ipl-logo

Textual Analysis Of The Mission Movie

1440 Words6 Pages

The Mission (1986) is an Oscar winning, historically based film set in South America during the 1740s meant to convey the tragedy of the fate of Jesuit Missions, a power struggle between the Spanish, the Portuguese, and the Catholic Church, and an abominable loss of life. It seems as though the protagonists in this movie are the Jesuits, conveying an image of peaceful, godly servants, and the antagonists seem to be a mixture of the Portuguese and the Catholic Church as they fight for power in the Americas. At least, this is the director’s assumption of who the “good” and “bad” guys are, but truthfully when looking at history from an unbiased viewpoint the true protagonists could be seen as the Indians of South America while the antagonists …show more content…

He begins to take what seems to be an extremely risky move and starts playing an oboe, knowing it will attract the attention of the Guarani. Though, when they make themselves known to Father Gabriel they do seem slightly hostile and break his instrument, he still seemed to gain the trust of the Guarani through music, leading the narrating Cardinal to comment, “if they were an orchestra, the Jesuits could have subdued a continent”. He begins to tell stories of the Jesuit religion and slowly converts the Guarani, persuading them to build a Mission named St. Carlos where much of the remaining plot will take place in. And everything seems to be going well for the Jesuits and the Guarani until a slave catcher name Rodrigo Mendoza come along stealing away and killing a good number of the Natives. The film then shifts again and starts to follow along with the point of view of this slave catcher to a different Mission called St. Miguel. Eventually, after a dramatic turn of events where he seems to lose the women he loves to another man, Mendoza kills his brother. In fear of eternal damnation for his actions, Mendoza meets Father Gabriel and leaves with him to find forgiveness for his crime, not only from God but also from himself. Mendoza ends up also being converted and becomes a set leading character …show more content…

There really was a horrible series of happenings leading up to the massacre of the Guarani, and the mission of San Carlos truly did exist, but many specifics of the movie, especially the characters, did not occur. During this time in which The Mission is set, the 1750 Treaty of Madrid was signed transferring the ownership of South American land from Spain to Portugal and the Spanish Jesuits were forced to leave their missionaries. However, Father Gabriel and Rodrigo are fictional characters. Also, if the film was meant to be as historically accurate as possible, the grand battle between the Guarani, the Jesuits, and the Portuguese never would have occurred since in truth no missionaries stayed to help protect the Guarani. Also, there wasn’t simply one horrendous fight to end the conflict and the aggression between the Guarani and the Portuguese lasted almost three years. Even the narrating Cardinal of this film is historically inaccurate. Though there was a man during this time named Altamirano, he was an emissary sent by Ignazio Visconti and not a Cardinal sent by the

Show More
Related
948 Words | 4 Pages

The period of missionization was known to the Spaniards as a time to mold the Indigenous people into the spitting image of what they wanted; cultivating the Indigenous people into civilized, Christian practicing beings. However, through the eyes of the Indigenous people this period was considered to be the end of the world – an end to the world they came to know so well. Settler colonialism introduced a cruel and brutal world upon the Indigenous people, especially for Indigenous women who were targeted by the priests to fulfill their needs of lust, during the period of missionization. In the book, Bad Indians, author Deborah Miranda finds a captivating way of presenting the brave story of Vicenta Gutierrez, who fell victim to the priest on the mission and spoke up about her traumatic event, through the literary genre of a letter. Using the letter as her literary device, Miranda vividly illustrates the sexual violence brought upon Indian women and how the priests used rape to establish power on the missions had a dehumanizing effect on these women.

Read More
1720 Words | 7 Pages

The Spanish’s’ main goal was trying to get the Aztec people to subdue to their demands, both in a spiritual and physical conquest. During the colonizing of the Aztecs, the Spanish were trying to impose the religion that they had brought over which was Christianity and tried to get the Aztecs to stop worshipping to their Goddess. One particular scene that shows Spanish colonialism is when the Aztecs are sacrificing a young woman to the Goddess by taking out her heart, then they were caught in the act by the Spanish and Father Friar Diego. Following that scene, Topiltzin is laying in front of the Goddess statue, when it is thrown over and is destroyed and then replaced with the statue of the Virgin Mary. This specific scene displays the Spanish superiority over the Aztecs, both in the physical world and as well in the spiritual world.

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

This is where Indies were founded but now called the Hispaniola. These Spanish Christians were honest, no grudges, and etc. According to “Brief Account of the Devastation of the Indies” there were cons about them, for instance, “…so weak and complaisant, they are less able to endure heavy labor and soon die.” The Hispaniola had a total of 12 million Native Indians on the island and blaming the church being involved somewhat. When the Spaniards noticed some of the Native Indians escaped, he sent out a ship where it took several years to find them to kill.

Read More
1516 Words | 7 Pages

During Spanish control of Presidio Hill, a key component for their method of colonization was building missions church that would teach the local native population of the religion of Catholicism. The first mission of the nine total Father Serra established was, “On July 16, (...) a crude church meant to serve both the Spanish colonist and begin Catholic outreach to local natives” (San Diego Mission). As a working priest, he tried to establish as many missions as possible in California in spreading the word of God to the population. Having established previous missions in Mexico, he was very passionate and determined of his role in the colonization of the Spanish. The establishment of this particular mission is significant to history of San Diego because it still stand today and serves the community of San Diego.

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

However, according to Father Junipero Serra, the natives were by far in the wrong with their actions to destroy the mission (Chan/Olin, 60). This argument is obviously one sided, but if the website for the San Luis Rey Mission mentioned the fact that the natives sometimes did not like the fact that they were being taken over by a force that merely controlled them with guns, it would most definitely affect their tourist income in numbers. In addition, the mission website is less likely to mention the fact that there were punishments for those natives who did reject the work or conversion to Catholicism. As mention in Francis F. Guest’s essay, “Cultural Perspectives on Death and Whipping in the Missions”, there were many instances in which the punishments for natives was excessive and superfluous. “There is incontrovertible testimony that delinquent Indians were whipped, sometimes excessively, by the padres”

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

It raises the question of how the Spanish viewed the natives: as people standing in the way of their gold, or fascinating and interesting people with rich culture and

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

Zinn also includes a quote from Las Casas that says “two of these so-called Christians met two Indian boys one day. . . and for fun beheaded the boys, emphasizing the often meaningless abuse of Spanish power. Quotations from Columbus and Las Casas along with shocking statistics of death strongly portray the Spanish as patronizing and bloodthirsty to

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

She vows to god she will never ask him for anything for her son” (260). This shows us how Lourdes once cared for her son, but now is burdened with him for all of his actions. The point of view shows us how how Enrique once cared for his mother but now his mother is crying because of what Enrique has turned out to be. In conclusion, the POV shows us how different perspectives show us how Enrique ended up because of how he changed. Analyzing how Nazario uses literary devices show us how Enrique has changed throughout the novel.

Read More
1051 Words | 5 Pages

I will outline the argument put forth by father Luis Jayme for support being sent from the Franciscian church to aid both neothytes (Indian converts to Christianity) and gentiles (non-converted Indians), who are allegedly subject to rape from the Portuguese soldiers. Father Jayme Is sympathetic towards the native Indians who he believes act in a better nature than that of the Portuguese soldiers. In summary, Jayme notes of his own Spanish Christians, he writes "I burst into tears to see how these neophytes were setting an example for us Christians"1. The outrageous acts of rape performed by the soldiers referencing personal accounts given to him by the native Americans as his main source of evidence. "some soldiers went their and raped their women .....

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

However, the criticism in his words are obvious as Las Casas utilizes satire to attack the decisions of the Spanish to first inforce Spanish rule or "Tyranny" onto the natives only to massacre a critical percentage of the 'Ten Kingdoms'. Las Casas goes further to describe what he believed to have been the two types of people who caused the downfall of the people of the Indies. The first division, Las Casas determines as killers, exterminating for the sake of their own consumption and benefit. Meanwhile, the other half Las Casas explains are those who oppressed the inhabitants to the point that they thirst for their freedom, which the Spanish would have said is in the form of embracing "Catholicism." However, Las Casas finally reveals the ultimate lure that incited the Spanish to turn the Indies into desolate lands as 'Gold'.

Read More
450 Words | 2 Pages

Las Casas viewed the natives as “docile and open to doctrine” (1) who presented themselves in a godly manner. Stating that he believes the Indians to be docile along with the fact that he saw they behaved in a godly fashion negates the notion that Las Casas felt threatened by the Indians. He believes the survivors endured the most difficult hardships in history. Las Casas carried a great respect for the natives and hurt for them and the injustice they had been

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

Death Comes for the Archbishop, by Willa Cather, revolves around the story of Bishop Jean Marie Latour, his death, and his legacy. Cather uses Latour as a vessel in order to display the world around him. It’s through him we learn about New Mexico, the people, and the visuals he encounters. He describes various legends, Indian traditions, religions Catholic Priests beliefs, and scenery as he travels along his spiritual journey reflecting on his new location. Latour’s point of view on New Mexico is filtered through his experiences, which is how Cather gains her audience.

Read More
1298 Words | 6 Pages

The late 19th century consisted of rigid work hours for children, the growth of strikes, and the use of yellow journalism. It was a challenging time for anyone below the upper class to live in. This is demonstrated throughout Newsies, a Broadway Musical displaying the challenges from this time period. Child labor, a major part of the movie, was the way of life and consisted of young children doing hard work as a vital part of the nation’s economy and income of families of the time. Another part of the movie, strikes, were the people’s way of refusing to work as a result of not getting their desires.

Read More
1441 Words | 6 Pages

Characters in the novel are frequently shown to be contradicting traditional Catholic values and the Ten Commandments, such as the prohibition of sex before marriage. Pedro Vicario, one of the Vicario brothers behind the killing of Santiago Nasar, was “trembling with rage” (p.47) after finding out Angela Vicario was not a virgin before marriage, despite having returned from the local brothel with his brother moments before. This use of irony demonstrates the satirical nature of Márquez’s work, all the while making a commentary on the contradictory communal religious ideologies entrenched in the town. In the novel, the revered religious figures in the community are portrayed as symbols of the hollow religious beliefs in the community, solely making appearances which portray them in a negative light. Father Amador and the Bishop are portrayed to be apathetic and demonstrate un-Christian values.

Read More
1472 Words | 6 Pages

Márquez’s novella ‘Chronicle of a Death Foretold’ tells the story of Santiago Nasar’s murder. It is based on the real-life incident that occurred in the 1950s in a small Colombian town, Sucre. Cayetano Gentile was murdered by the brothers of Margarita Chica for having allegedly stolen her virginity. This was revealed when she was returned to her family after her newlywed husband had discovered that she wasn’t a Virgin. In his novella, Márquez displays the influence of the social mores and shows how these supersede the law of the statute books and the authority of Catholicism, which was otherwise so important and therefore how these social mores affect the characters and their actions.

Read More

More about Textual Analysis Of The Mission Movie

Open Document