | 3 Pages

There is a positive correlation between higher levels of education and higher earnings for all racial/ethnic groups and for both men and women. Furthermore, college graduates are more likely than others to enjoy employer-provided health insurance and pension benefits (Baum & Ma, 2007; Pacarella & Terenzini, 2005). To illustrate this point, compare the average earnings of individuals with a bachelor degree relative to the average earnings of individuals with a high school diploma, expressed as a percentage, it is reasonably clear that the premium to bachelor’s degree has increased in the past twentieth century (Boesel & Fredland, 1999; Bound & Johnson, 1992; Freeman, 1994; Grogger & Eide, 1995; Katz & Murphy, 1992; Levy & Murnane, 1992; Murphy and Welch, 1992; Pencavel, 1991). In 1971, both male and female bachelor’s degree holders had an average annual earnings advantage (adjusted for inflation) of 48.5 percent over those who only hold a high school diploma (Pacarella & Terenzini, 2005). The typical bachelor’s degree recipient in 2007 can be expected to earn about 61 percent more than the typical high school graduate (Baum & Ma,

Read More

American Education System Analysis

665 Words | 3 Pages

What a lot of the jobs that the college graduates want are more interested in the students have skills such as critical thinking and communicating and solving complex problems. A lot of jobs consider the skills to communicating are more important than a college degree. I personally agree with the statements the author made about jobs care more about critical thinking and solving complex problems than college degree is because if you have a college degree it doesn't necessarily mean than you are well fit for the job,(“It Takes More than a Major”:) I can bring another example from my cousin who has a Bachelors of science for accounting who spent nearly two years looking for a job for accounting many of the jobs turned her down she was telling me about how many of the jobs didn't really care about her degree in accounting what they wanted was a candidate who had experience it goes back to show what the problem is with our education system is not preparing the students for the job difficulties they will face on the long

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Why Go To College

558 Words | 3 Pages

, “Experts that have researched the performance and job success of college graduates have concluded that, nationwide, college graduates with a bachelor's degree earn 74 percent more per year than those who only complete high school.” This seems very logical when you look at the big picture, having furthered your education will open you up to more jobs that that require more education that will most likely pay more. The University of North Texas in their article “Why Go to College?” shows a graph from The U.S. Census Bureau that shows a professional degree could earn you around 4.4 million dollars compared to less than a high school diploma could earn you around 1 million dollars for a whole worklife. Seeing

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Is A College Degree Worth It?

418 Words | 2 Pages

Although a degree is not essential for those looking to work in the more hands on fields of work, such being a plumber or an electrician, degree holders can look to not only make more, but to also fulfill more brain satisfying tasks in more intellectual fields of work. Even with that in consideration, a degree can help those that work in fields where holding a degree is not commonplace. “Construction workers, police officers, retail salespeople and secretaries, among others, make significantly more with a degree than without one.” (Leonhardt)

Read More

More about Our Overeducated Workforce Summary

Related Topics

Open Document