ipl-logo

The Response To Herbert Hoover's Critique Of The New Deal

981 Words4 Pages

Response to Herbert Hoover’s Critique of the New Deal. Herbert Hoover’s speech on the eve of the 1932 election presents a critical perspective on Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal, framing it as a dangerous departure from established American principles. While Hoover attempts to position the election as a pivotal choice between two philosophical visions for the country, his arguments often appear defensive and conservative, revealing a reluctance to embrace necessary changes to address the Great Depression. This response will analyze Hoover’s key points and assess their validity in the context of the period. Hoover begins by asserting that the election is “more than a contest between two men”. It is more than a contest between two parties. It …show more content…

His fear of change to “the whole foundations of our national life” lacks substantive detail and seems more like an appeal to tradition than a reasoned argument against the New Deal. If these foundations, built through “generations of testing and struggle,” were truly effective, they would not be collapsing under the strain of the Great …show more content…

Programs like the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and the Works Progress Administration (WPA) aim to create jobs and stimulate economic activity. The Social Security Act introduced a safety net for the elderly and unemployed, fundamentally transforming the relationship between the government and its citizens. These measures represented a bold departure from the policies of the past and a recognition that significant government intervention was necessary to restore economic stability and public confidence. Hoover’s emphasis on maintaining the “American system” overlooks the fact that the system has already failed millions of Americans. His speech reflects a reluctance to acknowledge the need for substantial reform. By clinging to traditional values and practices, Hoover failed to offer a viable path forward. His assertion that the American system had demonstrated its “validity and superiority” is contradicted by the widespread hardship and despair that characterized the era.The ongoing hardships showed the urgent need for new solutions and major

Show More
Related
1149 Words | 5 Pages

Hoover carried the blame for the Depression. The American people believed that he wasn’t doing enough in attempt to alleviate such a ruinous economic depression, so in the election of 1932 they demanded a change. Winning by a landslide, democrat Franklin Delano Roosevelt took over for Hoover and went on to become the longest-serving president in American history. Roosevelt believed that the government had to play a stronger role in the economy if America was to see any future prosperity. In his first inaugural address, Roosevelt utilizes metaphorical language, a personal and honest tone, and pathos in attempt to revive the lost trust and confidence of the American people in its federal government.

Read More
928 Words | 4 Pages

In Opposite of Hoover was Franklin Delano Roosevelt, the man who the American public saw as their saviour and as the one who singlehandedly led them out of the depression. This paper is going to compare and contrast Hoover and Roosevelt's policies in an attempt to explain why one

Read More
1091 Words | 5 Pages

Hoover did not want to do the work himself but rather put all of this pressure of a failing economy on state governments and the people of America. Still trying to exhibit the laissez-faire mentality entering presidency. The people of America needed change from someone who made some attempt to govern the country, to someone that would get involved and become applicable to the time of

Read More
134 Words | 1 Pages

Hoover’s run of ‘laissev-faire’ influenced the country politically for a good decade, through the introduction of the New Deal. Without the failure of Rugged individualism and the dire consequences of the Wall street crash, the

Read More
1389 Words | 6 Pages

Within the first one hundred days of the New Deal Roosevelt established the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) as well as the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA). Therefore, within the first one hundred days Roosevelt had already set America on its path to recovery. Kennedy also talks about the Social Security Act and it’s importance in shaping the modern welfare state. Ultimately, Kennedy argues that the New Deal helped everyone escape from the depression and receive a sense of security for the

Read More
525 Words | 3 Pages

Whether Americans decided to vote with or against the New Deal, both would take time and trust in the presidential candidates. As Hoover stated “the proposal to alter the whole foundations of our national life which have been built through generations of testing and struggle” (Hoover 3), he was discussing the original system that America has been using and how he was positive this system would benefit the citizens

Read More
931 Words | 4 Pages

Although the Great Depression had torn apart the prosperity of the United States, hope soon enough resurfaced in the form of presidential candidate Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s promises of a “new deal”. However, Roosevelt’s attempts at economic and social reform met mixed results - although his efforts to mend the extreme personal debt of farms and banks (as well as the general population) did succeed (at least in part), his attempts to remedy the unemployment crisis and the growing national debt were failures, and in the case of national debt, he may have even made the problem worse. The origin of these failures is likely the methods Roosevelt used themselves - one effort to fix the economy surrounding farmers was even deemed unconstitutional,

Read More
1080 Words | 5 Pages

His next suggestion is the “complete reorganization at once of our banking system” (Hoover). The banks of the country are a mess and Hoover does not fail to recognize they are an issue. He believes the banks have contributed to the severity of the depression and until they are reorganized, the country will be unable to move forward in the journey towards recovery. His final point is “vigorous and whole-souled cooperation with other governments in the economic field” (Hoover). He believes that cooperation with other nations will help America heal in that it would open up economic opportunities.

Read More
929 Words | 4 Pages

Hoover was forced take decisions against his philosophy of rugged individualism, but unfortunately his actions were too little, too late. While Hoover was office, during the depression, his successes were far, and few between. He had a philosophy of government keeping their noses out of business, but when the depression hit, it took him a while to get involved, and came up with the associative state. He thought that the government should team up with businesses and form a partnership.

Read More
1081 Words | 5 Pages

As someone who had always struggled financially throughout his life, he felt he could bring America back up from the depression, as seen in Document 4. Hoover is pulling up America from a waterfall as Europe keeps falling with no help, representing America striving for recovery and Europe’s past recession. A conservative idea seen by Hoover was his belief in rugged individualism, he believed that the Americans should help themselves from the despair of the Great Depression. He also believed that the people should not rely solely on the government’s assistance and the government should not overly aid the people. In Document 2, it is seen that Hoover felt the most effective way for the Americans to end the depression was to volunteer themselves into community services.

Read More
1944 Words | 8 Pages

Beginning with President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s inauguration in 1933, the New Deal was passed in the context of reformism and rationalism as the United States proceeded through the Great Depression. The American people looked to the President to instill reform policies to help direct the country out of an economic depression, and thus often sought to abandon the society that existed before the Great Depression. Roosevelt instituted New Deal policies to attempt to combat this period of economic decline, many of which were successful and appealed to the American people’s desires. President Roosevelt’s New Deal is often criticized for being excessively socialistic in nature, thus causing dramatic changes in the fundamental structure of the United

Read More
1032 Words | 5 Pages

Herbert Hoover, the 31st President of the United States, took office during one of the most depressing times in American history. Before office, he was known for helping a variety of charities as the head of the American Relief Administration and Food Administration. However, during his presidency and the Great Depression, Hoover failed to come to the realization that the country needed more than just bread lines and charities to fix the situation. The purpose of this paper is to give a brief overview of Herbert Hoover’s life and presidency.

Read More
1526 Words | 7 Pages

Hoover exclaimed “We in America today are nearer to the final triumph over poverty than ever before in the history of any land”(White House), but only months later the stock market would collapse and plunge the nation into a depression. After the crash, Hoover discarded Republican officials who “believed there was nothing for the government to do but wait for the next phase of the business cycle”(Britanica 1). Hoover started by calling business leaders to the White House and urging them to not reduce wages or lay-off workers. Hoover also “asked Congress to appropriate money for public-works projects to expand government employment”(Britnica 1). Though Hoover attempted to act, the depression worsened and plunged the nation's economy into further depths of despair.

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

Sources reveal that Hoover’s character was always extremely insensitive towards the well being of others, even before presidency. As a leader of the country, this portrays the idea of Hoover’s insouciant mindset. Therefore, the entire country was affected by his unsuccessful example of leadership. Hoover’s presidency modified the entire generation of the 1920’s. For instance, “ He was inclined to give indirect aid to banks or local public works projects, but he refused to use federal money for direct aid to citizens, believing the dole would weaken public morale.

Read More
573 Words | 3 Pages

In the 1930s, the United States faced the devastating impact of the Great Depression, leaving millions unemployed and struggling to survive. President Franklin D. Roosevelt responded to this crisis with his New Deal initiatives, aimed at revitalizing the economy and providing relief to those in need. This essay examines the effectiveness of the New Deal through its programs, its challenges, and its lasting legacy. The New Deal encompassed a variety of programs designed to alleviate economic hardships.

Read More

More about The Response To Herbert Hoover's Critique Of The New Deal

Open Document