ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Whaling

1085 Words5 Pages

Whaling by Japanese has been an issue against protection of all whale species. There was the agreement uphold for the protection of whale from "overhunting." It is The International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling (ICRW) and signed in 1946. The purpose is to "provide for the proper conservation of whale stocks and thus, make possible the orderly development of the whaling industry".(1) Among fifteen nations agreed taking effect in November 1948. Durig the progress, Main objective of the agreement is to protect whale species from "over" hunting with rules for the whale fisheries such as Mexican, Japanese, and Norwegian to ensure proper conservation, development, and optimum utilization of whale resources. As to the agreement, the International Whaling Commission (IWC) was established under this convention. They are …show more content…

The early Japanese thought whales as deities of the sea, and it is useful for corralling fish. There were Whale Shrines to worship the whales they hunted as gods. As I said, components of cultures are value, religion, and cuisine. Whaling is a religion, cuisine and valuable to Japanese. We cannot say your culture is wrong.
2. Do you think the whaling ban constitutes a violation of these nations' sovereignty?
The purpose of the whaling ban is clear that "provide for the proper conservation of whale stocks and thus, make possible the orderly development of the whaling industry."(1) It is not to ban cultural or personal preferences. For the greatest good, for the greatest number, the intergovernmental organization can protect the environment if individual countries cannot do that. So the whaling ban is not the violation of Japanese' sovereignty.
3. How should these kinds of questions about cultural exemptions be settled? Should an international panel (such as a committee at the WTO) be asked to weigh the validity of such claims? Who should serve on such a

Show More
Related
761 Words | 4 Pages

However, word leaked out that the program was for commercial purposes. The meat then would be sold, ‘in food markets or given away free or at low costs to schools and hospitals to encourage the consumption of whale meat.’ Japan

Read More
1365 Words | 6 Pages

The Young Lords Movement is national movement that allowed Bodega to obtain the favor of Spanish Harlem easily because of its failures. The Young Lords movement was a Puerto Rican civil rights movement in the 1960’s that implemented violence to obtain recognition and equality as Puerto Ricans and better living conditions within their communities in New York and Chicago. As the Young Lords Party, the branch in New York, became increasingly involved in using armed movements and guerrilla tactics to make a stance in America, they ultimately reached their downfall. The new movement that Bodega inspires, however, is not one that uses weaponry to make proclamations about Nuyoricans to the outside world but one that restores the barrio from within

Read More
920 Words | 4 Pages

(Article 6) They also say that the MMPA only allows aborgational whaling and the Makah do it for cultural needs, which isn’t legal. (Article

Read More
662 Words | 3 Pages

Did you know that killer whales are the most disturbed mammals in the world (not counting humans)? Humans always postulate that killer whales like doing shows, actually some of them don’t. Even in the wild, killer whales are harmed, for example, people on cruises throw trash and food into the water if they see killer whales. There has been a big debate for many years about the topic of killer whales in captivity. However, since Blackfish aired in 2013, there has been an even bigger controversy about whether or not killer whales should be kept in captivity.

Read More
1190 Words | 5 Pages

In Act I scene v, Hamlet, the titular hero of the of William Shakespeare’s classic tragedy, bemoans the vile corruption that has manifested “in this distracted globe” (Shakespeare, trans. 1986, 1.5.101-102) after discovering the heinous murder of his father. This is only the first of numerous catastrophes to transpire in Denmark. The most spiteful of these misfortunes is the death innocent Ophelia, lover of Hamlet and daughter of Polonius. Although her drowning may initially appear to be an accident, Ophelia has lost the desire the live after enduring several tribulations, most notably the sudden murder of her father.

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

We can 't be certain that whale populations can survive large-scale hunting as well as the other daily threats they face. Ban or no ban, whaling remains inhumane and whales are unsuitable for use by humans in this way.” On The Nature Publishing Group they say that “ Major disadvantages of whaling include the potential extinction of some whale species, the unsafe levels of mercury that whale meat can contain and the potential harm to ecosystems that removing whales can cause. In addition, whale watching is a lucrative business in many parts of the world, and whaling could have an impact on that activity.

Read More
452 Words | 2 Pages

47 out of 50 states of the United States hunt for whales. Those states are Japan, Norway and Iceland. They still hunt since whales give them profit. As a result, Japan, Norway, and Iceland have often refused the idea of ending whaling even though they have many different resources that could still provide them. “It's one way that counties can earn profit."

Read More
1093 Words | 5 Pages

This quote shows the dangers of whaling because it is common for men to be injured at sea. Whales are enormous creatures whos instinct is to fight for their lives if they are in danger, leading them to cause destruction on ships and kill the men who hunt them. Once the whale is dead, the task of bringing the whale towards the ship is even harder. The crew works six hour shifts until the body is processed, taking days to finish depending on weather or size of whale. “Trying out a whale could take as long as three days.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

As a means of protecting the traditional fishing villages and communities that have always depended on such whaling, yes I agree with the cultural exception for the wale hunting ban. What I don't agree with, is using culture as a gateway excuse for commercial whaling. Traditional whaling does not include the need for a fishing village to own and operate a multi-million dollar fleet of large commercial whaling ships for example. The problem is that Japan and Norway were seeking exemptions as nations, which leaves the door open to commercial whaling for these nations under the exemptions. The claim is that they are defending their cultural heritage.

Read More
857 Words | 4 Pages

Since America is trying to impose this law on Norway and Japan, both parties should have a chance to present their reasons why or why not these countries should adhere to the International Whale ban. Members of the International Whaling Commission can also vote on the issue of whether or not whaling should be continued given the fact that whaling is a cultural right of these nations. The World Trade Organization may be asked to weigh in the validity of these claims, however, the decision should be unbiased. The WTO should research this issue and have an open mind to determine whether or not whaling is done for cultural means and if it should be continued. Also, if whaling be permitted in these countries, there should be certain limitations to prevent the endangerment of these species.

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

The Exemption for Whaling Issue 1. Do you agree with the Norwegian and Japanese position on permitting the hunting of non-endangered species of whales as a cultural exemption? My position on whaling is that it should be permitted for non-endangered species of whales. I respect the aspects of nature preservation, but judging culture and rating the life by how it disturbs emotions is favoritism.

Read More
772 Words | 4 Pages

If the acts of the Japanese and Norwegian people are part of their culture and not harming the well being of the people of the world they live in, then they should be permitted to continue the pursuit of retaining their heritage and cultural identity. It does not matter who sits on what panel, there should be some validity in the history of any such people. If whaling has been a significant aspect of their culture throughout history, anyone has the ability to research and identify the validity. I would define a cultural activity as an identifiable part of the society in question. Do they make tools and crafts for whaling?

Read More
1436 Words | 6 Pages

Abiding the international regulation system, the Convention provides protection worldwide for all species of whales from over-fishing with the participation of member nations. Even though the IWC is the main whaling authority, discrepancies arise due to Japan’s “untamed” whaling linked to “research”, causing NGO to be skeptic in the IWC’s authority. The IWC’s has given Japan the ability to kill a vast amount of

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

They also used baleen whales to make tennis racquets and corsets! Today, modern technology has replaced the need for whale products, so there is no need to kill whales for their oil” (Campaign Whale, n.d.). I don’t believe that the whaling ban constitutes a violation of these nations’ sovereignty. If other countries who used to be whalers can join with the rest of the world to ban whaling, why couldn’t Norway and Japan? This will be an opportunity for them to adapt or focus on other resources within their country to fill the void created by the whaling ban.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

Wildlife Conservation is often seen as a bad thing, but if you look at it from my perspective, then it is actually a good thing. People think of it as holding wild animals captive, but we are actually protecting them from poachers. The purpose of Wildlife Conservation is to protect the animals in danger, which I am in agreement 110%. Other people argue that we shouldn’t have conservations, but they don’t know the harm that can happen to unprotected animals.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Whaling

Related Topics

Open Document