ipl-logo

Should House Of Commons Be A Representative Government Analysis

731 Words3 Pages

The House of Commons cannot representative for British citizens This essay will analyze that the House of Commons cannot be a representative of British citizens from the mandate, the choices of citizens, the social background of MPs, the influence of opposition to the government, and the conflict between roles of parliamentarians their aspects. Mandate During General Election, each area in the UK needs to elect a person(MP) who is transferred the mandate by constituencies to represent them. However MPs from different areas have different mandate to support them, like in Manchester which did not gain a strong mandate in 2017. It was fact without a doubt about Manchester always won in Labour Party, that is the reason why only 55.1 percent local …show more content…

The table (2017) below demonstrated the number of seats for each Party. In 2017, the House of Commons included Conservative Party were 317 seats, 262 seats in Labour Party, Scottish National Party were 35 seats. Table 2: General Election in 2017 This shows that the government can only be served by either the Conservative Party or the Labour Party because the government must achieve a majority of MPs which win in the General Election, however currently there is a minority Government. Even though the public take unkindly to both of two parties, the Party still evolves into the government. Social background -Men and Women According to the MPs’ background, it is accessible to find out the women MPs are less than the men MPs. In table 3, from 650 total MPs, the women MPs are account for 208(32%). By contrast, there only 19 women MPs in 1979. It indicated the proportion of women MPs has been constantly increasing. Although women are more than half of the population, they still are under-represented in Britain Politics. Even if the number was lower than 50% which was not equal, it was better than 0% which was small but …show more content…

-Ethnicity “52 MPs were from non-white backgrounds, 8% of the total. Around 14% of the whole UK population are from a non-white background”, cleared Lukas and Cassie (2017). The diversity of MPs can build the relationship beyond the races, however, it is a minority. -Education One of the social backgrounds includes the education of MPs, like MPs who receive high-education to represent their constituencies in Labour Party, however, they are not the worker in social life. Rebecca and Tim (2017) demonstrated that “86% of MPs are university graduates, 23% went to Oxford or Cambridge, 29% went to non-Oxbridge Russell Group universities and 33% went to other universities in the UK. Approximately 11% of MPs hold a postgraduate qualification”. The roles of MPs are to represent their constituencies, make legislation and scrutiny. They need to have adequate knowledge to improve the

Show More
Related

Identity Of Being A Representative In The House By Anita Hill

748 Words | 3 Pages

This can allude to the idea that there were even less women in the senate which led to the all male Committee. Therefore, as much of an impact that the few women in the House made, that they still were unable to fully support Anita, as there were no women on the Committee. In the event that there were women on the Committee, though they did not particularly have to support Anita, that it would have been more an even representation on the Committee and perhaps a more productive, respectful hearing. Yet, the all-male Committee reflects that women during that time are were not particularly active in government which was an important distinction to

Read More

Pennsylvania General Assembly Case Study

4600 Words | 19 Pages

The Women of the Pennsylvania General Assembly: Explaining Women’s Representation in Pennsylvania State Politics Abstract The Pennsylvania General Assembly is ranked 39th of the 50 state legislatures for its proportion of female legislators. Women constitute 17.8% of the bicameral legislature, including nine of 50 senators and 36 of 203 representatives. The structure of the Pennsylvania General Assembly appears to provide numerous barriers to women’s entry.

Read More

Explain How Effective Parliament Is At Carrying Specific Functions

527 Words | 3 Pages

In this essay I will be writing about how effective parliament is at carrying various of functions. One vital function parliament carries out is scrutinizing the opposition. Parliament does this in several of ways; one of the most important is having a select committee. Select committees scrutinize government policies. They carry out inquires and have question and answer sessions with ministers and other witnesses.

Read More

The Two-Party System Pros And Cons

1475 Words | 6 Pages

Because of the fact that there is a lack of enough parties to sustain the growing diversity of needs, many people are having to compromise their ideology to vote. While the goal of the two-party system is to simplify the voting process for the voters, it can not accomplish this due to the very definitions that makes two-party system up. Because there is a limited number of parties, each combination of ideas and policies the voter has in mind will not be supported entirely by one of the party. For instance, “a voter who supports the view of one party on a topic but supports the view of the other party on another topic is forced to compromise one of his views” making it harder for the voter to pick a side, according to a trusted Indian MBA exam preparatory website, TestFunda (“A Comparison of Political Systems”). With more variety, the voter has a better chance at not compromising all their ideals.

Read More

Two Party System Essay

941 Words | 4 Pages

34% is not the majority of the people, whereas 51% is. This detail highlights that if we were ever to transfer smoothly to a different system, a party would not be chosen particularly by the bulk of the citizens. This would create more disruption in the country, which is definitely not needed

Read More

Assess The Changes In Voting And Parliamentary Representation Between 1832 And Up Until 1928

1429 Words | 6 Pages

This essentially meant that a small borough had more power over the country’s future than big cities. Not only this, but those who were eligible to vote were men over the age of 21 and with a massive amount of wealth, more specifically property owners over a certain amount of estimated value rendering over 96% of the country ineligible to vote by those criteria: A system undoubtedly unfair by today’s democratic standards. As the French revolution happened, tension began to rise in the country midst social and economic changes within Britain that finally sparked a need for change among the

Read More

Summary: The Canadian Parliamentary System

866 Words | 4 Pages

The other part of the puzzle consists of the Executive branch of government. This branch consists of the Prime Minister and the Cabinet. The Prime Minister runs the Cabinet; he/she controls the ministerial appointments (Parl., 2012). Being responsible for government policy, it is crucial for the Cabinet to have confidence of the House of Commons (Parl., 2012). Not everyone can be a part of Cabinet, so the Ministers who are chosen by the Prime Minister are “Members of House of Commons… and at least one Senator… who serves as the Leader of the Government in the Upper house (Parl., 2012).

Read More

I Want To Pursue A Career As A Select Committee Inquiry Manager

694 Words | 3 Pages

I am a driven individual, passionate about political change and problem-solving. I have hands-on experience in many different roles and a breadth of degree level knowledge which will help make me the perfect candidate for the scheme. I am keen to learn, work hard and want to apply my research and analytical skills in a challenging environment. The House of Commons is the ideal environment for me to apply said skills. Thus, this opportunity will enhance the skills I have learnt throughout my degree, honing my professional capabilities.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Parliamentary General Elections

233 Words | 1 Pages

First-past-the-post is a type of electoral system used to elect the Parliament in the United Kingdom. During the time of voting the UK is divided into 650 voting districts known as constituencies. In each polling station, voters that are registered and eligible to vote, elect one Member of Parliament to take a seat in the House of Commons. Generally, the party that wins the bulk of the seats in the House of Commons forms the Government. Nonetheless, a situation when no party wins the majority of the seats can result in a ‘hung parliament’, in which a minority or coalition parliament is created.

Read More

The Classic Liberal Notion Of Quotas For Women

1098 Words | 5 Pages

The greatest increases in women’s parliamentary representation have occurred in those countries where quotas, whether legislated or voluntary, are in use. Nine of the 10 countries with the greatest increase in women representation had adopted an electoral quota, and of the 48 countries where elections were held, women won 24 per cent of parliamentary seats in countries with legislated quotas (McCann,

Read More

Consequences Of The First Past The Post Electoral System

1154 Words | 5 Pages

For example, in the 2015 general election it took the UKIP party 3.86 million votes to secure one MP into the House of commons compared to only 26,000 votes for every SNP MP, 34,000 votes for every Conservative MP, 40,000 votes for every Labour MP and 299,000 for every Liberal Democrat MP (Electoral Reform Society, 2015). This clearly highlights the issue of smaller parties not being able to represent voters as often their voters are not geographical concentrated enough whilst some parties can be over represented as evident by the 2015 General Election. In Scotland the SNP, despite only receiving just under 50% of the votes, won 95% of the seats (Electoral Reform Society, 2015). With these large parties being able to achieve a high number of seats compared to votes, it is now possible to form a government based upon just over a third of the total votes. This low voter win can be seen in individual constituencies such as Belfast South in 2015 which was won with only 24.5% of total votes (Electoral Reform Society, 2017).

Read More

Essay On Low Voter Turnout

1151 Words | 5 Pages

More women as compared to men, turnout to vote. Surprisingly, the number of women who vote has been on a consistent increase over the past elections. Notably, more persons from high income-families turn out to vote as compared to those from low-income

Read More

Majority Rule Advantages And Disadvantages

1312 Words | 6 Pages

"Candidate with the highest number of the vote wins the right to represent the particular seat in the House of Commons", according to CBC news. There are some limitations regarding this method. First of all, it could possibly happen that candidate with less than half vote wins, which means it only reaches minority people's desired outcome. In addition to the tactical voting, the two-party system could be a serious problem. Since only the first matters, candidates with the low possibility to win may exist the election.

Read More

Single Transferable Vote Advantages And Disadvantages

1046 Words | 5 Pages

It means the percentage of votes for parties are almost equal or same with the percentage of seats gained. During Scottish Local Election 2012, the SNP party got 32% of 1st preferences vote and they gained 35% of seats. On the other hand, the Labour party got 32% of 1st preferences votes and gained 32% of seats across Scotland. Next, STV have more representatives so people will have more choices to choose. For example, during Australia Federal Election 2016, there are few choices for people to choose their preferences.

Read More

Advantages Of The Westminster System Of Government

1131 Words | 5 Pages

The Westminster system of government comprises of a democratically elected lower house. After the executive members the head of government is the prime minister. The next system that falls in place is the opposition which is led by the leader of the party or the parties with the second largest number of seats in the lower house. It follows that in the British system the prime minister and the cabinets are fully in charge of Parliament.

Read More

More about Should House Of Commons Be A Representative Government Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document