ipl-logo

Should Pluto Be Considered A Planet?

1095 Words5 Pages

Adler Hoffmann Mrs. Rader 8th Grade Language 1 March 2024 Should Pluto be Considered a Planet? Textbooks, websites, school systems, books, acronyms, and more. What do they all have in common? They all had to change in 2006, when the International Astronomical Union (IAU) deemed Pluto, the ninth planet in our solar system, as a dwarf planet instead. At that time, this was a controversial decision because a lot of the general public did not want to have to remove Pluto from anything that mentioned the former nine planets because of the inconvenience of changing these things. However, the general public was wrong, and there are plenty of reasons why Pluto should never have been a planet in the first place. Pluto should not be classified as a planet …show more content…

According to Space.com, “Pluto, the object (then called a planet) was relatively small and had a highly eccentric orbit that sometimes even brought it closer to the Sun than Neptune is” (Howell para 8). This also proves that the orbit of Pluto is very elliptical because it is only sometimes closer to the Sun than Neptune, meaning that Pluto’s orbit cannot be a near perfect circle like the rest of the planets in our solar system. These two pieces of evidence both show that Pluto should not be a planet because its orbit is so elliptical. A third reason why Pluto should not be considered a planet is that it fits the description of a dwarf planet better than a planet. Welcome to the Space! The Dwarf Planet Pluto, “Pluto did not meet the requirements of a regular planet and was reclassified as a dwarf planet” (Lew para 1). This shows that Pluto fits the characteristics of a dwarf planet better than it fits the characteristics of a planet. As stated earlier, Pluto also had debris in its orbit, meaning that not only did Pluto fit the characteristics of a dwarf planet, but it did not fit the characteristics of a normal …show more content…

The opposing side that claims Pluto should be considered a planet might make the argument that Pluto is a planet because it has many similarities to planets, such as it also being round, having a moon, and orbiting the Sun. However, their argument is not necessarily true. Welcome to the Space! The Dwarf Planet Pluto, the IAU stated that planets must orbit a star, cannot be a moon, have no debris in their orbit, and are round (Howell para 2). Once again, this shows that Pluto is not a planet because Pluto does not clear its neighborhood of debris. Space for the adage! The Dwarf Planet Pluto also states, “The IAU is a group of more than nine thousand scientists from all over the world who study stars, planets, and other objects in space” (Howell para 1). This proves that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) is a very reliable source; they know all about the characteristics of planets. Who knows more about planets, a bunch of scientists that study space, or the average

Show More
Related
326 Words | 2 Pages

Article one of Pluto from science daily on the New Horizons map of Pluto: The whale and the donut. Shows the overview of the latest map of the on and off again named plant at the end of our solar system. The latest map of Pluto was providing by Ritchey-Chrétien telescope from the company named New Horizon being part of NASA, its primary mission to perform a flyby study of the Pluto system. On a mission that change the question to many explorers wanted answers to, how does Pluto look like? Well, their question was answers on July 9, 2015 that gave a close-up of Pluto.

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

Pluto was discovered in 1930 and was named a planet. In 2006 it was ruled a dwarf planet. I think that Pluto should not be a planet it should be a dwarf planet. Pluto should not be a planet because there is another planet bigger that was not a planet. It does not clear the neighborhood around the orbit of other objects.

Read More
312 Words | 2 Pages

Pluto should not be a planet, because it does not fit in the definition of “planet.” When Pluto was found it was considered a planet. Then an astronomer found something that he called Eris, this made other astronomers talked about what made a planet a "planet." This group decided that Pluto, and Eris were not really planets because of its size and location in space. Now, Pluto and objects like it are now called dwarf planets.

Read More
1530 Words | 7 Pages

Another KBO called Eris, is twice the diameter of Charon and is only slightly smaller than Pluto itself. This made astronomers reevaluate if Pluto should actually be considered a planet or as one of the larger bodies in the Kuiper Belt. As different evidence began to mount it was concluded that Pluto was a KBO that just happened to be found 62 years before the 1992 QB1 KBO was discovered. This led to the International Astronomical Union (IAU) voting to classify Pluto and Eris as Dwarf

Read More
308 Words | 2 Pages

Pluto should not be a planet. According to nasa.org it states, “Today, Pluto is called a “dwarf planet.” A dwarf planet orbits the sun just like other planets, but it is smaller.” At Discovery Education, it explains “The more astronomers learned about Pluto, however, the more uncomfortable they became with Pluto’s classification as a planet.” In USA Today the text states, “Another expert, Gareth Williams, associate director of the IAU Minor Planet Center, said that Pluto is not a planet, citing the official definition, which states that a planet is a celestial body that: is in orbit around the sun, is round or nearly round, and has "cleared the neighborhood" around its orbit, meaning it is not surrounded by objects of similar size and characteristics.

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

This explains to us that Pluto is called a planet every day and also, it is considered one as well. All of these facts help prove that Pluto should be classified as a

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

However, NASA has been doing research on Pluto since the year it was founded. Speaking of which, Pluto was founded in 1931. But in all honesty, who are we to say if Pluto is a planet? We didn’t create the universe. We don’t control the planets and everything that they do.

Read More
225 Words | 1 Pages

During the initial discovery of Uranus, Herschel believed that the planet was actually a comet. After months of studying the newly discovered planet/comet it was agreed that it was in fact a planet and not a comet. Uranus was originally named Georgium Sidus after his patron King James III but eventually was renamed Uranus after

Read More
319 Words | 2 Pages

Also, given that there is still more data that NASA says could be hear by next year, Pluto will continue to become less mysterious. Now, all the world has to do is figure out how to breathe on Pluto because it might be the number one location for skiing and

Read More
268 Words | 2 Pages

Pluto should still be a planet. The new definition of planet relies on information (mass, shape) that was not and could not be known in the 1930s. “Start calling Pluto a planet right now because that’s how science makes progress, by one person at a time being convinced of the truth and adopting it. Science is not decided by votes and you are not required to submit to nonsense.” When people explain why they think Pluto is not a planet, they say it’s just too small.

Read More
348 Words | 2 Pages

Pluto should be a planet because it meets many of the requirements to be a planet. Pluto also has many characteristics that the other planets have. The requirements to be a planet are: -It is in orbit around the Sun. -It has sufficient mass to assume hydrostatic equilibrium (a nearly round shape). -It has "cleared the neighborhood" around its orbit Pluto qualifies for the first two.

Read More
417 Words | 2 Pages

NASA has just released the most detailed view of Pluto to date. The images from the New Horizon spacecraft show a variety of unique landscapes of the likes never before seen. This would usually be cause for celebration, however, it seems the agency might have some explaining to do. According to some skeptics, these images of Pluto were released in 2012 and there is proof. If the agency is caught lying about this, it might open up the door to a wealth of other conspiracies like aliens on Mars or the Hollow Earth Theory.

Read More
442 Words | 2 Pages

What is Astronomy? Astronomy is the study of the sun, moon, stars, planets, comets, gas, galaxies,dust and other non-Earthly bodies. Astronomy is very important to understanding space and everything in it. When studying Astronomy it is very important to use models. Models are important because it makes it possible to study, for example the distance and sizes of the planets without having to go through all the trouble of going up into space, which is very far away and cost lots of money.

Read More
862 Words | 4 Pages

It is the fourth-largest planet in diameter and the third-largest in mass. Like all the other planets, Neptune turns on its own axis as it is orbiting the sun. The planets

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

This fifth grade lesson plan on planets will help as an introduction to an entire unit on the modules of the solar system. It will give my students an outline of the solar system, by describing the structure of how the sun is placed in the center, and the orbit of the planets around the sun; it will also show my students the planets relative sizes. I will then explain that due to new discoveries that Pluto is no longer considered a planet. This change was based on the size of Pluto it was even smaller than our moon. Also, due to its very far location at the edge of the solar system, scientists have decided to change Pluto’s classification, to a dwarf planet.

Read More

More about Should Pluto Be Considered A Planet?

Open Document