In the short story “participation trophies send a dangerous message” written by Betty Berden, Berden talks about how children shouldn’t be rewarded for participating only to winners. Also reading from “participating trophies send a powerful message” written by Parker Abate, Abate discusses how children should be rewarded with trophies because of their hard work and dedication. “In addition to acknowledging their effort, they also received trophies or certificates, reminding them that they were part of a team. Children should be rewarded with trophies for participating so that everyone is treated equally. While reading both passages, “participation trophies send a dangerous message” by Betty Berden and “participation trophies send a powerful
When I was younger, I received candy from my teacher for having the highest grade on a test, but everyone else also got candy for just taking the test. They gave everyone candy so no one felt left out, which is wrong because they are rewarding children who do not deserve rewards. In “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden, she makes a claim that is the opposite of Parker Abate’s in “In Youth Sports, Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message”. Children should not receive participation trophies. Betty Berden believes that participation trophies boost children's egos, making them believe that they should get a trophy for every simple thing that they do in their lives.
In the article “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden, she talks about why children should not receive participation trophies. On the other hand, in the article “In Youth Sports, Participation Trophies Send a Power Message” by Parker Abate, states why should children receive participation trophies? Kids should not receive participation rewards or trophies. Why shouldn't children receive trophies? According to Berden, there are many reasons why kids should be rewarded for participation.
The popular statement, “Children are our future," applies to life every day. We are responsible for what we give to them and know how it will affect them. In the article, “Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message” by Betty Berden, Berden explains the negative effects of giving participation trophies to children. Another author who explains the effect of participation trophies is Parker Abate. In Abate’s article, “Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message,” Abate highlights the positive effects of a participation trophy.
Participation trophies also show the children that if you work together, you can do a whole lot. In the text it says, “Let us give the winners a trophy and the participants a certificate or give them all small trophies”. These kids dedicate time, effort, and enthusiasm, and they deserve to have something tangible to make them feel that their participation was worthwhile.” This is beneficial because it helps the children establish some confidence and helps them feel a part of the team that they worked hard to be in. Finally, with the evidence provided, while participation trophies are pointless and send the wrong message, they are still beneficial to a young child's
Initially, participation trophies should be handed out to children because it boosts their self-esteem. While some people believe that trophies should be given out to “first, second and third” place
In our society, trophies symbolize numerous ideologies. While instant glorification is nice, this feeling of gratification will not last forever. In the passage, “Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message,” written by Parker Abate, the author debates the topic of whether kids should receive participation trophies. Children should be rewarded with participation awards because it teaches them to value self-esteem and teamwork.
Did you ever receive those small medals back in middle school after participating in a sports match? In two articles, “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden and “In Youth Sports, Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message” by Parker Abate, they talk of the negative and positive aspects of handing out participation awards to teams or athletes. Some people may say that giving participation awards allows others to have a false sense of society or reality; however, because of the acknowledgement of achievements to athletes and the applicable life lessons learned from the effort put into the game, kids should be able to receive participation trophies. There are some people who say that giving participation awards allows kids to have a false sense of society or
In “In Youth Sports, Participation Trophies Send a Powerful Message” they state, “Self-esteem is a big part of one’s childhood. Watching a peer receive a trophy and not receiving one yourself can be degrading. Any kind of honor can make a young kid feel as if he or she meant something to the team, and that can boost the child’s self –confidence.” Basically, when a child gets a trophy and other children do not, that can hurt the child. They can begin to think “Oh I am not good enough to get a trophy” or “I do not need to keep playing this sport”, and just negative thoughts.
Should Children Receive Trophies Just For Participating? What are trophies? They are memorable tokens that symbolize hard work and excellence. They are symbols of winners who worked hard to try and reach their goal.
While it is true that becoming a champion could be pressurizing to a younger child, wanting to be the best around at something is something that carries on even outside of sports, into life. We should be expecting kids to want to compete to win, not just to be participating. To be the winner of a sport will give you the mental mindset to be the best at other things later in life, such as being the best at their job, or being the best in school. One way that participation trophies could actually work is if each award was given to the child player with a purpose. The coach stating each players strength on the team as they hand them the award could give a powerful message to the children, showing them that they have control over their success.
Alex P. Doxsee Mr. Masih English 10 Lyceum 19 March 2016 Should Participation Trophies Stay or Should they go? Most people think that those little participation trophies that we get as children were great but, were they really something much worse in disguise? “It’s child abuse to give a kid a trophy that he has not earned. If a parent’s responsibility is to teach a kid how to deal with the real world, then that is child abuse. Because that’s not the real world” (Vance).
Secondly, it kills the competition. When participation trophies are given out, kids lose motivation. "The biggest complaint is that participation trophies discourage hard work and diminish competition. " The Participation Trophy Controversy: Problem or Progress? Studies show when every kid gets a trophy, it becomes somewhat of a "hollow victory" for the kids.
To summarize, not everyone who participates in an activity should get a trophy because it makes children feel
The thought going through most children 's minds is, "why try if I know I am going to get a trophy anyway." A trophy is always secured in their mind. Trophies today have a whole new meaning. They do not symbolize a victory or achievement; they are merely reminders of childhood. Betty Berdan, a junior in high school says, "When awards are handed out like candy to every child who participates, they diminish in value.
