ipl-logo

Roberta Seid Too Close To The Bone Analysis

571 Words3 Pages

Harrison Davis Mr. Fanara ACP 23 September 2015 Too “Close to the Bone” Summary Roberta Seid, in her article "Too ‘Close to the Bone’": The Historical Context for Women’s Obsession with Slenderness”, examines the positives and negatives of society outlook on obesity. Seids main argument in this article is that societies current perspective on body types are incorrect. Seid argues that the so called “religious” pursuit of having a slender and thin body is becoming way too extreme. She presents the pros and cons on this thin lifestyle. She shows this by using the example that one can gain social acceptance for being thin but the cost of getting to that slender comes at too high of a cost. She also uses an example of historical evidence. She states that in the past being thin was often looked down upon and that being obese was a sign that one is happy and healthy. …show more content…

At this turn, there was a huge movement to become thin and that it was the best thing for society. This was the first time in society that individuals could be deemed as “obese” for weighing more than the average person. Seid shows this by giving an example of how this was applied to everyday life. She states that the popular belief was that if you were overweight it was because one did not have the desire or will power to become thin. She also states that it was common to make the correlation between being thin and being successful. Seid then goes on to present the point of view of women in this turn in societies beliefs. Seid argues that women are more affected by this strive to be thin and that if they do not follow this they will be looked at differently then the everyday thin women. She does this by showing the perspective of future historians looking back on this subject and saying that this “religious” appeal to slenderness was only for those that believed in how they were perceived over their own thoughts and

Show More
Related
631 Words | 3 Pages

Saletan gives more than enough information on how, when, and what is happening worldwide about obesity. Although he does not give a solution, he still made an eye opening experience while reading this essay. Obesity is now happening worldwide. Yes I said it, worldwide according to Saletan. “Egyptian, Mexican, and South African women are as fat as American”, he claims in the second paragraph.

Read More
1287 Words | 6 Pages

By using an image most people have seen, Schwartz effectively appeals to any audience member’s ethos. Schwartz argues that fat people are not allowed to do well in whatever they choose to do with their lives because people are too focused on their looks rather than their work ethic. He then argues that physicians are just as bad as the rest of society because, “They find fat patients distasteful… Fat

Read More
1176 Words | 5 Pages

Bordo’s primary target audience are females, teenagers and possibly even advertising companies, where she too, creates an effective argument. Bordo claims we are influenced by media to believe that it is imperative to achieve the “slender ideal body” and reflects on how dieting has become normalized. She states “In the late nineteenth century, by contrast, the practices of body management begin to be middle-class preoccupations, and concern with diet becomes attached to the pursuit of an idealized physical body weight or shape” (Bordo 484). Bordo discusses the associations that have been created regarding body weight.

Read More
578 Words | 3 Pages

" The primary thing shown, is that fatness is a bad, temporary thing that leaves people forever traumatized. Negative characteristics of the character sends the very untrue message that all fat people are or should be ashamed to be that way, and do their best to shrink down their bodies as fast as

Read More
1011 Words | 5 Pages

A Global Problem through Rhetorical Eyes David Zinczenko, a nutrion and wellness editor of ABC news, portrayed a global problem to the public in a way that he could persuade them into agreeing with him that obesity is a problem that concerns all of humanity. He stated that obesity should not only concern the person suffering from it and the parents but all of humanity since it could happen to everyone. In fact, David Zinczenko himself suffered from obesity at an early age. Thankfully, he was able to turn his life around and use his situation in a way that he could help others not suffer what he did. Which is why he published the article, “Don’t Blame the Eater” in the opinion section of the New York Times and with that create knowledge of this

Read More
531 Words | 3 Pages

He begins to construct his point by describing how our caloric intake or food intake has consistently gone up over the years and fat intake has gone down, but obesity has continued on a dramatic incline. The initial response to the obesity epidemic was to cut fat out of our diets, considering the logic was that fat in food caused fat in the body.

Read More
1252 Words | 6 Pages

In American culture, the obese body is largely unaccepted and one factor that contributes to this annulling representation is the abundance of opposing reactions that people display towards overweight people. It is a stigma that often taints and belittles the person, leading others to judge the targeted individual in a cynical matter, rejecting, hating, or ridiculing him or her. That can often lead the person to develop severe psychological and emotional problems. The short story “The Fat Girl” by Andre Dubus follows a girl named Louise from age nine up until the time she becomes a mother. The usage of a compressed story on Dubus’ part provides the reader insight and brings attention to the damage that can be done when family members force negative body images on young children.

Read More
318 Words | 2 Pages

(p.15). In the case of the video, they do not show people who experiences difficulties time to find job according with their weight or the complexity and how other people observe people as overweight. It is the dominant discourse to be

Read More
1763 Words | 8 Pages

For obese, getting thinner means a chance to re-enter the society and have chances that they were not able to do before. For the youthful rebels, they have rejected the eating habits as part of their search for a new life-style. Mead stated that we should give up using food as a form of punishment or reward and recognize the rule of “three square meals a day” has become a kind of strait jacket. Eating on the basics of self-demand could be the beginning of self-discovery and flexibility throughout childhood and into adulthood. No matter what the circumstance, food is the easiest thing to go without and possibly the most easy to acquire and will therefore always be in the questioning whether someone should pay the heating bill or get food, school clothes or food, electricity or food, Christmas presents or food,

Read More
168 Words | 1 Pages

In them article “Let Them Eat Fat” the Author, Greg Crister, uses concrete facts and figures to buttress his arguments. Several researches were considered. There were also comparisons among race, culture, gender and social classes. For instance, “In 1998, Dr. David Satcher, the new U.S. surgeon general, was moved to declare childhood obesity to be epidemic. "Today," he told a group of federal bureaucrats and policymakers, "we see a nation of young people seriously at risk of starting out obese and dooming themselves to the difficult task of overcoming a tough illness."

Read More
823 Words | 4 Pages

“In the past, eating disorders were generally considered to be confined to young white females from middle-to-upper class families living in Western societies” (Caradas 112). Both studies exploit the false stereotypes associated with eating disorders and culture. Both parties believe that non Western cultures are being influenced by the “slim is beautiful” idea. Each view points out the false misconception that non Western cultures traditional ideas of being thick is related to health is protecting them from eating disorders. Studies prove all ethnicities have shown concern towards body shape and eating attitudes in recent years around the

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

Every individual is different and unique in their own way, may it be their body size or the color of their skin. No individual is similar, which is precisely the point that Cheryl Peck makes in her essay “Fatso”. The essay portrays Peck’s view of the conflicts that she goes through in her life as an overweight person. She makes a point by point contrast to her imaginary life, repeating the phrase “I have never”, and her real life where she faces discrimination because of her weight. Peck’s use of tone and word choice highlights the purpose of her essay, which is to raise awareness about discrimination against overweight people to audiences who are thin and have not experienced any judgment from others.

Read More
1758 Words | 8 Pages

I could remember how thin and ‘healthy” I was when I ran over fifteen miles a day. I had become physically sick because of the mileage between soccer and cross-country and even gym, but that didn’t seem to matter to anyone. I was an extreme competitor, I needed to outdo everyone else: in running, school, and weight. I had to win the what I perceived to be the unspoken weight competition. Choosing the smallest and healthiest plate would make me feel like a champion, sometimes I would even ‘forget” to eat.

Read More
806 Words | 4 Pages

In the poem, When The Fat Girl Gets Skinny, by Blythe Baird, the poet addresses the issue of social ideology and how these trends affect young women. Told in a first perspective point of view, the poet supports her theme by describing how teenagers are being affected, establishing a social conflict of false need to achieve trends by identifying motifs for teenager’s actions, incorporating the use of life experiences from the past to the present tense and finalizing with a shift to highlight positivity in change of habit. Baird’s purpose is to illustrate a major conflict among young women who are being affected by social idolization of being skinny. She creates a mood of hopeful in order to inspire young teenagers who are currently harming

Read More
1525 Words | 7 Pages

From an early age, we are exposed to the western culture of the “thin-ideal” and that looks matter (Shapiro 9). Images on modern television spend countless hours telling us to lose weight, be thin and beautiful. Often, television portrays the thin women as successful and powerful whereas the overweight characters are portrayed as “lazy” and the one with no friends (“The Media”). Furthermore, most images we see on the media are heavily edited and airbrushed

Read More

More about Roberta Seid Too Close To The Bone Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document