ipl-logo

Romeo And Juliet Compare And Contrast Essay

589 Words3 Pages

The first scene in Act III of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is an intense one. When Benvolio and Mercutio are met by the Capulets a brawl between Mercutio and Tybalt ensues, resulting in Mercutio's death. Vengeful Romeo then slays Tybalt and is banished by the Prince. Which media best captures the magnitude of the scene; text, film or a live production? First I will explore the text version of the play. The text version of Romeo and Juliet in the textbook has its upsides and downsides. One upside of reading the script is that you can go at your own pace unlike the uncontrollable timing of a movies. This version of the play has every word found in the original which keeps it exactly how Shakespeare intended it to be. Unfortunately the language is outdated and difficult to understand as shown when Mercutio says “ On top of this the text version simply has what the characters say, not what they do. To fully understand the play (as a student) the help of a teacher and a dictionary are needed. …show more content…

The main reason it would be ranked higher than the text is because watching the movie helps understand what is going on because it appeals to multiple senses. The ferocity in the scene is conveyed by not only through words but also through facial expressions and frantic music. On the other hand the film only shows the producers interpretation of the play. Some lines from the play are missing (e.g. line 20 through 25), but the movie compensates by showing us what is happening. An example of this is in the movie there is an extensive duel scene between Mercutio and Tybalt while in the text it simply states, “They fight.” The largest fault in the film clip I watched was that the whole section of the play where the Prince banishes Romeo isn’t included. Due to this a film version by not be the best option

Show More
Related

Comparing The Play And Film Version Of The Crucible '

720 Words | 3 Pages

Although it was a good representation, these reasons still are not good enough reasons for it to be better than the film. The film version reached a much wider range of audience due to innovations in technology compared to the written version. This is because most people nowadays tend to stray from written versions of literature and tend to be more inclined to watch something on film rather than read or view a play. This is another major reason why the Hytner’s version is the best version of The

Read More

Cyrano De Bergerac Fidelity

2119 Words | 9 Pages

Every Film Adaptation is Not Necessarily Faithful Throughout history, philosophers wrote thoughtful poems and sophisticated plays; plays sought to challenge the intellectual minds of those who would read them. Inevitably, as time progressed, people found ways to stage the plays for entertainment. When staging the play, whether it would be literal actors reciting lines on a stage or a movie with the reenactment of the play, the director always faces the problem of fidelity of the adaptation and how true their adaptation has to be to the original source. Fidelity in the terms of film refers to the authenticity and familiar similarities an adaptation has to its original source.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Romeo And Juliet 1996 And 1996

150 Words | 1 Pages

In the Broadway play produced in 2014, the writers wanted the audience to use their imagination. It’s more in keeping with the 21st century era. In the 1968 version of romeo and juliet

Read More

Similarities And Differences Between Romeo And Juliet 1996 And 1996

1101 Words | 5 Pages

Romeo and Juliet is a classic play by William Shakespeare, In 1968 it was adapted in a full movie, and later on in 1996 was again adapted into the big screen, both movies have so many similarities and so many differences, in the 1968 movie it is a more realistic, more true to the script, but the 1996 movie takes place in verona beach in the US, in modern times, the sword fights are actually guns, both use shakespearean english, but the most important part of any Romeo and Juliet performance, is to show their love was never meant to be, both movies do an excellent job in portraying this concept, in this essay I will explore that Romeo and Juliet’s relationship is starcrossed is portrayed by the 1968 and 1996 version through the first time they meet in the party, the balcony scene, and the scene where they are in bed. The first time Romeo and Juliet meet is at the Capulet party, this is portrayed in both movies differently, in the 1996 version Romeo is walking by an aquarium, looking at the fish, when he sees juliet, their eyes meet and follow each other, but just as they were going to come face to face, Juliet’s nurse grabs her, and takes her away to dance with Paris her future husband. In the 1968 version Romeo is far away from Juliet, and he hides behind a column, she is dancing with some people, but she is too far away, and has lots of people between Romeo and Juliet.

Read More

To What Extent Should Romeo And Juliet Be Taught In High School

476 Words | 2 Pages

In conclusion, Romeo and Juliet is a useful tool when demonstrating lessons on situations young adults need to consider being careful about. Therefore, it should be taught to students in their freshman year to inform them on what could happen when you’re careless. Furthermore, the play should be reevaluated in our junior/senior year to go over and strengthen their skills and

Read More

West Side Story Cultural Artifact

1539 Words | 7 Pages

Given the two artifacts I chose I looked at 6 sources: three for each artifact. For Romeo and Juliet, the first one being an article written by Chris Jeffery called “What Kinds of Play Is Romeo and Juliet?” for the source “Shakespeare in Southern Africa”. The second of my sources is a literary criticism by Peter C. Herman called “Tragedy and the Crisis of Authority in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet.” Written for Intertexts for San Diego State University and the third source for Romeo and Juliet is “Tragic Form in Romeo and Juliet” by Ruth Nevo written for “Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900” for Rice University in 1969.

Read More

Romeo And Juliet Movie Vs Play

829 Words | 4 Pages

The movie ties in more brutality and violence to appeal to a modern audience that demands intense appeal to the senses. The play uses the simplicity of setting elements such as the balcony and common acting techniques to communicate Shakespear’s original message. Given the time period of the text, Shakepear’s use of these strategies are as modern as those unique techniques used in the movie. The movie and the play attract their audiences based on what appeals to them. Most importantly, both deliver the message to the audience that “For never was a story of more woe than this of Juliet and her

Read More

Differences Between Macbeth Movie And Play

298 Words | 2 Pages

This shows how Ross will hold his loyalty to whomever is of power. To conclude, there are many similarities and differences in any film adaptation of a beloved novel or play. However, it is up to the audience to decide which version they enjoyed

Read More

Romeo And Juliet With Dancers From The Australian Ballet

713 Words | 3 Pages

The dance production I will be making this report about is a ballet performance titled Romeo and Juliet with dancers from The Australian Ballet, which Graeme Murphy choreographs. I have always wanted to watch a Romeo and Juliet production either in a live theatre or at least that was pre-recorded. I am glad I was introduced to the Marqueetv website to find all of the productions I have always wanted to see. I also wanted to relive the story of a book I read in high school, and I have always wanted to watch a ballet performance in general, so Romeo and Juliet was the perfect live show for this project. Due to their families' hatred for each other and the constant pressure to keep them apart, Romeo and Juliet couldn't express their love in public,

Read More

Romeo And Juliet Surry Arts Council Analysis

182 Words | 1 Pages

Shakespeare’s Romeo & Juliet: Surry Arts Council Many people regard William Shakespeare’s work as outdated and rather dry, especially when it’s been done many times before. However, the Surry Arts Council rendition of Romeo and Juliet directed by Mark Donnell was exceptionally enjoyable. The set looked appealing with a balcony; made up of mostly browns with a touch of blue on the curtains.

Read More

How Does Shakespeare Create Tension In Romeo And Juliet

593 Words | 3 Pages

“Romeo and Juliet” by William Shakespeare entertains the audience through use of character, language and drama. The plot focuses on the theme of conflict and consequences, using deep characterisation, descriptive language and high drama to entertain. Act 3 Scene 1 focuses on a brutal feud between two enemies and Act 3 Scene 5 follows the patriarchal society’s approach to women marriage and societal expectations. Shakespeare forces the audience to engage with the idea of conflict and what it must have been like to live through this time. Shakespeare cleverly utilises a changing atmosphere in Act 3 Scene 1 to expertly entertain his audience.

Read More

Ado About Nothing: Analyzing Modern Play Starring David Tennant And Catherine Tate

904 Words | 4 Pages

The play is widely considered one of Shakespeare's greatest comedies and is known for its witty dialogue, complex characters, and themes of love, jealousy, and deception. Here is a detailed analysis of the

Read More

What Is The Difference Between Romeo And Juliet 1968 And 1996

545 Words | 3 Pages

While both adaptations take from the same original text, the 1968 version has drastically better execution than the 1996 version. For instance, the quote "Neither, fair maid, if either thee dislike" (2.2.61) is originally said by Romeo but is also said in both adaptations as a response to Juliet asking him if he is actually Romeo, a Montague. In the 1968 version the sentiment is clearly present, as Romeo says this in desperation to try and make Juliet stay on the balcony. Again, in the 1996 version, after just scaring Juliet so much that she grabs him and falls into the pool, Juliet then asks in response if he is Romeo, just like in the other two iterations. However, the tone is not playful and questioning, but accusatory and defensive, showing that she is not quite ready to be in a relationship with him after he just heard her deepest thoughts.

Read More

Romeo And Juliet Character Analysis

1319 Words | 6 Pages

This can be evident in three aspects: the styles of the acting of the actors, the reaction of Juliet after learning about the death of Tybalt, and the setting of certain scenes. In Luhrmann’s film (1996), the acting of Romeo and Juliet make the audiences feel that they are more reliable and imperturbable, this is shown in many situations. Juliet’s first appearance in the movie seems more cool-headed. When Juliet is taking a shower when her mother calls her name, she puts on a bathrobe lightly and walks out.

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Soliloquy

966 Words | 4 Pages

ADAPTATI ONS O F PLAYS Adaptations of the play into a film will be more good than have in common with the film adaptation of the novel and the Novel itself. The issue of the length and angle of view is minimized. It 's time to play the actual (not including the time between acts or scenes) is rarely more than three hours. Structural Divisions Unlike the movie, the drama has a clear structure with a Division-acts or scenes of the influential position of peak power and dramatic intensity. The end of an action can be build to an emotional peak race, setting up the dramatic resonance to carry over into the next action.

Read More

More about Romeo And Juliet Compare And Contrast Essay

Related Topics

Open Document