ipl-logo

The American School System Gets A F Analysis

1742 Words7 Pages

The American School System Gets an ‘F’ “Government schooling… kills the family by monopolizing the best times of childhood and by teaching disrespect for home and parents.” This quote from author, former schoolteacher, and prominent advocate for education reform, John Taylor Gatto, encapsulates a facet of the struggle children face when they go to school, especially if they are the children of immigrants. American schools place a heavy emphasis on competition, on English fluency, and on assimilation. Moreover, children spend a significant portion of their lives at school, absorbing the standardized information and values that make Americans, American; what schools decide to value, they make their students value as well. And all too often, …show more content…

According to Lisa Speckhard in her article concerning a Hmong cultural summer program, Hmong American kids are lagging in academics, and a Hmong cultural summer program could help solve this problem. This program provides a safe space to learn where Hmong American kids do not have to worry as much about assimilation or acceptance, helps Hmong American children build confidence and self-esteem, and makes them better equipped to deal with academics (Speckhard). Their “attitude[s are] strikingly different from how Hmong kids often behave in public school” after participating in this program, and while some children “may be known for being quiet and not raising their hands” in public school, “here, it's a total difference. You see kids engaging, raising hands, asking questions, because they feel comfortable”; they “recognize that their other classmates look like them, talk broken Hmong like them” (Speckhard). When these students felt like they were in an environment where they were understood and felt safe and surrounded by community, they flourished. They were empowered to speak up and engage in discussions; a stark difference from the disempowerment they face in the public school system. It is also important to note that these gains made during the summer often do not last once the students return to public school. They go back to “the school year and they're struggling. They're back to, ‘Oh, I don't know who I am’” (Speckhard). It can then be inferred that a sense of identity and belonging is essential to educational success, and by denying this safety and sense of community to Xue and other Hmong American children, the American educational system is actively denying them the ability to fully reach their

Show More
Related
303 Words | 2 Pages

After reading Miguel and Valencia’s “From the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo to Hopwood,” I was shocked to find how Mexican Americans were treated in American students. I was expect poor treatment from our discussions in class as well as other readings, but after reading what the authors reported, including schools failing to address learning issues and pushing kids instead into economic mobility, I am deeply troubled I was not made aware of this sooner. Along with segregation on race basis, I would argue the struggles of Mexican American students was the greatest struggle for education equality in the 20th century, though the struggles gone through by other minorities surely should be discounted or overlooked. I found the role of religious institutions

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction Jane L. David and Larry Cuban do a great job of informing the reader of issues involving closing the achievement gap in education in their book, “Cutting Through the Hype”. David and Cuban, friends and colleagues for forty-five years, collaborated yet again to revise “Cutting Through the Hype” to re-address the “far more pronounced” effects of the federal role and the philanthropic foundations in funding and setting the policy agenda for reforming U.S. schools. Chapter three, Closing the Achievement Gap, begins with a realistic scenario of a fifth grade classroom of thirty students that range from six non English speaking students, limited English speaking students, and fluent English speaking, high performing students. The

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

Steven Singer attempts to contradict the narrative presented by many right wing politicians that claim the American school system is failing in his article, “U.S. Public Schools Are Not Failing. They’re Among The Best In The World” (Huffington Post February 13 2017). In this piece Singer works to argue the claims that have been made against the US public school system; he defends the system by listing the various positives in the system, and exercises pathos by shining light on how America guarantees the right of education to all students regardless of social class or race; Singer uses this point throughout the article by justifying the fact that our test scores are not up to par with other countries by reiterating the fact that because we

Read More
951 Words | 4 Pages

Education Reality in America “All systems of the society are meant to serve the mind, not the mind to serve the systems,” by Abhijit Naskar. The Rhetorical situation in the essay “Still Separate, Still Unequal: America’s Educational Apartheid” by Jonathan Kozol happens to be the differences in school systems by ethnicity rates. It is interpreted by the speaker that minority races are shown by the government they are not equally important because they have a lack of funding, old school buildings, and only are introduced to the races they see every day unlike the white schools who are introduced to various ethnic groups. The readers would refer to the speaker as passionate about the government making an effort to fix the school

Read More
441 Words | 2 Pages

The article “School vs. Society in America’s Failing Students” (2015), by Eduardo Porter reveals the debate surrounding the reasoning behind the failure of America’s educational system. Porter efficiently utilizes logos to fulfil his purpose of informing his audience of the multiple sides of the situation. Porter uses logos to fairly and thoroughly showcase both sides of the discussion. He begins his article by introducing the situation through a declaration of statistics of America’s ranking in the PISA standardized tests in math, reading, and science. He then presents Professor Martin Carnoy’s beliefs that “socioeconomic deficits impose a particularly heavy burden on American schools” and once these social statuses are adjusted for, the American educational system will

Read More
637 Words | 3 Pages

This novel To Kill a Mockingbird written by Harper Lee, is about a family in the depression time in Maycomb Alabama in the early 1940s narrated by a main character Jean Louise Finch. The Finch Family, ran by Atticus Finch who is not just a father but a lawyer with very high morals. Jean Louis Finch tells the story from a child’s mind and much mature mindset of it, since Harper lee is trying to prove that Jeam and Scout are immature. Jean Louis Finch quoted, “Maturity is the ability to reap without apology and not complain when things don't go well.” Harper Lee indicates several internal forces that leads up to why Atticus is representing Tom Robinson in his trial of accusing of raping a white lady.

Read More
1300 Words | 6 Pages

One of the great qualities of America is that everyone is entitled to equal opportunities. That if we work hard enough we will be able to reach amazing heights and pave the way to a better future, but unfortunately some aren’t given that fair chance and it’s America’s children who are sadly suffering. All over the country children in public schools, minorities especially, are being subjected to school segregation. Based on matters such as race, ethnicity, and social class students are given an education that undoubtedly contradicts the promise of equal educational opportunities. The goal of America’s educational system is to provide all of the nation’s students with a public, gratuitous education that is of fair and equal quality, insuring

Read More
1289 Words | 6 Pages

3.2 Schools and Teachers 3.2.1 The Condition of Schools Latino Students Attend A very effective way to reach Latino students is through the schools they attend. This would also help to address the difficulties they face. If a family cannot support their children’s academic development, be it because they lack the resources or because they don’t have any experience with the US school system, it should be the responsibility of the schools to support these students in any way they can. Yet, according to Gándara and Contreras “the evidence suggests that rather than addressing the disadvantages these students face, the schools perpetuate it” (87).

Read More
438 Words | 2 Pages

But even when they didn’t learn English themselves, their children grew up speaking it. Thousands of first-generation Americans still strive to learn English, but others face reduced educational and career opportunities because they have not mastered this basic skill they need to get ahead. According to the 1990 census, 40 percent of the Hispanics born in the United States do not graduate from high school, and the Department of Education says that a lack of proficiency in English is an important factor in the drop-out rate. People and agencies that favor providing services only in foreign languages want to help people who do not speak English, but they may be doing these people a disservice by condemning them to a linguistic ghetto from which they cannot easily escape.

Read More
1258 Words | 6 Pages

The relatively poor educational background of Hispanic immigrants reflects the fact that most Hispanic immigrants are educated not in the U.S. but in less developed countries. Hispanic immigrants who arrived in the United States early in childhood were enrolled in United States elementary and secondary schools are much better educated. Of those who arrived under the age of 10, only about one-quarter were high school dropouts in 2008, and their education approximates that of native-born Hispanic adults (Fry, 2010). Most immigrant Hispanic adults arrived in the United States after age 14 have a majority rating of high school

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

Illegal immigration in the United States has become a controversial topic throughout the past few decades. The decision whether to allow children of illegal immigrants to attend public schools has turned into both a political and socioeconomic debate in the United States of America. Although allowing children of illegal immigrants to attend school can pose significant hardships to the average tax payer, research conducted shows that illegal immigrants are vitally important to the economy and their attendance in school can be the difference between being successful in our country or living a life of crime. Our country was built on the foundations of social equality. Currently, the law of the land dictates that everyone, no matter their background, has a right to a public education.

Read More
1248 Words | 5 Pages

One of the history's greatest figures, Nelson Mandela, once said: “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” Over the course of years, this statement has only become more relevant. Maybe that is the reason why the topic of the decline of the American education has been recently spurring such a heated debate among national academic and teaching communities. In “The Chronicle of Higher Education”, Carl Singleton, a faculty member at Fort Hays State University, also presented his reflections concerning the U.S. education system.

Read More
569 Words | 3 Pages

In Carl Singleton’s article, “What Our Education System Needs is More F’s,” he argues that students aren’t receiving the failing grades they deserve. School systems are to blame for the lack of quality in America’s education. No other recommendation for improvement will succeed. The only way to fix the American education system is to fail more students. According to Singleton, the real root of the issue is with the parents.

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

Immigrants and Education We believe that teachers and parents are struggling to make their students and children involved in a different community from their original community. Because these students have different cultures, languages and values from their teachers who are doing their best to meet the needs of all international students (Shurki & Richard, 2009). The schools across the country today are looking for ways to welcome and assist immigrant families because they become a big part of their communities. So how these effect on each of students, teachers and parent? Teachers Some school districts respond to the needs of immigrant and refugee students by creating “newcomer” programs (Hertzberg, 1998).

Read More
394 Words | 2 Pages

As a four-year-old immigrant, a personalized education system would have provided me with greater confidence in my academic abilities. I found it difficult to excel in an elementary school with a “one size fits all” curriculum. I only knew how to speak Mandarin and Thai, and I was a visual learner. My teachers taught based on textbooks in English and disregarded my personal learning needs. Therefore, I was uninspired in all my classes which translated to poor grades.

Read More

More about The American School System Gets A F Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document