ipl-logo

Singer And The Capacity Argument Essay

1178 Words5 Pages

Sagan, Singer, and The Capacity Argument

The capacity argument is an ethical issue which if proven wrong challenges the ways in which humans use and abuse animals. The controversy about whether or not animals should be equal to humans and if their capacity to feel pain should determine if they should or should not be deserving of equality. Carl Sagan, Peter Singer, and Jeremy Bentham have formed opinions about the Capacity Argument concerning issues of morality, equality, suffering, and pain in regards to the treatment of animals and the ways our species use them.

If animals were deemed deserving of equality and our species was forced to change this would be devastating for fur farms, meat production factories, businesses, dairy farms, science laboratories and many more companies. If it was considered to be morally wrong our species most likely would not change our ways because there is so much money involved in using animals. (Bentham, 1789, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, Chapter xvii) States that, “The question is not, "Can they reason?" nor, "Can they talk?" but "Can they suffer?” Bentham developed …show more content…

I don’t think that the way in which humans use animals is ethical and we use them for selfish reasons because it's easy and there is money to be made. There are many alternatives instead of using animals in the year 2018. Our species no longer require them for servile and I believe it is time for things to change in regards to the ways in which animals are made to suffer through animal testing, slaughter, and meat production farms where they are packed into close quarters. If we do not require them for servile any longer but yet we constantly kill even when it is not necessary. Human lives are not the only lives that matter but we seem to think along these

Show More
Related

Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Foster Wallace

959 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout history, personal feelings, ethics, persuasion, and judgement is what lead the masses of countries. Such actions can be considered horrendous and uncivilized acts, which are unbefitting for our generation. There is no reason that we should be killing any animal inhumanely, just for pure succulent pleasure.

Read More

An Analysis Of Peter Singer's Argument

447 Words | 2 Pages

Yes, I agree with Peter singers argument on duty to render aid to others to an extent because it is the right thing to do for example take the drowning child scenario into consideration. The importance of saving the life of the child far outweighs the risks it doesn't necessarily need to even be a child when you see someone in need of help and you are able to help you ought to help them. Also the booze cruise scenario when everybody is off drinking,partying, and having a good time upon asking for their help they say they're to busy drinking even though saving the lives of the 20 naval officers is what they ought to do because it outweighs drinking instead you ought to try and save as many lives as you can. The parts I don't agree with Singer are his fair share view which says that if others aren’t doing enough you are obligated to do more than your fair share and when he says give till it hurts at all times because it is required of you that is a bit extreme and necessarily isn't true because for example in the drowning child argument if you're unable to help perhaps because you're a paraplegic then it isn't required of you.

Read More

Peter Singer's Argument Essay

381 Words | 2 Pages

So my issue with Peter Singer's argument is it's infallible to tell someone that they should not be spending money on luxuries, when they themselves are buying tickets to see a movie. I believe in "practice what you preach" and "actions speak louder than words". Which really puts me off about what Singer was trying to communicate. Now I understand his thoughts of trying to challenge people to not be selfish and think inwardly. But in that process, he himself fell prey to his own vices.

Read More

David Foster Wallace's Essay: Ethics And The New Genetics

1582 Words | 7 Pages

As the human, we stand at the top of the food chain. Thus, we can do whatever we want. We start to use animals to improve our lives. For example, we use animals’ furs to keep us warm in winter. Unfortunately, at the beginning of this cruel thing happens, the public just treat it as the luxury business since it is so expensive and not everyone can own it.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Animal Testing

800 Words | 4 Pages

The sacrifice of animals for human benefit is cruel. Animals are like slaves for humans by being involuntarily subjected to harsh conditions and procedures. Once an experiment fails, no one benefits; America just lost millions of dollars on a failed experiment and the lives of innocent creatures were ended for no valid

Read More

Singer's Argument

251 Words | 2 Pages

One argument that Singer provides in “The Singer Solution to World Poverty” is that individuals who give aid to those in need are probably more well off than those who do not give aid. However, regardless of where one stands financially, aid should still be given by all those who can give. A counter argument that Singer provides is that one might say if one individual gives, they may think that if more people also gave, then they would not have to give as much. A person might find it unfair if they are contributing more to benefit others than what other individuals are giving. In addition to this, one way this could be done would be by adding the “burden” of aiding overseas countries through taxes.

Read More

Peter Singer What Does It Mean To Eat Ethically

1147 Words | 5 Pages

While some authors will agree that eating meat is unethical, others will have a difference in opinion. According to “Equality for Animals?” author Peter Singer, when we consume meat we disregard the rights of the animals for our own interest and consumption. He believes in equality for animals and even goes as far to mention that if animals counted in their own right, then the way in which we use them would become questionable. He states, “One problem is, of course, that using them for food involves killing” (Singer 214).

Read More

Animal Welfare: Slaughterhouses In The United States

1077 Words | 5 Pages

“To satisfy the public's ever-growing appetite for meat, slaughterhouses in the United States killed ten billion animals last year. That's 27,397,260 animals every day, 1,141,553 every hour, 19,026 every minute” (Jones). Many animals are being placed in slaughter houses each year to meet this high demand. Farm animal welfare refers to the state, living condition, and treatment, animals are but under in farms. Cruel animal welfare has spread throughout the world killing millions of animals in inhumane ways.

Read More

Persuasive Essay: Is Cheerleading A Sport?

587 Words | 3 Pages

English 9 Mr. Primorsky There are men all over the world saying that cheerleading isn't a sport! Well, there are girls all over the world working hard and even getting hurt from these extreme stunts and hard choreography. For example, cheerleaders have a 56.7% chance of getting hurt while football players have about 47.2% chance. But still, football is said to be more dangerous than cheerleading.

Read More

Limits Of The Humane Slaughter Act

1640 Words | 7 Pages

As a society there should be a continuation of proceeding to develop new laws. Animals have rights that are not being protected or considered when they are not given the chance to live without suffering or harm. Additionally animal rights are violated when they are used as products for experimentation. Animal experimentations

Read More

Peter Singer's Argument Against Animal Rights

2076 Words | 9 Pages

Animals Rights In society, animals are being killed for food, fur, and experiments. This raises the question is it ethical to kill other animals for our own person gain? As human, we live in a society where it is humane to kill other animals when it comes to survival, clothing and to help cure diseases. But this is not really answering the question why is this okay?

Read More

Persuasive Speech On Animal Rights

1889 Words | 8 Pages

“In 2016, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) estimated that Americans ate an average of 54.3 pounds of beef, 92.1 pounds of chicken, and 50.4 pounds of pork, per person, per year” (Vegetarianism). Food production counts for only one of the many injustices animals face daily. Although they have been proven emotionally intelligent, mankind views these entities as subservient and continue to harm them. People around the world have created organizations that work to ameliorate the treatment of animals. As the animal rights movement nobly fights to improve the conditions of these living creatures, daily human activities and the moral values of some prolong the acceptance of animal equality.

Read More

Consumption Of Farm Animals Worth The Outcome For Better For Our Economy

1099 Words | 5 Pages

At one point in your life, have you ever thought to yourself how was the meat on your plate produced, and why is it so cheap? Billions of farm animals are consumed every year in the U.S. at cheap costs and endure in conditions that buyers wouldn’t acknowledge. A large portion of our meats originate from meat industries that produce, abuse, and process meat for the public from farms that abuse animals unless the animal was raised organically. The meats that are produced are a necessity for a us omnivores because we eat meat on a daily basis as a source for protein and fat, unless you are vegetarian, or vegan. Now since it’s a necessity for us living beings, is cruelty in animal agriculture worth the outcome for better for our economy?

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Eating Meat

1421 Words | 6 Pages

The meat packing industry disregards animal’s emotions and their rights all together by the malicious treatment of animals. The way animals are being treated is highly unfair. Being slaughtered for their body parts and suffering just to be used for protein or an asset to humans is unbearable. An animal’s life is at equal values to a human and deserve the same rights as

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Animals

710 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine a day in the life of a common farm animal. Far from the peaceful grazing life one would envision, the livestock of today endure horrific conditions - from suffering painful diseases to being separated from their mothers at too young of an age. Not only are these conditions harmful to the animals, the food produced by them is unnecessary to humanity’s well-being and can even be damaging to society’s overall health. Since the definition of ethics is having well-founded standards of right and wrong, this process of producing meat for our consumption is unethical.

Read More

More about Singer And The Capacity Argument Essay

Related Topics

Open Document