ipl-logo

Saving Anti-Heroes In The Miracle Girl, Say Yes, By Tobias Wolff

1406 Words6 Pages

Michael Lyakhov
Mrs. Ketcham
English 9 Honors
26 January 2023
How Relationships Can Save Anti-Heroes
An anti-hero is an individual who, despite not possessing exemplary qualities, manages to redeem themself. Each of the short stories The Miracle Girl by Rita Chang-Eppig, Nightingale by Tobias Wolff, and Say Yes by Tobias Wolff use anti-heroes to develop the central idea that despite one’s flaws, one can still achieve redemption. In the short story Miracle Girl, Xiao Xue, the protagonist was constantly belittled by the people around her because her sister was a more accomplished and holy individual. Feeling unimportant and overshadowed, Xiao Xue developed villainous traits such as envy and bitterness. In Nightingale, a father tries to make …show more content…

In all three of these stories the protagonists exhibit poor character traits. However, as the short stories progress, we begin to see how each of the characters redeem themselves. The possibility of redemption despite imperfection exhibited throughout the short stories The Miracle Girl, Say Yes, and Nightingale through the use of anti-heroes is that redemption is possible due to one having motivation to maintain relationships with their loved ones.
In the short story The Miracle Girl by Rita Chang-Eppig, Xiao Xue initially displays villainy in being envious of her sister, but makes an effort to pursue her own interests rather than be jealous of her sister’s accomplishments. For example, Xiao Xue recited a prayer and Sister Eunice’s endorsement: “But then, without even being asked, Xiao Chun had recited the Apostles’ Creed in front of the whole assembly, in Latin. In that moment, Xiao Xue saw clearly her place in Sister Eunice’s eyes (and by extension, she supposed, God’s). She never recited again” (Chang-Eppig 19). At the time, Xiao Xue’s main motivation is to gain approval of people that she respects. However, she constantly finds her sister outshining her. Thus, she loses all motivation to reach …show more content…

In the short story Say Yes by Tobias Wolff, the husband and wife have a seemingly perfect relationship that both partners deeply value. However, the husband exhibits flaws centered around racism. For example, When the couple is washing dishes together, the wife asks the husband whether or not he would marry her if she was black. To the wife’s disappointment, the husband answers “No” (Wolff 3). The husband’s racist beliefs on interracial marriage are clearly flaws in his character. Moreover, the husband goes so far as to say that he wouldn’t marry his wife if she was black. His wife is clearly hurt by this because their love should be unconditional to one another regardless of appearance. Clearly, the husband displays his worst traits to his wife in a simple conversation. However, the husband wants to show his wife that he is still the kind man she married. He changes his racist beliefs for the sake of his marriage and therefore redeems himself. For example, after recognizing that standing by his beliefs wasn’t worth compromising his marriage, the husband apologizes to his wife “‘Ann I’m really sorry’...‘I’ll marry you’” (Wolff 4). In agreeing to marry his wife even if she was black, the protagonist shows a change in character. He prioritizes his relationship with his wife over his and makes amends to his flaws. By loving his wife more than himself, the husband gained motivation

Show More
Related
357 Words | 2 Pages

In the article, “Against Antiheroes”, Laura Bennett demonstrates the characterizations of an antihero, while providing information that allows the antihero to be depicted as prevalent. An antihero is defined as a person that does not possess heroic attributes, and may be seen as selfish, corrupt, or sullen. Antiheroes usually tend to acquire the sympathy of another individual, causing them to become relatable, as seen as Bennett writes, “‘Antihero’ implies that a character encourages a conflicted sympathy; Walt forfeited our sympathy long ago” (472). Bennett’s characterization of an antihero demonstrates a sense of an internal struggle on behalf of the audience and the hero. An antihero may appear to be haunted by a tragic past, encounters

Read More
1311 Words | 6 Pages

Because she values whiteness as a whole, Mrs. Turner advises that Janie leave Tea Cake and marry her brother instead because he is light-skinned. The primary reason Mrs. Turner disapproves of Tea Cake is because he is dark-skinned. Mrs. Turner completely ignores the role that one’s character and personality plays in deciding if an individual is suitable for someone in a relationship, both romantically and platonically. Instead, she decides to entirely form her perception on someone based on the darkness of one’s skin and treats this as a factor in deciding someone’s individuality. Mrs. Turner subconsciously enforces stereotypes about darker-skinned

Read More
1062 Words | 5 Pages

Both David Weisman, who is a neurologist in Pennsylvania, and Lane Wallace, who is an adventure writer and pilot, discusses whether or not sports helmets should be used in sports and if it helps efficiently in the essays “Disposable Heroes” and “Do Sports Helmets Help or Hurt”. They have different views on the subject and what should be done to protect the athletes. Weisman argues that safety equipment’s such as helmets in football should be used to protect the athletes’ heads from injuries. Wallace on the other hand, believes that safety equipment’s should not be a part of sports because then people have a tendency to take bigger risks when they believe the safety equipment’s protects them. Wallace believes that to protect athletes, the culture

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

This makes him question what he is doing with his life and his wife if he doesn’t feel that positive way toward her. He also is shown questioning his work. For example. “There must be something in the books, things we can’t imagine, to make women stay in a burning house; there must be something there. You don’t stay there for nothing’” (48).

Read More
2126 Words | 9 Pages

In many books there are characters that you love, hate, and then some that you don’t have a particular opinion about. It could be because they aren’t around in the books enough, or it could be because their bad actions and their good actions cancel each other out. These characters are called ambiguous characters. In “The Autobiography of An Ex-Colored Man”, by James Weldon Johnson, the father can be seen as an ambiguous character. This is caused by the good things he does, like coming to see his son when he was young, buying his son a piano, giving his son the gift of not having to deal with racism until he is a bit older, and granting his son a way out of the African American lifestyle.

Read More
1322 Words | 6 Pages

Loving Negroes' ... ' It is about love. What else but love? Can't I love what I criticize?' ' Yeah, but except for skin color, I can't tell the difference between what the what women want from us and what colored woman want.

Read More
1456 Words | 6 Pages

Many of the women in these stories are portrayed as strong, independent women who, in many cases, are the hero themselves. Women in Chrétien and La Motte-Fouqué’s stories are given strong roles in order to highlight and emphasize the important virtues of peace, bravery, and power which ultimately transfers the role of the hero from men to women. In order to understand why the women in Yvain and The Magic Ring are considered to be the true heroes, the definition of a true hero must first be fully defined. Many will describe a hero as a character who performs deeds to remove people from danger.

Read More
633 Words | 3 Pages

In Janie’s third marriage with Tea Cake, they encounter a white racist woman named Mrs. Turner. She is comfortable talking to Janie because she is part white and wants to bring her from the dark side to that of the light. One of her beliefs is that “it’s too may black folks already. We oughta lighten up the race” (Hurston 140).

Read More
790 Words | 4 Pages

Debi Mazar is an actress who stated, “A hero is somebody who is selfless, who is generous in spirit, who just tried to give back as much as possible and help people. A hero to me is someone who saves people and who really, deeply cares.” Heroes are relevant to everyone, because at some point, everyone has had a hero. Sadly, today’s society degrades the meaning of the word “hero”. Heroes are an important aspect of life, but famous people are not always heroes.

Read More
981 Words | 4 Pages

Larsen uses inner conflict to make it coherent how racism will cause problems in relationships. First, Clare Kendry married a white man who detests people with color. She never told her husband

Read More
694 Words | 3 Pages

He wrote this piece to express his important opinion about the effect of racism and how he’s viewed as a man of color. He talks about his first encounter of racism when he was young man in college and was assumed to be a mugger or killer just because of skin. “It was in echo of that terrified woman’s footfalls that I first began to know the unwieldy inheritance I’d come into the ability to alter public space in ugly ways.” I feel that the author is trying to connect to his vast audience of people who don’t understand what it is like to a black man in society. Later he contemplated that he rejected or shunned by the white race collectively as a dangerous man.

Read More
602 Words | 3 Pages

Johnson’s role in the civil rights was highly significant because he played an important role in convincing congress to act, but it was the civil rights campaigns and not the Presidents that kept the issue of radical justice on the political agenda. This meant that Johnson’s role in civil rights was significant because he did more than any president before him and to add to that he was the President who masterminded the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which was the greatest advancement in black rights since the end of slavery in 1863.This demonstrates that Johnson’s role was significant because he had done so many thing for the civil rights for example he pushed through this long awaiting legislation on the back of the national mourning at the assassination of President Kennedy. Overall, Johnson’s role in the civil rights was significant as he was the most radical of the Presidents, as he worked with civil rights campaigners to bring about change.

Read More
618 Words | 3 Pages

His relationship with his wife deteriorates when he becomes this lying, deceitful man. "You were alone with her?... For a moment alone, aye.... Why, then, is it not as you told me" (Miller 2. 132-134).

Read More
1706 Words | 7 Pages

think that VCs are hard to regulate and monitor, as they involve different entities locally and internationally, most of the outside the traditional monetary system. Some regulators have started to respond to this issue. The regulators have developed several approaches, which include the possibility of applying the existing legislation to VCs, issuing warnings to consumers, enforcing licensing obligations on certain VC market players, banning financial institutions from dealing in VCs, completely prohibiting the usage of VCs, and suing abusers. However, these regulations are in early stage, and regulators should think more innovatively to address their concerns without harming the ongoing innovation (European Central Bank : Virtual Currency

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

The story represents the culmination of Wright’s passionate desire to observe and reflect upon the racist world around him. Racism is so insidious that it prevents Richard from interacting normally, even with the whites who do treat him with a semblance of respect or with fellow blacks. For Richard, the true problem of racism is not simply that it exists, but that its roots in American culture are so deep it is doubtful whether these roots can be destroyed without destroying the culture itself. “It might have been that my tardiness in learning to sense white people as "white" people came from the fact that many of my relatives were "white"-looking people. My grandmother, who was white as any "white" person, had never looked "white" to me” (Wright 23).

Read More

More about Saving Anti-Heroes In The Miracle Girl, Say Yes, By Tobias Wolff

Related Topics

Open Document