ipl-logo

The American Dream: The Effects Of The American Eugenics Movement

1936 Words8 Pages

Lina Lin
Mrs. Stall/Mr. Britton/Mr. Jablonka
Introduction to Humanities
26 April 2023
The Effects of the American Eugenics Movement
The modern American dream is amiable and wishes for all Americans—regardless of their identity or background—to be successful in their passions. The nature of this message makes America seem welcoming, but the discriminatory history of the country suggests otherwise. The American dream has always been made to seem like a symbol of the country’s democratic values, but the message has often been skewed and turned into a promise of bigotry and inequity—a clear contrast between the message people know today. America has an undeniably abhorrent history of discrimination, but many parts of the country’s daunting background …show more content…

Eugenists theorized that “undesirable” traits were inherited from parents, so measures were taken to ensure that supposedly feebleminded women would not be able to reproduce at all. This led to many women being forcibly sterilized; the most notable case of this being that of Carrie Buck, who was deemed feebleminded and was ordered to be forcibly sterilized along with her mother and daughter. She later went to the Supreme Court to challenge whether or not the act was constitutional. The Buck v. Bell case “gave states the authority to implement forced sterilization laws against those deemed ‘unfit’” (Powell). Not only were they barbaric, but compulsory sterilizations entirely removed mankind’s basic human right to reproduce; yet these were still deemed constitutional, as they supported a cause that eugenists believed was necessary to save society. The official legalization of compulsory sterilizations was a major step towards eradicating the “unfit” from society, and eugenists took full advantage of this advancement by continuing to expand their practices across the country. Due to the eugenist belief that feebleminded couples would pass their undesirable qualities to their offspring, laws continued to be implemented across the country to reduce the number of “unfit” offspring produced. By 1931, “27 states required the feebleminded to be sterilized before …show more content…

Standardized testing, while seemingly innocent, has a tragic history of prejudice and bigotry. Reproductive laws faced significant changes internationally throughout the twentieth century to support an unjust cause. Hitler admired America’s passion to create a superior Anglo-Saxon race and expanded upon this idea until he went too far in his practices. The modern American dream gives all citizens hope of a future of success, no matter their background or identity. Despite this, America’s history seems to consistently contradict this amiable message. When one recognizes the horrific actions committed by American eugenists, it raises the question of whether or not the American dream has ever been truly achievable, or if it simply serves as a facade to repress the most inhuman portions of the country’s cruel

Show More
Related
1284 Words | 6 Pages

The sterilization of Carrie Buck and the eugenics movement in the U.S. is an example of this relationship, as the eugenics movement and biological determinist thought permeated society. Carrie Buck was up against four powerful institutions, medicine, academia, law, and the judiciary, not to mention the gender and economic differences. While discussing the economy, Calavita explains a shift in business models that applies to Buck’s case. Calavita writes, “The charisma and credentials of the ‘grand old men’ who traditionally made up this transnational arbitration club continue to provide it with an aura of genteel legitimacy, but that its actual operation has been rendered highly technocratic and rational” (Calavita, 34). The ‘grand old men’ described can also be applied to the four, elite, professional institutions Buck was against during her case.

Read More
928 Words | 4 Pages

After the fall of the Nazis in the 1940s, eugenics continued to impact the lives of those in the United States negatively up until the 1970s. It was not due to the need to be “superior”, but to be able to control reproduction by increasing the top members and decreasing the lower members. The movement took place mainly in the East Coast during the Progressive Era, reaching its climax in the 1920s and 1930s with immigration control, marriage laws, and sterilization of those who were considered dangerous to the society. Due to the Nazis, their rise to power, and the horrifying Holocaust, it had formed the movements in the United States.

Read More
1527 Words | 7 Pages

Director of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare’s (HEW) Population Affairs Office, Carl Shultz, estimated that the government funded 100,000 to 200,000 sterilizations in America, paralleling the 250,000 sterilizations that took place under the Nazi Regime (Davis, 129). In the 1960’s and 1970’s, the nation experienced a population scare after Professor Ehrlich proposed his theory of a “population bomb”, which stated that an increase in population would lead to food insecurity due to the environment’s inability to support such a large amount of people. (Put cite) The threat of overpopulation pushed the nation to increase birth control in the name of the public good. However, common fixed beliefs, called hegemonic ideologies, of hyperfertility

Read More
151 Words | 1 Pages

I agree with your point that we shouldn 't have the authority to take away anyone 's right to bear children but sterilization is not inhumane if someone chooses to do it for their own personal reasons. I myself, after bearing 3 children, made the personal decision to not have anymore. There was nothing inhumane about my decision or the procedure. I do agree however that the inhumane practice of forced or "coercive" sterilization, favored by eugenicists and population controllers was wrong. Much of the controversy over Sanger and her involvement with eugenics came from a letter she wrote and an inartfully written sentence that describes the sort of allegations that fueled people 's suspicions that she was opening clinics to exterminate a

Read More
711 Words | 3 Pages

Villarosa argued that the eugenics movement played a significant role in shaping family planning policies and practices in the United States. In the book, she noted that the eugenicists believed that certain groups of people like African Americans and other people who suffer through poverty, were biologically inferior and should be discouraged from reproducing. These ideas were embraced by policymakers, public health officials, and family planning workers. They often saw their work as a way to control the reproduction of marginalized communities. The author also stated that the eugenics movement was intertwined with racism and classism.

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

Eugenics is not a thought of morale and is not designed to save the entire human race, just the upper socioeconomic class. In North Carolina, feeble minded individuals were used as subjects for all kinds of genocidal experiments. Feeble minded simply means someone who suffers from an illness or mental deficiency and are often easier persuaded because they think they are getting help when they were really being coerced into becoming a test

Read More
2207 Words | 9 Pages

Darwinists in turn, believed biology to be destiny and that if one's ancestors were unfit their children would be as well. Much like in evolution, Spencer assumed that the unfit populations would decline overtime due to their failure to compete, however paranoia led some Americans to speed up this process, introducing eugenics. Eugenics were supposed to improve men, ridding the undesirable traits of the unfit and changing genetic structure to create more fit individuals. The Eugenics movement in America took people of color, the mentally ill or disabled, LGBTQ individuals, and other members of society deemed unfit, and conducted experimentation ranging from forced breeding, involuntary sterilization, or institutionalization on them. Although the movement was eventually stomped out, it violated thousands of

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

The war and immigration played the largest role on the emergence of eugenics. In 1927, the supreme court ruled in favor of the sexual sterilization of a young woman named Carrie Buck. This paper discusses

Read More
1273 Words | 6 Pages

There are cases when law abiding and mentally healthy parents have children who become criminals or mentally ill. In addition, Bethenia Owens-Adair thought that genetics explained everything about the mental and physical state of a child born into a family. In the early to mid 1900’s, most of those who supported Owens-Adair’s idea of Eugenics were not educated

Read More
205 Words | 1 Pages

By the late 1800s, Indiana authorities believed criminality, mental problems, and pauperism were hereditary. In a paper presented in 1879 to the Social Science Association of Indiana, Harriet Foster claimed that imbeciles and the feeble-minded often inherit their conditions. Foster stated that "intermarriage of consanguineous persons, and intemperance of one or both parents, " are the most common reasons people have mental problems. Various laws were established based on this belief. In 1907, Governor J. Frank Hanly approved first state eugenics law, making sterilization mandatory for certain individuals that were in state custody.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Research Paper Rough Draft- Eugenics The amazing thing about the world today is the rapidly changing society, and the contemporary technology. Something that scientist have been working to perfect for many years is the modernization of eugenics. It is changing the way people are born by selecting specific traits for an individual to be smarter, stronger, more attractive and many other traits. Many parents of the new generation are willing to try the science of eugenics for their child to be customized to them.

Read More
918 Words | 4 Pages

“Eugenics and Compulsory Sterilization Laws: Providing Redress for the Victims of a Shameful Era in United States History,” is an article by, Michael Silver, that addresses the issue of eugenics and involuntary sterilization laws. He specifically looked at the sterilization laws that were practiced in the 20th Century in the United States. Silver brings forth the argument that sterilization laws violate the constitutional rights of Americans of procreation and childrearing. Throughout the article, Silver explains the history of how the laws were created, practiced, and how they affected those that were involuntarily sterilized. As the article progresses, Silver gave examples of how individual states and the United States, collectively as a

Read More
1622 Words | 7 Pages

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, eugenics is: “a science that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of hereditary qualities of a race or breed”. ("Definition of Eugenics by Merriam-Webster") The most common example of this concept would be the Holocaust, which was the extermination of Jewish people and others deemed “unfit” for society in World War Ⅱ. But little do many know, the Nazi’s were not the only people practicing eugenics in the early 1900’s, eugenics was being practiced in the United States long before the Holocaust. The American Eugenics Society aimed to educate American people on the science of Eugenics.

Read More
621 Words | 3 Pages

It is important to realize that Sanger’s campaign for a women’s to choose birth control was at a time when women where not thought of as equals and contraception was considered to be obscene at the time. In fact, she provokes a hostile reaction among Christian leaders that considered her concepts for birth control to be offensive and evil to society. Her advocacy work drew controversy from political followers that criticized her association with science to be immoral for seeking to improve or change the human population. She was often criticized and associated which eugenics, the branch of science that believed in improving the human species through selective mating. However her goal was to allow women to have control over how many children

Read More
565 Words | 3 Pages

1920 U.S.A Eugenics Eugenics: (Noun/Verb): The act of attempting the perfection of genes within a pre-existing population similar to that of selective breeding within a select species of mammals. During the Roaring Twenties of the United States a process of artificial selection arose known as the process of Eugenics. Eugenics is as stated, a process of elimination of the “Lesser” individuals to preserve traits that are thought highly of. During the latter 19th Century and the early 20th Century, eugenics was considered a favored method of preserving society, therefore only showcasing the preferred traits within society.

Read More

More about The American Dream: The Effects Of The American Eugenics Movement

Related Topics

Open Document