ipl-logo

Similarities Between The Lottery And Saboteur

1715 Words7 Pages

Throughout the twentieth century, citizens of many countries have fought for their personal rights and freedoms. But not all places have experienced expansions of freedom, and they stand as a threat to the free lands--they stand as an example of what could easily be. This fear is exploited in two short stories that are set in very different places: Ha Jin’s “Saboteur” which is set in communist China and Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” which is ostensibly set in mid-century, small-town America. In both “Saboteur” and “The Lottery” short stories, the citizens allow themselves to be controlled by a larger force, be it their political government or their traditions. It was obvious that all of the citizens have choices on where they should stand-- …show more content…

In this story, Jin noted about how family communicated with each other, “[...] “shut up, Tessie,” Bill Hutchinson said.”” (7). This phrase of a conversation shows the impoliteness to one another. In the text, it also stated about their actions within families, “Bill Hutchinson went over to his wife and forced the slip of paper out of her hand” (7). If they care about each other, their action should not be rough with each other. Their characteristics of their actions and words show the relationship that these people have within their families. And it was not a caring-and-love one family relationship. They let their tradition tear family apart, which they can stop if they are willing to do it. Throughout reading this short story, it informs the audiences that each individual character in this story have similar characteristics--loneliness-- except children, who does not fully understand family bonds. This story also shows their appearance of selfishness. When someone wins the lottery, they think it’s okay to do the tradition. However, when their time come to face the tradition, they start to point out how unfair the game is. It shows that when a person life is on the line, he or she starts to fight for it. A lesson that audiences can learn from these characters is self life is more valuable …show more content…

During a mess situation that happened in “Saboteur,” the setting was described as a small town, nothing magnificent places to roam around for honeymoon. Jin noted about a place, “the air smelled of rotten melon. A few flies kept buzzing above the couple’s lunch [...] young women, representing the local hotels, held up placards which displayed the daily prices [...]” (179). The author noting to describe the place is to show that this is place is a small city or town, that places to stay are cheaper, and people sales their fruits and advertise their hotels with using people. There are no such thing as TV ads or other medias that this modern days uses technology. The setting is established with unornamented place for honeymoon. Also this place seem like a place where democratic government services were not involved in. In democracy country, soldier, officers, and police are meant for nation--citizens protection. However, in communist country, people don’t really have a say to anything and the government formed like militarism because police and other military forces have power over

Show More
Related
762 Words | 4 Pages

In “Peanut’s Fortune”, Tan uses narrative to move the plot forward. With Peanut’s sister narrating the short story, Tan’s writing is predominantly narrative because it depicts events in the view of Peanut’s sister who is essentially a bystander to Peanut and Wen Fu’s interactions. Not only does the writing portray her observations, but it also reveals the thoughts and feelings of Peanut’s sister to the reader. The narrative especially shows her growing envy for Peanut’s love with Wen Fu, but also shows the dear love she has for her sister. Occasionally, when important events occur or when introducing new characters, Tan interjects dialogue into the narrative, revealing the thoughts and perspective of others surrounding Peanut and her sister.

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

Democracy and personal rights are a key component of American society and belief system, but citizens have begun to take the liberties given to them for granted. They have been around for so long no one can imagine society without them. Bryan Rittgers takes on a sarcastic and witty tone in his satiric essay in order to portray the irony of undervaluing the importance of rights to normal American citizens. This essay is laced with extreme sarcasm and is written in a true satiric manner. Rittgers openly denounces the rights he has been given and pushes for the removal or restriction of them.

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

Individual suffering is evident in Shirley Jackson’s short story “The Lottery”, a theme also taken up by author Ursula Le Guin in her story “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas”. The theme of an individual person taking on the responsibility of society to suffer for the rest of civilization to live in happiness is a similarity between the two short stories. The difference is the realization of why that one individual has to suffer. In both stories, the authors use a scapegoat for the happiness of their community.

Read More
222 Words | 1 Pages

The Lottery is a short story about a town of people that will crowd and all the men will get a slip of paper all the paper is blank… besides one and that one has a black dot, so a lucky person will get it and if they have a kid older than 16 they have play this game, anyway the winner will get a “prize”. The Lottery story and The Lottery movie have many things that were different. The Lottery story is different from The Lottery movie by where it is located and where the event took place, such as in the story they were sacrificing someone in a large field while in the movie they were stopped by the building. If they didn’t have the building in the way she could have lived longer while if they did she would have died sooner.

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

In the fabricated short stories “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas” by Ursula K LeGuin and “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, both have descriptive meanings of sacrifice. In these short stories, sacrifice is enforced to become beneficial for everyone else in these communities. By comparing and contrasting these short stories between how the society is developed, what is being sacrificed, and how the sacrifice is beneficial, shows how this helps make everyone in these communities mirthful. In “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas” by Ursula K LeGuin, due to sacrifice, the people in the society were joyful and satisfied towards the way they were living.

Read More
909 Words | 4 Pages

There are several aspects of plot development that were involved in the creation of both, “The Lottery,” and “The Hunger Games,”; some of which deem these The Lottery and The Hunger Games similar and others that distinguish one another different. When comparing both these works of art for similarities, it is apparent that many of their overall themes are similar. Both, The lottery and The Hunger Games involve an involuntary selection, that ultimately results in the suffering of those picked and death. These two works of art are, also, similar in the aspect that the people of the highest social class rarely suffer in result of these selections. Although, both The Lottery and The Hunger Games have more similarities than differences, one of the

Read More
455 Words | 2 Pages

In the short story, “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson and the movie, “The Hunger Games” by Suzanne Collins, tells a tale of dystopian communities where they have to choose a sacrifice by drawing their names and having them to kill to survive to make sure they have enough food for their communities. Even though both stories are violent and cruel, they both explain the purpose of a dystopian life. First, some similarities between both stories, “The Lottery” and “The Hunger Games” are that they are both in a rural community and that their children are involved with this yearly event too. Everyone is dressed poorly and their communities both don’t have enough food.

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

There are still some bad people in the world, and sometimes they aren’t who you would expect. Shirley Jackson uses different ways to trick the readers in, The Lottery, and, The Possibility of Evil. These two short stories involve two small towns and an ironic ending for the female protagonists. The stories are meant to use different types of irony to fool the readers or the protagonist.

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

Understanding and knowledge of one another is essential yet frustrating when a barrier exists. In Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club, she portrays the story of four mothers and daughters using their points of view. One mother-daughter pair is Jing-mei and Suyuan Woo. When Suyuan dies, Jing-mei has to try and fill her place in the Joy Luck Club that includes Suyuan’s friends: An-mei Hsu, Lindo Jong, and Ying-ying St. Clair. Amy Tan uses characterization to point out the character’s pride, lack of understanding, and resentment in order to illuminate the heritage lost between Jing-mei and Suyuan Woo.

Read More
264 Words | 2 Pages

Compare and Contrast Name Trinity Morse “The Lottery” and Hunger Games Both “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson and The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins are about dystopian societies in which life and death events occur. They are similar in a way and not similar in a way. They are similar because this event happens once a year. In “The Lottery” the whole Village Square gets rocks and throws them at the winner they will throw the rocks until the winner is died. In The Hunger Games they get slips and put them in a jar and a special person with pull a girl and a boy from the jar.

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

One afternoon Shirley Jackson decided to write “The Lottery,” all in one day. Jackson sets up the story by describing specific details about the town and where they were gathering to form a twisted end. “The Lottery,” and “The Hunger Games,” seem to have quite a few similarities. The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins and The Lottery by Shirley Jackson both show how humans are drawn to violent traditions and the hypocrisy human’s possess towards violence. I do believe author Suzanne Collins was influenced by Jackson to create her novels.

Read More
1681 Words | 7 Pages

America is often coined ‘land of the free, home of the brave’, it resonates feelings of pride and superiority to be free of all forms of oppression and be a nation with strict codes of natural rights. These certain rights become unanimous to being a citizen of a country or even the world, those rights have been developed over time and are pivotal in various forms of cultural framework. Although the United States, and United Nations have developed various rules and regulations to enforce and guide the basic rights of human beings and citizens of particular countries, there are still social divides. The Declaration of Independence and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights became a promise for people, but in Alice Goffman’s On the Run, both documents provide an outline of basic human rights stripped. The accounts on Sixth Street show a violation of human rights through punitive policing, fear of

Read More
2707 Words | 11 Pages

Family is an important aspect of living through rough times because it will make the hard times easier. In this short story, Kichizo and Okyo decide to be each other’s supporter and be there for one another. Kichizo does not know his family and it makes him sad, but Okyo tries to lift his spirits. Okyo says to Kichizo, “I don’t know what kind of people your parents were, but it makes no different to me” (975). Okyo does not care that he does not know his parents because that does not affect how he lives his life and he is doing better than his parents.

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

For some of my family the search for individuality is an ongoing process. In fact, my family and the family in “Everyday Use” share similarities and differences when it comes to actions of young people, the treatment of children, and relationships between family members. Firstly, the young people in my family and in the short story share similarities and differences when it comes to our actions. Dee, known as Wangero, and I have some similarities.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

One can be blind in the eye or by the heart… “A Secret For Two” by Quentin Reynolds is about a secret shared between a blind man and his only true friend, Joseph. On the other hand, “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson is a warning to humans that violence can happen very often and can be committed by the most ordinary people. A Secret for two and the lottery both uses foreshadowing and suspense to keep the reader on the edge, and share a similarity in language. However, these two stories have a significant differ in mood expressed using different details. First of all, “A Secret For Two” is about a hard working old man Pierre that is blind and works in a milk factory alongside with his horse for a very long period.

Read More

More about Similarities Between The Lottery And Saboteur

Related Topics

Open Document