ipl-logo

The Court Case Of Alex V. Upper Arlington School District

713 Words3 Pages

May it Please the Court, The Court case Alex v. Upper Arlington School District, a student named Alex refused to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance in the early hours of school. He was told countless times by teachers to stand for the flag. Alex refused and was sent to the office and received a suspension for insubordination. This action violated Alex’s First Amendment rights, going against his freedom of speech and religion. The First Amendment rights of Alex were violated because the school went against his belief of religion and did not allow him to express it. The school administrator tampered with Alex’s First Amendment rights. Quoting from the Bill of Rights, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or …show more content…

Quoting the Upper Arlington Student Handbook “It is the policy of the Upper Arlington School District not to discriminate, in violation of federal or state law, on the basis of race, color, national origin, ancestry, religion, age, sex or disability in admission to, access to, treatment in or employment in, any service, program, or activity sponsored by the Upper Arlington City Schools” (Upper Arlington Schools Students’ Handbook 4). The District itself went against its own rules that they have created. It is clearly stated above in the handbook that the school district does not discriminate on the basis of …show more content…

Furthermore the Court case is about a student who, as well as Alex, was forced to do the Pledge of Allegiance. According to the school, “refusal to salute was treated as ‘insubordination’ and was punishable by expulsion and charges of delinquency” (West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette). This is plainly obvious that this quote goes against the First Amendment Rights. It is shown that it’s not just the Upper Arlington School District that goes against students’

Show More
Related

Melton V. Young Case Study

231 Words | 1 Pages

The Melton v. Young case is about a high school student that was suspended for wearing a jacket with a Confederate flag. The issue that was discussed is, whether or not the school officials could suspend a student for wearing Confederate flag. The clothing sparking racial tension was also discussed. The racial tension from the previous year was an argument for the defense because it can be said that the jacket could have refueled this. The defense also stated that the Melton family was informed of the new rules and chose to break them.

Read More

Goss V. Lopez Supreme Court Case Summary

762 Words | 4 Pages

Per 3 Goss Vs. Lopez Supreme Court Case On October 15, 1975 Nine students were suspended from Central High School from Columbus, Ohio. They had destroyed school property and disrupting students from learning and were suspended for 10 days. One of the students amoung them was Dwight Lopez.

Read More

Kevin Swanson Case Study

1816 Words | 8 Pages

Principal Belding suspended Maria for five days and was prohibited from running for student body president the next year. Maria then sued Principal Belding alleging that he had violated her right to free speech protected under the First Amendment. In the courts, the District Court found in favor of Maria, while the Court of Appeals reversed the ruling of the District. This case will soon be heard at the Supreme Court.

Read More

Engel V. Vitale Summary

426 Words | 2 Pages

The issue in this case was whether school-sponsored nondenominational prayer in public schools violates the Establishment clause of the first amendment (Facts and Case Summary - Engel v. Vitale, n.d.). This case dealt with a New York state law that had required public schools to open each day with the Pledge of Allegiance and a nondenominational prayer in which the students recognized their dependence upon God (Facts and Case Summary - Engel v. Vitale, n.d.). This law had also allowed students to absent themselves from this activity if they found that it was objectionable. There was a parent that sued the school on behalf of their child. Their argument was that the law violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, as made applicable

Read More

Foster V. Chatman Case Study

1599 Words | 7 Pages

The case Foster v. Chatman is a very difficult and unpleasant case. The case highlights the embarrassing and disgraceful episodes of the United States’ history. Racism, discrimination and prejudice have occurred, since the inception of the country. The United States’ pledge of allegiance reads, “I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.” This statement is a very strong declaration, when it is often said, it can lose its sticking meaning, however this pledge can be deceptive.

Read More

Engel Vs. Vital Case Study

100 Words | 1 Pages

The Controversy began back in 1962 after the Engel v. Vital case, that state sponsored school prayers would be banned in public school systems. Since this ruling, the rules regarding school prayer have been clarified. The First Amendment allows students to freely express themselves religiously but also separates it from government-sponsored religion. Students have the right to pray while not involved in a school-related activity. They also have the right to pray, converse, and even persuade other students regarding religion.

Read More

What Is The Supreme Court Case Of West Virginia State Board Of Education V. Barnette

608 Words | 3 Pages

Interestingly, despite the issues of religion surrounding the case, the decision was reached due to a completely different reasoning; that the government cannot force anyone to express orthodox beliefs that are at odds with their conscience and values. According to the justices that ruled in favor of Barnette, the flag salute, in addition to the pledges, is a “form of utterance.” By enforcing a compulsory flag salute, the state board of education was creating a “compulsory unification of opinion,” inconsistent with the values of the First Amendment. The three other justices believed that the rules laid out by the state board of education was completely constitutional. Representing the dissenting judges, Justice Felix Frankfurter said, in essence, that the legislation was within the scope of power of the state because it encourages "good citizenship and national allegiance.

Read More

Essay On The Supreme Court Case Of Engel Vs. Vitale

1253 Words | 6 Pages

Moreover, this led to a notable disruption in America at the time and led to many affronted Americans. “... more difficult Establishment Clause cases involve government assistance or approval of religion...” (Brannen) This quote is saying that, just like other cases that involve the Establishment Clause, the public school’s composed prayer was seen as a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment due to the government's assistance in all public schools. This quote also reinforces that the court case influenced America by changing how much the church, and religion, were influenced in public schools.

Read More

The Pledge Of Allegiance Pros And Cons

414 Words | 2 Pages

“The Pledge Of Allegiance was written in 1892 by Francis Ballamy, an author, Baptist minister, and socialist. He was assigned to come up with something patriotic that school children could recite”. - Simon Brown. Since the existence or creation of The Pledge Of Allegiance, there have been many debates and controversy surrounding it. A lot of people oppose to the daily recital of The Pledge, while other’s are supporting and in favor of The Pledge being recited daily in school’s.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of First Amendment In Schools

200 Words | 1 Pages

On the contrary, although the defendant didn’t violate those the limitations stated by the First Amendment, the First Amendment does have other limitations such as the First Amendment applies differently to students in school. As the Supreme Court ruled in the Tinker case, it states that “students are not granted an unlimited right to freedom of speech or self-expression by the First Amendment, because First Amendment guarantees must be balanced against a school’s need to keep order and their school policies. Another example is the case Bethel School District v. Fraser; in this case, high school student Matthew Fraser made a speech nominating another student for elective office, his speech involved graphic sexual metaphors. The Supreme court

Read More

Mandatory Non-Denominational Prayer In Schools Case Study

528 Words | 3 Pages

A group of parents and students challenged the New York State Board of Regents mandatory non-denominational prayer in school. A parent sued the school, arguing that law had violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Engel claimed that the prayer violated the 1st amendment, freedom of religion. Plaintiff being Steven I. Engel, defendant as William J. Vitale. This was located at Herricks School District argued on April 3, 1962.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Pledge Of Allegiance

624 Words | 3 Pages

They said they wanted to show their support for the movement and did not feel that they were being disrespectful to the flag because they were kneeling. I told them that I understood and have had a number of students and friends who said they were frustrated by police brutality against people of color. However, I also wanted them to see that the lives lost fighting for freedom in the American Revolution, the Civil War and the civil rights movement, should also be respected.” These paragraphs show that this teacher understands why his two students kneeled instead of standing up, but then he states his beliefs by staying that it honors those who lost their lives for the country to be free so it should be respected. Now onto the counter article about why people shouldn’t stand during the pledge of allegiance it states, “How can I as a black educator have this bulletin board on my wall and make social justice a theme in my classroom each and every day and then get up and pledge allegiance to a country that has made it so clear that my life does not

Read More

The Pledge Should Be Banned Persuasive Essay

2009 Words | 9 Pages

The unconstitutional Pledge should banned. “I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.” These are the 31 words millions of children across the United States recite each and every morning as they face the flag and place their hand over their hearts. Most students go through this daily obligation without objection and probably without giving it much thought at all, however that is not true for all students. Many students oppose the pledge for a multitude of reasons, some on philosophical grounds, and others for religious reasons.

Read More

Brown V. Board Of Education Case Analysis

759 Words | 4 Pages

Decades ago, children of various races could not go to school together in many locations of the United States. School districts could segregate students, legally, into different schools according to the color of their skin. The law said these separate schools had to be equal. Many schools for children that possessed color were of lesser quality than the schools for white students. To have separate schools for the black and white children became a basic rule in southern society.

Read More

Violation Of The First Amendment In Schools Essay

472 Words | 2 Pages

Jackson wrote the majority opinion, the Supreme Court held that unconstitutional and a violation of the First Amendment and the Fourteenth Amendment. Under the First Amendment, the government cannot enforce laws on an individual’s will regarding of religious liberty. As long as the actions do not present a clear and present danger. The school district had clearly violated the student rights by forcing the student to salute the flag and pledge of allegiances. Jackson reasoned that by forcing the student to salute the flag it was a sign of communicated an expression of set idea.

Read More

More about The Court Case Of Alex V. Upper Arlington School District

Open Document