ipl-logo

Summary Of Robert Whitaker's Mad In America

630 Words3 Pages

Robert Whitaker asks the question why do people with mental illness in the United States fare less well than people in poorer countries? His research argues that antipsychotic drugs worsen the very symptoms they are supposed to treat. In 2001 he ended his book Mad in America with a fatalistic summary. “There would be no rethinking of the care of people with schizophrenia (or other psychotic diagnoses) in the United States. The drug companies and academic psychiatry had entered into a storytelling partnership, and together they would promote the belief that antipsychotics are an essential treatment for psychotic disorders and should remain the cornerstone of care.” (303) However today he espouses a more hopeful outlook, saying “society no longer trusts what psychiatry says about mental disorders and its drugs”. (304) However, I don’t fully agree with that statement. I do believe that as a society we are becoming better versed in mental health, medications, the marriage between the FDA and the pharmaceutical industry, but I don’t believe we completely distrust the field of psychiatry. …show more content…

In Voices from the Inside, caregiving is centered on the American context, which is in sharp contrast to other cultures. “… students from different cultures sometimes comment that the ambivalence felt by many Americans about caregiving would not even arise in the consciousness of people in their respective countries. In societies where the most fundamental social unit is the group rather than the individual, people automatically and unquestionably subordinate their personal goals to family needs”.

Show More
Related

Dsm III Saved Psychiatry Summary

199 Words | 1 Pages

Chapter two Dr. Frances talks about DSM III and how that edition of DSM has impacted people across the country as well, as the impact Philippe Pinel had on psychiatry. Mr. Pinel was known as the “Father of Psychiatry”, he destroyed the demonization of the mentally ill. He treated his patients like they were human which helped him create a movement of moral treatment for the mentally ill. This chapter also goes into historical details about psychiatry. After World War II psychiatry blossomed.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Bipolar World

1045 Words | 5 Pages

His transition from hating to accepting his medicine directly corresponds with his goal to show people, who see manic depression as some kind of disease, to reflect on what they actually know about it to increase the understanding of what BPD actually is. It is not something that needs to be fixed, but rather something brilliant that needs further analysis and comprehension. He tries to get the audience to see that like himself, they too can change their mind on something they were so sure

Read More

Who Is Giles Corey A Hero In The Crucible

594 Words | 3 Pages

They have been charged with witchcraft. They shall be hung for not confessing to their wrongdoings. In the book the Crucible it's about tragedy it Arthur Miller wrote about how it was scary back in the 1690’s. People were charged with witchcraft for doing nothing really. Anyone could just accuse you of it and you could just be called guilty right there.

Read More

Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders Chapter 11 Analysis

263 Words | 2 Pages

Reading in chapter 11 about schizophrenia spectrum disorders, I chose to focus on sociocultural factors in treatment. I learned in this chapter and from previous chapters I have read that, you cannot treat everyone with schizophrenia the same. It is very difficult to treat, and find the right medication. Many people who are diagnosed with schizophrenia are homeless, because they cannot find jobs, get treatment, or have family support. This section of the chapter spoke about how different ethnicities of those diagnosed receive family support, and how it affects their treatment.

Read More

A Brief Note On The Hmong Culture

1568 Words | 7 Pages

psychotic diagnosis is more prevalent than in other countries who are unfamiliar with western medicine. “With Lia it was good to do a little medicine and a little neeb, but not too much medicine because the medicine cuts the beeb's effect. If we did a little of each she didn't get sick as much, but the doctors wouldn't let us give just a little medicine because they didn't understand about the soul.” - (Fou Yang, 95) One culture that has been noted to oppose western medicine is the Hmong culture. The Hmong culture does not have a word for mental health , poor mental health meant that you had an unhappy spirit.

Read More

Virginia Tech School Shooting Essay

738 Words | 3 Pages

James, who had “no befits or insurance or any idea where he might find a doctor” (51). Gary Busch, who was tragically shot after appearing “to be experiencing a psychiatric crisis” (52). This helps to put a name and a person to the “over one million people suffer(ing) from mental illness” (53) in New York City. This number was staggering to me, as well as the fact that “close to 8,000 mentally ill people” are in NY prisons or jails. It was sad to read as well “that, nationwide, state spending on treatment for the seriously mentally ill is one-third less than it was in the 1950s” (55).

Read More

Lobotomy In The 1930s

883 Words | 4 Pages

The way mental health has been treated throughout history is constantly changing. We can see this in many different ways, but to see how this has consistently evolved, we need to look at and understand several different sources. Mental disability treatment is shown in historical contexts, through Steinbeck’s novel, and in statistics today. In the 1930s, mental illness was treated extremely harshly and a lot differently than it is handled today. During that time period, being emotionally unstable was at an all time high.

Read More

Who Is Thomas Szasz Anti Psychiatry

1687 Words | 7 Pages

Psychosurgery was also discontinued during this time. By criticizing the medicalization of normal behaviors, the power of the pharmaceutical business, and oppressive tactics in psychiatry, the antipsychiatry movement continues to have a significant impact. Supporters today argue against simply scientific methods and in favor of more patient-centered and holistic approaches that prioritize social and psychological variables. This trend has influenced traditional psychiatry to accept more integrated treatment approaches and

Read More

Analyse The Effects Of Dementia On An Individual Essay

1505 Words | 7 Pages

This is more than just the financial resources that they have, but also their psychological and physical health and their spiritual outlook on life and the situation. One important factor is the caregiver's location and place of residence in relation to that of the person to be cared for. It must also be remembered that the carer has a life outside of this role and, therefore, important factors in caring include other day-to-day roles such as being an employee, a parent and a professional person. The carer is also affected by the opinions and demands of people outside the caregiving relationship. Caregivers are also facing a health care system that seems to be placing more responsibilities on caregivers while providing less and less

Read More

How Did Josephine Zderad Initiated The Humanistic Nursing Practice Theory

131 Words | 1 Pages

This week I learn that Josephine G. Paterson and Loretta Zderad initiated the humanistic nursing practice theory in 1960 while they were teaching a graduate class together They recounted humanistic nursing practice theory as caregivers intentionally and purposely approach nursing as an existential experience, consider the experience and phenomenological recount the calls they get, their reactions and “what they come to know from” their existence in the nursing circumstance. According to Paterson and Zderad (1976/1988/2007), as caregivers turn out to be attentive of their particular reactions and the potential outcomes called forward by others, moreness happens, and the decisions can be made as to whether to relate and how to identify with other.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Schizophrenia

1517 Words | 7 Pages

Schizophrenia is one of the most recognizable mental illnesses that the world knows, this comes with benefits as it does with consequences. The benefit being that many people have heard of the term, but a minute group truly know about it. This has led to a society where it is commonplace to ostracize those with the illness, which subsequently leads to negative effects on those diagnosed. It is as if society still has not developed a sufficient system in which Schizophrenia fits in. People with heart disease, cancer, and Alzheimer’s, all receive sympathy and yet people will Schizophrenia seldom receive the same.

Read More

Mentally Ill Policy Essay

628 Words | 3 Pages

Originally, in the late 1800’s, the U.S. government passed a policy (State Care Acts), which made the states responsible for providing care to people with severe mental disorders (Goldman & Grob, 2006). This led to the building of asylums, and thus the cliché picture of institutionalization that we know today became a countrywide phenomenon and cruelty. In 1965, Medicare and Medicaid legislations were enacted, and these policies greatly changed the way mental health care was delivered (Frank & Glied, 2006). It was during this time that state institutionalization lost popularity and private or community mental health centers took precedence.

Read More

Direct Quotes For Research Papers

290 Words | 2 Pages

Professor Denson and fellow classmates, I do not actually have any direct quotes in my research paper to pull from for this discuss, however for this sandwich I will create some. I have never used direct quotes due to the rules and regulations around them, to me, it is easier to write my story and paraphrase as needed. This is just my way of handing, and writing, and I as we all know have no issues talking so writing is just that on paper. With that said, here goes let’s make some sandwiches (: I. Dr. Fredric Neuman (2013) in his article in Psychology Today, A Cure For Panic Disorder and Agoraphobia, states that doctors do not want to talk about cures when it comes to mental illness, when he states: “Too many illness are remitting and relapsing-that

Read More

Misdiagnosis In Mental Illnesses

950 Words | 4 Pages

John Goodman, in his article, “How Government Regulations Is Undermining Mental Health Care”, discusses how the business of medical care is twisted and how the government, in imposing regulations on mental health care, is creating a situation where the medical care providers lose interest in actually addressing the needs of the mentally ill. Goodman mentions a previous publishing of his which touches on the issue in medical care of how health plans are manufactured to draw in the healthy and turn away the ill; the ones who are actually suffering and actually need medical treatment. He provides statistics from medical journals that detail the twenty million Americans suffering with substance abuse and the forty two point five million adults living with a mental illness who are all not getting the proper care they require. Another point Goodman makes is that while treatment options are provided in brochures and such, many people seeking legitimate treatment will find that those options are inaccessible to them for a variety of reasons with the main source of those reasons being the government regulations placed on medical care. Government regulations on medicines and other medical care can be beneficial in some situations, but in others, it can prove disadvantageous to

Read More

Schizophrenia Informative Speech

645 Words | 3 Pages

In 1796 individuals with mental illness were in unheated, damp cells in ithe basements of hospitals where they slept on straw and kept in chains (Whitaker,). Out of sight out of mind has been America’s stance on those with schizophrenia or other mental abnormalities. Often viewed as animals by the early doctors and society they were often beat and starved. “A near-starvation diet was another recommendation for robbing the madman of his strength. The various remedies-bleeding, purging, emetics and nausea-inducing agents-were also said to be therapuetic…because of they induced pain” (Whitaker, p. 26).

Read More

More about Summary Of Robert Whitaker's Mad In America

Related Topics

Open Document