ipl-logo

The Impacts Of Transcendental Style In The Film Into Great Silence

1923 Words8 Pages

Impacts of Transcendental Style in the film Into Great Silence
The use of film in mainstream media tends to encompass genres such as action, comedy, romance, and horror. These films are usually produced with the same goal in mind. To grab the attention of the audience. A film where the viewer is on the edge of their seat, so engulfed in the story that one cannot leave their seat to use the restroom is what most audiences are drawn to. This is the opposite of the film Into Great Silence (Gröning, 2005). The near silent film displays a unique perspective into a monastery in the French Alps, showing 2 hours and 47 minutes of the daily lives of monks. There are no actors, no comedy, no jaw dropping scenes, and no dialogue. Instead, it uses a unique …show more content…

My mind was racing with questions and frustration as to why anyone would watch this, let alone make something so boring. However, it seemed as though the longer I watched, the deeper my curiosity grew. I began thinking about the practice of these monks, in disbelief of their way of life. Not only was their dedication to their religion incomprehensible, but what truly struck me was the isolation they lived in. They had no clocks or calendars, making them devoid of a sense of time. In many films, a story is told where a lifetime of moments and events are squeezed into roughly two hours. In the film Marley & Me, the 14-year story of a young couple and a dog’s life are shown in an hour and 55 minutes. The viewer loses a sense of time, becoming isolated by what is on screen. Although a yellow lab and a monk have little in common, it is this portrayal of time that makes Into Great Silence so unique. In an interview with Philip Gröning he was asked about how the idea for a film about time turned into a film about silence in which he answered, “I think the most profound experience a viewer can make when watching a film is to get a real feel for time. Usually, this experience is masked by a story. In a film about silence this experience of time is swept up to the surface” Vertigo …show more content…

The director uses many of these transcendental style strategies to challenge the audience like never before. Not often does someone walk into a movie with very little knowledge of the plot. People see movies for reason such as an actor they love, the next movie in a series, or a story plot they know they will enjoy. Unlike most films, it is nearly impossible to depict a plot or storyline for Into Great Silence. Besides knowing the film is about monks in a monastery, the viewer comes in completely blind. I believe Gröning was using the monk’s lifestyle as a distraction to create a film of this style and bring a greater appreciation towards silent films. This idea resonates much more strongly with me as I sit and reflect on how the film grew on me. If someone asked me the night after the viewing if I would watch a similar film, the answer would be a resounding no. However, after days of contemplation and reflection, the experience opened my eyes to this type of cinema. I believe this was one of the goals of the director, encouraging more people to appreciate silent film and view it as a time for reflection. It pushes the viewer beyond the norm, forcing them to step outside their comfort zone. It was this style and message that not only allowed me to appreciate what was being shown on screen, but more importantly the greater concept of

Show More
Related
509 Words | 3 Pages

During the 1830s, an intellectual movement took place called Transcendentalism. Transcendentalism is the idea that an individual is the center of the universe and is more powerful than any institution. This way of thinking was very new to the people during that time. Even though the movement took place well over one hundred years ago, traits of Transcendentalism are still abundant in society today. For example, the movie Wall-E contains many traits of Transcendentalism.

Read More
243 Words | 1 Pages

The methods of underscoring these two films suited each individual well as per the mode of presentation of the movies they used. As seen from the excerpt, they both employed the silent

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

Terence Davies film, “The Long Day Closes” portrays the life of a young homosexual boy living in a postwar society. The main protagonist Bud, represents Davies experience of the good and troubled times that childhood and his sexuality brought him. The Tammy’s in Love scene flawlessly applies mise-en-scene, cinematography, editing and sound to depict the underlying message of finding yourself, a theme that is emphasized throughout the film. The use of mise-en-scene signifies the importance of the setting and surroundings by allowing the viewer to make connections between imagery and plot relevance.

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Both men talked about how with advancements in technology there always has to be something going on. Postman in particular mentioned how it is difficult to sit anywhere and have a moment of silence. Given that people feel the need to be constantly entertained, they miss out on those silent moments. By having silent panels the author is able to make the choice of leaving out meaningless words simply because they feel the need to say something. Similarly to silent panels, scenes in movies and TV that focus more on the image rather than the dialogue can be some of the most moving

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

By the utilization of this technique, the film’s mise-en-scene brings the audience’s attention to the space as a sort of institution of relaxation, in times of

Read More
1170 Words | 5 Pages

With these these two outstanding examples of the same work, the book and the film continue to continues to spark debates sbetween which one is better. Along with Of Mice and Men, there are other books that have film and has create endless debates on which one of those is more effective to convey their message. This MGM film expresses the theme of loneliness and friendship, which relates to our world today by making the world a better place. But what is even more important than these debates about which one is better, is the idea that people analyze film and books. When people analyze films and books, they usually argue about which one is better.

Read More
1149 Words | 5 Pages

Taking many aspects of Wagner, the film becomes a game of musical remembrance of characters, situations, feelings, elements that constitute its own universe and that propelled the success of the series through

Read More
486 Words | 2 Pages

One technique was the long shot where the main subject can be fully seen with a background. For most of these shots, while something is going on in the foreground, a viewer must turn their attention to the background in order to notice any messages. In the film, the Quietus is not specifically talked about like it is in the novel. Instead, there is a scene that shows Theo waking up, and in the corner of the room, a commercial for the Quietus, very much like the one described by Theo in the novel, is being displayed. A viewer might miss this if they were not paying close attention.

Read More
1605 Words | 7 Pages

Buster Keaton uses creative approaches using the body, landscape, and the face that qualifies The General as one of the greatest films in American history. As Cohen writes, “Keaton is a uniquely self-reflexive figure in silent film because he associates his character’s acquisition of physical mastery with the capabilities of his medium;

Read More
687 Words | 3 Pages

During life, many people are persuaded to do extraordinary things. In the unprecedented case of Chris Mccandless, he is driven to the edge of society by a childhood discovery which traumatizes him, as well as the ideas of nonconformity and self-reliance. In Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer, Chris Mccandless is motivated by a family discovery as well as the ideas and tenets of Transcendentalism, to make his trek into the wilderness of Alaska.

Read More
1877 Words | 8 Pages

The Quiet Man plays on stereotypes in order to progress the story which isn’t necessarily bad as it can appeal to a wider and more international audience. The success of filmmakers is told through the setting, themes, characters and how the reception of the film was take

Read More
1441 Words | 6 Pages

In “Aesthetic of Astonishment” essay, Gunning argues how people first saw cinema, and how they are amazed with the moving picture for the first time, and were not only amazed by the technological aspect, but also the experience of how the introduction of movies have changed the way people perceive the reality in a completely different way. Gunning states that “The astonishment derives from a magical metamorphosis rather than a seamless reproduction of reality”(118). He uses the myth of how the sacred audience run out the theater in terror when they first saw the Lumiere Brother Arrival of the train. However, Gunning does not really care how hysterical their reaction is, even saying that he have doubts on what actually happened that day, as for him it the significance lied on the incidence--that is, the triggering of the audience’s reaction and its subsequence results, and not the actual reactions and their extent. It is this incident, due to the confusion of the audience’s cognition caused by new technology, that serves as a significant milestone in film history which triggered in the industry and the fascination with film, which to this day allows cinema to manipulate and

Read More
2800 Words | 12 Pages

Over the past century, film has served as a powerful means of communication to a global audience and has become a vital part of the contemporary culture in a world that is increasingly saturated by visual content. Due to the immediacy and the all-encompassing nature of film, the process of watching a film, is widely perceived to be a passive activity by the general masses. However, quoting Smith in his article about the study of film, “nothing could be further from the truth.” The study and understanding of film as an art form enhances the way we watch and appreciate films. It requires the audience's active participation and interaction with the film in order to fully comprehend the directors' intention behind every creative decision.

Read More
1056 Words | 5 Pages

When this is applied to a commercial, it gives viewers positive ideas and

Read More
1151 Words | 5 Pages

The most apparent themes in this film are loneliness and isolation. Based on the cinematography, it is evident that wide shots of the characters occupy a small space alone or an extremely large space with many people who are completely unaware of their existence. Both of these things work to portray the idea that Murray's character, Bob, and Johansson's character, Charlotte, are lonely, isolated, and missing something. The director also uses the concept of balance to pass the message on the emotional state of the characters.

Read More

More about The Impacts Of Transcendental Style In The Film Into Great Silence

Related Topics

Open Document