ipl-logo

The Patriot: Comparing Known History To Movie Magic

1539 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: American revolution a transformation of society

A Historical Analysis of The Patriot: Comparing Known History to Movie Magic Grace Christen HIST 1250: Early America Dr. Rebecca Mancuso March 12, 2023 The Revolutionary War was a time of immense change in the United States and brought about new attitudes, perspectives, and policies, along with the creation of a new country. The fight for American independence from Britain began in 1775 at the Battle of Lexington and Concord and concluded with the colonies' freedom from Britain in 1783 (Ambuske 2018). Today, over two hundred years have passed since the conclusion of the Revolutionary War, but Americans still honor and remember the fight for American independence. The film, The Patriot, directed by Roland Emmerich is one such …show more content…

There are very few colonial loyalists in the movie and the only one that is repeatedly depicted is Captain Wilkins who joins the British forces and is forced with carrying out the burning of a church full of his fellow townspeople (The Patriot, 2000). However, there were many colonial loyalists throughout the colonies. The American Yawp specifies that, “Approximately sixty thousand loyalists ended up leaving America because of the Revolution. Loyalists came from all ranks of American society, and many lived the rest of their lives in exile from their homeland” (Ambuske, The American Yawp, chap. 5). Therefore, The Patriot almost clearly ignores the fact that there would have been loyalists in South Carolina and the other colonies, demonstrating a historical inaccuracy. An additional historical inaccuracy in the film, The Patriot is that the British are portrayed as extremely brutal and did not exclude women and children from the violence of war. Towards the end of the film, British Colonel William Tavington, who is loosely based on Colonel Banastre Tarleton, burns a church full of men, women, and children who had given aid to the Patriots (The Patriot, 2000). Even though there were brutal …show more content…

Roland Emmerich’s depiction of the Revolutionary War is clouded by inaccuracies, fictional characters, and far from realistic and exaggerated depictions of authentic revolutionary America. This movie allows the general public to get a glimpse of the Revolutionary War and the spirit of independence that plagued many colonists, and certainly evokes feelings of patriotism, but if one is looking for a historically accurate film, The Partiot is not the most historically accurate. Consequently, The Patriot is capable of being a learning tool if viewers are aware of the fact that this film is loosely based on historical figures, embellishes some aspects of colonial life and military service, and has numerous inaccuracies. As a result of the factual errors, it is not a solid learning tool, but it does give a glimpse into the Revolutionary War, the time frame of the war, significant battles, and military strategies. The film also slightly conveys a patriotic, American bias, so that should be considered when viewing as well. The characters in The Patriot draw on emotions and use the viewers ability to empathize or their lack of empathy to create a meaningful storyline that centers on the revenge of Benjamin Martin on Colonel William Tavington, influencing the interpretation of the American and British conflict (The Patriot, 2000). In a

Show More
Related
751 Words | 4 Pages

The American Revolution was a war based off principles, and fought by both Loyalists and Patriots. The Loyalists believed that without the kings rule they would lose their fortune, be in chaos, and mob rule; however some were just against the brutality of war. Now the Patriots were complete opposites, patriots believed in principles, freedom;to be free from taxes, the king, the tranny they faced under the rule of the king, to be able to speak when and where you want, and to practice the religion they believe in; but who was actually right the Patriots or the Loyalists. In the novel, My Brother Sam is Dead a family struggles with the decision of being Loyalists or Patriots. War is negative because of the injustice of Life, Jerry, and Sam’s death, all of which convince Tim to become neutral.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Not only does the book highlight the positive reflection on the events of the American Revolution, but gives an overall unbiased insight of the happenings on through Martin eyes. Martin has been successful in portraying the truthful picture of the American Revolutionary War that includes the flawless character and moral perfection coupled with the problems and burdens that befell the army, and how they took it In the initial events of the book, Martin enters the war as a young boy who is anxious to protect his country and experiences noteworthy adventures along the way of his dream. He fights against the

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

In the text, Philbrick's selection of primary sources serve to develop his thesis into multiple authentic and surreal accounts of differing perspectives between loyalists and patriots. In his focus on primary sources, Philbrick knits together firsthand accounts from various Bostonian residents such as John Adams and John Andrews with events leading up to the war. For the most part, reading each journal and firsthand documentary is refreshing, but there are various points when Philbrick's reliance upon certain accounts prove to be unnecessary and exhaustive. He references to countless sources, and while most were significant, many appeared to have miniscule relevance to the main takeaway. For instances, Philbrick purposed John Andrew's narrative to aid readers in understanding the context of everything taking place in Boston during the 1700's, but most of the information referring to Andrew's personal accounts and the British's evacuation appears

Read More
1031 Words | 5 Pages

He starts the book at the beginning of the war and works toward the close of the Revolution. This layout allows for Royster’s main themes to develop as the war is reaching its peak points. As the book develops these key themes begin to intertwine and their significance becomes clear. The reader begins to understand how the American ideals are tied to their relationship with the Continental Army. One of Royster’s key arguments is that the revolutionaries’ loyalty to the war was based on the national character.

Read More
1085 Words | 5 Pages

Patriot Essay Patriot: “A person who loves, supports, and defends his or her country and its interests with devotion. Many people became patriots during the Revolutionary War that lasted from 1775-1783 against the British for independence from Great Britain. America was able to beat the British because of many heroes and leaders. Four such were: Daniel Morgan, Nancy Hart, Nathan Hale, and Sybil Ludington. Daniel Morgan is a leader at the Battle of Cowpens.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

The Patriot and 1776 The films The Patriot and 1776 are both films made to depict what the Revolutionary War and the making of the Declaration went through. They both have many similarities, yet are so different. In The Patriot it is about family and how to live to help them. But in 1776 it's about making the Declaration of Independence and how difficult it was to be someone back then.

Read More
551 Words | 3 Pages

As the colonies sought to break free from British rule and establish an independent nation, the American Revolution was an important turning point in history. However, not all colonists held the same viewpoint on this issue. Loyalists and Patriots emerged as two separate groups with opposing perspectives on American independence from British rule. The opposing views of Loyalists and Patriots on American independence from Great Britain can be analyzed through the perspectives of loyalty to the crown, economic interests, political rights and representation, and social and cultural identity, revealing the complex issues and motivations behind each group's position during the American Revolution. Loyalists, also known as Tories, were strong advocates of the British Crown.

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

During the 1700s America and it’s 13 colonies made a bold decision to revolt from Great Britain and become their own independent nation. This started a revolution that would forever change the way Americans would live. The War of Independence or better known as the American Revolution, consisted of the 13 colonies of America trying to gain independence from Great Britain and on July 4th 1776, America finally decided to declare their independence. Many say the revolution paved the way for many other great changes to take place, while others believed not a lot was impacted due to the revolution. This raises the question, “How Revolutionary was the American Revolution?”

Read More
844 Words | 4 Pages

The majority of people during the American Revolution fought for liberty without realizing the actual cost and brutal reality of war. In the novel My Brother Sam is Dead, the Meeker family consisting of a Father name Life, a Mother named Susannah, a rebellious teen named Sam, and a conflicted teen named Tim, journey through the life of colonists owning a tavern during the Revolutionary War. Sam departs from his family to fight alongside the Patriots going against his Father, a Tory. War brings a lot of terrible things, but some examples are families splitting, clash of generation, and an overall theme of principle vs reality. The soldiers who fought in the war thought they were fighting for liberty, when really they caused havoc and awfulness.

Read More
529 Words | 3 Pages

I believe that the movie ‘The Patriot’ is somewhat historically accurate based on comparisons and contrasts between ‘The Patriot’ and history. ‘The Patriot’ is a movie that was made in the year 2000 based on the Revolutionary war. This movie starred Mel Gibson as Benjamin Martin. The movie is about how Benjamin Martin led the militia against the British army. This final will compare and contrast the movie and actual history to show that the movie was somewhat historically accurate.

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout the book you can see each point of view. The first point of view is the Patriots. They want to be free of the British. They want their own land to rule with fairness. Throughout the book these Patriots fight for their freedom.

Read More
663 Words | 3 Pages

Realism is shown through the portrayal of young people, sentimentalism, and American society. (Stephen Crane revised edition) In the “The Red Badge of Courage”, Henry Fleming, the young protagonist, is cast into a literal “trial by fire” that will test his courage. War can change a young person’s frame of mind entirely.

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

In this essay I will be analyzing the overall attitude and movie of two movies. Both movies deal with the issue of the American revolutionary war. First one, “1776” a broadway musical transfer to the big screen, directed by Peter H. Hunt and realeased on 1972. Second one, “The Patriot”, more “popcorn” type movie, directed by Roland Emmerich, and realeased on 2000. We discussed 1776 is darker, almost pessimistic movie.

Read More
1121 Words | 5 Pages

The Patriot is a movie filmed displaying the time of the American Revolution, it is a very historically inaccurate film that features few historical accuracies. The Patriot offers inaccurate character portrayal, cultural details and social details. The few dainty accuracies of the film include apparel, battle occurence, and gun usage. As the movie progresses many parts throughout the film do not align with proper historical accuracy. The inaccuracies may seem true to the common eye but with proper intel it is clearly seen to be erroneous.

Read More
996 Words | 4 Pages

The movie The Patriot is about the American Civil War of Liberation that occurred in the 1770s. In this film, you will see Americans who is fighting against the British military for freedom. Benjamin Martin once proved a great heroism during the war against the French and Indians. Then he retired, bought a farm and married a woman with whom he formed a large family.

Read More

More about The Patriot: Comparing Known History To Movie Magic

Related Topics

Open Document