ipl-logo

Supreme Court Case Of David Sullivan And Thomas Chan

977 Words4 Pages

The complex interaction of mental health, substance abuse, and criminal law is apparent in the cases of David Sullivan and Thomas Chan. Both cases raise significant questions about criminal responsibility and defendants' rights within the Canadian legal system. When under the influence of drugs, both men engaged in violent behaviours—Sullivan assaulted his mother, while Chan took the life of his father. Subsequently, both were charged with criminal offences: Sullivan with aggravated assault and Chan with an additional charge of manslaughter, on top of facing the charge of aggravated assault. Both individuals claimed that their actions were a result of drug-induced psychosis. This particular case has brought into question the constitutionality …show more content…

The Court's decision resulted in the dismissal of the Crown's appeals and the acquittal of Sullivan, while also ordering a new trial for Chan. This ruling centred on the declaration of section 33.1 of the Criminal Code as unconstitutional, with a specific focus on its infringement on sections 7 and 11 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Court's decision strongly emphasized the importance of voluntary action and mens rea in criminal responsibility. By striking down section 33.1, the Court reasserted the principle that individuals should not be held criminally liable for involuntary actions committed in a state of automatism. This ruling serves to strengthen and uphold the principle that criminal liability should only be imposed when there is clear evidence of intent and voluntary action. Furthermore, the decision underscores the crucial need for a legal process that prioritizes rehabilitation and treatment for individuals struggling with substance abuse and mental health issues, rather than relying solely on punitive measures. In essence, this ruling promotes a fairer justice system that respects constitutional rights and ensures that the imposition of criminal liability aligns with the presence of intent and voluntary

Show More
Related

Mr. Anthony V. Wright Case Of 1991

203 Words | 1 Pages

Mr. Anthony Wright was charged with first-Degree Rape, burglary, robbery and possession of an instrument of crime in 1991. The evidence against Mr. Wright is the clothing that Mr. Wright allegedly used to commit the crime, his voluntary, and complete signed confession after 14 minutes in custody and they had five witnesses to testified against Wright. There were so many flaws in this case, the clothes at the scene did not belong to Mr. Wright and the officers used two known crack dealers and three teenagers as witnesses against Wright. No one bothered to interview any witnesses to rule out Mr. Wright. He was nowhere near the victim’s home

Read More

How Has Vince Li's Forever Fundamentally Changed Mental Health Discussions In Canada?

2128 Words | 9 Pages

The case, regarding Vince Li, forever fundamentally changed mental health discussions in Canada. Vince Li, a mentally ill person experienced a psychotic episode. Li brutally murdered an innocent man and was deemed NCR. Recently, Li has been placed under consideration for more freedoms. This paper will discuss how the media responded, if Li should be released, and why Li differs from a normal criminal.

Read More

Nebraska Press Association V. Stuart Case Study

690 Words | 3 Pages

The Supreme of the United States is the body entrusted with interpreting the Constitution in relation to cases whose outcomes will establish precedents with weighty, far reaching legal implications. In many such cases, the conflicting parties may both claim that their actions or (in the case of public officials) rulings, are protected by one or more amendments to the constitution. In reconciling these conflicts, justices must reckon with the intent of laws written centuries ago in relation to contemporary issues. They must also make decisions where the scope of one legally protected right comes into conflict with another. The 1976 case, Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart, provides an example of this nuanced, subtle process and highlights the way in which Supreme Court decisions have potentially monumental, everlasting consqequences.

Read More

Supreme Court Case: The New York Times V. Sullivan

75 Words | 1 Pages

New York Times v. Sullivan (1964) is a significant United States Supreme Court case which held that the court must find proof of actual malice before it can hold the press guilty for defamation as well as libel against any public figure. This was a landmark Supreme Court decision regarding freedom of the press. Mr. Justice Brennan delivered the decision of the Court. In 1960, The New York Times ran a full-page advertisement paid by

Read More

Supreme Court Case: Earl Versus The Board Of Education

740 Words | 3 Pages

The US District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma upheld that the policy was in fact constitutional based on the existence of a “special need, indicated by accounts of drug abuse since 1970.” The verdict would be reversed in the appellate court. However, the Supreme Court reversed the decision of the Court of Appeals reaffirming that like in the district court, the policy was in fact, constitutional.

Read More

Elastic Clause

933 Words | 4 Pages

Both of these cases go to show that judicial interpretation allows some flexibility into the constitution. It allows things that are not expressly stated in the constitution to be made

Read More

Gregory Lee Johnson's Impact On The US

1550 Words | 7 Pages

The constitutional issue in this case was the 1st amendment. Gregory Lee Johnson was tried for burning an American flag but the Supreme court decided he wasn’t guilty. They said that it was

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Sobriety Court

305 Words | 2 Pages

My rhetorical situation for this argument is to bring to light the corruption of the Michigan Judicial system, focused more on Sobriety Court. My audience is directed towards students and instructors at NMC. My stance is that the Sobriety Court system needs to be more supportive to their partakers. My context is derived from a personal experience with my topic.

Read More

New York Times V Sullivan Summary

514 Words | 3 Pages

As New York Times v. Sullivan began in 1960 and continued through 1964, the South overflowed with racial tensions. Just one month before the Times published “Heed Their Rising Voices” in 1960, a student-sit-in at a Woolworth lunch counter sparked the sit-in movement that spread throughout the Deep South. Not long after that, the Freedom Riders boarded buses across the Southern States in ‘62 and faced violence from the Ku Klux Klan, which only provoked more protests. This situation attracted the attention of both the media and the Court. The “Heed Their Rising Voices” ad boldly summarized: “Again and again the Southern violators have answered Dr. King’s peaceful protests with intimida-tion and violence.”

Read More

Mapp Vs Ohio Case Study

1872 Words | 8 Pages

This ruling is controversial because many say that this will let guilty people go free on police carelessness, while others say that the constitution is not a technicality and allows for the equal prosecution of all

Read More

Summary Of Incognito By David Eagleman

952 Words | 4 Pages

The case of Kenneth Parks is explained, since he was a man who murdered his mother-in-law and attempted to murder his father-in-law all while he was sleepwalking. Eagleman begs the question of whether it was Parks fault, and if it was not, then is if all criminals are not faulted for committing a crime when they have a mental disorder. He asks how far the scale can go to forgive a person of their crimes, a main theme of his writing. The topic is interesting, since gunman that fire away at others because of a tumor in their amygdala, for example, may only have done what they did in the heat of the moment. Though the question remains as to why that person did not see a doctor so that the issue could have been corrected, so it could have also been their fault.

Read More

Injustice In Brave New World

1203 Words | 5 Pages

This injustice damages the rehabilitative intent that prisons were meant

Read More

How To Interpret Supreme Court Decisions

556 Words | 3 Pages

If we fail to question the validity of these decisions then we are empowering the Court to usurp powers not guaranteed by the Constitution itself. Brennan maintained, “judicial power resides in the authority to give meaning to the Constitution, the debate is really a debate about how to read the text, about constraints on what is legitimate interpretation.” For Lincoln it was the duty of all citizens to interpret the Constitution that right should not be reserved for the select few members of the Supreme Court.

Read More

Schizophrenia And Suicide Thesis

1378 Words | 6 Pages

The extents of persons with schizophrenia who obtain feelings for vicious wrongdoings additionally shifts by time period, reflecting contrasts in arrangements in regards to preoccupation of rationally sick persons blamed for criminal acts from the equity framework to the wellbeing framework (for further discourse, see Hodgins & Janson 2002). Most savage offenses submitted by persons with schizophrenia are strikes. While manslaughters pull in much consideration from the media, they are uncommon. In a few nations, all persons blamed for crime experience careful psychiatric assessments preceding trial. These assessments have been utilized to gauge the extent of crimes that are perpetrated by people with schizophrenia and evaluations fluctuate from 6 to 28% , demonstrating considerable variety starting with one nation then onto the next and inside nations by time period (Erb et al. 2001).

Read More

Drug Addiction Punishment

2078 Words | 9 Pages

This leads to the question of whether the justice system is doing an adequate job of dealing with drug addiction. Instead of incarcerating people for drug abuse, an alternative is treating victims by rehab and treatment. This paper will exam why treatment is the superior option for

Read More

More about Supreme Court Case Of David Sullivan And Thomas Chan

Open Document