ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of American Immigration Reform

1777 Words8 Pages

According to a study conducted by the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), the cost of harboring illegal immigrants each year in the United States is $113 billion. The Department of Homeland Security estimates that there are approximately twelve million undocumented immigrants currently residing in the United States. Based on these statistics, it is not a surprise that immigration reform has taken top priority on the agenda of the Obama Administration. Suggestions on a workable solution have created a division between citizens, advocates, and political parties. On proposed solution is grating amnesty to illegal immigrants. However, opponents argue that granting amnesty not only violates an important principle within our legal …show more content…

In an attempt to discredit the Perryman Report, the Federation for American Immigration Reform conducted their own study and found that an estimated $52 billion was spent on education for the children of illegal immigrants (Fox News). Here we have two different reports on opposite sides of the spectrum. In order to fully comprehend illegal immigration on the whole, it is imperative to understand the effects it has on our economy, demography, and the people (citizens/legal aliens and illegal immigrants). Only then, can we decipher whether the pros outweigh the cons or …show more content…

Their rebuttal to the argument that illegal immigrants harm the economy by displacing low-skilled natives and depressing wages is simply that illegal immigrants do jobs that U.S. workers refuse to do. Because illegal immigrants are considered to be part of the secondary sector (low earnings, unskilled work, and job impermanence) they are more likely to accept jobs in poor working conditions. In addition, they maintain that there is a lack of evidence demonstrating that illegal immigrants and native workers occupy the same jobs

Show More
Related
126 Words | 1 Pages

Our current immigration system is broken, harms our economy, and does not reflect our values as a nation. Without true immigration reform, we suffer severe economic, cultural, fiscal and political strains in communities across America. Immigration has become an urging issue in legislation on both the national and state levels. Immigration legislation made the policy agenda in all 50 states in 2007, with 46 states enacting into law a total of 240 immigration-related bills. This proposal of the “Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act of 2015” (H.R.213) stands out as the most promising measure to fix part of the problems.

Read More
333 Words | 2 Pages

First, I think it 's cute how you 're dictating what I should think, as if I 'm incapable of developing an knowledgeable opinion. Secondly, before we continue with Immigration reform we have to shut the border and figure out what to do with the people here. Period. The only reason you have to shut the border is due to the welfare state.

Read More
662 Words | 3 Pages

Comprehensive immigration reform would not only be a practical and humane solution to clarifying the legal status of the estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants that currently reside in this country (Dann 2013), but would also address the issues of labor demand and immigration enforcement. Citizenship would be granted to those undocumented immigrants currently within our borders. These people have established a life here in America. Most work and pay taxes, some have children who were born here and thus have citizenship, and all consume goods and services which benefit the economy. It would also be impractical to deport an estimated 11 million people in any reasonable time frame.

Read More
1520 Words | 7 Pages

Policies relating to undocumented minors in the US are of key importance because of how powerful and influential the group can be. Although undocumented minors and students living in the United States lack official rights of residency, immigration policies should be altered to allow citizenship for these future Americans in order to benefit individuals and the country as a whole. Providing undocumented immigrants a future in the United States welcomes a large, diverse group of people to the country, allowing for improvements in the labor force that would not be possible without granting citizenship. The United States continues to grow greatly due to immigration: “More than 80 percent of the population growth over the next generation in the United States will be via migration”, meaning that more immigrants are entering the country than native-born citizens (Gonzales 3). With this large number of people coming to America from around the globe, the labor force will continue to expand and benefit from the varying skills.

Read More
1195 Words | 5 Pages

Unaware to their large, necessary contributions to American communities and the economy, more than 33% of the U.S population does not think a legal status should be given to illegal immigrants (Wright 6). This also includes DACA recipients, illegal immigrants who were brought to the United States by their parents when they were less than sixteen years of age. This belief can then lead to attacks, mostly led on by bigoted thoughts. There are two main categories of sorts of judgments, “Attribute-based and Categorical judgements passed on a prejudice of certain ethnic groups and religious groups suggest that illegal immigrants individual attribute will affect their way of living in the U.S” (Wright 7).

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

Immigration reform has been a big issue for our country in recent years. Many U.S. citizens claim that immigration is harmful to the US economy. In just 20 years, we have seen the average number of immigrants per year jump a staggering 20%. This has lead to the biased opinions we see towards immigration today. Currently, our country is not receiving any benefit from immigration.

Read More
915 Words | 4 Pages

A 21st-century immigration system will accelerate the integration process for a facet of natives who aspire to call the United States home. Reforming will bring legality to thousands of immigrants who live in this country without a legal status. A new system that is reflective of our status will satisfy the American people knowing these individuals are paying taxes, accounted for and contributing to what we believe is the American dream will calm fears and promote unity. This is a common interest of all American people. This will solidify the numerical reality and replace an outdated system that disconnects Americans and disarms those who desire to become citizen.

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

Ever since the United States declared itself independent in 1776, immigrants have flocked to the country in search of freedom and opportunity. In the past, the government has developed many different ways to deal with the rushing flow of immigrants. However, new challenges have emerged over the past few years. Today, the government of the United Stat es faces many challenges of trying to develop immigration policies that fit the needs of the country. These policies would need to deal with who to let in, how many people to admit, and how to deal with the influx of illegal immigrants.

Read More
1633 Words | 7 Pages

The U.S. political landscape is influenced by the debates over immigration and the pros and cons associated with it. It is necessary for policymakers to construct a compatible secure, economic, and humanitarian environment in this country. It has always been a challenge for Congress to formulate comprehensive immigration reform that support the country regarding security and economic issues. The Congress was also unable to incorporate the implication of vital policy decisions into the judicial and executive branch of the government that would enable the whole system to take certain actions against illegal immigration, which somehow was causing scarcity of resources. This issue also causes a severe effect on the economy and security of the United

Read More
544 Words | 3 Pages

Immigration in the United States is questioned to be wicked or precise; Although, there are several immigrants looking for a better surroundings, many figure it will agonize the country rather than assistance it. Culture and diversity is what builds America and unites us as a whole so why shall we limit those who have Franklin D Roosevelt Quotation has a very valid point; Even though, immigration is not legalized is e pros will outweigh the pros in this conflict that has prolonged for years. Immigration should be granted amnesty; There are lots on immigrants out there trying to make a better life. It is said “That everyman is equal” so why would the government make it seem like we aren’t.

Read More
1204 Words | 5 Pages

Illegal immigration is also one of the negative impacts of immigration policies because of the many other affects it brings to a community. Illegal immigration can affect job securities, crime prevention, health care services, public education, the national security, but most importantly the economy as a whole. “With the growing numbers of illegal immigrants, they will need social programs like government, schools, and hospitals. They may also need to be included in the socialized housing programs if necessary” (U.S. Guide). Basically, when illegal immigrants enter the country they will need help from the government to attempt to live a good life, schools because everyone needs an education to get somewhere in their lives, and hospitals in case an emergency occurs.

Read More
2228 Words | 9 Pages

Another example of the opposing sides argument on how illegal immigrants contribute to the US economy would be a statement by Francine J. Lipman, who is a professor of Law, Business and Economics at Chapman University. Professor Lipman had stated in 2007 that undocumented immigrants contribute through their investments and consumption of goods and services. On the other hand, although illegal aliens fill the jobs of those Americans that don’t want to take on the labor force, it is still a job for the American people, which should be an option available to tax paying people. It is well known that illegal immigrants do not pay their fair share uncle Sam, something that the American people do on a constant basis. Another article proving the point that illegal immigration does burden the American economy would be an article written by historical fiction and nonfiction novelist Walter Coffey.

Read More
1959 Words | 8 Pages

Excluding any costs involving children, an immigrant without a high school diploma typically creates a lifetime fiscal drain of $89,000. The average lifetime fiscal drain is $31,000 for an immigrant with only a high school diploma. More educated immigrants, however, are capable of creating a lifetime fiscal surplus of $105,000. The ordinary illegal immigrant possesses only ten years of schooling and uses nearly $14,400 more is services than it paid in taxes.

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

Immigration, especially as it pertains to illegal immigration is one of the most pressing issues in the United States today. To expound on the subject matter is one that would most certainly trigger passionate opinions. These diverse viewpoints and passions will often result in conversations exploding. Our current system is in shambles.

Read More
778 Words | 4 Pages

People in favor of immigration would believe that “[i]mmigration has been an engine of economic dynamism and a wellspring of economic vitality in the United States.... The diversity of skills [immigrants] infuse into the economy yields dividends that no other country can claim.” Immigrants

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of American Immigration Reform

Related Topics

Open Document