ipl-logo

Evolution And Challenges Of The United States Electoral College

2242 Words9 Pages

San Diego State University From Compromise to Controversy: The Evolution and Challenges of the United States Electoral College. Maria Sakhnova POL S436: The American Presidency. Prof. Kimberley Fletcher. 21 March. 2024 The Electoral College, as envisioned by the Framers of the Constitution, was intended to serve as a compromise between the presidential election by Congress and the popular vote. However, the practical application of this system has experienced significant challenges, specifically in how states select electors. These changes have steered the institution away from its foundational goals, thereby affecting its effectiveness and the level of democratic representation it provides in American politics. This essay argues …show more content…

Secondly, this paper investigates specific amendments and legislative reforms intended to improve the Electoral College system, focusing specifically on the implications and outcomes of the 12th Amendment. Next, an examination of the fluctuations in state-level electoral methods, highlighting the diverse approaches such as the winner-take-all rule, and the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, will demonstrate their significant impact on the Framers’ intended balance of power. Finally, this paper concludes with an evaluation of how current changes at the state level have impacted the Electoral College’s effectiveness and alignment with the original democratic ideals envisioned by the Founding Fathers. This analysis will explore whether these changes only solve operational challenges within the Electoral College, or if they represent a significant departure from the foundational democratic ideas that the Framers aimed to incorporate into American electoral processes. The Electoral College was established during the 1787 Constitutional Convention in response to disputes over the presidential election process. A faction led by James Madison and Alexander Hamilton sought a federal

Show More
Related
351 Words | 2 Pages

The United States government is one of the most admired and complex in the world, On the contrary one of the fundamental components that has an extensive impression on the American People and the Election is the Electoral College. Our founding fathers created The Electoral College over two hundred years ago, and it is still in effect today. They feared that having just the Popular Vote would give too much power to one person. In this paper, we will be discussing what the Electoral College is, the benefits and disadvantages of the Electoral College as well as if the Electoral College should be abolished or reconstructed.

Read More
1603 Words | 7 Pages

To What Extent Should the United States Restructure its Electoral College System? : States With the 2016 election in the books, the United States has elected a candidate that lost the popular vote by over two million votes. This is the second time in the twenty first century that this has occurred. In such a democratic nation, the ability to win the important office of the presidency without popular consent raises a few concerns about the two hundred and forty year old system. In a democracy, the voices of the states and their respective populations must be heard.

Read More
605 Words | 3 Pages

Did you know that in two out of the last five U.S. presidential elections, the candidate who won the popular vote did not win the presidency? Now, to explore the question, Should We Abolish the Electoral College? The very system that defies the will of the majority. This question is often being thought about as the Electoral College has what some may argue advantages and perks, but it does have its downsides and what some may argue flaws. We will be exploring on why the current Electoral College should be left alone, as it does not allow the majority to always get their way, it ensures that all parts of a country is involved in the election and that candidates will serve the entire country, and lastly, the Electoral College creates a compromise between popular vote and congressional choice.

Read More
1100 Words | 5 Pages

The existence of the Electoral College has remained a source of debate for the population of the United States for centuries. Despite the evident discontent surrounding it, the United States is largely unaware of the disconnect between citizens’ voices and the Presidency. It can be said that popular sovereignty, no matter how pleasant a concept, has become little more than an illusion the people cling to. In short, the Electoral College is an institution that must be abolished, because it violates political equality, is unfair to third party candidates, and is not an accurate representation of the people’s votes.

Read More
397 Words | 2 Pages

The United States has benefited from the Electoral College for hundreds of years. This essay will discuss the presidential voting process and the merits of the Electoral College. The Electoral College is a more effective method of choosing the president than the general election. This is due to the fact that it greatly improves efficiency and ensures the integrity of the election. There would be a huge number of candidates to pick from if the Electoral College did not exist and we had a public vote instead.

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

The decision to abolish the electoral college is not a new one. Ever since the introduction of the Constitution, with the electoral college being introduced in the second article and reaffirmed in the Twelfth Amendment, over seven hundred propositions have been made to modify or abolish the electoral college. Even though these attempts have all failed, it is important to note that there are major flaws in this system, and the decision to abolish, or discontinue, this way of life should be reevaluated. The first and largest flaw of this presidential college is its potential for corruption and misrepresentation.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

The recent presidential election has had a controversy on the abolishment of the Electoral College. With many citizens not understanding whether or not their vote is actually being counted during the election, more debates have risen on if popular vote should be the deciding factor of presidential determinations instead. Popular vote is an actual count of individual votes from all states in America while the Electoral College is a measure of the House of Representatives and Senators choosing directly who the president should be (Kimberling, 1992). The reasoning behind why the Electoral College was the determining factor for president was declared by the founding fathers decades ago to ensure equality (Pavia, 2011). Recently, critics have expressed that this system is not as equal as predetermined.

Read More
876 Words | 4 Pages

Pate claims that presidential candidates would ignore “issues Iowans care about, particularly rural matters” (Pate). He asserts that abolishing the electoral college would harm these smaller states. However, in a majority-wins-all election, every vote is equally important. This cannot be said for the Electoral College currently, as it favors smaller swing states and ignores bigger states. Pate argues for equality, but fails to recognize that the current system does not fairly represent the entire country.

Read More
1607 Words | 7 Pages

In November of 2012, Donald Trump would tweet arguably one of the most ironically true statements he has ever articulated: “The electoral college is a disaster for democracy!” Although he didn’t know it then, Donald Trump’s position on the Electoral College would soon change. Following election day in November of 2016, Donald Trump was elected the 45th President of the United States despite losing the general election to Hillary Clinton by over 2.8 million votes. He did, however, win the Electoral College by 74 votes; winning with a system he had once looked at with disdain. Trump’s presidential victory has reignited debate over whether the country should continue to utilize the Electoral College. This vexing system is not an easy one to change and erasing it completely from our political system has complex and serious consequences.

Read More
2474 Words | 10 Pages

Though the Electoral College is a cornerstone of American government and politics from its conception in the early years of the United States to modern day, its time and purpose has come and gone and the Electoral College, as we know it, should be placed in the country’s rearview

Read More
378 Words | 2 Pages

The modern electoral college is a remarkable refurbish of the

Read More
594 Words | 3 Pages

Abheek Nath Kathleen Rothman Introduction to American Government 1 March 2024 The Electoral College: How it Perpetuates an Unrepresentative Democracy The struggle for democracy and managing the delicate balance between a rule of the people and of governing institutions is perpetual. One important, current form of this struggle is how the United States elects its next president. To resolve this, the Electoral College should be abolished.

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

Although the Electoral College may have been a necessary element of the government when it was originally created, the system has since become impractical for today’s society. The will of the people is now far better expressed through the resulting popular vote than the electorate of the Electoral College. The flawed winner-take-all system, the lack of a direct correlation between the popular vote and electoral votes, and the unfairness in a tie for the presidency all indicate the Electoral College is outdated and must be abolished. In the current electoral system, the slightest majority in a particular state means all of the votes in that state are given to the candidate that wins the majority.

Read More
977 Words | 4 Pages

A debate that has existed in American politics for centuries has flared up again. The debate in question is whether we should keep our Electoral College for the purpose of electing our President or abolish it and elect our Presidents through a popular vote. Those who seek to abolish the Electoral College cite instances -recent and past- in which Presidential Candidates have won the popular vote yet lost the majority of the Electoral College. They also argue that the undemocratic philosophy behind the Electoral College, the thought that the American people aren’t competent enough to choose their own Commander in Chief, is an outdated remnant of a backwards past that has no place in modern society and law. Those who seek to preserve the Electoral

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

When the making of the Electoral College, the founding fathers took into condensation that the small states might not be noticed, so they had to take some of the electoral votes from the bigger states. And to add on to the existence Allen Guelzo and James Hulme go on to say that “It may appear inefficient. But the Founders were not interested in efficiency; they were interested in securing “the blessings of liberty.” With this in mind we can conclude that we do need change within its system, but its core values are at heart a system to help us. With this in mind, there has been many articles that help you explore the

Read More

More about Evolution And Challenges Of The United States Electoral College

Open Document