ipl-logo

Teleological Argument Analysis

850 Words4 Pages

In order to gain a full understanding of the teleological argument, it is also important to examine the viewpoints of those who question the validity of the teleological argument. Critics discount the argument in a number of ways. They say the premise that “the universe has a design” is groundless because there is also apparent disorder and absence of design that cannot be disregarded. Critics argue that the belief that there can be no design without a grand designer is also not true. For example, “Ink drops folded in a paper sometimes appear strikingly symmetrical. If some patterns are produced unpurposively, then it is at least possible that such patterns as the world as a whole may have been produced unpurposively” (A. Bahm, 1944, …show more content…

Similarly, what if the designer created the universe by accident, or designed the universe as a result of some mechanical necessity instead of as a result of purpose? Others argue that the universe could have been designed for a purpose long ago, but it no longer has the purpose it once had as its purpose may have been either lost or fulfilled. Charles Darwin argued that just because we reveal order in something, it doesn’t necessarily mean that it is the product of some purposive action. Darwin goes on to say that as difficult as it may be to acknowledge, the complexity of connections between things can all be explained by nature without having to appeal to the supernatural. “Undeniably, the power of the design argument as an inference to the best explanation has been seriously weakened since Darwin and Alfred Wallace independently came up with natural selection as a naturalistic explanation for design” (H. De Cruz, J. De Smedt, 2010, p. 679). There is no doubt that Darwin’s work on biological evolution suggesting that humans evolved through a process of natural selection is now seen by many as one of the most powerful substantiations of world …show more content…

Kant also believed that human reason is unable to arrive at specific conclusions regarding the noumenal world as human scientific knowledge cannot extend beyond the phenomenal world. Based on Kant’s “transcendental idealism”, human reasoning, from effects to causes, has no legitimacy beyond the phenomenal world. Kant does, however, conclude that the design argument plays an important investigational role within science. “Unlike many philosophers of science since Darwin, Kant believed that it is a legitimate and important function of science to investigate the overall design of nature. He implicitly rejects the conception of science that limits it to the study of impersonal, unguided, and purposeless forces” (R. Koons, n.d.). Kant does not see the design argument as an adversary or as hindering scientific progress, he sees the argument as a beginning and a guide to the scientific

Show More
Related
784 Words | 4 Pages

The conclusion, thus, is that Nature was created by intelligent design. This argument is the centerpiece of Paley’s “Argument from Design”, as he spends the previous two sections deliberately lining the specifics of a watch, the clear order a watch follows, and that there must be a creator for a watch. In this section, he puts forward an analogy that nature is like a watch in that both have specific orders and contrivances which thus mean that both were created by an intelligent

Read More
388 Words | 2 Pages

Paley simply responds to this by saying that something doesn’t have to perfect to show that there was a designer. Another problem with this argument is that things in a watch (or a universe) contain different parts that look like they have no function, so these parts are somewhat proof that he universe wasn’t designed. Paley replies to this by saying that just because we do not know the function of something it doesn’t mean that it has no function, Paley looks at different parts of the watch (or universe) and from this he decides that it must have been

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Hambourger’s argument from design argues for the existence of god based on the perceived evidence of deliberate design in the world/universe. To further elaborate on the concepts he uses, Hambourger uses three main concepts; determinism, chance, and mere hap. Hambourger’s argument from design claims that though many things occur by chance, there are some things which we cannot simply accept to have happened by chance, and must therefore have some common explanation in the causal chain of events connecting the two events. For instance the universe is created by many states of affairs coming together. If some slight changes had occurred, the end result could have been vastly different than it currently is.

Read More
1087 Words | 5 Pages

At the start of the 19th century, the Church of England was the governing authority. Therefore, the predominant beliefs and principles that the Church held, were also the main viewpoint of the people. Any individuals who opposed the religious norms, were criticized and given a title of an infidel. William Paley’s argument in his book Natural Theology, was naturally favored at that time because he argued, that there must be a “designer,” which is to be held accountable for the design, the creation of such complex and precise design of organisms can only mean that designer is God. The focus from religion to science shifted as more scientific advances, such as Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution challenged religious orthodoxy by undermining William Paley’s design argument.

Read More
123 Words | 1 Pages

During the mid 1800s, the pro-slavery argument was at its strongest. The Proslavery Argument by Boundless, an online textbook, discusses the famous Mudsill Speech of James Henry Hammond which stated that the pro-slavery political argument, an ideology that defended a class-sensitive view of American antebellum society. He believed that many past societies carried the burden of the existence of a class of landless poor. Continually, other southern pro-slavery theorists felt that this class of landless poor was “inherently transient and easily manipulated, and as such often destabilized society as a whole” (Boundless). Thus, the greatest threat to democracy was seen as coming from “class warfare that destabilized a nation's economy, society and

Read More
218 Words | 1 Pages

The Teleological argument is also a cosmological argument it also begins with the existence of the cosmos. McCloskey rejects this argument along with the argument of design by rejecting the premise. However, “Tennant and Swinburne developed a version of this argument not as strict deductive proof but to show probability of theism” (Evans & Manis) The theory of evolution was offered as an explanation for the creation of design which was rejected because there many things before the theory of evolution. McCloskey believe there must be indisputable proof of actual evidence to prove evolution.

Read More
194 Words | 1 Pages

For example, none of the beings that existed originally on our planet still exist, they changed and adapted. What is interesting is who is considered the designer of said machine. Perhaps the universe is the designer and all things that exist are the intelligent design. I believe the one major flaw in the universe

Read More
1777 Words | 8 Pages

The book “Darwin’s Doubt” by Stephen C Meyer attempts to negate the negativity surrounding the theory of intelligent design by giving a creationist’s perspective on the different issues surrounding the controversy and provide an argument for the legitimacy of intelligent design from a scientific and rational viewpoint. The book is broken into three different sections part one titled “The Mystery of Missing Fossils”, part two titled “How to build an animal” and part 3 titled “After Darwin. What?” Part one of the book focuses on the lack of validation and evidence hence the name “The Mystery of Missing Fossils” and gives a very brief introduction to the problems of missing fossils, missing phyla, and just general missing validation of the evolutionary

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

The Design Argument The question of whether God truly exists has been debated between believers and non-believers for centuries. Also known as the Teleological Argument, the Design Argument argued by William Paley states that there are so many intricate details and designs in our world that there must be a creator. In addition, it also argues that this world could not have been created by chance alone due to the characteristics that make it the perfect condition for human life to exist (Pecorino). In this essay, I will be giving a brief overview of what the Design Argument is, then providing evidence and reasoning in favor of the argument, then addressing the criticisms of the argument, then comparing both sides of the argument, then finally

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

The concept of teleology is based on the idea that everything has a purpose or was intended for a purpose. This idea leads to a specific design, which instinctively guides many to make the connection that there is a designer. When a person sees massive structure, such as the Empire State building, its clear that the building was designed and didn’t just arise by chance. The complexity of the design implies that the building was built for a specific purpose or multiple purposes. Similarly, those that are believers of the concept of teleology, point to the complexity and design of the universe to support that the universe would also require a designer.

Read More
2263 Words | 10 Pages

The quick appeal of intelligent design to theism has made natural scientists, like Alister McGrath to heavily criticize the inability of the Anthropic Principle to make new conversions to theism. McGrath argued that the Anthropic Principle is meant for a theistic worldview since it sounds apologetic due to an assumption that its proponents hold the some theistic values. Darwin, in the Origin of Species gives an alternative account of the supposedly amazing discoveries of the anthropic principle. What looked amazing is explained as having happened through pure chance.

Read More
749 Words | 3 Pages

When thinking of a theory, the first step is a question, which is somehow always a ‘Why?’ or a ‘How?’. We wonder and look for patterns between evidently unrelated things. Darwin’s question was “How did evolution happen?”.

Read More
1166 Words | 5 Pages

“Nor could I consider the magnitude and complexity of my plan as any argument of its impracticability. It was with these feelings that I began the creation of a human

Read More
676 Words | 3 Pages

The main issue Kant evaluates, is the a priori quality of metaphysics. For something to be a priori it must be entirely beyond experience, and in order for a science to provide knowledge, it must be established in experience. Our reasoning cannot provide us with knowledge, but helps us categorize and classify concepts of sensibility, understanding, and reason. Kant questions that if metaphysics is entirely a priori, then it cannot establish experience and will not provide

Read More
5485 Words | 22 Pages

That is, our feelings of nature are properly designed and therefore ought to be heeded. Kant’s belief of ethics might be seen as an over-arching design and order of nature. The third illustration considers the issue of developing one’s talents. Nature endows us with aptitudes that are intended for a given purpose, which Kant implies, are valid in an appropriate system of nature.

Read More

More about Teleological Argument Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document