ipl-logo

Skepticism About Practical Reason By Christine Korsgaard Analysis

1951 Words8 Pages

In Bernard Williams’ essay “Internal and External Reasons” he discusses the notion of reasoning and why people choose to act in certain ways. Williams believes that reasons for our actions can be separated into an internal and external category. Internal reasoning suggests that we have reason to perform an act because it will fulfill the motives that we have. External reasoning suggests that we still have reason to perform an act even if it will not fulfill our motives. Williams believes that external reasoning is impossible and therefore all sentences that follow external reasoning are incorrect. In her essay “Skepticism about Practical Reason” Christine Korsgaard responds to Williams and she argues that external reasoning is very plausible …show more content…

The college student has anxiety about their schoolwork and knows that by completing their work they will remove their anxiety, but instead of satisfying their desires they lay in bed all day and watch television. This example is a clear case of acting against what would satisfy out desires, as the college student specifically knew that they had the reason to satisfy their motives but still chose to perform a different action. In a situation such as the college student, Korsgaard would suggest that he did not satisfy his desires by completing his work simply because he was being irrational. Korsgaard discusses David Hume’s notion of irrationality in which she states that “So a person may be irrational, not merely by failing to observe rational connections-say, failing to see that the sufficient means are at hand but also by being “willfully" blind to them, or even by being indifferent to them when they are pointed out” (14). Korsgaard is stating here that external reasoning is possible when the notion of irrationality is factored in. If an agent acts in an irrational matter, then it is quite obvious that external reasoning is a possibility and therefore it is possible to act against what we believe will satisfy our desires. Korsgaard completes her discussion of irrationality by stating that if it is indeed possible to be irrational, then it is obviously possible to use external reasoning (14). It is only logical that there can be an external factor in one’s decision-making process, we cannot always be completely rational and even if deliberates there is still the possibility of irrational decisions being made. Deliberation and arguing are not enough to be able to create a rational decision making process and this where Williams’ argument fails to stand up to Korsgaard’s

Show More
Related
1743 Words | 7 Pages

Rational behavior is not easy to achieve but it is possible. According to Charles Elder and Roger Cobb, “Rationality implies that political actions and evaluations are the product of consistent preferences, logical analysis, and abundant [unbiased] information. Irrationality, on the other hand presupposes that political actions and reactions are based on emotional impulses and blind prejudices that defy logic and that are insensitive to fact.” Elder and Cobb both compared the understanding of rational behavior and irrational behavior. Human beings are basically non-rational people.

Read More
1528 Words | 7 Pages

The Importance of Rationality At often times one may believe that making decisions should be predominantly based upon what one may feel or desire, though in reality such process frequently results in negative consequences, thus why in the process of making decisions, love should not overtake rationality. When love is prioritized in decision making, it tends to cause thoughts that typically won’t better the situation for those who are involved, while rationality would instead provide the proper reasoning to create a suitable outcome. In the process of making decisions, love should not overtake rationality.

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

Human beings have exhibited signs of irrationality as well as animalistic behavior. Why this deportment occurs is a question that continues to be unanswered. Voltaire’s Candide & Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” both explore the nature of human beings along with how a majority of them tend to think irrationally. The purpose of these two works of literature is to identify human nature in a negative light. Swift states what the problem with the intrinsic nature of human beings is.

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

“An irrational society is a society of moral cowards—of men paralyzed by the loss of moral standards, principles, and goals. But since men have to act, so long as they live, such as a society is read to be taken over by anyone willing to set its direction. The initiative can come from only two types of men: either from the man who is willing to assume the responsibility of asserting rational values--- or from the thug who is not troubled by questions of responsibility.” Ayn Rand explains that in order to survive in an irrational society, you have to overcome the fear of moral judgement, and let that be your responsibility. In “Anthem”, Equality 7-2521 understand the evils of an irrational society—which is fear of moral judgement.

Read More
590 Words | 3 Pages

Hello Village of Ridgewood Council Members. We are from Dr. Bernardo’s philosophy honors class at Ridgewood High School and are here to discuss the issue of rationality that has been affecting this town for the past few years. People have not been acting in a way that would be considered rational and so we have put together guidelines for people of the town to follow in order to live their lives more rationally. Rationality is acting according to the truth, so our presentation has a focus on getting people to act according to the truth.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

The irrational behavior can be judge as reasonable in many

Read More
1284 Words | 6 Pages

According to the principles of Ayn Rand’s objectivism, man must decide what is best for himself based on reason. This often plays a major role in the survival of that organism, as some decisions, if incorrect in the circumstance, can result in death. Frequently, the deciding factor in such circumstances is reason. Equality 7-2521 uses reasoning while traversing the Uncharted Forest outside of the City after he has decided to leave his old life behind. In the City, he did not have to care for himself nor provide himself with basic necessities, such as food and water.

Read More
1569 Words | 7 Pages

The relationship between the reason and religious beliefs has been highlighted by the three parts mentioned According to Pojman an argument for an ethical duty to strictly believe in accord with the evidence available that supports it (170). I concur that a person’s beliefs can affect the well-being of others, it is best to be open- minded towards criticism (167). According to Pojman, one can hold positions that faith and reason are compatible, that it is rational to belief in God (166). And lastly that faith can be opposed to reason and therefore faith is the questionable area of rationality (166).

Read More
1170 Words | 5 Pages

Unlike human will, human reason is free and has no innate morality. Human reason is persuaded by the external world and is influenced by other people’s thoughts and actions. In other words, the reasoning of one person can rub off onto other people, sending a ripple of ideas out into society. It is the element in which humans control and use to handle their thoughts and actions. Through human reason, people become imperfect and in short, human.

Read More
476 Words | 2 Pages

This is imperative to invalidating Hobbes’s claim because this shows how one’s irrational emotions drives one to create an irrational outcome through one’s

Read More
1210 Words | 5 Pages

Our rationality and reason give us the ability to distinguish between good and bad, just and unjust, and to assess whether or not we are good people. It also gives us the capability to understand and perform higher intellectual activities. The three alternatives can also be said to be split into 2 categories, the rational part of the soul and the non-rational part of the soul. The life of growth and perception falls

Read More
1021 Words | 5 Pages

Overall, the rational is but an attempt to define the undefinable. To understand Otto’s rejection of the rational, the rational must be understood. “Rational,” in The Idea of the Holy, refers to the conceptualization of religion and the divine itself. Otto’s basic definition of the rational stems from the establishment and application of concepts evidenced in “they can be grasped by the intellect; they can be analyzed by thought; they even admit of definition. An object that can thus be thought conceptually may be termed rational” (Otto, 1).

Read More
941 Words | 4 Pages

Though many people think that emotion helps make rational resolutions, often times it hurts one’s ability to do so. In To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, Scout, the protagonist, and her family discover the need for logic when her father takes an important court case. Sadly, most of the people of Maycomb in the 1930s became corrupt because they do not use rationality in their lives. Throughout the novel, Scout and the reader both learn that one should not let their emotions rule their reason when making decisions. Even before the court case began, Scout learns about the recurring theme of logic being more effective than her feelings when forming opinions of others and in communicating.

Read More
467 Words | 2 Pages

Teens are having trouble passing their driving test because they do not get proper training. Poor instruction causes these young drivers to be involved in accidents on the road, which is why driving schools need to be aware of the various bad habits of driving. Educating new drivers on the proper way to drive will provide a safer environment on the road. Using a mobile device while driving is a huge dilemma causing thousands of deaths and accidents per year. Texting, changing the song, and looking at the time are all examples of this careless habit.

Read More
1031 Words | 5 Pages

Lizeth Tinoco Professor Stephanie Arms English 101 22 February 2018 Benefits of Being Rational Although arrogance gets in the way of rationality, our understandings of different matters of the world shape us into believing what to be is true and what is not true. To be rational means that one is able to think logically or critically with reason. A critical thinker is not someone who expresses just the first thought that comes into mind, they have to think more than two times to be rational and express something that is important. Being rational is being able to weigh options to make the best decisions, like in Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave,” when the prisoner returns to the cave, he learns that the reality is outside the cave and what he’s

Read More

More about Skepticism About Practical Reason By Christine Korsgaard Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document