ipl-logo

The Knight's Tale Vs Pardoners Tale Essay

990 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Morals of the pardoner's tale

In both “The Knight's Tale” and “The Pardoner's Tale,” there are valuable lessons that should be recognized. Each tale was not only educational, but they were also entertaining, they both held a strong meaning behind them. Here is the real question: does one tale trump the other? Did one have a more valuable lesson? Well, the answer is yes. “The Knight's Tale” had more moral value and it vital points that are important, while “The Pardoner's Tale” was more for entertainment. In “The Knight’s Tale,” both Palamon and Arcita are held as prisoners of war by King Theseus. One day, Palamon was looking outside of his cell and saw a beautiful woman named Emily. He instantly fell in love with her. When Arcita had saw Emily, he fell in love as well, which was very unsettling for Palamon. Then, one day, Theses had only freed Arcita upon the request of a friend, which angered Palamon because now Arcita could spend countless hours with Emily and win her heart. Little did he know that Artcita could not be seen at the kingdom or he would be executed. Still, this did not stop Arcita because he ended up disguising himself anyway. After a couple of years, Palamon had enough and drugged the prison guard in order to escape. When Palamon ran out of town and found Arcita they began to fight for Emily’s love. Theseus found them fighting and was displeased that they were …show more content…

Personally, I believe “The Knight's Tale” had more meaning behind it than “The Pardoner’s Tale” considering that a vital lesson was learned at the end. “The Knight’s Tale” states that you should be careful for what you wish for. While “The Pardoner’s Tale” included three drunken men that ultimately when behind each others backs for the sake of wealth and the ending was fatal. Therefore, I believe it is more entertaining than knowledgeable. This being said, “The Knight’s Tale” showed better understanding of the

Show More
Related
313 Words | 2 Pages

The parables between A Knights Tale by Hegeland and “A Knights Tale” by Chaucer may seem to be similar, but if you look deeper they differ from one another. The moral lesson that you obtain from the movie A Knights Tale has more of a “you can do anything you put your mind to” type of lesson. In the movie the saying they use is “Change your stars” and that is based off William coming from being a peasant, to wanting to be known as a knight. He overcame many challenges by doing whatever it took him to become a knight.

Read More
66 Words | 1 Pages

Chaucer wrote The Pardoner's Tale with the ideas of hypocrisy in mind. He attacks this subject with a thorough use of personification and irony in his story telling. Chaucer captivates these rhetorical techniques multiple times throughout the piece. He brilliantly personifies the ideas of greed and death, as a walking man. He also displays irony throughout the story with also the ideas of greed and death.

Read More
1189 Words | 5 Pages

Some may say that it is more suspenseful because towards the end two of the rioters plan to kill the other rioter when he returns from the town so that they only have to split all of the golf two ways instead of three. While the one rioter was in the town he bought poison to put in the other two rioters drink, hoping to have all the gold to himself. Although it may be suspenseful “The Wife of Bath’s Tale” is overall more entertaining and suspenseful than “The Pardoner’s Tale.” In the beginning of “The Wife of Bath’s Tale” the queen says to the knight, “yet you shall live if you can answer me: What is the thing women most desire” (187). Later in the story it is also very suspenseful because the knight had to go back to the queen after a year and a day and he did not yet have the answer to the question but then he met the old woman and everything changed.

Read More
1053 Words | 5 Pages

The Canterbury Tales depicts the differing levels of society of the Medieval period. The tales with the most notable differences are “The Pardoner’s Tale” and “The Reeve’s Tale.” The former story is about three men consumed by greed, which ultimately leads them to their h. The latter tale is about two clerks who seek revenge on a miller who steals grain from their school. “The Pardoner’s Tale” and “The Reeve’s Tale” drastically differ in their moral themes that depict revenge, sin, and greed. “The Pardoner’s Tale” illustrates the effects of revenge, sin, and greed.

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

The Canterbury Tales all have the same common factor of depicting a common social issue or truth. However, the Pardoner’s Tale depicts an important, universal and timeless message of greed. Greed is the intense and selfish desire for something, especially wealth, power, or food. It is a common factor in the chaotic history of humanity because, as the Pardoner’s Tale describes it, greed is the root of all evil. This tale is timeless and universal because of no matter when or where greed will always be the source of chaos and depravity.

Read More
685 Words | 3 Pages

“ Down to my heart, and that my bane will be. The beauty of the lady I see”(p.41, lines 240-241). They were both captivated and fell completely in love with her at first glance. Palamon and Arcita would do anything in order

Read More
888 Words | 4 Pages

In “ The Pardoner's Tale” and “ The Wife of Bath” by Geoffrey Chaucer, the people who do not learn from the mistakes they make suffer repercussions. In “The Pardoner's Tale” a major theme of greed surfaces, and it plays a role in the decisions of the three rioters. The men decide it is necessary to take revenge on death for the killing of their friend, where avengement is a very noble deed. After the men rally themselves as a brotherhood, they find an old man who points them in the direction he last saw death, “[They] began to run, and reached the tree,and there they found a pile of golden florins on the ground” (lines 167-169).

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

Both of their tales were quite interesting, but the knight did in fact tell a better story. The knights story captivated its readers by attaching them to its characters, making every failure, emotion, and success affect the reader personally, and by the end of the tale the reader was able to take away a lesson they would never forget. The knight's tale spoke of two brothers in arms, who had sworn a blood oath to protect each other, and die for eachother. However, when they both fell in love with the same woman, all the memories and promises of the past were gone.

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

After reviewing the two tales “ The Pardoner's Tale” and “ The Wife of Bath's Tale” told by Chaucer, one tale effects me the most. Out of the two tales, I believe “The Pardoner's Tale” has better moral values and is more entertaining than, “The Wife of Bath”. The first reason that makes”The Pardoner's Tale” effective is the

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

As a result of his injuries, Arcite dies soon after. Years of mourning Arcite’s death have passed, but finally, Palamon marries Emily, and they lived, happily

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

“There are three gates to self-destructive hell: lust, anger, and greed” was a quote of an Indian text called the Bhagavad Gita. Chaucer’s stories “the wife of bath” and “pardoner 's tale” in Canterbury Tales are good examples of the Indian text written in two different stories. In both of the tales Chaucer describes greed into very distinct ways, one involves a greed for lust the other involves a greed for money. In Chaucer 's the pardoner 's tale you can easily tell the type of greed that is in the story ,which is the greed for money. This is also one of the most ironic tale since the pardoner is the most greediest person amongst the group.

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

Of all intelligence and intuition attributed to man, it is not enough to overcome the characteristics that will lead to the downfall of our own kind. Such characteristics take root in man and protrude out of him no matter how hard he tries to deny their presence. Man himself is aware of these characteristics and they play a part on all forms of entertainment, and fuel almost all actions made by man. In “The Pardoner’s Tale” written by Chaucer, the theme of pride and greed leading to demise is prominent.

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

The Pardoners Tale is a short story about three irresponsible men who caused nothing but trouble. The men would spend their nights drunk, nearly hopeless. " No, let me drink the alcohol of the grape"

Read More
330 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout the Pardoner's tale, the Pardoner tells a story about the love of money and its consequences. However, instead of applying these lessons to his life, he completely neglects the morals of the story and continues down a path of

Read More
402 Words | 2 Pages

“The Pardoner’s Tale” by Geoffrey Chaucer, the three rioters originally planned to travel to kill Death. After traveling less than half a mile, The three rioters met a poor, old man; the old man told them where they could find Death. The three rioters followed his directions and found not Death but a pot of gold coins under a tree. After, discovering the gold coins, they secretly plotted to kill each other, hoping to keep the treasure to only himself. Because of this, the role of the gold coins acted as the source and main cause of their death.

Read More

More about The Knight's Tale Vs Pardoners Tale Essay

Related Topics

Open Document