ipl-logo

Summary Of Flew: Death By A Thousand Qualifications

1069 Words5 Pages

Homework #1 Flew: Death by a Thousand Qualifications (Handout) 1. Describe the parable of the garden. Explain what Flew means by the death of a hypothesis by a thousand qualifications and how this parable is relevant to this claim. In the parable of the garden, Flew presents two explorers that have stumbled upon a clearing amid a jungle in which grew both flowers and weeds. One explorer states the “garden” must be tended by a gardener and the other dissents by claiming that it is not. They set about finding said gardener by establishing progressively more stringent modes of surveillance to detect him/her/it/ (them?) to confirm or deny eithers claim. With each new mode of observation the explorer who believes in a gardener tending the …show more content…

Honestly? I can’t really answer right now. I would need considerably more time to mule this over and a different medium to articulate my thoughts, but the short, very crude answer goes as follows. I guess that for the time being I agree with Flew’s argument, or its implication, if it is that “theological utterances” aren’t genuine assertions. However, I fail to see how this would devalue them, as I take what is put in parentheses in paragraph three to be implying. Further, I have always seen such utterances as “there is a God” as axiomatic, and if I can liken this statement to the parable above then I also fail to see how “analogous” statements like “there isn’t a God” as significantly different. For each statement the criteria for the confirmation or refutation of them are quasi-arbitrarily set. In example, for the first explorer the presence of the garden is enough to confirm that there is a gardener who tends to it, and therefore he makes his statement, for the other explorer, his inability to find the gardener with his battery of tests is enough to confirm that there isn’t one, and he makes his. In essence, each “assertion” is irrefutable because the criteria for the confirmation or refutation of the statements are set by those making them and employed in ways to confirm the hypothesis of either. One is saying that that which cannot be found exists (outside the context of the “axiom” that there is a gardener) and the other that what

Show More
Related

Juxtaposition And Personification In Sandra Cisneros The Monkey Garden

165 Words | 1 Pages

Sandra Cisneros’, “The Monkey Garden”, uses juxtaposition and personification to provide ominousness to her vignette. For instance, a bit after Esperanza first entered the garden following the family moving, she noted the “hollyhocks perfumy like the blue-blond hair of the dead”, comparing aromatic flowers to dull colored locks from the deceased, foreshadowing that there must be an upcoming negative event of some sort involving death. The foul use of corpses’ hair color to describe a fragrant plant is placed to accentuate their clear differences. Cisneros also uses personification to establish an ominous mood to this piece. For example, after stating the garden was taking over itself, the “flowers stopped obeying” their designated areas.

Read More

Juxtaposition In The Monkey Garden By Cisneros

387 Words | 2 Pages

In the vignette, “The Monkey Garden,” Cisneros uses similes, personification, and juxtaposition to show how the garden quickly changes from a child’s playground to a place of haunting grownup memories. In the beginning, Cisneros uses similes to describe the carefree nature of the garden: “There were big green apples hard as knees. And everywhere the sleepy smell of rotting wood, damp earth, and dusty hollyhocks thick and perfumey like the blue-blonde hair of the dead" (Cisneros 95). Initially, Esperanza and the other children are young and naive and play in the garden without any worries. The garden is a place of childhood innocence and shows that although Esperanza wants desperately to grow up, she is still a child.

Read More

Bird Symbolism In The Scarlet Ibis

484 Words | 2 Pages

In this it shows how the bird had traveled many miles just to die; just like

Read More

Human And Nature In Lester Rowntree's Collecting Myself

999 Words | 4 Pages

The beginning of this essay is “ Twenty- five years ago my gnawing curioity to kow more about plants in their native homes got out of hand.. ”(Lester Rowntree, Collecting Myself). This first sentence of the essay directly give out the infomation for the whole essay: a people who moved herself into a forest, stay clear away for the moderrn life, and the purpose of this choice is for “study of plants”. But when read throught the whole essay, audience can not only realize what a live in a forest like, but also can get in touch with the deep thought for the relationship between human and

Read More

Wager's Argument For The Existence Of God

378 Words | 2 Pages

For this disputation, I had the pleasure of arguing against the topic of be it resolved that you can convince a non-believer to affirm the existence of God using philosophical arguments. As the opposing side, Sarah and I counter argued the following: the argument from motion, the ontological argument, Pascal’s Wager, the cosmological argument, the teleological argument, and the moral argument. The argument from motion argues that it is only possible to experience that which exists, and people experience God, therefore God must exist; however it can be counter argued that since faith cannot be demonstrated or experienced, as it is unseen, God cannot exist.

Read More

A Soldier's Fugue Analysis

810 Words | 4 Pages

In a simile, she compares gardening to “boxing… The wins versus the losses” (Hudes 16). Through this comparison, Hudes conveys Ginny’s deep desire for a sense of control and success in her life. This desire is fed by the memory of her father, who was only bearable when he was gardening. Specifically, the assertion of this desire for control is evident as she recalls that her father “was a mean bastard…” but “became a saint if you put a flower in his hand” (Hudes 15). From those experiences of dealing with her father, a psychological analogy between nature and peace was instilled in Ginny’s mind at a young age, and is what she relies on as an adult to handle her emotional trauma.

Read More

Flight 001 Essay

627 Words | 3 Pages

Flight 001 1. Marketing corporate gift products to companies such as Orbitz and MTV could affect sales by bringing more publicity to the store. When customers see these products given to famous people and companies, they may be more tempted to visit Flight 001. The more people visit the store, the more sales Flight 001 is going to make. 2.

Read More

The American Dream In Annie Dillard's Living Like Weasels

903 Words | 4 Pages

Metaphorically, she depicts the steer as “they look like miracle itself” (“LIVING”). Then, she describes “miracle’s nonchalance” (“LIVING”). Not only does she purport that nature miraculously exists, but it also is unconcerned in its awesomeness. Furthermore, the fifth paragraph expounds upon this contrast by utilizing phrases such as “highway at one end of the pond,” symbolizing man versus “a nesting pair of wood ducks at the other,” representing the natural world (“LIVING”). Likewise, the bushes contain man’s polluting beer cans and muskrat holes which reveal the opposing sides whereby humanity disrupts its beautiful surroundings.

Read More

The Dead Parachutist In Lord Of The Flies Analysis

827 Words | 4 Pages

The Lord of the Flies novel, by William Golding, is a symbolic allegory, delving deep into the true horrors of war, savagery, and the loss of innocence throughout the duration of time the children spent on the island. I the novel a situation arises involving a dead parachutist, still he represents so much more than Mr. Golding makes apparent. Commonly applied to the story is the ideology of a “beast,” the concept behind these two aspects are similar, yet have a distinct separation between them. Just like the notion of the “beast” and the dead parachutist is the “Lord of the Flies” himself, pertaining to reasons related to that of the other two major examples of symbolism. The dead parachutist is so much more than what you see, you must go deeper

Read More

Rape In Laurie Halse Anderson's Speak

1636 Words | 7 Pages

One weekend, Melinda is bored of partaking in her usual activity of sitting on the couch and doing nothing, so, upon looking at the state of her front yard, she opts for some gardening. The work refreshes her and she feels lighter as the muscles in her arms throb from hours of hard labor, her hands calloused from gripping the rough surface of the rake. She has found a hobby that she enjoys, this is important to her recovering as it gives her a distraction from the thoughts beating at the inside of her head. Aside from just a distraction, gardening can be used as a metaphor for her clearing away the things that are holding her back from speaking out about what happened to her. As Melinda begins the grueling task of clearing out her yard she says, “I start on the leaves suffocating the bushes… They look harmless and dry on top, but under that top layer, they’re wet and slimy...

Read More

The Human Rumblebee By Michael Pollon Analysis

888 Words | 4 Pages

At first Pollon believes that humans are the subject but we see that thought change when he says “But that afternoon in the garden I

Read More

Summary Of How Flowers Changed The World

1255 Words | 6 Pages

But Eiseley said, “there is nothing very “normal” about Nature. Once upon a time, there were no flowers at all.” Further implicating that without the emergence of flowers, the world wouldn’t be considered as a whole. Eiseley’s main purpose is to allude the readers into thinking that there are many other possible reasons as to why the world came to be, and his reason is the emergence of the angiosperms. The Immense Journey was specifically written to discuss the history of humanity, however Eiseley’s “How Flowers Changed the World” was written in a way to combine science and humanity in a poetic manner.

Read More

Gaunilo's Ontological Argument

924 Words | 4 Pages

Anselm delivered the first known ontological argument in a prayer. He claimed, 1) God exists in the understanding, 2) good might have existed in reality, 3) if something exists only in the understanding, then it is possible for it to be greater, 4) suppose God exists only in the understanding, 5) God might have been greater than it is, and 6) the greatest possible being could have been greater. There is a contradiction between #4 and #6. Guanilo counters Anselm’s argument by demonstrating that one could substitute different words with God and make absurd claims. For instance, he substitutes God for

Read More

Personal Narrative-Wheat Field With Cypresses

584 Words | 3 Pages

Wheat Field with Cypresses There was an electric buzz that filled the small room while people milled around. A crowd gathered to the left, perplexed by something that hung on the beige wall. The sound of shuffling feet floated in the air while everyone struggled to get prime position to witness something so many before and after themselves have and will experience; an experience that defies the natural order of life, having a man just stand there, within arms reach, not in his living form but rather in a form he created himself, and have their breath taken away. I bobbed and weaved against an invisible opponent, straining to find a clear view while the backs of heads stared back, unrushed and disregarding my intent. The small group of tourists proceeded slowly like that of a mourning stroll while a sombre silence filled me.

Read More

Thomas Aquinas Argument For The Existence Of God

468 Words | 2 Pages

Contingency of Being Thomas Aquinas argued for the existence of God through his understanding of science along with the help of physical evidence, unchangeable facts and logic. I will discuss Aquinas’ Third proof and how he does prove that there is a God or Gods without the need for faith and revelation. In philosophy, we often distinguish things between being necessary being and contingent beings. Necessary beings are beings that have always existed and that could have never not existed.

Read More

More about Summary Of Flew: Death By A Thousand Qualifications

Related Topics

Open Document