ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Canadian Electoral Reform

2447 Words10 Pages

The Pros and Cons of Canadian Electoral Reform: A Critical Analysis

The topic of Canadian electoral reform is a pivotal and controversial issue in Canadian political discourse, with advocates contending that it will result in enhanced representation and stimulated voter engagement. The heart of the discourse lies within the topic of removing the first-past-the-post system in favour of a proportionately representative system. A change would result in enhanced democratic representation as well as an increase in voter engagement. While those in support of the first-past-the-post system convey that this system maintains stability and accountability within the democratic environment, critics voice concerns over hindered inclusivity, especially …show more content…

Figueroa v. Canada is an especially important example of the complexities of shifts to the Canadian electoral system and electoral reform in general (Katz, 2011). Figueroa v. Canada, a 2003 decision of the Supreme Court to remove the previous requirements for political parties to nominate 50 candidates in unique constituencies to receive registered party status. This case, being the only case in Canadian history to require legislative amendments on four occasions, was built around the leader of the Communist Party of Canada, Miguel Figueroa, and his desire to have his party’s name established on the ballot for the upcoming election at the time. The resulting decision of 50 candidates being unconstitutional has carried major implications for future changes to the electoral system. While this decision of the Supreme Court of Canada does not directly affect the specific electoral reform issue of the electoral system, this case directly shows the complexities of working around specifically stated measures within Canadian jurisprudence. Libman v. Quebec, Longley v. Canada, and Harper v. Canada, all related to the electoral process or voter rights, were circulating the legal system similarly debating the legality of specific parts of the electoral process that …show more content…

By examining their respective statistical outcomes and implications on the political landscape, the perspective of system effectiveness can be determined. It is also important to understand that in the event of a change in electoral systems or any case of electoral reform, voter engagement and response to electoral issues and events will be altered compared to the original format and experience. Historically, in periods of increased popularity toward electoral reform, there are certain benchmarks that tend to stay constant. Voter turnout tends to follow a significant decline in such periods of time as well as significant increases in opposition support for electoral reform in the same period (Leduc, 2009, 23; Elections Canada, 2019). However, the Ontario Citizen’s Assembly, a group of randomized Ontario citizens designed to educate the selected group members and create a proposal for whether electoral reform in Ontario would be beneficial and the specific type of electoral reform that would be the most beneficial. Through months of education, deliberation, and study of all the data and information available, the recommendation came forward to be a form of proportional representation called mixed member proportional. Mixed member

Show More
Related
1526 Words | 7 Pages

4)Robert J. Sharpe, Patricia I. McMahon Persons Case: The Origins and Legacy of the Fight for Legal Personhood. Toronto: Univ of Toronto Press, 2007, 1-206 5) Michael Dorland and Maurice René. Charland, Law, rhetoric and irony in the formation of Canadian civil culture (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2002), 218. 6) Vivien Hughes.

Read More
1137 Words | 5 Pages

The greatest reform of democracy came from the people pushing the boundaries of what a democracy should be—the Progressive Movement. If there is to be hope of abolishing partisan gerrymandering and bringing true voting equality, or at least moving toward equality, for the first time in U.S. history, it is going to require another social movement, similar to the Progressive

Read More
1213 Words | 5 Pages

Much like the infamous Siberian snow leopard, the first past the post system is a predator in the way it targets small parties and causes discord amongst the Canadian people. But, also like the fierce Siberian snow leopard, the first past the post system does not belong in Canada. When Trudeau stepped into office he brought with him many promises he has yet to fulfill, one of which is to focus on the electoral system and looking into alternatives. Canada has been continuously playing themselves by using first past the post. Ever since the creation of the Canadian government in 1867, the Canadian electoral process has been exposed to manipulation through its chosen electoral process.

Read More
3068 Words | 13 Pages

The Senate is a chamber of "sober second thought" in which its members review the legislation that has passed through three readings in the House of Commons. They review most of the bills with a lens that explanations for their regional constituents, particularly those who may not have figured into the debate of the MPs who represent most their constituents, and evaluate how each new law or policy would affect the Canadian people (Dodek, 2015, 39). But this legislative body has long been criticized for not being representative of a democracy and there is no time in our history in which there have not been calls for its abolition or reform. According to Docherty (2002) the Canadian Senate "represents and embodies some of the most anti-democratic

Read More
1045 Words | 5 Pages

Although I agree that Powell highlights the general problem of all human affairs and the conditions under which they occur, Steele fails to emphasize and clearly point to the current economic system as the biggest hindrance to democracy. At the barest, Steele refers to an intangible force which truly governs, regardless of one’s Cabinet position. Thus, if citizens chose to participate in politics to serve the public, balance competing interests, and create a most just and equitable society, both Powell’s maxim and capitalist ethics render such aspirations elusive, at best. The purpose of this essay is to demonstrate that the proper democratic functioning of Canadian society is hindered by dishonest relations between political parties and electorate, and more importantly, that it is not enough to have democratic institutions if the economic system is governed by and for a particular few at the expense of the

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

Aucoin Essay Our new prime minister of Canada, Justin Trudeau has given a set of democratic reforms to minister LeBlanc who has been given the task to deal with the problems regarding parliament issues. Our prime minister has promised Canadians real change to the way the government governs by committing to invest in Canada’s growing economy, to strengthen the middle-class, to help the hard working class, to provide help to those whom need it most compared to those who do not need it, and to invest in the public to create jobs, economic growth and a broad-based expansion. Aucoin’s democratic reform proposal tests for good reforms that include clear objectives, no loopholes, clear enforcement mechanism, entrench the house of commons power, fixed

Read More
1531 Words | 7 Pages

The Canadian Senate has been a fundamental part of Canadian Democracy since the Constitution Act, 1867. It was created to protect minorities from the tyranny of the majority in the House of Commons. For 147 years the Senate has acted as the house of “sober-second” thought in the Canadian Parliamentary system. Overall, the senate has performed exceptionally at its role, but due to recent scandal and corruption the good work of the Senate been ignored. This has caused calls for reform to be brought back into the Canadian spot light.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

Institutional and historical analysis often portray the motives of governments, especially in the cases of Quebec separatism and Aboriginal mistreatment. History describes attempts at compromise to rectify the problems by altering political institutions to provide more autonomy to the provinces, witness in various accords and the methods described previously. However, in regards to Aboriginals a historical relationship of exploitation and eradication sheds on the systemic issues that Aboriginals cope with and the institutions that caused them. As scholars of Canadian politics, it is important to consider historical and institutional analyses when looking at any issue, as it reveals the underlying motives of actors in regards to the cleavages that comprise a state.

Read More
1425 Words | 6 Pages

If we were to take a close look at the House of Commons, we would instantly notice that most individuals are white men, supporting one of only four political parties. Statistically speaking, twenty percent of Canada’s population is of visible minority or Aboriginal status however only a mere eight percent of recent MP’s are non-white individuals. Based on this information, we can make a cultivated assumption that Canadian minorities are severely underrepresented in political life. Senate reform provides a legitimate chance for our country to address this long-established and indelible shortcoming. According to Gibbins and Roach (2010), “Electing Senators through some form of proportional representation should be a key element of Senate reform.

Read More
1988 Words | 8 Pages

For a long time, political parties have shaped how people assess governmental affairs and how they organize themselves in society. Generally, political parties seek to resemble the political ideologies on which they are based to provide people with a universal worldview and philosophical stance from which to approach reality (Breaugh, Jan 18). Yet, is it true that political parties always, and in all cases, accurately reflect the political ideologies on which they are based? In this paper, I will discuss four claims from the conservative and liberal parties of Canada. I will start by analyzing two claims from the conservative party and two claims from the liberal party to draw differences and similarities between them and assess whether both parties stick to the political ideologies they seek to represent.

Read More
1565 Words | 7 Pages

Democracy within our country has been questioned and tested through our voting system. In America, our system for electing our president has remained under a process that aims to benefit our nation. By doing this, America uses the Electoral College, in which may cause disputes about the process of electing our president. Overall, there are advantages and disadvantages within the concept of winner-take all system, representing our nation as a whole, and equality of our votes. The Electoral College can be reformed to establish a more democratic voting system in order to allow for the voices of American citizens to be heard.

Read More
1118 Words | 5 Pages

Jerome Black and Lynda Erickson in article studies Canadian cases to analysis if voter bias contributes to the underrepresentation of racial minorities in the national legislatures of diverse societies. The representation in Canada’s House of Commons of the minority ethnic population has improved in the past two decades. Nevertheless, some minority groups remain under representative. They also assumed that minimizing the gap by pressure does not help to make a signify differences in anytime soon.

Read More
808 Words | 4 Pages

This essay will argue that our current system of First Past the Post is the best systems to have in place for Canada today and why it is currently a better option than the alternative systems of Proportion voting and majoritarian systems. Our current system of First Past the Post works in a simple way that all

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

Words often associated with democracy are freedom, choice, representation, voice and opinion. However, what happens when there is an excessive number of representatives and too many politicians voicing their opinions? The choice of who to vote for becomes harder due to the barrage of opinions. The influx of political parties has greatly affected the elections, as poll results show that minority parties are receiving votes from Canadians which diminishes the amount of votes going to the main parties.

Read More
1312 Words | 6 Pages

"Candidate with the highest number of the vote wins the right to represent the particular seat in the House of Commons", according to CBC news. There are some limitations regarding this method. First of all, it could possibly happen that candidate with less than half vote wins, which means it only reaches minority people's desired outcome. In addition to the tactical voting, the two-party system could be a serious problem. Since only the first matters, candidates with the low possibility to win may exist the election.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Canadian Electoral Reform

Related Topics

Open Document