ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Electoral Reform In The United States

3434 Words14 Pages

Owen Barnes Professor Raynaldo Composition and Rhetoric 1302 11 April 2024 Electoral Reform in the United States The United States voting system should be reworked because the currently used voting system is flawed and biased. While the Simple Majority Voting System and Single-Member districts, which are the current voting systems being used in the United States, do have advantages over other electoral systems, these small advantages are far outweighed by the advantages of other electoral systems. There does not exist a single electoral system or combination of electoral systems that are perfect in every, or even in a single, way. Though, this does not mean that electoral reform shouldn’t or couldn’t happen. The Ranked Choice Voting system, …show more content…

As a result of this convolutedness, many critics will also argue that the Ranked Choice System is actually worse in terms of representation. Specifically, critics argue, one critic, Dr. McCarty, claims in his article that “[Ranked Choice Voting] disproportionately decreases the representation and electoral influence of minority voters”. Dr. McCarty explains that this happens because “[minority voters] disproportionately ‘exhaust’ their ballots thereby removing them from decisive vote tabulations.” While these claims are not untrue, they do not necessarily hold merit either- it’s essential to take into account the effectiveness of a voting system varies greatly depending on context and a Every single voting system has potential pitfalls that are almost inevitable to arise as an issue at some point in time; despite this, the Ranked Choice Voting system, while not perfect, has been shown in multiple studies to improve the representation of both minorities and the majority through the curtailing of gerrymandering, political polarization, and other forms or causes of unfair democratic government. In conclusion, electoral reform is needed in the United States, as

Show More
Related

Summary Of How Democratic Is The American Constitution By Robert Dahl

1393 Words | 6 Pages

According to Article II, Section I of the Constitution, the number of electors in each state will be “equal to the whole number of Senators and Representatives to which the state may be entitled in the congress.” Every state has 2 senators (an equal number), which means that states with lower population size are represented the same as states with higher population numbers. Robert Dahl explains this unequal representation as “a situation in which your vote for your representative is counted as one while the vote of a friend in a neighboring town is counted as seventeen” (Dahl 2003). Unequal representation is a “violation” of democracy, completely discounting political equality among all citizens. The author argues that the Electoral College contains additional inherent problems, for example, the fact that the winner of popular votes may not be chosen for President unless they win the electoral votes.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Electoral College

351 Words | 2 Pages

The United States government is one of the most admired and complex in the world, On the contrary one of the fundamental components that has an extensive impression on the American People and the Election is the Electoral College. Our founding fathers created The Electoral College over two hundred years ago, and it is still in effect today. They feared that having just the Popular Vote would give too much power to one person. In this paper, we will be discussing what the Electoral College is, the benefits and disadvantages of the Electoral College as well as if the Electoral College should be abolished or reconstructed.

Read More

Should The Electoral College Be Abolished Dbq Analysis

635 Words | 3 Pages

Time-out for the Electoral College Write thesis here. Write Background here. Write prompt/question here. The Electoral College is unfair and should be abolished because third party candidates are given no chance to win the election, voting isn’t distributed equally, and it is undemocratic and flawed. One reason why the Electoral College should be abolished is that it’s almost impossible for third party candidates to win.

Read More

DBQ Essay: The Electoral College

967 Words | 4 Pages

As one of the most hotly debated areas of the US government, the Electoral College deserves to be given a more in-depth look. It was originally founded as a way to prevent a lack of informed voters from electing an unqualified president. Now, it still serves its original purpose, but has become far less necessary in an age of easily accessible information. Despite having some positive points, the Electoral College is too overburdened by issues like unfair vote distribution and a high failure rate to be an effective system. The way the Electoral College distributes votes is overtly favorable to less populated states.

Read More

Should Electoral College Be Abolished Dbq Essay

1100 Words | 5 Pages

The existence of the Electoral College has remained a source of debate for the population of the United States for centuries. Despite the evident discontent surrounding it, the United States is largely unaware of the disconnect between citizens’ voices and the Presidency. It can be said that popular sovereignty, no matter how pleasant a concept, has become little more than an illusion the people cling to. In short, the Electoral College is an institution that must be abolished, because it violates political equality, is unfair to third party candidates, and is not an accurate representation of the people’s votes.

Read More

Summary Of Maintaining American Democracy Not Through Reform

2144 Words | 9 Pages

March 21, 2016 Jessica Sanford ! 1 Maintaining American Democracy Not Through Reform (PG Independent Study) Introduction In Reforming the Republic - Democratic Institutions for the New America Todd Donovan and Shaun Bowler discuss the necessity to reform the American electoral process and ways in which it could be done. Although the article discusses in depth how and why civil participation and trust in the government are severely lacking, it does not pose a convincing argument for codifying a new electoral process through changes to the Constitution, nor does it present specific paths to take for change. Their overarching argument is this: the American electoral system must be reformed through amending the Constitution in order to increase

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Abolishing The Electoral College

876 Words | 4 Pages

An article published by Brookings Institution counters Pate’s argument, and explains how the current Electoral College system is unrepresentative of the majority. Darrel West writes that “at a time of high income inequality and substantial geographic disparities across states, the Electoral College systematically over-represents the views of relatively small numbers of people” (West). These states have a smaller population, and “smaller economic activity [disproportionate to the] power to choose presidents and dictate public policy”

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Electoral College System

1006 Words | 5 Pages

On the other hand there are those who wish to abolish the Electoral College and label this action as “past its due date”. These people argue that it is no longer effective in a nation where media presents us with the information needed to make informed decisions. These critics argue that it presents unequal and unfair representation of the people and individual states by not always being representative of the popular vote and place the final vote in the hands of only a select amount of elected officials. The most significant aspect to be considered by the American people is whether or not the Electoral College is still efficient in the mass media influenced society and ever changing world we live in today in order to decide whether the system our forefathers created for us needs to update, is outdated, or a fair representation of the American

Read More

Should Electoral College Be Abolished Research Paper

837 Words | 4 Pages

The Electoral College Needs to be Abolished Every four years, millions of Americans rush to the polls to vote for the next President of the United States of America. What many Americans voting today may not know is that they are participating in an unfair system; this system is taking power from a majority of Americans and placing an emphasis on the few. The best solution to this problem is the simplest one, abolish the Electoral College. The Electoral College should be abolished because of over-representation of small states. “The Electoral College violates political equality”.

Read More

Electoral College Should Be Abolished Essay

1104 Words | 5 Pages

The United States democratic political system serves to pursue practices that are quite undemocratic. The flawed principles consist of an abundance of issues with a major one being the electoral college. This controversial practice is a heated argument amongst politicians and everyday civilians. The real question is however, is the system in place the prime resolution to maintain a democracy in which the people’s vote actually count? The Electoral College should be abolished with the amount of complications instilled in it and be replaced by a popular vote implementation in order to have a healthy and equal democracy.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Electoral College

491 Words | 2 Pages

Therefore, the electoral college is an outdated practice containing discriminatory matters and numerous loop-holes; it is time for a change in our county. In order to create a system the states would agree to, the electoral

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Electoral College

910 Words | 4 Pages

The electoral college has controlled the voting system within the United States since the writing of the United States Constitution. The system promises to fix problems that would otherwise exist in a popular vote system, but also exhibits many problems of its own that are often overlooked. In this essay, I will argue that the current model of the electoral college should no longer be in place in the United States of America. I will begin with the most common and obvious reason that the electoral college is criticized. The ideas that make up the electoral college directly conflict with those of a true democracy.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Implementing The Electoral College

839 Words | 4 Pages

Being a person of politics yourself, you of all people should know that many compromises have been made over the course of the establishment of the United States. However, some of the compromises, like the electoral college, were made because of factors in the past and are now not needed in today’s modern democracy. While the electoral college once worked as a compromise in the past, it is an archaic system that unfairly represents the votes of citizens all across the nation. A popular vote should instead be utilized to fairly choose the people of power in this country and would better represent voters’ opinions. In implementing the electoral college, most states’ votes either go to one candidate or the other, leading to candidates to only campaign in swing states (Bradford Plumer 13).

Read More

Essay On Electoral College Vote

2998 Words | 12 Pages

The United States utilizes a fair, equally representative system to elect its president, right? Wrong. By examining the most basic criterion of evaluating elections, the classic “Everyone’s vote should count the same,” the United States, and more specifically the Electoral College, is doing an unequivocally terrible job representing its citizens in presidential elections. The Electoral College currently counts one Vermonter’s vote as equal to three Texans’, and one Wyomingite’s vote is worth four Californians’. Clearly this is unacceptable, and thankfully it can be changed.

Read More

Essay On Vote In Democracy

736 Words | 3 Pages

In the United States, people always talk about freedom and equality. Especially they want elections could be more democratic. In American Democracy in Peril, Hudson’s main argument regarding chapter five “Election Without the People’s Voice,” is if elections want to be democratic, they must meet three essential criteria, which are to provide equal representation of all citizens, to be mechanisms for deliberation about public policy issues, and to control what government does. Unfortunately, those points that Hudson mentions are what American elections do not have. American elections do not provide equal representation to everyone in the country.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Electoral Reform In The United States

Open Document