ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Civil War

1066 Words5 Pages

Arguments both for and against this paper could be made on theoretical grounds. On the one hand, one could argue, as Thompson (2007; 56) and Spalding (2009; 64), among others, asserts, that “interstate war (in contrast to civil war) can lead to a strengthening of states, by forcing participant states to strengthen their power in order to survive. On the other hand, it can be argued that “states or the state system have changed, and that war is unlikely to have such effects in contemporary conditions”. (Thompson 2007; Spalding 2009). As Mahmood Mamdani asserts: “we have just ended a century replete with violence. The twentieth century was possibly more violent than any other in recorded history. Just think of world wars and revolutions, and …show more content…

It is violence that is neither revolutionary nor counter-revolutionary, violence that cannot be illuminated by the story of progress, that appears senseless to us. Not illuminated paradigmatically, non-revolutionary violence appears pointless. Unable to explain it, we turn our back on history. Two such endeavours are worth noting. The first turns to culture, the second to theology.
The cultural turn distinguishes modern from pre-modern culture and then offers premodern culture as an explanation of political violence. If revolutionary or counter-revolutionary violence arises from market-based identities such as class, then non-revolutionary violence is said to be an outcome of cultural difference”. (Mamdani, 1996; 133 - 35).
This paper takes the discussion of the links between race, war or violence and state formation as its starting point. It focuses on the conflict in South West Africa (Namibia) and Rwanda, and asks whether these conflicts have led to strengthening of the state in Rwanda and …show more content…

In the milieu of fluidity ethnic consciousness and "way of life" may be created and reinforced to maintain the status quo at certain times and be transformed to embrace other social constructs at other times”. (Haug, 1998; 90).
3. POLITICAL VIOLENCE IN POST-COLONIAL AFRICA
Arendt argues that: “Of the two main political devices of imperialist rule, race was discovered in South Africa, and bureaucracy in Algeria, Egypt and India; the former was originally the barely conscious reaction to tribes of whose humanity European man was ashamed and frightened, whereas the latter was a consequence of that administration by which Europeans had tried to rule foreign peoples whom they felt to be hopelessly their inferiors and at the same time in need of their special protection”. (Arendt, 1975; 41). Race, in other words, was an escape into irresponsibility where nothing human could any longer exist, and bureaucracy was the result of a responsibility that no man can bear for his fellow man and no people for another

Show More
Related

Condoleezza Rice Rhetorical Analysis

457 Words | 2 Pages

In this interview, it illustrates how power may ignite cultures to have a division based on their cultural group. It may cause a nation to become captivated by misleading mistakes and false representation of a political group. Although, segregation exists, individuals felt the need to react in ways that became unjustifiable causing destruction affecting beliefs, values, and other perspectives amongst other cultures, religions, and beliefs differently than their own. By taking the lives of innocent individuals and shaping and conforming lives according to their biases alters how children may shape their own human world views based on exceptionalism, power and segregation, and improving history and evolution through integration.

Read More

Summary Of Is Religion Killing Us By Jack Nelson-Palsmeyer

1432 Words | 6 Pages

Normally, people look at religion as a tool for peace and rarely associate it with violence. In reality, religion has been used as a tool to justify violence for centuries. In the book called ‘Is Religion Killing Us?’, the author, Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer, critically examines the sacred scriptures of the major religions including Christianity, Islam, and Judaism to unveil despicable portraits of a violent God. According to Pallmeyer, each sacred text is dominated by what he calls ‘violence-of-God-tradition’. He does not believe that the texts directly instigate the human violence, but they justify the use of violence amid the conflicts in which antagonistic parties see religious differences as divisions.

Read More

Modernity Of Genocides Eric D. Weitz Analysis

1524 Words | 7 Pages

Synopsis In Eric D. Weitz’s article, “The Modernity of Genocides: War, Race, and Revolution in the 20th century,” the author investigates the connection between modernity and genocide to understand why genocides became more frequent, and more systematic, in the 20th century. Weitz remarks that there appeared a synthesis between the European revolutionary movements and race thinking, a pseudoscience that had become hegemonic in the period. This synthesis, Weitz argues, was unique to the 20th century in that the political chaos that allowed for the seizure of power by popular revolutions coincided with the dominance of racial thinking that infected the platforms of these political groups. By these racially twisted platforms, the revolutionary

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Violence Vanquished

1017 Words | 5 Pages

Another fact Pinker uses to illustrate how the violence started and how we are where we stand today in society is “Forensic archaeology – a kind of “Csi : Paleolithic” can estimate rates of violence from the proportion of skeletons in an ancient site with bashed in skulls, decapitations or arrowheads embedded in bones.” With this evidence from the text the reader may also conclude that not only was the era of primitive society barbaric, but those who committed the crimes didn’t value human life. In contrast to this Pinker’s uses the fact, “On average 15% of people in pre-state eras died violently compared to about 3% of the earliest states”. This evidence from the article illustrates to the readers that before the earliest states were made more than one fifth of people died from violent deaths in the world’s

Read More

Analysis Of Religion, Identity, And Violence By Rabbi David Rosen

584 Words | 3 Pages

Summary Upon investigation of the article titled, Religion, Identity, and Violence by Rabbi David Rosen, the author drew very clear conclusions on religion’s role in violence around the world. This article’s thesis gets at religions role in violence and why it seems religion is the main suspect in the cause of many of today’s wars and conflicts. Rabbi Rosen specifically ask the question, “Why is religion so easily exploited in this manner” (Rosen, p13)? This statement is directly referring to the thought that religion is automatically the cause of conflicts, while territorial conflicts and other issues could be the cause of violence, using religion as a sort of cover for their disputes.

Read More

The Weather Underground Was Influenced By The Vietnam War

298 Words | 2 Pages

Their turn to violence was not as abstract as one might think as violence

Read More

Violence In Robert Pinker's Better Angels

1035 Words | 5 Pages

The central thesis of “Better Angels” is that our era is less violent, less cruel and more peaceful than any previous period of human existence. The decline in violence holds for violence in the family, in neighborhoods, between tribes and between states. People living now are less likely to meet a violent death, or to suffer from violence or cruelty at the hands of others, than people living in any previous century. The 20th century, the century of Hitler, Stalin and Pol Pot, of Mao in China and Mobutu in the Congo, was horrendous, but the number of deaths by violence as a proportion of the total population remained unexceptional compared with the brutal cruelties of the wars of religions in the 17th century.

Read More

Hannah Arendt's Critique On Violence

2052 Words | 9 Pages

Violent means can be justified by its ends, but it can be a risk of overwhelming the ends as a result of the unpredictable outcome due to unexpected events (Arendt 1969:4). The implements of violence are characterised as the tools which give more power of the one who possesses it (Arendt

Read More

Gendering The Israel-Palestinian Conflict Essay

976 Words | 4 Pages

Though the essay was limited at the two events, the analysis, however, can be applied throughout the conflict because of the fact that the justification for violence used by the two parties has remained fundamentally identical. Most of the time one party attacks because of “self- protection” and “self-defence”; and the narrative has always been evolved around “we” versus “them”, and “ours” versus “theirs”. The characteristics of “militarising”, “racialising”, “protecting”, and “self-defending” has long been associated with masculinity; as a result, they are vindicated because of the socially constructed role of masculinity which is being superior and powerful. This gives way to an endless cycle of violence.

Read More

Violence Practices When Oppression By Gandhi Essay

501 Words | 3 Pages

Violence Practiced when Oppressed Violence is the root of hate. If you water it with more violence, it will grow- never taming it. The poisonous tree will bloom with fruits bearing more hate and injustice than before. The cause, even if it is a good one, will be lost within the fight, resulting in pure violence. In violence people forget who they are; they forget why and what they are fighting for.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Revolutions

225 Words | 1 Pages

Some historians said that revolutions are harmful to humanity. They believed that revolts and rebellions were the cause of thousands of deaths within the country. Yet this was true, many people die, but the people fought and died for a good cause. The people knew that if they don’t take action against evil leaders or unjust societies, they would live their life suffering and without happiness. So instead, rebels decided they must change the way people act, and they express their enmity as violence.

Read More

Sociological View Of Religious Violence

1504 Words | 7 Pages

Religious violence arises from the uncertain, and undefinable aspects of religious thought. In this case, the very nature of religious violence is something which is distinctly religious, as it is a direct result of interpretation and translation of religious rhetoric. Religious ‘militancy’ is a consequence of this ambivalence, in which both the peaceful and the violent are able to turn radical. Religion is neither inherently peaceful or violent - instead it is a matter of interpretation, or circumstance as to what is believed. In this vain, other ideology is able to be considered ambivalent, such as nationalism or Marxism, and can simultaneously inspire both violence and peace.

Read More

Political Violence Analysis

1427 Words | 6 Pages

However, when deviating participants turn to the utilization of physical force to compel planned change, then the threat turns violent (Schweitzer, 2002). When individuals or group of individuals resort to the violence to achieve political nature’s change, one states about political violence. Violence only turns political when utilized instrumentally to affect or control power’s

Read More

John Galtung's Theory Of Conflict Analysis

1038 Words | 5 Pages

The violent conflict approach is defined through coercion, threats, and destructive assaults. Galtung’s, model suggests that each of these components influence one another, and while each

Read More

African Ethnic Conflict

901 Words | 4 Pages

Yet many of these conflicts have arisen due to political competition canvassed with deep rooted grievances of the “divide and rule policy” of the colonials (Mamdani, 2009). In South Sudan, ethnic interests set a crucible of conflict between the Nuer and Dinka. The discordant or contradicting interests has cut a swathe through all forms of ethnic cohesion and to a large extent political patriotism (Akiwumi, 1999). In Rwanda, when the majority Hutu rose against the designated politically economically dominant Tutsi minority a cataclysmic explosion took place, the genocide (Mamdani, 2009). In Kenya, the 2007/8 contested election which almost led to outbreak of a civil war in Kenya due to conflict of interest between the Kikuyu and Luo.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Civil War

Related Topics

Open Document