ipl-logo

Psychoanalytical Criticism Of Turn Of The Screw By Henry James

1622 Words7 Pages

Psychoanalytical Criticism of Turn of the Screw- The Governess’ Descent Into Madness

When one looks at Freud, they can see that he was primarily concerned with the unconscious, as well as the conscious mind. He sought out the answers to the unconscious motives that drove people then, and still manage to drive us today. In Henry James’ “The Turn of the Screw”, we see an unnamed governess and those around her act strangely. These predominant questions arise - Did the governess actually see the apparitions of the governess and servant before her? What would motivate her to see them, or to even create them in her mind?

In Turn of the Screw, Henry James focusses on the Freudian notion that unconscious desires control the thoughts and actions …show more content…

Murfin compares Freud’s levels of the mind, based around structure or purpose, to an iceberg. It consists of three parts - the id, the ego and the superego. “The id, the part of the iceberg completely submerged in the unconscious, is driven by one’s libido and consists of the inherited components of one’s personality, including one’s sexual instinct. The second part of the iceberg, the ego, found in both the unconscious and conscious mind, can gain purpose from fulfilling the desires of the id. However, the ego–because it wavers between the unconscious and conscious only fulfills the desires of the id in ways that are socially acceptable. The last part of Freud’s iceberg, the superego, also found in both the unconscious and conscious mind, ensures that the one’s conscious actions are in tune with social standards and norms.” (Murfin). In Turn of the Screw, it seems as though the governess’ conscious and unconscious mind are a little off-kilter. The governess had a desire to fix the family; to swoop in and be the mothering figure that she thought the children didn’t have, yet needed. This isn’t even taking the evident Electra Complex (comparable to Oedipus Complex) from the governess towards the homeowner into consideration. The governess’ need to be the woman of the house and compete with the others for the affections of the uncle, combined with the loneliness could have driven her to madness. The uncle left …show more content…

When one looks to Ever Scarier: On The Turn of the Screw by Brad Leithouser one thing is made clear: “If the ghosts are mere illusions, then she is suffering a bout of insanity, in which her “revelations” about the children’s unearthly communications, and her perception of them as allied to unspeakable evil, must reflect her deeply suppressed aggressions and hostility.” This could speak on behalf of her aggression for things not going the rosy way she had intended them to. Miles wasn’t the good boy she had hoped he would be, with his being expelled from school and odd personality. Flora tried to suck up to the governess, then, in the governess’ delusioned mind, turned her nose up toward her by “communicating” with the deceased Ms. Jessel. As for Mrs. Grose, she wanted to see what the governess saw, but couldn’t, thus making the governess feel like she wasn’t validated in her new home. The governess felt oddly alone in all aspects that truly mattered besides one - her

Show More
Related
1157 Words | 5 Pages

Burch is a mentally ill and estranged women who no longer understands the needs of her children which causes the children to mature and develop in different ways like the city-states of Greece. Since Jennings’s mother performs such thoughtless or witless actions, Jennings is the one to pay for her deeds. “ ‘I couldn’t dear. I was sick’ “ (62) Jennings has just escaped from the terrors of The Home of the Angels, and Mrs. Burch thought that the usual excuse would cut it. However, this act would forever ensure Jennings that his mother will not be there for him when he needs her most.

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

Williams’ definition of a crisis apparition, “appears to a witness at a time when the person whose apparition is seen experiencing a state of crisis” (Williams 2), provides context to the theory that The Governess saw Peter Quint because of high levels of anxiety that she didn’t know how to control. Williams quotes from The Gift, a book written by Dr. Sally Rhine Feather and Michael Schmicker, and tells the story of a woman had undergone the hardship of moving halfway across the country with her daughter and leaving her father behind when he was extremely ill. The Governess was experiencing a similar stress level as the woman in the article. The Governess had received “disturbing letters from home, where things were not going well” (James 33). The mood in this

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

One significant moment of such, is shown in this quote, “She’s not alone, and at such times she’s not a child; she’s an old, old woman” (77). This quote may seem like its being directed towards Flora and Flora only, but instead portrays a sense of ambiguity that suggests that Flora is working with an old woman, perhaps Miss Jessel, the currently departed former governess. However within the context of that quote, there seems not to be a logical explanation as to why Flora had suddenly decided to sail a boat across the river, it’s infallible, to the point where all reasonable explanations are replaced with theories that only the supernatural could have caused it. With the governess assuming that Flora is in league with the ghost of Miss Jessel, it causes the governess to assume that the ghost of Peter Quint is associated with Miles, as seen in her description of the scene, “Peter Quint had come into view like a sentinel before a prison” (97).

Read More
1506 Words | 7 Pages

Depending on how the story has been analyzed, the governesses’ intentions vary from interpretation to interpretation. While some readers will vehemently insist that the governess is in fact seeing these apparitions, others stress that her odd infatuation with the master of the house, whom she had seen “only twice” is what causes this reaction to occur because she seeks to impress him by “saving” her charges from “possession.” It can even be inferred that the apparitions are merely a reflection of her imagination and that she has simply gone insane. Whatever her intentions are, the mere fact that the reader is beginning to question her observations shows that her credibility has been seriously compromised. It’s important to note that these interpretations are all well founded on evidence that James has hinted at throughout the novel.

Read More
1647 Words | 7 Pages

The Turn of the Screw is about the life of a governess who has been hired to watch over two kids and the home while the master, their uncle, is away. The uncle left a short but specific set of instructions about the occupation and what it included. The instructions plainly said not to bother him under any circumstance. The Governess is

Read More
443 Words | 2 Pages

In Henry James’s novella The Turn of the Screw, the Governess purportedly sees the ghosts of her predecessor and her lover. Critics have been debating whether the Governess was really seeing the ghosts or if they were visual hallucinations ever since the publication of the work. On one side, some argue that it is a simple ghost story and can be easily over-analyzed. The more prevailing opinion is that the “ghosts” are figments of a sexually repressed woman’s imagination. This implication of this is far more sinister than just ghosts.

Read More
1238 Words | 5 Pages

This is the point in the story where the governess’ sanity is proven and Mrs. Grose’s trust towards the governess is formed. However, even though the governess has Mrs. Grose on her side throughout the novella, she does not always have the children on her side. The governess continually tries to help the children, but they start playing “a game” with her and begin “leading a life of their own” (James 49). She is trying to fulfil her duties of watching over the children, but they simply distance themselves from her.

Read More
1203 Words | 5 Pages

The way that Henry James opposes several binaries in his work The Turn Of The Screw is intriguing and riveting. James’ novel opposes several binaries throughout the story. These binaries are used to serve as a form of normalcy in most books, but in this novel it is used to confuse the reader and also lay a solid foundation of the setting in this book. There are several The first of these binaries to oppose each other is the master to servant binary.

Read More
2116 Words | 9 Pages

James' book is a novella, which means long story, shorter than an ordinary novel yet concentrating on activities with a more noteworthy lens than a short story. James distributed the novel fresh in 1908, rolling out a couple of minor improvements and one noteworthy change. In the 1898 production, Flora is six years of age: in the 1908, she is eight. James acknowledged after his first distribution that Flora talks and acts like she is a couple of years more established then six. The Turn of the Screw was composed in a period when apparitions and spirits were predominant in England and even more so in America.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

Henry James’ horror novella The Turn of the Screw is a tale about the haunting of Bly Manor, the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel remaining behind to stalk the manor after their untimely deaths. At least that is what the narrator of the story within the story, the governess, came to see and believe during her time there. The much more likely alternative, however, is much more mundane while also being horrific to a degree; the governess is mentally ill. Through the self made recounts of her actions and behaviours during her time at Bly Manor, it is made clear that the governess is not seeing the supernatural, but rather that she is suffering from the onset of paranoid schizophrenia. Many factors throughout the story point to the governess

Read More
1409 Words | 6 Pages

The Screwtape Letters was a book written by C. S. Lewis in 1942. The book contains thirty-one letters written from Screwtape, a fallen angel, to his nephew Wormwood. The letters explain how Wormwood should conduct his business with the human, which he has been assigned. Wormwood is to pull his “patient”, a young British male, away from his faith in God. Throughout the book Lewis uses various letters to communicate with the reader about love.

Read More
699 Words | 3 Pages

The governess continually has encounters with these apparitions and they only seem to appear to her. As the novel continues, Miles’ behavior in school becomes bad to the point where he is prevented from returning and Flora becomes sick with a fever. The governess believes that all of the bad events happening are actions of the ghosts and blames them for corrupting the children. The ghosts are not real, but are merely the evidence of the falling apart of her sanity. The governess encounters the ghost of Peter Quint, the previously mentioned valet of the two ghosts.

Read More
1384 Words | 6 Pages

Money, power, and success have blinded people into thinking they are in love and it has led to these women being oppressed. Tom and Gatsby in this book are what is called the patriarchy. According to Revise Sociology, the patriarchy is “The systematic domination of women by men in some or all of society’s spheres and institutions.” In Tom and Daisy’s marriage; they are both having an affair, Tom wasn’t at his child’s birth, and he oppresses Daisy physically, maybe by accident, and socially, by not allowing her to go wherever she wants to go. In Tom and Myrtle’s affair; they are both married, yet they have this affair, she is dependent on him because he oppresses her economically and psychologically, and he also oppresses her physically when he broke her nose.

Read More
1591 Words | 7 Pages

Characteristics of the apparitions were key in the story Turn of the Screw, not only for the visualization of the story, but also to display a meaning that is only significant when the apparitions had the characteristics that they did. When recalling the first encounter with Miss Jessel, the governess wrote, “Suddenly..on the other side of the Sea of Azof, we had an interested spectator. The way of this knowledge gathered me was the strangest thing in the world-the strangest, that is, except the very much stranger in which it quickly merged itself” (James 24). According to Apparitional Experiences, “many apparitions are described by witnesses as being solid looking and life-like” (Williams 5). This correlates directly to the governess’ sights of Miss Jessel, who appears to be solid as well as lifelike, so much so she didn’t realize it was a ghost until she had further information and thought of it.

Read More
1109 Words | 5 Pages

She demands that Miles sees Peter Quint as she did with flora, Miles claims he doesn't see anything. The governess spirals out of control and definitely slips into insanity. She tries to touch Miles, Miles then gets worked up over all the stress she put on him and decides to hug him but he has a heart attack and dies or smothered him to death it's unclear how Miles really dies. The governess claimed she had dispossessed his heart of the evil, but really she had killed him with her obsession with the uncle and her

Read More

More about Psychoanalytical Criticism Of Turn Of The Screw By Henry James

Related Topics

Open Document