ipl-logo

Patterson & Wilkins: Case Study

634 Words3 Pages

Is it ethical to report the facts of a story, especially stories with accusations tied to them, without doing independent research to find the truth? Case study 2-D presented by Patterson & Wilkins (2014, p. 42) is concerned with whether it can be irresponsible to use objective reporting when someone’s reputation is on the line. Objective reporting refers to the practice of presenting information objectively to allow a public forum of discussion, but many people have also argued that the press shouldn’t print stories unless they know “the truth of the facts” (Patterson & Wilkins, 2014, p. 43). Stories should be reported in a fair and balanced manner, but stories can’t be considered balance if the presented information isn’t fully investigated. …show more content…

The lack of research done into the accusations being presented in the article is directly opposed the ethical news value of confirmation. Confirmation refers to writing articles that can withstand scrutiny from the public and attempting to find the truth in news situations, but Laurens submitted a story that did not consider investigating the truth behind the mayor’s accusations (Patterson & Wilkins, 2014, p. 35). Similarly, the mayor is wrong when arguing that Laurens provided balanced coverage for both sides of the controversy without trying to judge which side is right. The story was not balanced because it presented information that did not have context and didn’t seek to explore the truth behind the mayor’s accusations. The article heavily favored the mayor as a result of the lack of research. Many postmodernists argue that context is everything and facts can’t stand alone, but Laurens did not provide proper context in the article (Patterson & Wilkins, 2014, p. 24). Accordingly, the councilman was correct when he argued the Laurens was irresponsible by ignoring the “truth of the facts.” In essence, the story was presented to the public without proper research into the controversy where the coherence theory of truth states reporters should investigate facts and ideas through a variety of methods (Patterson & Wilkins, 2014, p. 25). The story was simply rushed as information was being gathered right before the

Show More
Related

Annotated Bibliography: Jonbenét Ramsey Murder Case

1134 Words | 5 Pages

With this information, the authors argue their point thoroughly to get all the known facts across. The tone of the text gives a sense of legitimacy. The authors’ use of containing their information in one article helps to get their point across without missing any crucial points. “When word leaked that prosecutors dismissed the jury's five alternate members over the winter, many people in Boulder took it as a sure sign that the proceedings were nearing an end--and that arrests were

Read More

Noah Rothman's Essay 'Taking Sides In Ferguson'

917 Words | 4 Pages

Rothman scolds the media for physically participating in the riots. It proposes that the media themselves are lawless criminals, and invalidates many stories. Similarly James Fallows accuses the media of defying ethics in his article “Learning to Love the (Shallow, Divisive, Unreliable) New Media” with the statement, “Gawker posted the pictures and headline, “I Had a One Night Stand with Christine O’Donnell” (36). The headline from Gawker illustrates the lengths that journalists will go to get a story. The headline suggests that the media destroys people’s livelihood in order to sell a story, even if there is no basis for the story or accusation.

Read More

Chris Byers Accused In The Killings Of 3 Boys

757 Words | 4 Pages

Body Paragraph #2: analysis of the bias in your second article A. Topic Sentence (A) In the New York Times article, “3 Teen-Agers Accused in the Killings of 3 Boys”, there is a great deal of bias by word choice. B. Quote (C): “ Chris Floyd, a 16-year-old from Marion High School, said Mr. Baldwin kept to himself at school, hanging out other times with Mr. Echols and Mr. Misskelley, who were both high school dropouts.” C. Explain (E) This publisher assumes that these kids are as horrible as everyone else made them out to be, because 2 of the 3 kids who were accused of murder, so happened to be dropouts.

Read More

Summary Of Bias By Bernard Goldberg

721 Words | 3 Pages

Media that could reflect the real America should be based on diversity of views, pluralism of opinion as the American society. First of all, when someone provides the truth of the actual situation, that person is automatically called a “whistle blower”. There are not many of those people, which are willing to expose all secrets that would benefit the society by finding out the actual story. As Goldberg elaborates in his insider book, danger is a big risk factor to them, losing a job for example, takes a lot of courage or foolishness to do that. Goldberg states that it should be normal common sense for the media give accurate information, which surprisingly does not happened in

Read More

What Is The Laramie Project Unethical

1222 Words | 5 Pages

In Moises Kaufman’s play The Laramie Project , a group of people travel to Laramie, Wyoming to conduct interviews about Matthew Shepard’s horrendous death. These people go into Laramie with the pre-determined notion that it was motivated by Shepards sexual orientation. , therefore they are very biased in this way. The media immediatly jumped on this case and made it a hate crime, and ignored all other evidence in the case. By doing this they stayed away from the problems that Shepard had, such as prostitution and Methamphetamine.

Read More

Controversial Issues In The Jungle By Upton Sinclair

981 Words | 4 Pages

From the time the word “muckraker” was conceived by President Roosevelt as an insult toward journalists, to the later years where the phrase was worn with pride, it remains that “muckraking” has had a profound impact on the way American society has reacted to controversial issues. While originally defined by Roosevelt as a journalist who ‘goes too far’ in the pursuit of their story, the definition has morphed through the years to mean one who “searches out and publicly exposes real or apparent misconduct of a prominent individual or business.” Though there have been a few instances where “muckraking” has led to an exaggerated response, when the proposed information was true, it had led to a groundbreaking awareness of situations in society.

Read More

Marion Barry Research Paper

687 Words | 3 Pages

The films The Nine Lives of Marion Barry and Anita, contribute to history in allowing us to go back in the past to see how we as a society chose how to handle scandals, which creates certain expectation and set boundaries during the era in which they occurred. With this information, we can then redefine the differences between events in the past and compare them today. For example, Barry was elected into office countless times after countless drug scandals surfaced about his coke addition, yet Anita Hill’s reputation was destroyed after she accused Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment. Many would consider this to be great injustice, resulting in confusion. As a result, the media plays such an important role in helping us understand and in showing how some scandals are very specific to time, place, and culture which is why people react differently to them.

Read More

Overdiagnosed Adhd In Children Summary

898 Words | 4 Pages

The use of subtle suggestive wording and questionable phrases can be seen throughout the article, sapping some of the credibility that he gains from his credentials. The use of wording such as, “I think” and “I believe” at the end of the article to form a broad conclusion, such as “I believe this denial has indirectly contributed to high rates of school dropouts and unnecessary commitments to juvenile detention centers.”(12) With his target audience such far-reaching statements could be construed as unprofessional and extremely subjective considering that his credentials state that he worked in a juvenile detention center for 10 years. He limits himself by placing his article on a professional website, and explains the case in an overly subjective manner without any reason. It’s very confusing why he address’s professionals in such a simple manner, but there is no question that the content of the article is excellent and it was enjoyable to

Read More

Analysis Of How To Read Nonfiction Like A Professor By Thomas C. Foster

763 Words | 4 Pages

The people of the internet spread a rumor that a child sex trafficking ring was being held in a pizza parlor basement… albeit, said pizza parlor has no basement. Foster points out that the bandwagon mentality fueling this claim could all have been avoided if people actually thought for themselves. Everything that happened surrounding this allegation is the consequences of today’s public lacking general critical reading and thinking skills. Had those skills been present, the conflict and misinterpretation could have been avoided, as the “ many listeners and commentators” thought this was the “fake news” she was referring to (Foster 94). These people took that to mean her idea of “fake news” was simply news that she didn’t like.

Read More

Bill Cosby Media Analysis

1451 Words | 6 Pages

Each news source has its own social and political view on who is considered the offender and victim. The viewpoint of that source can affect an individual’s perception on the case.

Read More

Little Rock 11: Impartiality For Journalists In 1958

864 Words | 4 Pages

Impartiality for Journalists in 1959 Reporters and journalists from around the country raced to Little Rock in 1959 to cover the unfolding events. People from across the world watched and read the events play out from news articles and their television. People could see the emotion, they could see the hate in the crowd, and the news story helped explain the scenes. Except, was the story accurate? Bias is a term used for news stories and their accuracy.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Nursing Ethics

1014 Words | 5 Pages

This lends the reader to believe there is a lack of current evidence to support Fowler’s claims, therefore, she loses credibility she might have had (Fowler, 2016, p. S9). Furthermore, when Fowler (2016) utilizes evidence such as “the 1926 “suggested code” it leaves her readers confused as to how Fowler has any relevance (p.S9). None of her readers can view her as credible because she never cites any of the current ethics policy. The lack of up to date information ultimately is a detriment to Fowler’s article, thus leaving her audience

Read More

Media Influence On Law Enforcement

1175 Words | 5 Pages

After all, news programming is meant to relay facts and inform of recent events. Does that mean undertone opinions should be adapted? When attempting to be the “first to report” a story, the lack of hesitation may allow for a story to be aired without all the facts. In the recent high profile events involving law enforcement, many times it initially appears the officer did something wrong. Viewers are incited, accusations fly, protests begin, and violence erupts creating a whole new situation for law enforcement fueled by media (Carlson, 91).

Read More

Watergate Essay

2193 Words | 9 Pages

Woodward and Bernstein relied heavily on anonymous sources to uncover information about the Watergate break-in and subsequent cover-up. They faced the ethical dilemma of whether to reveal the identity of their sources to protect their own credibility and that of the newspaper, or to protect the anonymity of their sources to ensure continued cooperation in the investigation. Following this, they were reporting on a scandal that involved the Nixon administration, which was also their primary source of news and information. They had to navigate the ethical minefield of reporting on a subject that could damage their relationships with key sources while maintaining their journalistic integrity. As they dug deeper into the Watergate story, Woodward and Bernstein had to decide whether to publish personal information about the people involved in the scandal.

Read More

Rolling Stone Article Analysis

728 Words | 3 Pages

In this article Sabrina Ederly interviewed Jackie, a student at University of Virginia, about a rape case at the campus. When she reported this interview to Rolling Stone she believed she was writing a perfectly good story about a rape on campus and helping everybody. However, she did not do enough research to make sure all the facts that were given to her were true and, therefore did not follow the ethics of writing. “Research ethics or norms promote the ‘knowledge, truth, and avoidance of error’ and protect against ‘fabricating, falsifying, or misinterpreting research data’” (Stichler, 2).She granted Jackie too much freedom

Read More

More about Patterson & Wilkins: Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document