ipl-logo

Summary Of Haidya Hartman The Terrible Beauty Of The Slums

1580 Words7 Pages

“The Terrible Beauty of the Slums” by Säidya Hartman features a carefully crafted narrative meant to illustrate the incompleteness of historical archives that fail to capture the hope in intimate Black life. Hartman’s work is a genre-defying text that refuses categorization due to its unconventional rhetoric. Typically, readers assume that Hartman’s purpose is simply to liberate the young Black girls from dehumanizing stereotypes by undermining the othering gaze of the outsider, the perpetrators of surveillance and racism. This assumption fails to take into account Hartman’s choice to place readers in the role of the undermined outsider. If we do not explore the implications of having the role of the outsider imposed on us, then we fail to …show more content…

However, Hartman’s note on method informs us otherwise. Her project is to liberate them from the inherently racist label describing them as the worst elements in a “human sewer” (4). By subjecting the young Black girls to scrutiny instead of retrospective praise, Hartman’s actions are unexpected. For example, Hartman chooses to identify them by their intersection between age, gender, and race. Keeping in mind that gender and race are social constructs, the young Black girls are described by societal labels instead of with their names, which would pay homage to their heritage and humanize them. In another unexpected choice, Hartman gives more page space, regarding who speaks the most, to the outsiders. If Hartman’s intent is to liberate the young Black girls, why would she give more room to the outsiders, the supposed perpetrators of confinement? Initial observations would lead to the conclusion that Hartman does not liberate the young Black girls at …show more content…

But after this vulnerable moment of intimate Black life, the passage ends with the voice of the outsiders who view the young Black girls as threatening. At the mention of insurrection, Hartman’s ironic use of the voice of the outsider undermines the content of their words. Contributing to the undermining of the outsiders is the awareness that the narrative of the outsiders comes at the expense of surveillance that consumes Black intimate life. The subject of the intimate scene turns to “elude capture” (7) from the hungry gaze of the outsiders. Outsiders, sociologists like Hartman included, perpetuate the struggle of surveillance that undermines their rhetoric that intends to tear down the young Black girls. The style of the outsider’s voice serves to undermine their own argument, and inadvertently liberates the young Black girls from degrading

Show More
Related
511 Words | 3 Pages

In September of 1979, Audre Lorde, poet, spoke about the impossibility of dismantling the patriarchy through oppressive means. The black feminist woman, Lorde, who has cancer at the point of this speech, uses ethos, pathos, and logos in order to guilt the audience into making a change of how black feminists are represented. Ethos is the building of the author's credibility in order to become more persuasive because people tend to believe people who they deem likable or respectable. “I agreed to take part in a New York University Institute for the Humanities conference a year ago, with the understanding that I would be commenting upon papers dealing with the role of difference within the lives of American women: difference of race, sexuality, class, and age. The absence of these considerations weakens any feminist discussion of the personal and the political.”

Read More
583 Words | 3 Pages

Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes and Black Women in America, by Melissa Harris Perry is a collection of statistical data, narratives and African American literature to accurately portray the history of black women while also proving that politics is not only voting and public policy. It is also a struggle for recognition and how that recognition holds immense political power to create change. The book offers the unique experiences and explanations of African American women in the American society that consistently overlooks their hardships and achievements.. For three centuries, black women have been under the shadow of black men’s fight for equality. Black women have fought hard to achieved such a high feat, but have only ended up as less than second class citizens; citizens that are not easily recognized to receive fundamental rights. These misrecognitions stem from the Perry’s main argument that the four common stereotypes falsely define black women, and misrecognizes them so much that society doesn’t deem them fit or worthy enough to have equal rights.

Read More
1385 Words | 6 Pages

In the book, there are significant racial tensions and racial divisions in society. Young Black women like Lauren, the primary character, must find their way in a society where they face prejudice and marginalization. In the story, racism is shown as a persistent menace in a society where one's character or aptitudes are more often evaluated than the color of one's skin. Unfortunately, this is a problem that persists in modern culture. The work emphasizes the consequences of institutionalized racism, which persists today.

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

The speaker is uneducated, so the writing in the first person is readable for beginners as well as educated adults. Walker addresses the audience specifically to to create deeper imagery, where the audience can add their own experiences to the story, such as “You’ve no doubt seen those TV shows” (46). The speaker directly addresses the audience, and so anyone reading the story, whether a minority, or the majority, will be connected to the story. Purpose: Walker describes the impact of oppression on the relationship between mother and daughter, and how the oppressed view themselves.

Read More
453 Words | 2 Pages

Cassie has grown up knowing not everything is equal. When the African Americans to school they must walk, even if it is rain or shine. The whites get to ride the bus all the time, no matter what. When the bus catches the African American children walking down the street they speed up and splash them with mud. The got sick of the discrimination so they decided to do something about it. ”

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

Moreover, demonstrate consequences are taken to oppress racial and ethnic minorities to keep them in a subservient position. Overall, this film has provided me with a visual depiction of how stereotypes are a mental tool that enforces racial segregation and self-hate. The label of “White” became a necessity for Sarah Jane to achieve in society. To attain it she needed to move to a new city, change her name and deny her mother.

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

Although critics claim that Beyonce’s album portrays the black woman as the ‘victim,’ Lemonade instead empowers black women to freely express themselves and their ‘anger’ because there is no greater oppression than suffering in silence. Truly, Bell Hooks’ claim that “much of the album stays within a conventional stereotypical framework, where the black woman is always a victim,” is false and insensitive. As an artist, Beyonce crafts music that resonates with women, especially black women, who have suffered pain due to patriarchal ideals that infiltrate the household as well. The

Read More
174 Words | 1 Pages

In the film "For Colored Girls" by Ntozake Shange, introduces us to a theme of an almost stereotypical view of violence committed by black men on black women, and the problems women of color have faced and are facing in society today. While showing how economic oppression and race produces the men and women that go through these things. In this film we experience an emotionally interacted style of drama that targets the problems and struggles women of color face in America. More specially, we experience the lives of seven women who are only recognized by the color of their clothes ans face many obstacles in the society that beholds racism and sexism.

Read More
999 Words | 4 Pages

As a very young girl, her mother’s ex-boyfriend molested and raped her. Her rape took up a big part of her life, as it never really completely left her. Early on in her life, she branded herself as a bad person, but as she grew and matured, she realized she no longer identified as a bad person, but rather a strong, independent, intelligent woman who takes pride in her black

Read More
1194 Words | 5 Pages

The discrimination against the white race begins with a gradual distinct treatment of the African Americans who appear to have a trace of the white race. Helene proves to have a more formal dialect as she asks for “the bathroom” (23) and the black woman cannot understand until Helene finally refers to it as “the toilet” (23). The difference in word choice distinct Helene from the African Americans in the Bottom. The fact that Helene also has fairer skin than the African Americans gives the black woman a reason to believe Helene has a trace of white. Therefore, when Helene approaches the black woman on the train, “[the woman fastens her eyes]…on the thick velvet, the fair skin, [and] the high tone voice” (23), as if surprised and shocked to see an African American women appear in such a manner.

Read More
3280 Words | 14 Pages

Afro-American women writers present how racism permeates the innermost recesses of the mind and heart of the blacks and affects even the most intimate human relationships. While depicting the corrosive impact of racism from social as well as psychological perspectives, they highlight the human cost black people have to pay in terms of their personal relationships, particularly the one between mother and daughter. Women novelists’ treatment of motherhood brings out black mothers’ pressures and challenges for survival and also reveals their different strategies and mechanisms to deal with these challenges. Along with this, the challenges black mothers have to face in dealing with their adolescent daughters, who suffer due to racism and are heavily influenced by the dominant value system, are also underlined by these writers. They portray how a black mother teaches her daughter to negotiate the hostile, wider world, and prepares her to face the problems and challenges boldly and confidently.

Read More
3436 Words | 14 Pages

The movie clearly exposes the many ways that the human dignity of African- American maids was ignored. They had suffered daily embarrassment but were able to claim their own way dignity. The film described about empowerment of individuals as well as about social justice for a group. It is a moving story depicting dehumanization in a racist culture but also the ability to move beyond the unjust structures of society and to declare the value of every human being.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

Black women are treated less than because of their ascribed traits, their gender and race, and are often dehumanized and belittled throughout the movie. They are treated like slaves and are seen as easily disposable. There are several moments throughout the film that show the racial, gender, and class inequalities. These moments also show exploitation and opportunity hoarding. The Help also explains historical context of the inequality that occurred during that time period.

Read More
2515 Words | 11 Pages

In addition to that, the black community isolated Sethe because she did something that the community considered wrong. Black feminism will be the approach utilized here to see the oppression of woman of color because it includes sexism, classism and racism. Since the female characters are very dominant in the novel, a black feminist approach should be very effective and it enables one to see how the female characters deal with the past and live with it in the present, what motherhood mean to the female characters, and how much the past influences the female characters who lives in the present. The end of the novel reveals the forgiveness and the acceptance not only of the black community toward Sethe’s choice (killing her daughter) but also of the white people (the Bodwins) who accepted Denver to work for them. This reconciliation shows that the courage and the will to get rid off from the past to live side by side peacefully and to move toward the future together.

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

A constant comparison and contrast between Maggie and Dee is prominent structural feature of the narrative. This structural strategy helps in conceptualizing the plurality of female experience within the same milieu. This strategy encapsulates another dimension of womanism, viz. , womanism refuses to treat black woman as a homogeneous monolith. Unlike feminist position, womanism is sensitive to change with time.

Read More

More about Summary Of Haidya Hartman The Terrible Beauty Of The Slums

Related Topics

Open Document