ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In Nuclear Engineering

1919 Words8 Pages

Engineering has one main goal, to assist and benefit humanity through its specialized and creative works. Throughout history, many ethical issues have risen in the field of engineering. Some of these issues led to infamous incidents that resulted in the death of many. Though engineers have the capacity and knowledge to create new technology and use it to promote the health and welfare of the population, the result of it may not be sufficient to justify its use. A current moral controversy emerging from this thinking is related to the use of concepts found in nuclear engineering to build thorium reactors. Despite the fact that the goal of these reactors is to supersede fossil fuel energy, moral concerns emerge about whether or not this is the …show more content…

Such arguments can be endorsed by act utilitarianism, an ethical theory that studies the consequences of actions taken to justify their morality. Utilitarians believe that actions that lead to the best consequences for the greatest number of people is deemed as moral. Such theory can be applied to engineering and the technology behind thorium reactors. Those in support of this technology believe and argue that this is the most optimal path to take when compared to other energy sources, along with the benefits that thorium fueled reactors can bring to humanity. Big proponents of nuclear energy support their arguments with the introduction of Molten Salt Reactors. These types of reactors have been previously tested at Oak Rid National Laboratory in the 1960s and were proved to be successful and inherently safe. Molten Salt Reactors are unique, in that, they do not meltdown (fuel is already melted) and operate at atmospheric pressure, hence it makes them inherently safe. Thorium can be used as a fuel in these reactors to produce electrical energy, heat and other valuable products. The result leads to a community in the future that is self-sustained and energy independent. In addition, it would create a …show more content…

In addition, thorium is chemically more stable and more proliferation resistant than uranium. The benefits itself do not directly impact the utilitarian view, but the effects from these benefits do. Such effects are a safer outcome in the event a nuclear meltdown occurs, because thorium releases less radioactivity to the atmosphere. These results provide a greater net positive consequences for utilitarians because it positively affects people in the event that an accident were to occur; thorium fueled reactors can contain the radiation much easier than uranium fueled

Show More
Related
787 Words | 4 Pages

These jobs will both positively impact the environment as well as the economy. Nuclear energy technology has continued to improve with two types of reactors; the Molten Salt Reactor and the Fast Breeding Reactor. Doyle believes nuclear energy will be a beneficial energy source for the

Read More
348 Words | 2 Pages

The general attitude by the public towards nuclear reactors is that of fear or disapproval simply due to its name or the rumors. Nuclear reactors are merely devices that sustain chain reactions, in which only one of the emitted neutrons hits another nucleus to create fission. Though nuclear reactors cannot become a weapon or a bomb, some of the dangers relate to our lives to the extent that we may need to seek alternatives, as demonstrated by the reactors in Three Mile Island and Chernobyl. Nuclear reactors operate on chain reaction, which does not grow due to neutron multiplications of 1. They depend on slow neutrons—in explosion, they are only as powerful as TNT.

Read More
695 Words | 3 Pages

However, there are few opposition opinions. “Rebuttal”: a) Environmental Impact - The process of mining and refining uranium hasn’t been a clean process. b) Nuclear Accidents - The Chernobyl accident that occurred on 26 April 1986 at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant in Ukraine was the worst nuclear accident in the history. c) High Cost - At present, the nuclear business let waste cool for a considerable length of time before blending it with glass and putting away it in enormous cooled, solid structures.

Read More
824 Words | 4 Pages

Over 20 percent of the energy in the United States comes from nuclear energy power plants. (Rinkesh, 2018) They so their best to get as much energy to the country as possible, but there are those out there who don’t agree with them. While there are downsides to nuclear energy, the pros vastly outweigh the cons. Nuclear power plants are a great way to get energy because they don’t let out much pollution, are very efficient, and are very safe.

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

Nuclear power produces fewer carbon emissions than traditional energy sources because energy is not produced by burning molecules but splitting atoms. ‘An energy mix including nuclear power has the lowest impact on wildlife and Ecosystems’ as shown by a Conservation Biology paper. Consequently, greenhouse gas emissions have reduced by nearly half which shows the benefits and popularity of nuclear power use. Nuclear power has many environmental benefits such as small waste production, leaves no adverse effect on water, land or any habitats. By reducing fossil fuel consumption and switching to Nuclear Energy, we will sustain the environment, quality of air, improving the overall quality of

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

If we look at chernobyl, future generations installed safety features into nuclear reactors that prevents them from melting. We learn from our

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

SPACE SHUTTLE COLUMBIA DISASTER Seham Binouf Ibrahim ID: 201210112 Study program: (BSEEE) Email: 201310112@agu.ae.ac Asmae Bornak ID: 201310299 Study program: (BSCSE) Email: 201310299@agu.ae.ac Alaa Samir Halawani ID: 201310036 Study program :( BSEEE)

Read More
1790 Words | 8 Pages

One of these fuels is known as the element thorium. Thorium has great potential to be a reactor fuel because it outputs far more energy at the same cost, as well as being a safer material to use in the event of a nuclear meltdown (“Pros and Cons”). Another pro of nuclear energy is its relative safety compared to other sources of energy. Fossil fuel energy comes with a high rate of accidents and death. Mining accidents, oil rig explosions, and illnesses such as lung cancer and other ailments are far more common to occur than issues with nuclear reactors.

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

Radiological Technologist like all of healthcare professionals have ethical principles. The Standards of Ethics of radiologic technologists is set forth by The American Registry of Radiologic Technologists, also known as ARRT. The Standard of Ethics of Radiologic Technologists are meant to apply any individual who holds certificate and registered by American Registry of Radiologic Technologists, also Standards of Ethics applies to future candidates, like myself, for certification and registration by the American Registry of Radiologic Technologist. According to American Registry of Radiologic Technologists “The Standards of Ethics are intended to be consistent with the Mission Statement of ARRT, and to promote the goals set forth in the Mission Statement.” Certified and registered Radiologic Technologist must uphold the Standards of Ethics, because it sets the professional values on what is meant to be qualified

Read More
3678 Words | 15 Pages

“Nuclear power will help provide the electricity that our growing economy needs without increasing emissions. This is truly an environmentally responsible source of energy.” Michael Burgess Prior to the introduction of nuclear energy, fossil fuel was thought to be the only available source in producing energy. Although fossil fuel, such as coal, petroleum, and natural gas, contains high energy value, it produces too many harmful byproducts that ultimately pollute our environment. With the rising concerns over global warming as more and more greenhouse gases accumulate in our Earth’s atmosphere, many voice such opinions that new alternative, yet sustainable method must be adopted to produce energy.

Read More
1466 Words | 6 Pages

Speaker Credibility Now, it’s obvious that I’m no nuclear engineer, but it has always fascinated me. Growing up very close to Turkey Point nuclear plant in Miami and having a father that worked there, I was able to see things normal people wouldn 't have seen. I got to go into the training room where they train the new reactor operators. And this interest lead me to do more research on the other sources of energy and what I found lead me to this conclusion.

Read More
944 Words | 4 Pages

It is true that there have been major accidents at Three Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima. However those are the only accidents that have occurred in a total of 16,000 cumulative reactor years (“Safety of Nuclear Power Reactors”). The actual amount of accidents that happens are quite low. Moreover, even when those accidents happen, the radiation that you would receive would (normally) be the same or less than what you would receive from natural sources (Lynas). Thus, if those accidents happen, and it is very unlikely that they will, they will not give you any adverse effects when handled

Read More
776 Words | 4 Pages

It has become apparent throughout time that moral conflicts are constantly challenging engineers. Whether it is related to infamous incidents that led to the downfall of professionals or the daily obstacles that engineers face, moral excellence is of the utmost importance in any field. Intellectual and character virtues, as exemplified in the philosophical context, are essential to engineering ethics. Of these virtues, engineers should strive for honesty, courage and fairness. Achieving the aforementioned moral excellences will allow engineers to conduct good judgments and commitment to their professional life.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

New technologies that people had never imagined a decade, or even some decades ago, are now expanding and changing all our lives. Taking smartphones as an example, people in old time had never imagined that small, tiny box could enable people to bring smart computer to everywhere. Yet, smartphones are now completely embedded into our lives and changed how we communicate. Technology lets us live simply, more conveniently, and more easily, but at the same time, it creates complex debates and controversies of ethical problems. In this world, where humans cannot live without the benefits of technology, it is impossible to ignore ethical problems.

Read More
897 Words | 4 Pages

In utilitarian and Kantian view of ethics, such virtuous values are not taken into consideration. This short paper suggests how future engineers should apply the virtues and excellences in their fields and why virtuous engineers are more likely to contribute to society and make it better. In Aristotle’s view, virtue(arête) is defined as an essential factor to achieve happiness of an individual, while happiness(eudaimonia) is defined as an ultimate objective of human-being. Aristotle insisted that the order of priority may decide whether one’s goal should be considered as a means or the goal itself.

Read More

More about Ethical Issues In Nuclear Engineering

Related Topics

Open Document