ipl-logo

The Arguments In Favor Of Balancing Liberty And Security

585 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: George orwell 1984 literary analysis

Similarly, these individuals who are in favor of balancing liberty over security also reference the ongoing IRS scandal, and how this also raises concerns about the concentration and abuse of power when it comes to government surveillance, (Sterner, 2014).
All things considered, these people who side with civil liberties and believe that it trumps national security measures; generally hold a consensus that our constitution should protect us from these overreaching aspects of government surveillance. In addition to that, they fear that if such measure are not controlled properly we may become a society that has a government which holds all too much power and control; resulting in pushing the limits, just like we saw in the course materials on George Orwell’s 1984 and also just like we saw in the course materials on Plato’s critique of democracy. …show more content…

On one hand, you want the government to be able to collect data in order to better protect our national security interests. However, on the other hand, I understand why many Americans argue that the government is overreaching with some of its security measures. Especially, when considering the NSA and how they collect data on millions of innocent Americans; which more than likely have no involvement with acts that would endanger our national security interests. For these various reasons, I’m not quite sure that there will ever be a specific answer to where a line should be drawn between liberty and security. However, in my opinion the extent in which we collect data on our own citizens is somewhat frightening and perhaps does present a point of contrast to where we can draw a line; or at least in the public’s

Show More
Related

Research Paper On Fahrenheit 451

572 Words | 3 Pages

Shah 1 Farhan Shah Ms. Benedetto CP English IV 14 April 2024 Editorial Fahrenheit 451 serves as a reminder of the dangers posed by government surveillance and censorship. Fahrenheit 451 depicts a society where government control over information stifles dissent and curtails individual freedoms. This shows the erosion of civil liberties in the face of expanding surveillance measures. Similarly, the Patriot Act and government data collection underscore the risks posed by unchecked surveillance to privacy and freedom of expression. The Patriot Act marked a significant expansion of government surveillance powers in the name of national security.

Read More

Civil Liberties In Gary Colombo's The Myth Of Freedom

377 Words | 2 Pages

The American Constitution gives U.S. citizens basic civil liberties that provide protection from the federal government through the Bill of Rights and the Amendments added throughout American history. However, the national government has repeatedly taken away these significant liberties during a war, and in this era the government’s war on terrorism stirs up controversy all over the globe after the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. Supporters of the government’s detainment of non-citizens and the NSA’s surveillance of data Internet Service Providers--for example, claim that being secure and safe takes priority over established values. In the anthology Rereading America, Gary Colombo’s The Myth of Freedom;

Read More

Dbq Essay On Edward Snowden

1418 Words | 6 Pages

Edward Snowden perfectly sums up the thought process behind the rejection of the mass surveillance: “Privacy isn’t about something to hide. Privacy is about something to protect… freedom of speech doesn’t mean much if you can’t have a quiet space… arguing that you don’t have privacy because you have nothing to hide is like arguing that you don’t care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” (Document 2). The point of view is from an ardent Libertarian that has contributed to Ron Paul’s campaign numerous times. Edward Snowden firmly believes in the right to self.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The NSA Surveillance

2274 Words | 10 Pages

The recent revelations about the NSA surveillance programme have cause concern and outrage by citizens and politicians across the world. What has been missing, though, is any extended discussion of why the government wants the surveillance and on what basis is it authorised. For many commentators surveillance is wrong and it cannot be justified. Some commentators have argued that surveillance is intrinsic to the nature of government and its ability to deliver the public good.[1] Few, though have looked at the surveillance within a wider context to understand how it developed. A notable exception is the work by Steven Aftergood.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Alexander Hamilton

1590 Words | 7 Pages

The United States spends more on its defense than any other country in the world, in a democratic state whose constitution Alexander Hamilton helped to inspire. It’s questionable as to what lengths a democratic system should go to keep its citizens safe as ultimately security cannot be unconditionally guaranteed. Having a debate between liberty and security is by no means a new one, its influence on political thought can be profoundly polarizing, as the extremes of both liberty and security can be witnessed around the world and throughout history. The principles that must be prioritized within a democracy while still affording safety, revolves around the ability of citizens to exercise their political liberties.

Read More

The Right To Freedom For Sacrifice For The Sake Of National Security Dbq Essay

838 Words | 4 Pages

World War II was a time of uncertainty and panic. The United States was fighting the protect democracy against Nazi Germany. At the same time this was happening, there was a war happening internally. The US was hypocritically and irrationally taking away American freedoms for the sake of possibly protecting national security. Japanese Americans who were not guilty whatsoever were being imprisoned because of government fear.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The NSA Scandal

952 Words | 4 Pages

The NSA’s surveillance of American citizens caused a debate over whether or not the Fourth Amendment of the constitution was being violated. The NSA, and the Fourth Amendment have been a touchy subject for some American citizens. The NSA, or National Surveillance Agency, is being closely watched by American citizens since a debate has formed as to whether or not the actions of the NSA regarding the surveillance of American

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Patriot Act

997 Words | 4 Pages

Some Americans believe that the Patriot Act is a violation of privacy, but the government takes crucial steps to ensure the privacy of all law-abiding Americans. Despite contrary beliefs, the

Read More

How Is Walter Presented In A Raisin In The Sun

877 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine being so obsessed with owning a business, but needing to borrow some of your family members money but they will not give in. This is how Walter Lee Younger, Lorraine Hansberry’s A Raisin in the Sun, feels because he wants to use a check that his mother is receiving from the insurance company after his father’s death. Walter, a selfish man with a wife and child, lets his shallow, naive, and ambitious nature interferes with his family.

Read More

Why Is The Patriot Act Important

513 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever wondered why the Patriot Act played a big part in history or why it is so important to us? Well the government has compromised our civil liberties through the use of the Patriot Act. They also abused our privacy which wasn’t fair for us. The history of the Patriot Act, the abuse of our rights, and the way everything ended made the Americans feel like they couldn’t trust their government because they felt like they were always being watched. Through the Patriot Act, the law enforcement agencies and the government are given wide optional powers to acquire information not only from suspected people but also from the law-abiding Americans.

Read More

The Espionage And Sedition Act

376 Words | 2 Pages

The personal liberties of Americans is what gives meaning to being an American. These liberties should be respected and upheld to the greatest efforts possible and should not be abridged by no means less than do process as exemplified by the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the American Constitution. However, over time, we have learned about legislation that has been enacted by our government with said efforts to protect the nation. Hence, the Espionage and Sedition Acts, the confinement of Japanese-Americans during the Second World War, the Red Scare post-WWII, and the Pentagon Papers of 1971 are all examples that depict some of the behaviors performed by the federal government that would appear to infringe on these liberties.

Read More

Personal Privacy In 1984, By George Orwell

946 Words | 4 Pages

Many people might say that the privacy of modern day American citizens is being violated, that to similar to the world of 1984. The novel 1984 written by George Orwell is about a totalitarian government who oppresses its people and controls all aspects of their lives. The government is symbolized by Big Brother, people are monitored their entire day for flaws in their thinking towards Big Brother. I believe that privacy of American citizens is being violated and that people should not give up aspects of their personal privacy for greater good of society.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Civil Liberties

1030 Words | 5 Pages

Civil liberties are rights guaranteed to citizens in the Constitution that the government cannot interfere with, however, in the name of national security, they do. The government sometimes finds it necessary for Americans to give up some of their basic rights to keep the nation protected, but many people find this unnecessary. A law-abiding citizen’s extremely personal information should not be essential to finding terroristic threats within this society. Under no circumstances should an American citizen’s civil liberties be violated in a time of war or crisis, because those are assured rights that are most valuable to their freedom during national conflicts.

Read More

Legitimacy Of Government Authority In John Stuart Mill's The Mongol Empire

657 Words | 3 Pages

However, Mill’s harm principle indicates the latter. He justifies state interference into citizen lives as a means of preventing said citizens from harming each other. The state has an obligation to ensure the safety of its people. The government achieves this by monitoring the information of its citizens as a preventative caution. I concluded that while surveillance did infringe on liberty, concessions were necessary for security.

Read More

A Short Summary: Two Concepts Of Liberty

999 Words | 4 Pages

Two Concepts of Liberty Summary of the essay: In this essay, the famous political theorist Isaiah Berlin tries to differentiate between the notions of positive liberty and negative liberty. Berlin briefly discusses the meaning of the word ‘freedom’. He says that a person is said to free when no man or body of men interferes with his activity. He makes reference to many philosophers in the essay, but there is more emphasis on the thoughts of J. S. Mill and Rousseau, the former being a firm advocate of negative liberty while the latter believes strongly in the ideals of positive liberty.

Read More

More about The Arguments In Favor Of Balancing Liberty And Security

Related Topics

Open Document