ipl-logo

The Crucible Theme Of Justice Essay

755 Words4 Pages

Christian Goicoechea
Mrs. Wrabel
Honors English III
25 May 2023
Justice Is Blind We all make choices in life. Good and bad. Right and wrong. It makes us human. Our experiences in life shape us for better or for worse. Conceptually, true justice ensures that we are treated equitably and fairly based on these choices that we make. Though, justice in practice isn’t as fair nor even humane. The “justice” in literature such as Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and in modern society with the reactions to the death penalty repeal in Connecticut, show just how misunderstood the concept of justice really is. Notably, The Crucible depicts the twisted, more accepted interpretation of justice, vengeance. The Crucible is a tale based on the Salem witch …show more content…

The reaction received from Dr. Petit, a victim of injustice, shows the inner longing for vengeance during the search for justice. Through a vote of 86-62, the death penalty was repealed in Connecticut. I see it as a giant step forward towards the path of justice. Whereas, Dr. Petit sees this as a painful experience because of his constant painful reminder. Two men on death row, who are not going to die because of the repeal, made Dr. Petit listen as they murdered his family. As to why he wants capital punishment is explained when Petit says, “We believe in the death penalty because we believe it is really the only true punishment for certain heinous and depraved murders” (Applebome). Clearly, Dr. Petit is in search of vengeance and no one can blame him for that. However, justice would be to let them rot in a prison cell for the rest of their lives. Whether Dr. Petit wants the killers to die should be irrelevant to the actual justice system. The killing of those men will not bring back his family and it will not bring him peace. We can’t run a society where we tell people to not kill people and then kill them for killing people because it is improper and immoral. Widely accepted as it is, vengeance is not justice and it doesn’t represent any of the core values of the term justice. As mentioned with The Crucible, the accusers aren’t always telling the truth and the accused aren’t always guilty. That’s what our justice system is based on. Innocent until proven guilty. Within Dr. Petit’s vulnerability, I see that he wants justice. That he wants a way to forget what happened and to move on. What about the murderer’s family? The murderer has loved

Show More
Related
655 Words | 3 Pages

However, their hanging is definable as murder due to the premeditation of those responsible for their deaths. In regards to the crimes committed and the fact that the victims were well-loved community members, the jury felt as though these criminals’ actions merited their execution. However, if one strips the cloak of law from these citizens, the reasoning behind these hangings is incited by malice and a belief in the necessity of the deaths of these men. Consequently, in a court of law, no intentional killing is justifiable; a murder is a murder, regardless of circumstances. Nonetheless, a juror states during the voir dire examination, “Ordinarily I’m against [capital punishment].

Read More
170 Words | 1 Pages

‘The Crucible’ is about the Salem Witch Trials that happened in 1692. Arthur Miller used The Salem Witch trials as a metaphor for what occurred during this time period. ‘The Crucible’ is a lot like the Red Scare. ‘The Crucible’ included the witch trials

Read More
1280 Words | 6 Pages

The Crucible gives a firsthand account of the Salem witch trials in 1692. Although the characters are fictional, the story is not. One thing that can be learned from The Crucible is that nobody is safe when it comes to paranoia. Paranoia is the first step into societal failure.

Read More
442 Words | 2 Pages

In Bryan Stevenson’s Just Mercy, he writes to illustrate the injustices of the judicial system to its readers. To do so, Stevenson utilizes multiple writing styles that provide variety and helps keep the reader engaged in the topic. Such methods of his include the use of anecdotes from his personal experiences, statistics, and specific facts that apply to cases Stevenson had worked on as well as specific facts that pertain to particular states. The most prominent writing tool that Stevenson included in Just Mercy is the incorporation of anecdotes from cases that he himself had worked on as a nonprofit lawyer defending those who were unrightfully sentenced to die in prison.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

The Crucible by Arthur Miller, is a play based on the events that occurred during The Salem Witch trials. It follows the townspeople as they accuse more and more women and men as witches. Throughout the Crucible many themes exploit themselves, and many of these themes influence the story itself. Integrity influences the reader's thoughts on different characters, corruption of justice helps the climax grow, and the mass hysteria helps to create the initial problem of the play.

Read More
3453 Words | 14 Pages

Who gets to decide the consequences of actions committed, and if they are proportionate to the original decision itself? People make decisions unknowing of the results. Their original decision could result in getting justice, getting what they deserve, or possibly getting wronged. As shown in this essay, there are various examples of literature, including novels and short stories, that discuss and symbolise the consequences of decisions made and their results in justice. Both the novel Between Shades Of Gray by Ruta Sepety and the short stories “Marionettes Inc.” by Ray Bradburt and “The Possibility Of Evil” by Shirley Jackson all contain and debate this theme.

Read More
503 Words | 3 Pages

“Ethical principles [……] are subjective, emotional commitments that cannot be judged right or wrong. Ideas such as justice or moral good are only the expressions of arbitrary personal preferences and are no more rational than a person’s preference for one kind of beer over” – Timothy Sandefur. In the “The Crucible” by Arthur Miller, a small village named Salem is caught in the midst of a storm of threats and accusations. The little town was originally riled up by the peculiar [account?] of several girls from the town and a slave dancing together in the woods. In order to save themselves from any punishments, the girls and their main leader, Abigail, begin to accuse people of forcing them to go in the woods by using witchcraft on them.

Read More
556 Words | 3 Pages

In the book, The Crucible, by John Miller has a lot of injustice, unfairness and hypocrisy in it. Behavior or treatment means justice. Fairness is the quality of making of making judgements that are free from discrimination. Hypocrisy is the practice of claiming to have moral standards or beliefs to which ones own behavior does not conform. Justice failed to protect the individuals of Salam and who were instead blinded by their personal jealousies and fears.

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

Although, many people that were condemned weren’t actually apart of the Communist Party, (under McCarthyism around 1950-1954) they got blacklisted or lost their jobs. This social injustice is also portrayed in The Crucible as its characters face the Salem Witch Trials. Arthur Miller wrote The Crucible as his own reaction to the injustice of McCarthyism. Miller’s purpose was to show how people accused each other with false denunciations because of their fear, jealousy and solely hatred of one another under McCarthyism.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

The crucibles a play written by Arthur miller. The Salem witch trials, event written by humans. The play only could portray half of the horrors that actual people went through. The crucibles demonstrated the themes of mob mentality and justice.

Read More
1760 Words | 8 Pages

Judgment and hypocrisy have become two themes that we either see, are a victim of, or participate ourselves in our everyday lives. These themes are also seen and used in the book, The Crucible. In The Crucible, the witch trials would have never gotten as far as it got if it weren't for all the judgment, hypocrisy, and lies. Without all the rumors and accusations of witch craft so many innocent people wouldn't have died. Readers will realize that saying something untruthful and making judgments about people will have a bigger consequence than they would have ever imagined.

Read More
767 Words | 4 Pages

Jaxon Bruzgul Mr. Frederick AP English 11 12 February 2023 The Consequences of Victim Mentality In his essay "Epidemic of Accusations," William Shermer explores the phenomenon of mass accusations and how they can spiral out of control. In many ways, this essay serves as a useful lens through which to interpret Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible. The events depicted in the play are seen as a manifestation of the kind of mass hysteria and false accusations that Shermer describes.

Read More
1523 Words | 7 Pages

Through drawing on different historical contexts, these writers could indirectly critique the fundamentally flawed delivery of justice in the political movements they were commenting on. In both The Crucible and Minority Report, we are left questioning the idea of justice itself. We see societies torn apart in the attempt to deliver it, and lives lost to its name. True justice is shown to fall victim to people’s own versions of it repeatedly.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Lying for love, “so-called” murder, and the need for land cause horrific events to happen in the small town of Salem, Massachusetts all because revenge. Arthur Miller’s The Crucible, is during the Salem Witch Trials in 1692. A group of girls pretend to be possessed by witches to cover up what they have done. People get accused of witchcraft and have to testify if they are a witch or not. Revenge in The Crucible is portrayed very negatively throughout the entire story.

Read More
603 Words | 3 Pages

This demand focuses on retribution, or punishing the guilty as much as they deserve.’’ Byron, Michael. "Why My Opinion Shouldn’T Count: Revenge, Retribution, And The Death Penalty Debate." Journal Of Social Philosophy 31.3 (2000): 307-315. Academic Search Premier.

Read More

More about The Crucible Theme Of Justice Essay

Related Topics

Open Document