ipl-logo

Sweatshirts From Sweatshops: Intellectual Standards And Logical Fallacies

647 Words3 Pages

Sweatshirts from Sweatshops: Intellectual Standards and Logical Fallacies

The essay “Sweatshirts from Sweatshops” was a persuasive piece that covered the issues of companies overseas that thrive through the exploitations of its workers. The reading selection depicted the behind the scenes activities that actually occurs with the mistreated workers and also the morality of such treatments. Throughout the essay, the reader can assume the writer’s overall objective was to discourage their audience from wearing such attire until their school decides to switch their apparel supplier. The writer also violated a few universal intellectual standards as well as a few logical fallacies.
Universal intellectual Standards
One universal intellectual standard that was violated in the text was relevance. The first three sentences in the second paragraph covered details about the company “Transterra Textile” and its size of business as far as expansion. This was not relevant to the writer’s accusation and is not considered …show more content…

Another universal intellectual standard that was violated was logic. In the second paragraph, the writer stated “In a recent tour of Transterra’s Honduran Factory, WorldWeave observers noticed some children who appeared to be as young as eleven or twelve working with dangerous fabric-cutting machines-in spite of local laws that prohibit anyone under the age of fourteen from doing factory work.” No one can determines a person’s age just by simply looking at an individual and if there are laws prohibiting such employment the companies must abide to them in order to stay in business or suffer the consequences. The workers should have

Show More
Related
1266 Words | 6 Pages

Cumulatively, these horrific incidents --- which could have been prevented with legally-required health and safety measures – resulted in the deaths of 1,500 garment workers in less than a year. We are currently seeing more media, government, and public attention on the garment industry since sweatshop issues hit the front pages in the 1990s. These catastrophes are the latest evidence of two decades of failures of global corporations’ Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) programs in protecting

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

Part Three of Pietra Rivolli’s book, titled “Trouble at the Border”, focuses on the hurdles the T-shirt faces during its return to America during a time when concerns about the adverse effects of free trade are rising. She points out that the American public remains uneasy about trade not because the people are unaware of its benefits but because they tend to view matters with a local rather than a global perspective. Subsequently, she refers to the textile and apparel industry as the most protected manufacturing industry in the US, often shielded by complicated rules made by politically driven policymakers.

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

Up until the early 20th century, American labor laws did not protect employees and work environments were not monitored for unsafe conditions. Factories were allowed to run without proper fire exits, ventilation, pay, breaks and even children were forced into labor. These unsafe conditions came crashing down just before the end of the workday on March 25th, 1911 in the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in New York City. In just under 30 minutes, 146 lives perished (Benin). Today, we call these factories “sweatshops” and they are primarily found in countries that lack laws enforcing proper working conditions.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction The fire that erupted at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in New York City is remembered as one of the worst disasters since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. The infamous incident claimed 146 lives of young immigrant workers due to negligent safety precautions. To this day this incident has continued to have great significance because it highlights the inhumane working conditions that industrial workers have to be subjected to. Sweatshops before 1911

Read More
433 Words | 2 Pages

Through “Sweatshop Oppression,” an essay written by Rajeev Ravisankar, the reader gains insight on the truthful and factual reality of oppressive workplace conditions. Ravisankar seeks to appeal to the morals and values of the audience by having relatable content and using the emotion and logic based rhetorical devices “pathos” and “logos.” In the opening paragraph the author connects with the audience by inclusively saying: “being the “poor” college students that we all are, many of us undoubtedly place an emphasis on finding the lowest prices” (). Through revealing he is a student with mutual financial struggles, the audience quickly picks up on his relatable and likeable voice.

Read More
870 Words | 4 Pages

The struggles over child labor and minimum wage had become the ideas that large corporations should be responsible for workplace practices advanced from radical notion to mainstream business practice. In 2008, the United States and other European country had included labor protections in all of their future trade agreements. In the book, the author stated that in the summer of 2008, United States and most of the European apparel firms announced that Uzbeki cotton will no longer be used in their apparel because of the concerns over child labor in the cotton farms. In conclusion, many textile and apparel manufacturing had established the code of conduct all thank the activists, consumers, and other religious

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

Labor Practice Paper Angelia Henry PHL/320 May 2, 2016 Bridget Peaco Labor Practice Paper Merriam-Webster online defines a sweatshop as a shop or factory where employees work long at a low wage that is under poor and unhealthy conditions (Merriam-Webster On-line Dictionary, 2016). Sweatshops are factories that violate two or more labor laws to include wages, benefits, child labor or even working hours (Ember, 2014-2015). Companies will attempt to use sweatshop labor to lessen the cost to meet the demands of customers. When we think of sweatshop, we always want to look at third world countries and never in our own backyard. In 2012, the company Forever 21 was sued by the US Department of Labor for ignoring a subpoena requesting the information on how much it pays its workers just to make clothes (Lo,

Read More
424 Words | 2 Pages

So WorldWeave report did not make investigation the age of those workers. Nothing was done to verify their ages. WorldWeave should go back to and investigate those workers before making a judgment. Also, this “details report by American garment workers’ unions.” The statistics of how many workers for the company’s total workers is not approved through a non-bias party, and works cited to go and read the details about this report.

Read More
1264 Words | 6 Pages

The idea of sweatshops is a widely contentious one, the morality of its conditions being such a debated topic that the kindling of the argument’s intensity can be traced all the way back to the 19th century. Writer Brittany Hunter shares her own perspective in, "Banning Sweatshops Only Hurts the Poor," pointing out how essential sweatshops are as they support their countries' economies in a way that hard labor jobs simply cannot. Backed up by a plethora of factual evidence, she implements her ideas to influence rethinking within opposers of the factory. her own audience’s ethical views and embedding knowledge on the matter to ensure credibility from a strong, indisputable position. Influenced by controversy surrounding Beyonce and her clothing

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

We may be buying a cheap item, but we must learn to ignore the $5 t-shirt sale and see the true unethical treatment of millions of children behind the making of that shirt. Alternative brands that support their workers to ensure safe conditions should instead be supported to create widespread change in how companies run their businesses. It is important to avoid large brands that manufacture their items inexpensively, at the expense of

Read More
1139 Words | 5 Pages

It is irrefutable that sweatshops effectively improve economic conditions and provide some opportunity to workers where work may be challenging to find. So, does this make sweatshops acceptable? Although sweatshops are economically beneficial, it would be negligent to ignore what the benefits entail. The same sweatshops employing millions of workers continue to disregard safety and well-being. With conflicting positions towards sweatshops, it is critical to bring change and to identify obligation in the effort to do

Read More
1825 Words | 8 Pages

Abstract The global garment industry, worth more than $400 billion dollars today, is a very lucrative industry. Garment factories in developing countries working for retailers in developed ones shows how efficiency is increased and every party can benefit through outsourcing of labour from developed countries; retailers and consumers get clothes at cheaper prices while employment is provided to areas plagued with poverty. However, it is evident that many of these garment factories are sweatshops, which are factories and businesses that violates local or international labour laws, such as providing workers with atrocious working conditions, providing minimal compensation or even employing child labour. Like it or not, many of our clothes does not come ethically and they have probably encouraged labour exploitation in one way or another.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

As well as factory fires killing hundreds of workers due to locked doors. An example from The Corporation, investigators found children from a developing country made pants for a Wal-Mart children’s charity in the west. Workers do not have much of a choice as factories can replace them with many others willing to work regardless of conditions. The industrialization of the fashion industry exploits cheap labour and these sweatshops often violate two or more Universal Declaration of Human Rights. For example, the right to life and living in freedom and safety (3), no slavery (4), no torture, cruel, or degrading treatment or punishment (5), and the right to rest and leisure, including reasonable limitation on working hours.

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

And, unfortunately, it’s more prevalent in America than many may believe. When defining what exactly a sweatshop is and what it consists of, there are many forms that it has taken over the many decades of America’s existence. The basic definition of a sweatshop is a factory in which its employees, many being children, are exploited; working long hours in extreme cases of hazardous and unhealthful conditions for little pay. Despite the fact this is a

Read More
1816 Words | 8 Pages

Ethical Fashion Foundations, Origin and Practices Joergens (2006) refers Ethical fashion as fashion clothing that is produced under fair trade principles in sweatshop-free labour conditions, with efforts made to reduce the environmental harmfulness of the process. It is also often described as “fashion with a conscious” as it concerns labour conditions and the environment. Ethics within the fashion industry developed in the late 1800s and early 1900s, where sweatshops became a global concern. A ‘sweater’ was a person working in extremely harsh labour conditions within a manufacturing factory that’s now established as sweatshop factories (Barraud de Lagerie, 2012). Ethics within fashion grew when those deemed morally wrong as workers were forced to perform in such minimalist factories.

Read More

More about Sweatshirts From Sweatshops: Intellectual Standards And Logical Fallacies

Related Topics

Open Document