ipl-logo

Summary Of The Andrew Bedner Case

1028 Words5 Pages

The Andrew Bedner Case There are many cases of child abuse around the world. But in the case of Andrew Bedner there are many ethical issues and in the end the case is not resolved in a proper amount of time. Bedner abused his baby and tried to take advantage of the fact that he was the surrogate. The baby died before the court could decide on appointing a new surrogate. A new surrogate should have been appointed immediately. Especially since Bedner’s motives were selfish and morally wrong. Josh O’Gorman explains in the Rutland Herald that Andrew Bedner denied charges of inflicting life-threatening injuries on his 8-week-old daughter. Bedner pleaded innocent in the White River Junction District Court to two counts of first-degree aggravated …show more content…

also state “The best interests principle requires that the surrogate act in the best interests of the patient, disregarding the interests of others, including the interests of the family, society, and those of the surrogate. The best interests principle thus demands that the good of the patient and nothing else be considered” (2013, p.74). The best interest of the baby is not what Bedner keeps in mind when making any medical decisions concerning the baby’s health. His focus is on the interests of himself and not getting charged for murder. There is a conflict of interest in this case, because Bedner wanted to keep the baby on life support in order to avoid murder charges. “An actual conflict of interest exists when a health care provider subordinates the interest, including the financial interest, of the patient to the interests of the provider or a third party” (Baillie et,al. 2013, p77). “First, the health care provider has no obligation to prolong dying merely for the sake of prolonging it. That is, it makes no sense to prolong life when the true result is the prolongation of the dying process. Furthermore, when treatment is only prolonging the agony of the patient, its continuation is unethical as an insult to human dignity” (Baillie et,al. 2013, p.175). It is unethical for the baby’s life to be prolonged. The baby has to endure pain because Bedner refused to take her off of life

Show More
Related

State Of New York V. Jorgensen Case Brief

1680 Words | 7 Pages

Judge Fahey starts with the Homicide statue. Judge Fahey looks at Penal Law 125.00 which defines homicide in a more relevant way as “death of a person or an unborn child with which a female has been pregnant for more than [24] weeks under circumstances constituting murder, manslaughter in the first degree, manslaughter in the second degree, criminally negligent homicide, abortion in the first degree or self-abortion in the first degree.” This statue clearly applies to the case because it focuses on unborn and born children. Judge Fahey, furthermore, deals with the issue of reckless conduct in the case. The baby was not a person yet when the crime occurred in the Judge’s eyes.

Read More

Tomcik Case Study

785 Words | 4 Pages

The caregivers lacked commitment, compassion, conscientiousness, fairness and honesty, and if they had taken their jobs seriously probably Tomcik wouldn’t have suffered as much. Trial began on July 22, 1991 and the decision was made on October 7, 1991. Tomcik’s total damage came out to be $85,000 according to the text. The defendants were proven wrong and they were charged. The court did the right thing, but I think a stricter action should have been taken against the defendants.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Summary

1953 Words | 8 Pages

One of the main objections to autonomy-based justifications of physician-assisted suicide (PAS) that Gill talks about is that many people believe it does not promote autonomy, but instead is actually taking it away (366). First, it is important to clarify what autonomy means. According to Gill, it is the ability of a person to make big decisions regarding their own life (369). Opponents of PAS argue that it takes away a person’s ability to make these big decisions and so it is intrinsically wrong for them to choose to take their own life.

Read More

Karen Ann Quinlan Argumentative Essay

192 Words | 1 Pages

Even in a persistent vegetative state a person still has fundamental rights under the state and federal constitution to refuse or direct the withdrawal of death prolonging procedures. The hospital fear of removing the feeding tube is justified under most state laws. Only in a few states it has been legalized for physician-assisted suicide. That is they allow doctors to assists patients to end their lives if the patient are to ill to do it by themself. In other states, doctors who assist their dying patient end their life of excoriating pain and suffering could be charged with murder.

Read More

Analysis Of Sallie Tisdale's We Do Abortions Here

490 Words | 2 Pages

However, if she shows kindness to the unborn child by not letting the woman abort the child, she would be showing crudity to them by ruining their lives. The audience discovers that no matter the choice, whether they did or didn’t abort the child, there will always be

Read More

Summary Of Wombs For A Price By Ellen Goodman

1016 Words | 5 Pages

Summary In the article "Womb for Rent-For a Price", the writer Ellen Goodman's main point discusses labor out-sourced "beyond our reach"; surrogate parenthood. Goodman started her article by clarifying what and how global child generation developed.  Goodman argues that an industry has risen as the outcome of an increment in the quantity of ladies attempting to pick up international surrogates. The leading place she discusses is India, where the woman is paid up to $7000 to carry a baby to another wealthy couples who can't.

Read More

Baby M Surrogacy

946 Words | 4 Pages

Case Response 2 Many women desperately desire a child, but sadly some are unable to conceive their own child. However, there are many surrogacy companies that enable women to “purchase” a child. There are affordable companies over in India that is becoming more and more popular. Certain people view commercial surrogacy as unethical.

Read More

Interprofessional Collaboration Case Study

586 Words | 3 Pages

An experience I had involving ethics in relation to an interprofessional collaboration was in my present nursing case. Prior to me starting my patient a 13-year-old girl had a severe asthma attack and went into cardiac arrest, died and was brought back to life this past February. Although the EMTs were able to bring her back, she has been in a coma ever since. What makes this case an ethical dilemma is that several months ago the doctors wanted to diagnose her as brain dead and remove her from life support. Through the use of medical terminology, lack of understanding about her daughter’s condition and unempathetic doctors they managed to convince the mother that her child had no hope of survival.

Read More

Surrogacy And Altruistic Agreements

321 Words | 2 Pages

Many long to have children and for one reason or another, are unable to conceive. However the solution is in the process of surrogacy. Those eager to start a family are opting into altruistic or even commercial agreements with a surrogate woman. The Legislation Act, intricate legal processes and issues of surrogacy will be elucidated upon in this essay including future recommendations to the law.

Read More

Essay On Commercial Surrogacy

2052 Words | 9 Pages

COMMERCIAL SURROGACY- NEED FOR LAWS IN INDIA INTRODUCTION ON SURROGACY The word surrogate is derived from its Latin root word ‘surrogatus’ meaning substitute, that is, a person is appointed in place of another. Colloquially, the term surrogate mother means a woman who carries a baby on behalf of another woman According to the Black’s Law Dictionary, surrogacy means the process of carrying and delivering a child for another person.

Read More

Effects Of Surrogacy

1007 Words | 5 Pages

Many adults yearn to add to their lives by having or adopting children. When people are unable to adopt or to bear children, perhaps because of illness, infertility, or disability, they might enter into a business relationship called commercial surrogacy. This term describes the practice of paying an unrelated woman, also called a surrogate mother, a sum of money for carrying the child. The would-be parents also pay the birth mother 's medical costs. Commercial surrogacy is seen by some families as the answer to their dreams.

Read More

Summary Of Womb For Rent By Ellen Goodman

511 Words | 3 Pages

Ellen Goodman is an award-winning, American journalist with the freedom of speech well within her rights. Notwithstanding, Goodman’s opinion piece “Womb for Rent” puts a light-hearted perspective on a heavy controversy: surrogacy. Throughout “Womb for Rent,” Goodman uses risky techniques to convey her point of view of the economic marketplace involving surrogacy, which causes confusion to the reader. “Womb for Rent” by Ellen Goodman uses puns and plays on words. This type of literary device intends to create a humorous effect, but surrogacy is not commonly a ‘humorous’ topic.

Read More

Arguments Against Surrogacy

1271 Words | 6 Pages

According to Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases: Surrogacy1: Surrogacy an armament in which a woman (“the carrying mother”) agrees to bear a child and to hand over the child on birth to another person or persons (“the commission parents”) the carrying may have been artificially inseminated with the sperm of the commission father or donates gemmates from the commissionating partners may be used to create an embryo that is a carried to term by her. In the later case, the carrying mother will be genetically unrelated to the child. Commercial Surrogacy2: Commercial Surrogacy is a form of surrogacy in which a gestational carrier is paid to carry a child to maturity in her womb and is usually resorted to by higher income infertile couples who can afford the cost involved or people who save or borrow in order to complete

Read More

Essay On Abortion Pro Life

1265 Words | 6 Pages

That seems to be the best option in any other case, because you should allow the child a right to life. I really do not see this debate ever getting anywhere because there is so much support from both sides of the debate. I don’t think that we will ever come to a conclusion that is able to satisfy both sides of the

Read More

Gestational Surrogacy Introduction

1786 Words | 8 Pages

Introduction Procreation of children is one of the main objects of marriage. It is a natural desire of every human, being to leave behind his descendants for the continuity of lineage. Matrimonial happiness depends not only on satisfying biological need of sexual urge but also on begetting o f a child. Attainment of Parenthood gives social recognition of the parties to the marriage. A situation of childlessness arises if the married couple is unable to procreate children due to infertility.

Read More

More about Summary Of The Andrew Bedner Case

Related Topics

Open Document